Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Portion size and DH - crumb of perspective needed

140 replies

BakedPotato10 · 17/03/2024 19:15

Name changed

My Husband's done all the cooking today as I'm working on a project - not unusual, we share the life stuff depending who is free.

He made me sourdough and egg this morning for breakfast, around 500 calories I'd say. I've not eaten since and then he made this for dinner at 5ish.
For context, I used to have a physically active job and so have gained weight since being desk based. Peri menopause and increased stress have further cemented bad habits but I am actively working on better routines.

I had a 'feast or famine' childhood with periods of food shortage and food not always equally shared (not abusive, just not positive relationships with food) and so I'm very open to the possibility I'm projecting as I know I struggle with food shortages and dislike greed - maybe I just haven't noticed it in myself until now? But I am also conscious that I don't want further food issues, I eat a lot of fruit and veg and value a good relationship with food. Lately it's feeling quite stressful when I'm with DH.

I do feel that DH portions and attitude to food (increasingly smaller portions, usually only ever 2 meals a day at weekend, referring to food as 'naughty' etc) have only begun since I put on weight. But I'm aware my appetite might just have crept right up and I'm the one who's changed, not him. I feel like I'm being dieted and it's triggering food issues. So I'd like a little perspective please.

YABU - That's plenty of food for a day. Sourdough and egg, jacket potato with chickpea in mayo (a veggie version of tuna mayo) with salad

YANBU - That's not much food for a day.

Portion size and DH - crumb of perspective needed
OP posts:
justanothermanicmonday1 · 18/03/2024 02:08

Gymmum82 · 17/03/2024 19:18

That’s a fine portion of food for a meal. More likely a lunch. So the egg and bread for breakfast would be good. That would be my lunch and I would have another meal for dinner. That would equate to roughly 1500kcal and would be fine to loose weight on should that be your goal.
2 meals a day would likely just lead to binge eating after a few days/week as it’s not enough food to sustain

her breakfast was 500kcal.

this is NOT an extra 1000kcal.

500 max.

YANBU. This is lunch portion, OP.

JordanPeterson · 18/03/2024 02:02

I practice a carnivorous only diet so this type of food is not recommended for weight loss in our community

But even for a standard diet this day's worth of food was carb heavy & lacking in protein

Sourdough for breakfast topped off with a potato slathered in chickpeas

While it's a decent amount of food f or a sedentary person of our age, the wrong food choices (or offerings in this case) are the downfall

It's unsurprising to experience a blood sugar drop & to feel cranky come dinner time when eating this way

If a partner is cooking not just one but 2 meals for their significant other then it's good practice to express gratitude for their effort in order to nurture a harmonious relationship.

If, after advising them that a larger serve is required they will have the option to either just cook more next time, or they may choose that moment to address an ongoing weight issue.

By voicing the desire to have an increased portion, the partner is afforded the opportunity to react in a positive way & gives the partner the benefit of the doubt in regards to their motive behind the provided portion size.

Fraaahnces · 18/03/2024 01:41

It’s fine for dinner IF you are eating 3 meals. Your metabolism will go to shit if you are not eating enough. I would recommend that you grab a protein shake somewhere in the day to fill you up and increase your metabolism. (And what he doesn’t know won’t hurt him.)

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 18/03/2024 01:36

I would be more concerned about my husband using the word ' naughty ' in relation to food - what are you 2 years old ?

and a 5pm meal would be a late lunch for me, and I would then have dinner later on i.e. 8pm onwards.

But then if he is in the habit of only eating 2 meals at a weekend, you now know to go into the kitchen at lunchtime and sort yourself some lunch.

HollyKnight · 18/03/2024 01:12

Forget what your eyes say, what does your body say? Were you still hungry after eating it?

KattyBoomBoom95 · 18/03/2024 00:42

DaoineSidhe · 18/03/2024 00:15

Honestly how a jacket potato with chickpeas? Even if it was an absolutely enormous potato? I am not being confrontational or trying to be mean, I really don't understand? That dinner is about 500 calories at best

About a third of a woman's recommended daily intake?

