Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Portion size and DH - crumb of perspective needed

140 replies

BakedPotato10 · 17/03/2024 19:15

Name changed

My Husband's done all the cooking today as I'm working on a project - not unusual, we share the life stuff depending who is free.

He made me sourdough and egg this morning for breakfast, around 500 calories I'd say. I've not eaten since and then he made this for dinner at 5ish.
For context, I used to have a physically active job and so have gained weight since being desk based. Peri menopause and increased stress have further cemented bad habits but I am actively working on better routines.

I had a 'feast or famine' childhood with periods of food shortage and food not always equally shared (not abusive, just not positive relationships with food) and so I'm very open to the possibility I'm projecting as I know I struggle with food shortages and dislike greed - maybe I just haven't noticed it in myself until now? But I am also conscious that I don't want further food issues, I eat a lot of fruit and veg and value a good relationship with food. Lately it's feeling quite stressful when I'm with DH.

I do feel that DH portions and attitude to food (increasingly smaller portions, usually only ever 2 meals a day at weekend, referring to food as 'naughty' etc) have only begun since I put on weight. But I'm aware my appetite might just have crept right up and I'm the one who's changed, not him. I feel like I'm being dieted and it's triggering food issues. So I'd like a little perspective please.

YABU - That's plenty of food for a day. Sourdough and egg, jacket potato with chickpea in mayo (a veggie version of tuna mayo) with salad

YANBU - That's not much food for a day.

Portion size and DH - crumb of perspective needed
OP posts:
mrsbyers · 17/03/2024 21:52

That’s the kind of meal I’d have if I’d had a large lunch earlier tbh - I know you didn’t

CantFindTheBeat · 17/03/2024 21:49

No food is 'naughty'.

Your husband should not be policing your food intake or habits.

What you eat or don't eat is for you to decide.

Take back control. Either cook for yourself for a while, or be clear about what you want and how much of it.

learieonthewildmoor · 17/03/2024 21:34

If my DH served that for dinner, I’d be asking where the rest was. That is half a meal.
According to my dietitian, a controlled portion on a plate contains a quarter protein, a quarter carbs and half salad/veg.
Tell your DH to lift his game and stop starving you.

IwishMaxTheriothadanOnlyfans · 17/03/2024 21:32

I'm dieting at the minute (26lb down since New Year) and today I had:

Breakfast: 3 soft boiled eggs, two slices wholemeal toast with lurpak lighter

Snack: banana

Lunch: Subway Chicken salad (double meat and MASSIVE) with extra spicy chipotle sauce

Snack: Grapes (probably 1/2 punnet)

Dinner: Garlic Parmesan Chicken Skewers with greek flatbread, mushrooms, onions and peppers

Snack: Chocolate protein pudding

Just about to finish off my day with a cup of milky tea and 2 Rich Tea Light biscuits.

This is a pretty typical day for me and I'm losing 2+ lb per week. Oooh, forgot, I also had a gin and sparkling water with dinner.

I like my diet A LOT better than your DHs idea of one - tell him it's a shit one and won't sell.

Seaside3 · 17/03/2024 21:31

It looks fine for me, I'd add more salad, maybe a small half a potato extra.

But what worries me more is how he speaks about food. Please, please explain to him how talking about food like this is triggering to you, and how your daughter is at a very vulnerable age.

Good luck with improving both your relationships with food.

RealHedgehog · 17/03/2024 21:31

YANBU. You got hungry, you need three balanced meals a day and to listen to your hunger signals.

Skipping meals is a quick way to spark a binge eating problem, especially when your relationship with food has been affected by scarcity and issues in your childhood (no judgement- I'm in a similar boat).

It's possible your DH thinks he's helping you, especially if you've told him you want to lose weight. You need to have a chat with him about it and just tell him what you're thinking. He might just want to help and will support you with whatever plan you want to follow.

IME men can be very solution-oriented and go 'You want to lose weight? I'll make you 1500 calories of food. Problem solved', without engaging properly with the problem in the first instance, i.e your body changing with your circumstances and a complex relationship with food. And he needs to know it's not working for you and is instead creating more problems.

All that said, it sounds like he is willing to help and wants to take care of you, even if he's going about it imperfectly.

diddl · 17/03/2024 21:31

I think if he's eating the same it's fine.

Sometimes we have lighter days as we are doing bugger all!

Today I had a crumpet for breakfast, carbonara for lunch & a scone for tea.

(Not lighter in calories I realise!)

Attryn · 17/03/2024 21:27

I wouldn't accept that as a dinner even if I'd had lunch! It doesn't look like enough food for me, and I wouldn't want to top up on snacks so I'd be a bit cross about it.

