Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I thought I was pro-choice, is this judgey?

342 replies

Calmondeck · 18/03/2024 09:23

I always thought I was pro-choice. I know the difficulties that can come with pregnancy, I understand the complexities of becoming a parent. And yet I suddenly find myself frustrated at a woman I know for choosing not to follow-through with her pregnancy. Does that mean deep down I am not pro-choice?

In a nutshell, I am friends with the male partner in a couple together for 1.5yrs. They’ve been having sex without contraception but avoiding her fertile window. Several weeks ago, had sex in the fertile window, discussed whether or not to use the morning after pill, (apparently) mutual decision not to. Now early days pregnant. The woman reached out to me asking to meet for a chat “on all things birth and motherhood”. I told her I’m probably not the best person to speak to since my review of motherhood is somewhat clouded by spending half of my toddler’s life in hospital as he undergoes aggressive chemotherapy for infant cancer.

We met anyway. The first thing she said was “I’m getting cold feet, we decided to throw caution to the wind, I’m 35 so thought it’s unlikely the first time ever I have sex in a fertile window I would get pregnant, but now that I am, I was excited, and now I’m suddenly scared. I follow all of the midwives on Instagram even though I wasn’t actively planning to become pregnant, I just think becoming a mother is fascinating”.

I was sympathetic and honest about all of the pros and cons from my tiny experience.

My friend, the dad-to-be, is shocked but genuinely excited.

The pregnant woman has decided today that she will get an abortion. And suddenly I feel deeply sad for this growing little person. And frustrated that the mum said “I had my year and travels planned. I’ll try again in 2 years”.

OP posts:
Vistada · 18/03/2024 11:50

You don't get to feel the progressive smugness of being pro choice and then be "pro-choice only actually only in circumstances I on my moral high horse deem appropriate"

You're either pro choice or you're not.

You're not.

JMSA · 18/03/2024 11:48

Does she know about your wee one?
I wouldn't judge her so much for the abortion. But I would judge her to hell and back for using you as her abortion sounding board.
Completely inappropriate and lacking in awareness.
I'm so sorry for what you are going through Flowers

crockofshite · 18/03/2024 11:45

They shouldn't really have discussed it with anyone, just gone and done whatever they wanted ie keep or abort.

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:44

sandyhappypeople · 18/03/2024 11:39

I mean, this has ZERO to do with you. I would completely ignore any feelings you have about it.

Okay, so what is the point of this advice? If she was able to just ignore her feelings she wouldn't be here seeking advice, this issue has (not unsurprisingly given her circumstances) affected her to a certain extent.

The point is that this is what I would tell myself if I found myself in this position. And I have found myself in similar positions. Actively deciding to take steps in moving on from them helped me. You aren't required to agree, nor is the OP, so I'm not sure why it bothers you.

Resilience · 18/03/2024 11:43

To be pro choice, you don't have to agree with the reasons, only the right.

Although given the fact this woman has come to @Calmondeck to discuss this and has made the comments she has, I wouldn't be surprised if this is needless drama and when the time comes she'll say "I just couldn't go through with it."

KateMiskin · 18/03/2024 11:40

You are not pro-choice.
They should not have asked you at all.
I am really sorry about your toddler.

ChristinaXYZ · 18/03/2024 11:40

Lovingitallnow · 18/03/2024 09:28

You can be pro-choice without having to like the choice. I'm pro-choice but I do believe life starts at conception. I find the whole thing really difficult. I understand that my belief shouldn't be foisted on someone else so although I celebrate the fact we have a choice, I can't celebrate the choices.

That pretty much what I think.

And I also think that few of us are truly fully pro-choice - we all have lines.

Would most pro-choice supporters think the day before birth was ok? The hour before birth? If not then you've got a line to draw somewhere where you're saying at that point but no further am I pro-choice. At some point you think that something (the age or viability of the baby) means the woman's automomy over her body is no longer the over-riding principle.

And if that's the case why is it only time, the length of pregnancy, that gives you a line? That makes no philosophical sense.

Having said that my own illogical view is that up to the baby being viable then women should have the right to chose for whatever reason. I don't like it, especially for trivial reasons like the ones OP mentions, but I support it.

Microdisney · 18/03/2024 11:40

mondaytosunday · 18/03/2024 11:29

Well in this situation I'm not conflicted at all. I do think some women who have repeated abortions due to careless birth control practises need their heads knocked together.
One family, staunch Catholics, really did have the courage of their convictions and even though I didn't agree I had to respect it. They were the kind to lock themselves to the gates of abortion clinics. All well when it's not you grappling with the decision you might think, but their learning disabled daughter was raped in her sheltered home and they said if she was to get pregnant they would raise the child. And they did, with as much love as they gave to their other nine kids.

To me the incredible thing here is that you find this worthy of ‘respect’.

sandyhappypeople · 18/03/2024 11:39

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:24

Great. I didn't ask you to not reply to me or imply you shouldn't. I don't have an issue with whatever you say to me. I will, however, continue to clarify my posts if you are questioning them – which is also allowed. You will note that I am not questioning yours.

I mean, this has ZERO to do with you. I would completely ignore any feelings you have about it.

Okay, so what is the point of this advice? If she was able to just ignore her feelings she wouldn't be here seeking advice, this issue has (not unsurprisingly given her circumstances) affected her to a certain extent.

JollyJellyfish · 18/03/2024 11:39

You can be pro choice and still have your own opinions on people and their lives.

