Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I thought I was pro-choice, is this judgey?

342 replies

Calmondeck · 18/03/2024 09:23

I always thought I was pro-choice. I know the difficulties that can come with pregnancy, I understand the complexities of becoming a parent. And yet I suddenly find myself frustrated at a woman I know for choosing not to follow-through with her pregnancy. Does that mean deep down I am not pro-choice?

In a nutshell, I am friends with the male partner in a couple together for 1.5yrs. They’ve been having sex without contraception but avoiding her fertile window. Several weeks ago, had sex in the fertile window, discussed whether or not to use the morning after pill, (apparently) mutual decision not to. Now early days pregnant. The woman reached out to me asking to meet for a chat “on all things birth and motherhood”. I told her I’m probably not the best person to speak to since my review of motherhood is somewhat clouded by spending half of my toddler’s life in hospital as he undergoes aggressive chemotherapy for infant cancer.

We met anyway. The first thing she said was “I’m getting cold feet, we decided to throw caution to the wind, I’m 35 so thought it’s unlikely the first time ever I have sex in a fertile window I would get pregnant, but now that I am, I was excited, and now I’m suddenly scared. I follow all of the midwives on Instagram even though I wasn’t actively planning to become pregnant, I just think becoming a mother is fascinating”.

I was sympathetic and honest about all of the pros and cons from my tiny experience.

My friend, the dad-to-be, is shocked but genuinely excited.

The pregnant woman has decided today that she will get an abortion. And suddenly I feel deeply sad for this growing little person. And frustrated that the mum said “I had my year and travels planned. I’ll try again in 2 years”.

OP posts:
Desecratedcoconut · 18/03/2024 10:39

Didimum · 18/03/2024 10:37

I mean, this has ZERO to do with you. I would completely ignore any feelings you have about it.

You would ignore the op's feelings, or your own feelings, or the op should ignore her own feelings - because they are the wrong feelings?

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 18/03/2024 10:39

Didimum · 18/03/2024 10:37

I mean, this has ZERO to do with you. I would completely ignore any feelings you have about it.

This woman has involved op, despite her saying she isn't the person to talk to. Op hasn't inserted herself into the conversation.

35965a · 18/03/2024 10:38

I am pro-choice. Personally, I’ve never had an abortion and I believe I wouldn’t unless there was a health concern either way. The reasons women have abortions might seem ‘wrong’ to me sometimes but I do still support abortion. I don’t have to like it, but it’s not for me to try and stop someone or openly judge them.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 10:37

I mean, this has ZERO to do with you. I would completely ignore any feelings you have about it.

Desecratedcoconut · 18/03/2024 10:33

I'm pro-choice. I suppose I have to suck up bad choices for the greater good of women in general.

So yeah, I'm pro-choice, which doesn't mean to say I think that her particular choice isn't a shit, selfish choice.

Itsacruelsummer · 18/03/2024 10:31

I think you can be pro choice on a macro level but judge individual micro decisions. I would for example judge someone who aborted due to gender.

She sounds incredibly insensitive to talk to you about it when you have an ill child.

DonnaBanana · 18/03/2024 10:29

You can support people’s legal rights without being an ally. Actually that is a very honourable position to hold, that you can overlook your personal preferences in your broader ethics. For example, you can be religious and not personally approve of homosexuality, transgenderism, smoking, gambling, or abortion, say, while simultaneously understanding and supporting people’s legal rights and freedoms in those areas.

Alalalalalongalalalalalonglonglilong · 18/03/2024 10:28

There are many things I do not agree with but I keep them to myself, because although I may feel strongly about something I do above all believe in people's right to have opinions that differ from my own. I have found myself in your position many times over the years about various issues. Personally I would never have an abortion and I felt this very strongly even as a teenager, but I know people who have been casual about this like your friend and I find it upsetting but i keep my thoughts to myself. Even if people are having a general discussion about it I nod along and say nothing because I have found that if I express my personal view its immediately misinterpreted as being judgmental or oppressive when it is merely my own take on it. It's ironic because people who have more liberal views on things like to shout from the rooftops and try to 'enlighten' those that differ. I never do this and try to respect people's differences, although I find this difficult sometimes.

Anahenzaris · 18/03/2024 10:25

Pro choice doesn’t have to mean you agree with or support every individual person’s choice. You can be completely behind the legal right to access abortion while still having your own moral stand on when abortion is and is not ok.

It is actually very rare for people to support abortion without restriction as morally right behaviour - everyone has their own personal moral stance of what is and is not ok.

It also isn’t wrong to be upset that your friend has lost (or will lose) his child.

Just keep your opinions to yourself. If you support the right to choose - then even if the reason isn’t one you support, then you support the right for her to make that decision based on her moral stance.

takemeawayagain · 18/03/2024 10:19

Who knows she might change her mind another 10 times between now and the abortion and might find she just can't go through with it. I'm not sure she is ready for such a life changing thing as a baby though from what you've said, but that could change completely by the time the baby arrived.

I think all we can do is accept that she is allowed to make the choice that feels right for her even though it might not be our choice or even the right choice in the long term for her (ie if she really struggles to conceive in the future). Alternatively maybe it will prove to be the correct decision and she will be in a more settled, ready position in 2 years and fall pregnant at the drop of a hat and be very happy with her decisions.

Unmute · 18/03/2024 10:17

It was very strange of this woman to involve you. Since she did, you will, of course, have your own views about her decision.

Maybe you wouldn't have made the same choice in her situation, but if you don't believe she should be forced to carry on with a pregnancy she doesn't want, then you are pro-choice.

VickyEadieofThigh · 18/03/2024 10:16

Others have described my stance - pro-choice meaning neither society nor the state should prevent a woman having an abortion.