Luckily my DH, who currently does all the cooking, knows to give me a decent meal in the evening.

But clearly some people do think this is enough (they probably are also the type of people who think soup is ok for dinner) so I think you just need to mention to DH that it's not what you think of as a dinner, for future reference.

I don't think you need to be grateful for a substandard meal! The whole point of cooking a meal is to give people enough to eat, and he hasn't.

Winnipeggy · 17/03/2024 21:18

I have so many questions.

Does he always cook for you? Are you able to make your own food? If you feel like he is trying to control your eating then I'd take back control and make my own food (I do anyway)

What would happen if you had lunch or snacked in between? Would he comment?

Does he himself have food issues? Because it sounds like he very much does.

I find this a little odd tbh. It seems a little controlling but it depends on his more general reaction to you eating. Does he comment on your food choices all the time?

My advice would be cook for yourself and have a conversation with him about not wanting any more negative food talk because you find it upsetting.

Fwiw I could easily live off this but it's unusual not to have lunch. You should have done if you were hungry.

KvotheTheBloodless · 17/03/2024 21:17

Honestly, you need to talk to him about his emotive language around food. Calling a meal 'naughty' or saying "'you'll never eat all that" is really triggering to someone with food issues, even if most of the trauma is way in the past.

I had anorexia as a teenager, DH is aware, and has always been careful not to attach feelings to food or comment on how much I'm eating - I'm an adult, what I eat is my business unless I become unheathily underweight.

Sounds like you need a calm discussion with DH about his language surrounding eating.

Tbry24 · 17/03/2024 21:14

BakedPotato10 · 17/03/2024 20:21

That's the exact issue. I work really hard to have a positive relationship with food and not see one as 'good' and another 'bad' but to to encourage we all 'eat the rainbow' - whether that's mayo slathered coleslaw or steamed broccoli. But his wording and attitude towards food is triggering me. We have a teenager, eating disorders are rife with the rise of social media. I don't want to hear "you'll never eat all that", or "oh my favourite, I like a naughty dinner".

He's a good, gentle, kind and intelligent man. I know he's not a person who would deliberately cause pain but none the less, he is.

I'll try and chat with him when I can think how to word the issue. Or he'll think it's about a jacket potato and I'll get 3 next time 😕😂

Poor you 😰. I need to be able to sit quietly and enjoy my food whatever it maybe and however much I need or don’t need to fill me up at that point in time.

those sorts of comments are really triggering for me too ….if I hear stuff like that (even if I’m out and say it’s someone saying it about someone else’s food on a bench near me) I stop eating completely and then later on go and raid my fridge and eat in private and no one knows what I ate. It’s all to do with my childhood and one of my parent… just didn’t realise this until my mid 40s.

FasterthanaButteredOtter · 17/03/2024 21:13

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 17/03/2024 19:25

i'm confused; you said eggs on sourdough for breakfast (unless 3 eggs and 2 slices of bread with a load a butter it won't be 500cals)
then this photo is again egg salad on toast/bread with a green side salad?
not the portion size but the lack of variety and potentially the number of eggs it's not balanced at all.

READ!!! the OP again. It's chickpea mayo, not egg on a jacket potato.

Baileyqueen · 17/03/2024 21:13

I’d need more salad than that, otherwise it seems okay.

HungryBeagle · 17/03/2024 21:11

DaoineSidhe · 17/03/2024 21:09

Jesus that is not a dinner, I can't believe the above responses. I'd tell him to just order a takeaway if this is what he came up with - is this what he ate himself? Not normal at all, that is not a dinner and anyone who thinks it is has food issues. He is trying to 'diet you' for want of a better way of putting it.

I’m fat, and that’s a normal sort of dinner for me. I’d have another meal in the day though.

DaoineSidhe · 17/03/2024 21:09

Jesus that is not a dinner, I can't believe the above responses. I'd tell him to just order a takeaway if this is what he came up with - is this what he ate himself? Not normal at all, that is not a dinner and anyone who thinks it is has food issues. He is trying to 'diet you' for want of a better way of putting it.

Wigtopia · 17/03/2024 21:06

Weekends I often only have two meals. Mainly because I will have a later, breakfast than usual, and like you won’t feel hungry at lunch. Jacket potato and salad is a perfectly good meal and with chick peas includes protein too. But if after the potatoe you’re still hungry, listen to your stomach and have something else! A bowl of cereal? Some more of the yummy sounding sourdough?

