Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I thought I was pro-choice, is this judgey?

342 replies

Calmondeck · 18/03/2024 09:23

I always thought I was pro-choice. I know the difficulties that can come with pregnancy, I understand the complexities of becoming a parent. And yet I suddenly find myself frustrated at a woman I know for choosing not to follow-through with her pregnancy. Does that mean deep down I am not pro-choice?

In a nutshell, I am friends with the male partner in a couple together for 1.5yrs. They’ve been having sex without contraception but avoiding her fertile window. Several weeks ago, had sex in the fertile window, discussed whether or not to use the morning after pill, (apparently) mutual decision not to. Now early days pregnant. The woman reached out to me asking to meet for a chat “on all things birth and motherhood”. I told her I’m probably not the best person to speak to since my review of motherhood is somewhat clouded by spending half of my toddler’s life in hospital as he undergoes aggressive chemotherapy for infant cancer.

We met anyway. The first thing she said was “I’m getting cold feet, we decided to throw caution to the wind, I’m 35 so thought it’s unlikely the first time ever I have sex in a fertile window I would get pregnant, but now that I am, I was excited, and now I’m suddenly scared. I follow all of the midwives on Instagram even though I wasn’t actively planning to become pregnant, I just think becoming a mother is fascinating”.

I was sympathetic and honest about all of the pros and cons from my tiny experience.

My friend, the dad-to-be, is shocked but genuinely excited.

The pregnant woman has decided today that she will get an abortion. And suddenly I feel deeply sad for this growing little person. And frustrated that the mum said “I had my year and travels planned. I’ll try again in 2 years”.

OP posts:
Didimum · 18/03/2024 18:32

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 18:27

@Didimum

I agree with what you've said, and I honestly don't have all the answers. But it still doesn't justify killing an innocent human being.

I’m sorry, but if you don’t have any answer to that then pro-life is a poor and insufficient stance. If you’re OK with it being a poor choice, then fine.

Brawcolli · 18/03/2024 18:31

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 17:50

@Brawcolli

Pro life means that I believe all lives are valuable. However, all lives cannot be saved. So yes, in the case of an ectopic pregnancy, let's say, there has to be an abortion to save the mother's life. Of course there are exceptions.

Would you be ok with banning abortion apart from those that are medically necessary?

Of course I wouldn’t, I’m pro choice. No one should have to go through pregnancy and birth if they don’t want to, and bringing an unwanted child into the world is cruel.

sarahsunny · 18/03/2024 18:30

Lovingitallnow · 18/03/2024 09:28

You can be pro-choice without having to like the choice. I'm pro-choice but I do believe life starts at conception. I find the whole thing really difficult. I understand that my belief shouldn't be foisted on someone else so although I celebrate the fact we have a choice, I can't celebrate the choices.

If you believe life starts at conception, but are okay with someone else choosing to terminate, does that not mean you are okay with someone killing their child? Not a dig - I feel the same as you and so have been struggling with this.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 18:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 18:29

Boredandstressed · 18/03/2024 18:23

Some are just too vocal about how little it means to them / affects them/ how easy it was to make that choice that’s my experience anyway on a few occasions. It’s a choice and that’s good but there are some people who can be tactless about it

Why should a woman not feel free to voice how she feels about her own body, experiences and medical history? No woman is responsible for any other person’s negative feelings regarding her own experience.

Imisscoffee2021 · 18/03/2024 18:27

I know exactly how you feel @Calmondeck . I too am pro choice and staunchly so, but now I've had a baby I cant help think of this little burgeoning flicker of life. The two feelings can coexist in my mind though with some discomfort, not everything is black and white and nor should it be, the nuances and grey areas are where progression lies and has helped pave the way for prochoice laws as it should. But the emotional pull having been pregnant is there too.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 18:27

@Didimum

I agree with what you've said, and I honestly don't have all the answers. But it still doesn't justify killing an innocent human being.

