Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think why are men still shit?

208 replies

Momsitter · 17/03/2024 23:49

Off the back of another thread I just read...

still thread after thread of abusive men. Calling their wives "fat fucks". Seeing hookers. Cheating. Cocklodging. Financial, physical, emotional abuse.
Still women raising them, marrying them, having 3 kids with them.

We've got better rhetoric and "feminism" in the media and arts, better representation in the workplace and social awareness but really fuck all is changing in relationships, is it? Why is that? What are we missing?

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 19/03/2024 14:13

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 19/03/2024 14:10

Badburyrings Yeah but this is being said in response to 'this is why men are still shit'. So by saying The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone, the woman is being blamed for men's shit behaviour. And that's wholly unfair and a totally inaccurate reason.

Your friend's husband is an abusive alcoholic bastard. His wife has stayed with him. She doesn't want to be alone. I think her choice is a bad one. It very obviously is because she's only harming herself. So, judge her choice to stay, but she is not why he's a waste of space. Even if she's what a person might call an enabler, her staying with him is not the reason he's a total assclown. If he were all alone tomorrow, without her in his life, guess what he would still be? A total assclown. Because that is what he is, not what she made him.

Ladies, give your heads a collective wobble!

Nobody is saying his behaviour is her fault. He is what he is. It’s her choice to stay with him that is being judged.

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 19/03/2024 14:10

Badburyrings Yeah but this is being said in response to 'this is why men are still shit'. So by saying The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone, the woman is being blamed for men's shit behaviour. And that's wholly unfair and a totally inaccurate reason.

Your friend's husband is an abusive alcoholic bastard. His wife has stayed with him. She doesn't want to be alone. I think her choice is a bad one. It very obviously is because she's only harming herself. So, judge her choice to stay, but she is not why he's a waste of space. Even if she's what a person might call an enabler, her staying with him is not the reason he's a total assclown. If he were all alone tomorrow, without her in his life, guess what he would still be? A total assclown. Because that is what he is, not what she made him.

Ladies, give your heads a collective wobble!

middleofthenightmediumsizedtoblerone · 19/03/2024 14:08

Lets remember abuse is not always physical. Abuse is not always overt. You have no idea what is happening behind closed doors. I can also guarantee you that some of the men you know or have known who you think are 'good men', when they get home and they are alone with their wives are not good men at all.

Of course we don't know what happens behind closed doors. It is annoying though when women say that you don't know you're own DH & DS properly when you've lived with them for 20 years as if you're some naive unintelligent person.

My first boyfriend was abusive and the second one showed signs of male chauvinism which is why it didn't last with either of them. My DH is none of these things.

I don't think it is healthy for a woman to decide all men are not nice people.

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/03/2024 14:08

So she would prefer an evening of screaming abuse at each other with him stumbling around pissed out of his head than being alone.

I wonder if some women like this have a degree of the sunk costs fallacy going on. They might also not want to admit what a terrible relationship it is, and possibly how much time they wasted and what a huge mistake it was, by ending it.

I guess if whatever you get out of the relationship makes it worth it to you then that's your business but God I hate it when it gets inflicted on children.

Badburyrings · 19/03/2024 14:03

Hivernal · 17/03/2024 23:55

The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone.

Yes this. I have several friends in awful awful marriages. One in particular springs to mind, she is retired now but had an excellent career in the city in London, earnt a small fortune and is a formidable person. Has no worries financially and could easily leave, sell the house and buy a decent detached property for herself.

Her husband is a waste of space alcoholic, has nearly burnt their house down (amongst other horrific instances), they have screaming rows, totally toxic behaviour, whenever I say to leave her answer is simple "I don't want to be on my own".

So she would prefer an evening of screaming abuse at each other with him stumbling around pissed out of his head than being alone. Each to their own I suppose!

