Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think why are men still shit?

208 replies

Momsitter · 17/03/2024 23:49

Off the back of another thread I just read...

still thread after thread of abusive men. Calling their wives "fat fucks". Seeing hookers. Cheating. Cocklodging. Financial, physical, emotional abuse.
Still women raising them, marrying them, having 3 kids with them.

We've got better rhetoric and "feminism" in the media and arts, better representation in the workplace and social awareness but really fuck all is changing in relationships, is it? Why is that? What are we missing?

OP posts:
MarmaladeOrangey · 19/03/2024 10:20

LifeExperience · 18/03/2024 12:10

Women in long-term, happy relationships have no reason to post on MN. I've been married to a wonderful, loving, giving man for decades, and together we raised a wonderful, loving, giving ds who makes his partner very happy. Good men are out there, but you rarely hear about them on MN because there's no reason to post about them.

I will also say this, which might be controversial--girls raised without fathers tend to settle for less worthy men, because they have no idea of how a good man acts since they haven't seen it modeled in childhood. Our dd is very selective about men because they have to meet the standard she was raised with. She's in her 20s and has only had a couple of boyfriends so far, but they have both been good, decent men who adored her. She's just not ready to settle down yet.

I would change what you said from girls raised without fathers to girls raised without good male role models.

User135644 · 19/03/2024 10:16

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 09:24

'Bragging' that I have decent men in my life?

Blimey, it really is a race to the bottom, isn't it? 🙄

Misery loves company, as they say.

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 09:40

LifeExperience · 18/03/2024 12:10

Women in long-term, happy relationships have no reason to post on MN. I've been married to a wonderful, loving, giving man for decades, and together we raised a wonderful, loving, giving ds who makes his partner very happy. Good men are out there, but you rarely hear about them on MN because there's no reason to post about them.

I will also say this, which might be controversial--girls raised without fathers tend to settle for less worthy men, because they have no idea of how a good man acts since they haven't seen it modeled in childhood. Our dd is very selective about men because they have to meet the standard she was raised with. She's in her 20s and has only had a couple of boyfriends so far, but they have both been good, decent men who adored her. She's just not ready to settle down yet.

Girls raised without fathers tend to settle for less worthy men.

This! I was raised by my incredible dad, which I definitely think influenced my choice of boyfriend/husband. If nothing else, an arsehole wouldn't have made it through the front door!!

What I would also say - and this too might be controversial - is that I found that being a daughter raised by a dad gave me good insight into how men 'work' in general. Definitely helped when the time came to move in with my (now) husband.

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 09:24

'Bragging' that I have decent men in my life?

Blimey, it really is a race to the bottom, isn't it? 🙄

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/03/2024 06:33

5128gap · 18/03/2024 11:15

Very occasionally. And if you explore with them what that actually means, and why, it's never about wanting a useless waste of space who sits there on the x box in his pants while she runs around after him. Or losing everything she owns to his addictions. Or having him cheat on her or abuse her. It's almost always referring to an image of hyper masculinity. Strong, possibly feared by other men, so able to 'take care of himself' and her, a risk taker who will offer fun and excitement. An image that's been constructed by men to create their own hierarchy amongst themselves and sold to women as desirable.

Yes, I think this is it. They see it as strength, possibly dominance. Sometimes they feel like they are healing and changing him with the power of their womanly love (they're not) and paradoxically, you can't be reminded of what you're healing him from if he doesn't display it sometimes. Trauma and drama can be exciting, as horrible as that is to say. They don't like it exactly, but it satisfies some sort of need.

My mother dumped her first fiance because he didn't stand up for her and protect her enough. She then married my father, an angry abusive misogynist who spent their marriage calling her disgusting names, terrorising the house and bashing the kids around. All hearts and flowers on Valentine’s Day though. He was so strong and caring.

silentassassin · 19/03/2024 06:18

Amazing humble brag. Best I’ve read in years

A prime example of my earlier post:

This is true. I've seen people post about their great partners and they get told to stop bragging so I feel like it's not really encouraged to post about happy healthy things. The posts that are awful and shocking get the most attention, traction and advice.

LadyMonicaBaddingham · 18/03/2024 20:30

WandaWonder · 18/03/2024 00:01

And all women are perfect saints?

Here we go... Literally no-one said that. Guilty conscience?

ABwithAnItch · 18/03/2024 20:19

Jumpingthruhoops · 18/03/2024 00:04

People can only treat you how you let them. If my man was like any of those you describe, he'd be gone. Period.

Personally, I can't relate to the men you speak of. My dad and husband are both legends!

Amazing humble brag. Best I’ve read in years.

ABwithAnItch · 18/03/2024 20:16

Ponoka7 · 18/03/2024 09:11

@ABwithAnItch
"There is some part of every woman’s ego that is tied up and how attractive we are, and that means how attractive we are to men."