Would you like to remove her option to have an abortion and make her continue with a pregnancy /baby she does not want?

No, I'm sure you don't want that.

So you are pro choice. You're just human and have your own private opinions, but you won't let it interfere with someone's right to choose for themselves and their body.

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 18/03/2024 11:31

mondaytosunday · 18/03/2024 11:29

Well in this situation I'm not conflicted at all. I do think some women who have repeated abortions due to careless birth control practises need their heads knocked together.
One family, staunch Catholics, really did have the courage of their convictions and even though I didn't agree I had to respect it. They were the kind to lock themselves to the gates of abortion clinics. All well when it's not you grappling with the decision you might think, but their learning disabled daughter was raped in her sheltered home and they said if she was to get pregnant they would raise the child. And they did, with as much love as they gave to their other nine kids.

You respect someone who made their disabled child give birth after being raped?

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 11:30

I think you can be pro choice but still be sad about the choices some people make. Or the choices we sometimes make ourselves. The point is that women have to be free to make the choice.

mondaytosunday · 18/03/2024 11:29

Well in this situation I'm not conflicted at all. I do think some women who have repeated abortions due to careless birth control practises need their heads knocked together.
One family, staunch Catholics, really did have the courage of their convictions and even though I didn't agree I had to respect it. They were the kind to lock themselves to the gates of abortion clinics. All well when it's not you grappling with the decision you might think, but their learning disabled daughter was raped in her sheltered home and they said if she was to get pregnant they would raise the child. And they did, with as much love as they gave to their other nine kids.

Guavafish1 · 18/03/2024 11:25

Totally insensitive to your situation

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:24

sandyhappypeople · 18/03/2024 11:21

and as it's a public forum, people are free to tell you your 'advice' is ridiculous.

If OP was able to just not feel a certain way she wouldn't be here would she?

Great. I didn't ask you to not reply to me or imply you shouldn't. I don't have an issue with whatever you say to me. I will, however, continue to clarify my posts if you are questioning them – which is also allowed. You will note that I am not questioning yours.

ancienticecream · 18/03/2024 11:23

I had my year and travels planned. I’ll try again in 2 years
Usually, this means "in two years I'll say that I'll try again in another two years" at least, this is what all my friends have been saying for 5 or so years. I think YANBU to judge even if you think traditionally you have been pro-choice. It's not like your judgement can do anything to her decision anyway. How does your friend feel after being excited to be a dad?

Mnetcurious · 18/03/2024 11:23

They were incredibly irresponsible. Abortion shouldn’t be for situations like this- it wasn’t an accident. Ultimately I’m still pro-choice but this could easily have been avoided by not having unprotected sex until they were sure they definitely wanted a baby.

Liv999 · 18/03/2024 11:22

fleurneige · 18/03/2024 09:41

I am 100% pro abortion and choice. But 1000% more pro responsibility.

I have known just too many cases of people playing russian roulette with contraception, and actually saying they don't want to use any, or 'don't believe in it' - and often even leave it late to ask for abortion. Just far far far too many.

Yes, things can go wrong with contraception, and yes rape does exist - but I am sure the genuine proportion of the above in the number of abortions is rather small.

The after sex pill is even more so used as a form of 'ah well, I can always take the morning after'.

Abortion, in this morning age of contraception in so so many forms available for all, easily and cheaply - should be RARE and exceptional. Unlike for our mothers, grand-mothers and so on.

100% 👏

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:22

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 18/03/2024 11:04

If you're told something that gives you conflicting feelings can you instantly just switch it off?

In the real world most of us will take a some time to think and discuss things before we can move on.

Do you go on every thread and just tell people to stop having feelings to resolve their issues?

I didn't say or imply that she should or can "instantly switch it off". I also didn't tell her to stop having feelings. I advised she moved on from them – I didn't imply or suggest a time frame either. I'm really not sure what so difficult to comprehend. This is an advice board and I am free to give my advice – irrespective of whether you personally have a problem with it.

sandyhappypeople · 18/03/2024 11:21

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:16

I didn't say there was – this is an advice board. I am free and able to offer my advice.

and as it's a public forum, people are free to tell you your 'advice' is ridiculous.

If OP was able to just not feel a certain way she wouldn't be here would she?

Didimum · 18/03/2024 11:16

Desecratedcoconut · 18/03/2024 11:02

Or, she can continue to have feelings for as long as she likes. She can think, ruminate, and judge for however long she pleases. There is no moral imperative to move on.

I didn't say there was – this is an advice board. I am free and able to offer my advice.

RegardingMary · 18/03/2024 11:15

Being pro choice is about believing that women have the right to choose whether to continue or end a pregnancy.

You can think and feel wholeheartedly that she has the 'right' to do what she wishes while also internally disagreeing with her reasoning.

I wouldn't think it makes you any less pro choice as your belief is that it's 'her' choice and she has a right to make the decision.

Desecratedcoconut · 18/03/2024 11:14

Ihearyousingingdownthewire · 18/03/2024 11:10

You’re not pro-choice.

Go on then, what's your definition of pro-choice if it goes beyond defending a woman's right to choose?

MagpiePi · 18/03/2024 11:11

VikingLady · 18/03/2024 09:29

I'm sorry about your child. Best of luck to you all.

She would be unlikely to be a good parent in her circumstances anyway.

How judgemental!

Ihearyousingingdownthewire · 18/03/2024 11:10

You’re not pro-choice.