KimberleyClark · 19/03/2024 14:02

LovelyTheresa · 19/03/2024 13:18

Except that shouting down all women who have decent standards and are dating or married to decent men actually does nothing for the women who are dealing with bad men. If you believe that 'men are shit' in general, then there can be a real 'better the devil you know' built in excuse for not leaving. If more women raised their standards early on and just moved on from the losers instead of ruminating about why they are 'all shit' there would be fewer unhappy relationships.

Exactly this 👏👏👏

SerenityNowInsanityLater · 19/03/2024 14:01

The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone.

Jesus, victim blaming by stealth. I'm amazed this comment even got accolades!

CALLI0PE Preach! I am so sick of the narrative by women about women, "She married the shit and stayed with him and that's why there are so many bad men." I'm actually gobsmacked that women even think this way. I really hope that mentality belongs to a much older generation because at least then it can be reasoned that they come from a time when women were blamed for everything. Oh wait... we still are? Seems to be the case. Goddammit, we have MILES to go.

Are we our brothers' keepers?

KimberleyClark · 19/03/2024 13:52

ohdamnitjanet · 19/03/2024 11:16

I’ve never heard a woman say this. Men very conveniently say it about women though.

I’ve heard women say this. Both on here and in real life.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 19/03/2024 13:51

CALLI0PE · 18/03/2024 09:14

They don’t show how shit they are until the woman is pregnant / just given birth , so it’s almost impossible for her to leave unless she has family who will take her in.

And it’s pretty hard to give up on your dream of a family with two parents.

And there’s plenty rhetoric out there of how HARD it is for men when they are not getting enough attention / sex / housework standards are slipping etc

So she stays and tries to make it work for the kids.

Don’t blame women for biology ( she is the one who is pregnant , gives birth and BF) .

Don't blame women for their instincts to do their best for their kids - that is one of our very best traits, don’t use it against us.

Don't blame women for the fact that society ( run by men) makes it hard to be a single mum because of the costs of childcare.

Don't blame women for the fact that most men abandon their kids after they split up with their mum and hardly any of them do 50:50.

Don’t blame women for the fact that most men don’t pay full child support and our legal and financial system lets them away with it.

I think 'blame' isn't the right term but my father was a gambler, almost lost the house with a wife and four young children under 7. I asked my Mum why she let him go on for so long, cossetted and looked after him (and us). They divorced when I was 17 at my Mum's behest.

She said that it was the thing to stay together for the children. That's possibly true but I also think that women's longing to be mothers, have a family, blinds them to the flaws of their men. Some of those flaws are deep cracks but, biology.

Dismantling the CSA should have led to the rebuilding and establishment of a far more powerful entity to force men who father children to pay for them, pay properly and not receive a single penny in benefits themselves until those children are paid for. It's still kinder than my solution of castration.

Women do get a raw deal because, biology along with societal pressure and lack of support. It's so wrong.

MarmaladeOrangey · 19/03/2024 13:49

Lets keep the blame for abuse firmly where it belongs which is 100% at the feet of the abuser. Lets not muddy the waters with turning it around of women for what they 'tolerate'. Lets keep the focus on the abusive person.

Talk of what women tolerate and individual anecdotal stories does not help women living with abuse. This sort of talk only compounds the shame that these women already feel for living in the relationships they are. These things further erode the self esteem of the abused. These are the things that keep women in abusive relationships. The abusers rely on the shame the abused feel, they rely on these women feeling like they are nothing. The abuser is already telling the abused that it is all their fault, they don't need more voices in the crowd compounding this false information. It is not ever their fault.

Lets remember abuse is not always physical. Abuse is not always overt. You have no idea what is happening behind closed doors. I can also guarantee you that some of the men you know or have known who you think are 'good men', when they get home and they are alone with their wives are not good men at all.

5128gap · 19/03/2024 13:41

middleofthenightmediumsizedtoblerone · 19/03/2024 13:26

I don't think you or other posters are being unfair to men who don't abuse. I don't need to defend the good men in my life. They know there are good and bad out there.