No there isn't. I was beautiful, personally I like that the harassment has stopped. I don't want to be critiqued by men while just living my life. How dare they reduce my to how I look. I see what you talk about for what it is and how it should never have been the case. You are still internalising your Mother's messages, your feelings don't apply to all aging women.

I don’t think I explained what I think very well. I think it’s pretty well established that women are judged heavily for their looks and I think this is very difficult to overcome and ‘not care’ as a woman. I grew up with the message that being attractive (to men) is very important. This of course is not a good thing. What I was trying to get to is that this gives power to men, who act like shits, because women internalize that being ‘wanted’ by a guy, any guy, is better than none. Of course not all women and of course it’s great if you don’t feel this way. But I think a lot of women do whether they realize or not and struggle to overcome this feeling. It’s just my thoughts.

Adhdorlazy · 18/03/2024 16:23

taxguru · 18/03/2024 12:51

Another aspect is that the "good" men aren't on the market as they're less likely to have affairs, divorce, get thrown out, etc., so basically snapped up quickly and then disappear from the dating/matching/meeting scene. I'd venture further and say the reliable (but some would say boring) blokes are less likely to be out pubbing, clubbing, socialising etc., as they'll be happy living a safe and simple family life!

It's the ones who are thrown out, divorced, etc multiple times who keep appearing on the dating/meeting scene, so women who are also on the look out will be coming across "that kind" of man more often. Likewise the men who are in relationships but on the lookout for someone better, are more likely to be those pubbing, clubbing and socialising. It's like a revolving door for people who are older and havn't found "the one", with series of relationships constantly breaking down, and then the subsequent one breaks done too, etc etc., because it's all the same "gene pool" of people who are available in their 30s and 40s.

I think these days, if you don't get in there when you're young and find a decent reliable bloke by your early 20s, you're pretty much stuffed as all the decent/reliable blokes will have been snapped up by someone else and most will be "off the market" for the rest of their natural lives.

I agree with this 100% …you’ve just described dating in your 40’s to a T!

I also tell any young people I know to get in there fast and find someone at uni or early 20’s.

Adhdorlazy · 18/03/2024 16:19

Just another thought…

there are lots of posts on here about women putting up with a load of BS from their partners. And being ‘passive’

However, if you look at divorce rates - it’s mostly women who start divorce proceedings.

that suggests that lots of women don’t put up with bad behaviour and/or that men are a bit shit.

User135644 · 18/03/2024 14:40

TheCadoganArms · 18/03/2024 13:24

I think your first paragraph is interesting. From my observations those 'boring' but otherwise reliable, faithful and non abusive blokes were often overlooked in their 20s as they were not gym bunnies or Mr Funny Confident Alpha Male types. It was only later on when these very same 'boring' men who were now in good careers and generally had their shit together in life were suddenly seen as possessing desirable traits .

I think as well once women mature more they grow tired of the arseholes and toxic men and start to look for other qualities, so men who were passed up in their 20s, or priotritised other things like a career, have a wider pool should they so wish.

wherethewildthingis · 18/03/2024 13:29

I wonder if mnhq are happy about the number of MRA and incels who now post on this site all the time.

TheCadoganArms · 18/03/2024 13:24

taxguru · 18/03/2024 12:51

Another aspect is that the "good" men aren't on the market as they're less likely to have affairs, divorce, get thrown out, etc., so basically snapped up quickly and then disappear from the dating/matching/meeting scene. I'd venture further and say the reliable (but some would say boring) blokes are less likely to be out pubbing, clubbing, socialising etc., as they'll be happy living a safe and simple family life!

It's the ones who are thrown out, divorced, etc multiple times who keep appearing on the dating/meeting scene, so women who are also on the look out will be coming across "that kind" of man more often. Likewise the men who are in relationships but on the lookout for someone better, are more likely to be those pubbing, clubbing and socialising. It's like a revolving door for people who are older and havn't found "the one", with series of relationships constantly breaking down, and then the subsequent one breaks done too, etc etc., because it's all the same "gene pool" of people who are available in their 30s and 40s.

I think these days, if you don't get in there when you're young and find a decent reliable bloke by your early 20s, you're pretty much stuffed as all the decent/reliable blokes will have been snapped up by someone else and most will be "off the market" for the rest of their natural lives.

I think your first paragraph is interesting. From my observations those 'boring' but otherwise reliable, faithful and non abusive blokes were often overlooked in their 20s as they were not gym bunnies or Mr Funny Confident Alpha Male types. It was only later on when these very same 'boring' men who were now in good careers and generally had their shit together in life were suddenly seen as possessing desirable traits .

taxguru · 18/03/2024 12:51

LifeExperience · 18/03/2024 12:10

Women in long-term, happy relationships have no reason to post on MN. I've been married to a wonderful, loving, giving man for decades, and together we raised a wonderful, loving, giving ds who makes his partner very happy. Good men are out there, but you rarely hear about them on MN because there's no reason to post about them.