Boredandstressed · 18/03/2024 18:24

I’m not saying that anyone should
feel shame but I’m saying there’s no need to be shouting from the rooftops with inflammatory language it’s should just be one of those things that happens and is dealt with sensitively by all

Didimum · 18/03/2024 18:24

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 18:15

@Didimum

You raise a good point. There should absolutely be more help for families. However, even if these services were not in place, it still wouldn't be ok to kill unborn babies.

But they AREN’T in place, and what’s more multitudes pregnancies don’t come about in ‘families’. So as someone who (presumably) would eradicate non-medically-necessary abortions, how are the resulting children to be cared for?

Boredandstressed · 18/03/2024 18:23

PrincessZelda89 · 18/03/2024 18:17

For some women it is though, and who are you to say that’s wrong? I had an abortion at 24. I got pregnant on the last day of my period, whilst on the implant. I had no strong feelings about the abortion. I went with my partner, had the short procedure done and was home with my partner in a couple of hours. Now nearly a decade later I still don’t any guilt or remorse. It wasn’t the right time for me for many reasons. It wasn’t the right time for me to carry a baby for 9 months, birth it and then provide for it for 18+ years. Abortion is essential health care and you don’t have to agree with abortion or have one yourself, but denying other women a choice is just wrong and so is dictating how women should feel about it.

Some are just too vocal about how little it means to them / affects them/ how easy it was to make that choice that’s my experience anyway on a few occasions. It’s a choice and that’s good but there are some people who can be tactless about it

maddening · 18/03/2024 18:22

You can support her choice but also judge that her attitude is flippant and irresponsible.

you can support her choice and consider that it is a waste of resources on her whims (but lots of resources are used up by different whims of many many people- eg drinking alcohol)

You can also support her choice and feel sad that a potential foetus will be destroyed.

You can support her choice and not feel sorry for her if she decides to wait several years and then has fertility issues, whilst also feeling sad for her missed opportunity.

It is OK to hold opposing thoughts and feelings, it is a complex subject.

Switcher · 18/03/2024 18:20

I guess the whole point of having a pro choice legal framework is that your friends can judge you all they like, but you can still go ahead and get an abortion. You're quite entitled to your opinion, and I must say I agree with you, it's very cold. I too had planned my travels for years, and had finally booked them, I too thought I wouldn't get pregnant so fast, but I did. I suppose it has made some things really hard, but for me, abortion was not a choice I was willing to make. That's the point. As Suzanne Moore said, if you don't want an abortion, don't have one. End of.

LovelyTheresa · 18/03/2024 18:20

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 17:47

@LovelyTheresa

If you read her post, she is doubting her pro choice status, so actually extremely relevant.

She isn't doubting her pro-choice status in the sense that she thinks she is 'pro-life' (or anti-choice, as I prefer to call it. Nothing 'pro-life' about the actions of a lot of anti-choicers) She is struggling with her personal judgement of one individual woman and wondering if that makes her a bad pro-choicer. At no point did she show any signs of coming around to your way of thinking.

fleurneige · 18/03/2024 18:20

jengachampion · 18/03/2024 17:42

Would it be better if that kind of unstable woman were forced to have the child?

No not at all. But I do believe it's right to have the discussion and to expect women to not consider abortion as a form of 'contraception' willy nilly. And some do, far too many.

PrincessZelda89 · 18/03/2024 18:17

Boredandstressed · 18/03/2024 17:02

I agree. It’s sometimes presented as an equal and as easy to make choice as whether to have tea or coffee and I struggle with that. Obviously I don’t want anyone to have a hard time deciding but equally wish sometimes the gravity of the choice was acknowledged. I don’t ever and wouldn’t ever say anything to anyone but yes I’d absolutely privately judge them.