YANBU to feel hungry - people will have peaks and lows of hunger based on loads of things and can vary day by day.

however

YABU to not take responsibility for your hunger and eat something else if you’re still hungry. I don’t think this is a DH problem (unless he is commenting on/ preventing you from eating anything else - I really hope this is not the case). It sounds like he has tried to make lovely food for you.

honeylulu · 17/03/2024 21:06

I'd be delighted. My husband does most of the weekend meals and they are nearly always huge portions (and delicious so I can't help eating it all). I used to be able to eat tons and stay size 8 but peri and a less active post covid life and getting into the habit of stretchy clothing means I've piled on weight and I'd really like to shift it. H is a feeder - it's his love language. But I end up eating even when I'm not hungry because beautiful meals are plonked in front of me. Maybe your H is the same but with a "healthy" slant?

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 17/03/2024 21:04

@HungryBeagle and @Tbry24
it's not about me and the fact i've never seen anything presented like this despite the op's clear description.
with hungy's explanation and your's T i can see how this could work.
back to whole food/portion size.

Tbry24 · 17/03/2024 21:00

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 17/03/2024 20:56

except @HungryBeagle i've NEVER seen chickpeas presented ON a baked potato and the angle of the photo looked like egg salad on toast.

It’s delicious I make it it’s called a deli topping in my fridge . It’s tin of chickpeas mashed, carrot and onion or other stuff mixed with mayonaise. Gorgeous on potatoes, in sandwiches or on its own 😁

Tbry24 · 17/03/2024 20:58

Very similar to what I have so egg on toast (plus spinach, tomatoes, mushrooms or grapes with it depending on what’s in the fridge) for brunch, baked potato topping and (a much bigger) salad for tea but you’ve still skipped your lunch or the third meal? I tend to have a piece of fruit or something about 3ish and then what would have been my lunch like crackers and cheese or a sandwich and a second piece of fruit I have for supper. So yes you’ve missed an entire meal.

i am trying to get myself back on track as to when and how I eat too….toxic childhood and food being part of that as well sadly. Makes life hard as an adult and your husband is certainly making it much harder than he needs to as well. No idea why he thinks behaving like that would help.

HungryBeagle · 17/03/2024 20:58

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 17/03/2024 20:56

except @HungryBeagle i've NEVER seen chickpeas presented ON a baked potato and the angle of the photo looked like egg salad on toast.

Fine, but if you’d read the OP you’d have seen that that’s what it was!

CurlsnSunshinetime4tea · 17/03/2024 20:56

except @HungryBeagle i've NEVER seen chickpeas presented ON a baked potato and the angle of the photo looked like egg salad on toast.

BakedPotato10 · 17/03/2024 20:21

Thisisnotarehearsal · 17/03/2024 20:15

It's not really about the amount of food though is it?

Different people have different needs. My DHs needs and mine are so far apart it's laughable. I'd say he's eaten triple what I've had today and I'm fat, while he's like a rake.

It's not about that fact that on this occasion he cooked. The bar for men is low on Mumsnet and a man doing is share is practically revered and women are expected to be pathetically grateful.

It's about the unhealthy attitude he is fostering towards food, that it is sinful, an indulgence or as you said 'naughty'.

Perhaps chat to him and tell him how it is coming across. He may not even realise he's raining you if he's shoveling snacks into himself all day.

That's the exact issue. I work really hard to have a positive relationship with food and not see one as 'good' and another 'bad' but to to encourage we all 'eat the rainbow' - whether that's mayo slathered coleslaw or steamed broccoli. But his wording and attitude towards food is triggering me. We have a teenager, eating disorders are rife with the rise of social media. I don't want to hear "you'll never eat all that", or "oh my favourite, I like a naughty dinner".

He's a good, gentle, kind and intelligent man. I know he's not a person who would deliberately cause pain but none the less, he is.

I'll try and chat with him when I can think how to word the issue. Or he'll think it's about a jacket potato and I'll get 3 next time 😕😂

OP posts:
Noicant · 17/03/2024 20:20

Honestly I have no idea what Dh has eaten during the day, even when we are home together. I would make what I make and if Dh needed more he would add something and vice versa. The negative language around food would bother me but it may not be directed at you.

Also that looks like a small potato to me. I ate 1300 calories today and my meals looked much bigger (I only eat 2 meals a day) and yeah salad doesn’t count (I love it, ate a bucket of tabbouleh today) but no-one ever got stuffed eating a mixed leaf salad.

DrCoconut · 17/03/2024 20:16

It would be a light lunch for me and I'd then need dinner too. My ex was extremely controlling around eating and it really messed my relationship with food up, possibly forever (I'm not saying needing dinner is messed up btw, more that I feel very on edge if I'm not sure I can source food for me and my kids).

Swipe left for the next trending thread