I will also say this, which might be controversial--girls raised without fathers tend to settle for less worthy men, because they have no idea of how a good man acts since they haven't seen it modeled in childhood. Our dd is very selective about men because they have to meet the standard she was raised with. She's in her 20s and has only had a couple of boyfriends so far, but they have both been good, decent men who adored her. She's just not ready to settle down yet.

Another aspect is that the "good" men aren't on the market as they're less likely to have affairs, divorce, get thrown out, etc., so basically snapped up quickly and then disappear from the dating/matching/meeting scene. I'd venture further and say the reliable (but some would say boring) blokes are less likely to be out pubbing, clubbing, socialising etc., as they'll be happy living a safe and simple family life!

It's the ones who are thrown out, divorced, etc multiple times who keep appearing on the dating/meeting scene, so women who are also on the look out will be coming across "that kind" of man more often. Likewise the men who are in relationships but on the lookout for someone better, are more likely to be those pubbing, clubbing and socialising. It's like a revolving door for people who are older and havn't found "the one", with series of relationships constantly breaking down, and then the subsequent one breaks done too, etc etc., because it's all the same "gene pool" of people who are available in their 30s and 40s.

I think these days, if you don't get in there when you're young and find a decent reliable bloke by your early 20s, you're pretty much stuffed as all the decent/reliable blokes will have been snapped up by someone else and most will be "off the market" for the rest of their natural lives.

MrsKeats · 18/03/2024 12:49

Hivernal · 17/03/2024 23:55

The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone.

This.

ACynicalDad · 18/03/2024 12:48

It would be wonderful if women said we won't procreate with these shits, even if it means being alone and we took them out of the gene pool. Not sure if it's nature or nurture, but it would be a start.

Momsitter · 18/03/2024 12:33

I think it's really insidious. My brother for example is a really nice lovely guy and is also "woke".
But we were home together a few weeks ago to visit, and at lunchtime, he went and made himself the biggest, juiciest sandwich you've ever seen. Cheese, ham, tomatoes, lettuce. Not a problem, except he'd used up everything. All that was left was a tiny chunk of cheddar. So I made this ridiculous sandwich that involved this three slivers of cheddar with just butter. I said "seriously did you not think anyone else would want lunch?". Then my mum came in and I cut mine in half and gave her that.
It's just one dumb example but it says a lot. It's not about pulling anyone up on it either, it's like how could you not even think of that in the first place?

OP posts:
LifeExperience · 18/03/2024 12:10

Women in long-term, happy relationships have no reason to post on MN. I've been married to a wonderful, loving, giving man for decades, and together we raised a wonderful, loving, giving ds who makes his partner very happy. Good men are out there, but you rarely hear about them on MN because there's no reason to post about them.

I will also say this, which might be controversial--girls raised without fathers tend to settle for less worthy men, because they have no idea of how a good man acts since they haven't seen it modeled in childhood. Our dd is very selective about men because they have to meet the standard she was raised with. She's in her 20s and has only had a couple of boyfriends so far, but they have both been good, decent men who adored her. She's just not ready to settle down yet.

TotoroElla · 18/03/2024 12:08

TuliLily · 18/03/2024 09:40

Exactly this, always baffles me when people say they won't see their kids every day as if shit men suddenly step up and become great fathers once you leave, truth it most don't bother seeing their kids at all after the relationship ends, personally I know I'm alone with this but I see some child free time as one of the perks of separation 🫣

I do to but that is because my Dc have a lovely dad.

User135644 · 18/03/2024 12:00

bonzaitree · 18/03/2024 11:52

Agreed I’d be calling the police every single time.

I'tll only escalate as well. Intervention is needed early.

TinkerTiger · 18/03/2024 11:57

Hivernal · 17/03/2024 23:55

The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone.

Absolutely this. And yes of course men should be better, but the world isn't a perfect place and never will be, so while we can't control men, we can control ourselves and who we choose.

User135644 · 18/03/2024 11:52

Combattingthemoaners · 18/03/2024 11:46

Sadly I have!

You see it on here all the time.

There are plenty of women who are addicted to drama and a volatile relationship. Or if they do meet someone who is more nice and dependable they're tempted to cheat with the hot guy at work or whatever.

Nice men and nice women tend to find each other. Women who are drawn to arseholes and narcs need - for their own benefit - serious introspection to what's made them that way. Maybe it's childhood trauma, maybe they're just arseholes themselves.

We have to look beyond the superficial charm, or how much he earns and see the person underneath. What's his relationship like with his Mum, what's his Dad like, what are his mates like and the people he hangs around with the most. There will always be tells.

bonzaitree · 18/03/2024 11:52

Easipeelerie · 18/03/2024 11:01

I’d call the police about this as you’re regularly witnessing domestic abuse.

Agreed I’d be calling the police every single time.

Combattingthemoaners · 18/03/2024 11:46

Desecratedcoconut · 18/03/2024 11:06

In real life? Never.

Sadly I have!