For some women it is though, and who are you to say that’s wrong? I had an abortion at 24. I got pregnant on the last day of my period, whilst on the implant. I had no strong feelings about the abortion. I went with my partner, had the short procedure done and was home with my partner in a couple of hours. Now nearly a decade later I still don’t any guilt or remorse. It wasn’t the right time for me for many reasons. It wasn’t the right time for me to carry a baby for 9 months, birth it and then provide for it for 18+ years. Abortion is essential health care and you don’t have to agree with abortion or have one yourself, but denying other women a choice is just wrong and so is dictating how women should feel about it.

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 18:15

@Didimum

You raise a good point. There should absolutely be more help for families. However, even if these services were not in place, it still wouldn't be ok to kill unborn babies.

wordler · 18/03/2024 18:14

I'm pro choice because the alternative is making a woman simply an incubator rather than a person with her own rights to manage what's going on in her body. Which is a really dangerous path to go down.

However, I do have uncomfortable feelings about abortion since having a baby of my own and cherishing that little life at all the stages from 9 weeks onwards when I saw my first scan. I was much more ambivalent about under 16-week and even under 20-week abortions before I watched my little bean growing.

I don't think we should shy away from acknowledging that there are things about allowing abortions which are upsetting, even when you believe it's the only choice to protect women's autonomy.

daliesque · 18/03/2024 18:06

It's not ideal, but she realised it wasn't a good idea before it was too late. Better an abortion now than a child who isn't wanted 🤷‍♀️

Cauliflowery · 18/03/2024 18:00

I believe it is her choice.

I don't think you're unreasonable however OP. I think you are bound to have strong feelings around the subject of infancy and life, given your experiences with your own child. These things can hit us in surprising ways 💐

I think personally I would find her flippancy annoying, because whilst I've been lucky, I have watched so many friends struggling with fertility heartache. But I also agree that children should be wanted.

It is a difficult topic. The positive thing about the notion of choice is that each of us are free to make our own choice, and free to disagree with another's choice.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 17:59

fleurneige · 18/03/2024 09:49

NO, totally disagree. Choice is for when things go wrong despite being responsible, not for those who want to 'play russian roulette' with pregnancy.

If you work in health care, you will know of so many women who refuse all contraceptive advice, and have abortion after abortion. And, call me judgy I don't care, this is so so WRONG.

What the what now? Pro-choice means choice for everybody. End of.

WhatWhereWho · 18/03/2024 17:58

Being pro-choice means supporting the legal rights to an abortion not necessarily agreeing with the reasons for every decision made or having a personal opinion on someone's choice..

watermelonsugar56 · 18/03/2024 17:55

I think the woman’s attitude seems a bit flippant to say the least. Also rather insensitive to ask you about motherhood when your own experience has been such a tough time, as you’re a Mum whose child has been battling a life-threatening illness. I’m not against abortion but she just seems like a bit of a nincompoop.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 17:54

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 17:50

@Brawcolli

Pro life means that I believe all lives are valuable. However, all lives cannot be saved. So yes, in the case of an ectopic pregnancy, let's say, there has to be an abortion to save the mother's life. Of course there are exceptions.

Would you be ok with banning abortion apart from those that are medically necessary?

In a world where abortion is not permitted, who is paying for these multitudes of new babies and children? How are they being housed, fed, educated and brought up with quality care?

HuckleberryBlackcurrant · 18/03/2024 17:52

@fleurneige

Why is it wrong?

MumblesParty · 18/03/2024 17:51

fleurneige · 18/03/2024 09:49

NO, totally disagree. Choice is for when things go wrong despite being responsible, not for those who want to 'play russian roulette' with pregnancy.

If you work in health care, you will know of so many women who refuse all contraceptive advice, and have abortion after abortion. And, call me judgy I don't care, this is so so WRONG.

@fleurneige better for them to have abortions than bring innocent babies into the world that they’re not capable of looking after properly.

Whenever I see women with chaotic lives who want an abortion, I breathe a sigh of relief. That’s one fewer neglected child to be born.