I do think a bunch of women agreeing with other that all men are awful is unhealthy though.

Edited

To be fair to the OP, that isn't what she invited us to do. She asked why we thought that these types of behaviour continue. I think that's a valid and useful question because understanding cause is vital to addressing the problem. It stands to reason that with such an emotive topic women will want to share their personal experiences of abuse as part of that discussion. Many survivors do indeed find it therapeutic and healthy to do so in a supportive environment. I don't think they should be begrudged a space for that on one of the only women centred forums available.

middleofthenightmediumsizedtoblerone · 19/03/2024 13:26

5128gap · 19/03/2024 13:13

Talking about domestic abuse and exploitation of women by men, and questioning why it occurs is not 'misandry'. And if your only motivation for being on a thread about these issues is to bleat about the semantics of saying men in the title, rather than 'some men'; and your key takeaway from reading about the abuse of women is that we're being unfair to men who don't abuse...well, you need to have a word with yourself.

I don't think you or other posters are being unfair to men who don't abuse. I don't need to defend the good men in my life. They know there are good and bad out there.

I do think a bunch of women agreeing with other that all men are awful is unhealthy though.

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 13:19

Either treat me with the respect I deserve, or fuck off.

AMEN to that! 🙌🙌

LovelyTheresa · 19/03/2024 13:18

5128gap · 19/03/2024 13:13

Talking about domestic abuse and exploitation of women by men, and questioning why it occurs is not 'misandry'. And if your only motivation for being on a thread about these issues is to bleat about the semantics of saying men in the title, rather than 'some men'; and your key takeaway from reading about the abuse of women is that we're being unfair to men who don't abuse...well, you need to have a word with yourself.

Except that shouting down all women who have decent standards and are dating or married to decent men actually does nothing for the women who are dealing with bad men. If you believe that 'men are shit' in general, then there can be a real 'better the devil you know' built in excuse for not leaving. If more women raised their standards early on and just moved on from the losers instead of ruminating about why they are 'all shit' there would be fewer unhappy relationships.

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 13:18

5128gap · 19/03/2024 13:13

Talking about domestic abuse and exploitation of women by men, and questioning why it occurs is not 'misandry'. And if your only motivation for being on a thread about these issues is to bleat about the semantics of saying men in the title, rather than 'some men'; and your key takeaway from reading about the abuse of women is that we're being unfair to men who don't abuse...well, you need to have a word with yourself.

You're completely twisting what I said. But OK, you do you.

TheFancyPoet · 19/03/2024 13:16

The short version is that most women would rather be with a shit man than be alone.

and do not forget, from many mens perspectives, there are shit women also.

5128gap · 19/03/2024 13:13

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 12:29

Exactly. You can't expect to use such a sweeping generalisation as: 'Why are men still shit?' on a discussion forum and not expect some posters to respond that, in their experience men - generally speaking - are NOT 'shit'.

It's important to have other points of view. Otherwise, all you've got is a misandrist echo chamber.

Talking about domestic abuse and exploitation of women by men, and questioning why it occurs is not 'misandry'. And if your only motivation for being on a thread about these issues is to bleat about the semantics of saying men in the title, rather than 'some men'; and your key takeaway from reading about the abuse of women is that we're being unfair to men who don't abuse...well, you need to have a word with yourself.