I AM judging their attitude to contraception, however and because I'm nosey, would love to hear their justification for being so cavalier with her health (abortion is not 100% risk free and pregnancy certainly isn't) and the already dwindling NHS resources.

Applescruffle · 18/03/2024 10:09

Pro-choice is just that. Pro-CHOICE. It's not pro-abortion. It's not pro-irresponsibility. It's just the belief that a woman has choices over her own body.

You don't have to like the choice she makes, it doesn't have to very the same choice you would have made. But if you support her right to make it and don't think that right should come with conditions, then you are indeed pro-choice.

sandyhappypeople · 18/03/2024 10:06

I also don’t agree that what they did was a ‘mistake’, it was an intentional act that they knew full well could result in pregnancy, it was always going to be a gamble and it personally doesn’t sit right with me that they are gambling with a human life when there are other options available.

i think she is utterly unbelievable to come to you with this with everything you’re going through though, engaging with you and then so flippantly announce that she’s going to abort, it’s horribly insensitive and it’s not surprising you feel a little sad about their decision to terminate.

AgnesX · 18/03/2024 10:03

As someone else said you can be pro-choice without liking the choice.

That's choice.

LovelyTheresa · 18/03/2024 10:03

You are still pro-choice in that you (presumably) still believe that the state should not have the right to prevent this woman from going through with her abortion. That doesn't mean that you can't have your own feelings about it, although it would obviously better not to let her know about them. You are human and humans judge each other.
I've said it on here before, but I am staunchly pro-choice but if I fell pregnant I would not have an abortion unless I had to for medical reasons. I am childfree and do not want a child, but I still wouldn't have an abortion. I'm still pro choice.

Zaxi · 18/03/2024 10:02

MrsKintner · 18/03/2024 09:53

It makes no difference to the foetus what the woman's reasons are.

The stance that abortion is wrong unless the woman has a reason I deem acceptable, it makes no sense.

You feel 'deeply sad for this growing little person' because you've decided the mother is selfish or flakey, but if you liked the mother and thought she was a saint in genuine need, you wouldn't give a fuck about the little person?

So actually it's not about the foetus at all, it's purely about judging women.

THIS^^

And dont forget the "its ok in case of rape or incest" - so whats happening here? Advocating for the foetus based on willing conception??? But not if sex was consensual? What's that about then? Punishing the woman is what its about

LassZombie · 18/03/2024 10:01

Women should never have to continue a pregnancy if they don't want to, for whatever reason.

Daft that they're being stupid with contraception though. That's a separate problem.

WhereIsMyLight · 18/03/2024 10:01

I think there’s an indifference from the woman. They are having sex without contraceptions during her fertile window, not taking the morning after pill. Then saying “becoming a mother is fascinating” like it’s some social experiment. Then she’s decided that the social experiment isn’t worth her holidays but she can try properly in a few years with the assumption she’ll fall pregnant easily and with no issues to the child.

It’s not the choosing the abortion for me, that might be the best, but the casual approach to family planning and not acknowledging that her choices affect more than her. Children aren’t some sort of social experiment. With your child being so ill, you of all people know this. You know the commitment of children and how things don’t go to plan. Added into that, your friend is the dad, not the mother, and he was genuinely excited and so some of you feelings will be coming from his disappointment too.

I think the woman was insensitive to have this conversation with you, especially when you detailed what you’ve been through.

Allthingsdecember · 18/03/2024 10:01

I think that you can be pro choice without necessarily believing someone is making a good choice. The key point is that you believe she should have that choice.

I think women should be able to dress however they choose. It doesn't stop me silently thinking some women choose stupid outfits... I just wouldn't try to stop them.

Stompythedinosaur · 18/03/2024 10:00

Well, I think you are being quite self-aware to consider your reaction.

I think we all have occasions where our internalised reaction to a situation doesn't fit with our rationale view, because we grew up with views that we've later questioned.

It isn't a baby, it's a collection of a few cells. Even if it was a baby, the woman has a right to body autonomy, and she is allowed to decide how her body is used. I suspect you know this, though.

I suspect that "I'll try again in a few years" really means "I don't want a baby but I don't feel I can say that".

I wonder if your thoughts could be less about views about abortion, and more about the narrative in society that women are meant to sacrifice themselves for others, and the woman is putting her own comfort and enjoyment first? Even though I believe that's fine, I still catch myself being judgemental when I see women doing this sometimes, because misogyny is locked deep in my head!

FirstFallopians · 18/03/2024 10:00

There are plenty of things that are legal, but where I judge the decisions of the players involved depending on the circumstances.

Having more children that you can afford/cope with, adopting an animal you have no intention on caring for properly etc.

But what’s the alternative? Stricter controls on peoples’ lives. We just need to accept that with freedom of choice, some people will chose to make decisions we don’t agree with and actually that’s the lesser of two evils.

I wouldn’t judge the abortion, I would judge the couple for being laissez faire with contraception knowing they weren’t ready for a child.

iLovee · 18/03/2024 10:00

I am 100% pro choice (in the sense that I don't believe you need a "reason" to end a pregnancy) but cases like this do make me very sad. It seems very cold.

I think if you "have your year planned" the only sensible thing to do would be to use protection.

Mumoftwo1312 · 18/03/2024 09:58

Pro-choice, to me, means believing abortion should be legal and available. That pregnant women shouldn't be prevented from having one.

That's not the same as whole heartedly approving in every circumstance.

It's like freedom of speech: I don't have to agree with the speech itself, I still believe in your right to say it

KreedKafer · 18/03/2024 09:57

Well, do you think she shouldn't be allowed to terminate her pregnancy? If so, then you aren't pro-choice.

If you think she should be allowed to terminate her pregnancy regardless of whether you personally think it's the right thing to do, then you are still pro-choice.