RageAgainstTheCoffeeMachine · 19/03/2024 13:12

Women are too quick to move a relationship forward.
How many women do you hear referring to their bloke as their partner when they've only been with them a few weeks and how many move in with their blokes within months of meeting them or worse still, become pregnant.
It's like they're not mentally strong enough to be alone.
They don't take their time to get to know him properly and they allow his behaviours, rather than walking away once the mask slips slightly.
A man will only treat you how you allow him to treat you.
Rather than telling him that they will not tolerate being spoken to / be treated in a certain way, they say nothing and put up with it, only for that behaviour to worsen further down the line.
I had several boyfriends ( I'll call them that, as that's what they were ) before I met my DH and the minute they criticised a family member of mine, a friend, or indeed me, they were dumped. Just the same as they were dumped for behaving badly towards me or others.
One boyfriend appeared to be lovely on the surface, but a few months in, he swore at me in a nasty way while he was attempting to fix something. Dumped, despite his apology!
Another laughed and called me thick because I didn't know the answer to something. Dumped!
Another tried to slide his hand up my top while we were kissing, despite my pushing it away. Dumped!
I had been with each of them for a few months at the point of dumping and that's just a few examples.
These are the sort of behaviours that women today tolerate, then wonder why it gets worse and they're not treated with respect.
I won't put up with a bloke who raises his voice or his hands, regardless of how long I've been with him.
Either treat me with the respect I deserve, or fuck off.

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 12:43

MarmaladeOrangey · 19/03/2024 12:33

As I said, you don't have a clue.

I may have a clue.
My MIL was regularly beaten to a pulp by one partner (not DH's dad!). She managed to get out of that relationship eventually but, still to this day, she freely admits she would rather be in an abusive relationship that was 'OK sometimes' than ever be alone.
So, unfortunately, it is a thing.

taxguru · 19/03/2024 12:39

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/03/2024 12:05

Plenty of domestic abusers beat up their partners and present a perfect face to the rest of the world.

I'm not saying there aren't.

What I'm saying is that "some" women go into relationships with their eyes open knowing that their bloke is a "bad boy" and then suffer the, usually, entirely foreseeable consequences. Often the signs are there.

Those who are in relationships with blokes who manage to "hide" ALL aspects of being unreliable, criminal, aggressive, etc., have indeed been incredibly unlikely if there were no signs at all and the bloke did manage to pull off a "perfect" image in all aspects during the early stages of their relationship.

NonPlayerCharacter · 19/03/2024 12:37

0sm0nthus · 19/03/2024 12:36

Predators will gravitate towards those who are easy victims; those who come from dysfunctional or abusive backgrounds, they have been subjugated and weakened by others and it's easy for the predatory types to step in and take over.

Some of them go for more difficult ones; there's a kind of man who enjoys "breaking" a strong woman.

LovelyTheresa · 19/03/2024 12:37

MarmaladeOrangey · 19/03/2024 12:33

As I said, you don't have a clue.

How do you know? I actually pulled the plug on more than one relationship that I didn't like: I don't know if it would have ended up as abusive or not, but I didn't like the way it made me feel, so I ended it and ended up with my wonderful husband. Maybe my picker is stronger, who knows, or maybe I just have a higher self worth so I wouldn't settle. All I know is that I am not stuck with a crap man and miserable kids.

0sm0nthus · 19/03/2024 12:36

Predators will gravitate towards those who are easy victims; those who come from dysfunctional or abusive backgrounds, they have been subjugated and weakened by others and it's easy for the predatory types to step in and take over.

LovelyTheresa · 19/03/2024 12:35

middleofthenightmediumsizedtoblerone · 19/03/2024 12:33

I was once told on here I was naive because I said I was pretty confident that my DH wouldn't murder me one day.

OMG. These people cannot bear the fact that they have picked crap men doesn't mean that all men are crap. They would rather fling out 'not my Nigel' insults than do the work on themselves that would maybe help them understand why they pick such losers. It is sad, really.

middleofthenightmediumsizedtoblerone · 19/03/2024 12:33

Jumpingthruhoops · 19/03/2024 12:29

Exactly. You can't expect to use such a sweeping generalisation as: 'Why are men still shit?' on a discussion forum and not expect some posters to respond that, in their experience men - generally speaking - are NOT 'shit'.

It's important to have other points of view. Otherwise, all you've got is a misandrist echo chamber.

I was once told on here I was naive because I said I was pretty confident that my DH wouldn't murder me one day.

Swipe left for the next trending thread