DaoineSidhe · 18/03/2024 00:15

Simonjt · 17/03/2024 23:19

I weigh 98kg, that is a completely normal meal for me.

Honestly how a jacket potato with chickpeas? Even if it was an absolutely enormous potato? I am not being confrontational or trying to be mean, I really don't understand? That dinner is about 500 calories at best

PyongyangKipperbang · 18/03/2024 00:01

I have an eating disorder, I find it very hard to eat every day even once.

But I feed my kids normally, I feed guests normally as I know what a normal meal looks like I just cant eat one but when I saw that picture even I thought "Fuck, is that it?!"

That to me is a lunch, it is not a dinner. If you speak to him he will say he thought it was enough and make some bullshit excuse. So next time you cook, give him the same sort of portion he gave you today and when he mentions it say "Oh well you said that a small potato with a toppping was enough so I assumed you had decided to eat less!"

KattyBoomBoom95 · 17/03/2024 23:26

I'd eat double that meal but I train a lot.

RobertaFirmino · 17/03/2024 23:24

When someone puts a plate of food in front of you, the correct response is 'Thank You'. Not happy with the food? That's your problem, it's up to you to sort it out.

Simonjt · 17/03/2024 23:23

As above it would be a fine evening meal for me, I do most of our cooking, I don’t change our meal plans if my husband has decided to skip a meal, he’s a grown up, so if he’s still hungry thats something he can solve himself.

Simonjt · 17/03/2024 23:19

DaoineSidhe · 17/03/2024 21:09

Jesus that is not a dinner, I can't believe the above responses. I'd tell him to just order a takeaway if this is what he came up with - is this what he ate himself? Not normal at all, that is not a dinner and anyone who thinks it is has food issues. He is trying to 'diet you' for want of a better way of putting it.

I weigh 98kg, that is a completely normal meal for me.

Toastjusttoast · 17/03/2024 22:53

I get where you’re coming from. I haven’t had eating issues myself but I’ve had friends and relatives who have and that kind of language still makes me uncomfortable. I’d ask him nicely to stop.

gannett · 17/03/2024 22:52

I think the strangest thing isn't the portion size but that you and your husband didn't communicate over what he was making at any point. "I'm absolutely ravenous because I missed lunch" from you; "I'll make dinner, shall I do a jacket potato and salad" from him. Then if you feel that won't be enough you can top it up with something else without being disappointed.

(The portion size would be fine on some days, not fine on others, there isn't a strict norm.)

(I couldn't be doing with his comments about naughty food though. Eating shouldn't make you feel guilty, food isn't naughty. I'd tell him to cut that out, then stuff my face with cake.)

Igam · 17/03/2024 22:51

I’d have been fine with the 2 meals but definitely would have eaten snacks in between. Mainly chocolate because sadly I’m addicted to it. But if being healthy, some fruit.

5128gap · 17/03/2024 22:28

Well, I'm 54, not very active and maintain a BMI of 21 so you can tell I don't over eat, and I think that is a tiny and inadequate main meal. It looks like only half a potato for starters. It's a light lunch. How much did DH serve himself out of interest, and what had he eaten that day? If he'd eaten similar and isn't watching his weight I'd say he was maybe just projecting his appetite onto you. Otherwise, and if as you say its a trend, I agree he's putting you on a diet.

Catsandcuddles · 17/03/2024 22:27

It wouldn't be enough for me, sometimes I'll only have 2 meals , but I would always have a couple of snacks and there is no mention of snacks at all? 5pm is also quite early to have your last meal.

I calorie count, so based on your meals i would estimate the eggs and sourdough toast to be around 400-500 calories. Based on 2 slices of bread with 2 or 3 eggs. If your DH is health conscious I reckon he's been light on the butter.

Jacket with chickpea mayo and salad, around 400 cal , and even that could even be generous to be honest as the portion size is small and more like a lunch rather than an evening meal..

So you've consumed around 900 calories of food, it is no wonder you feel hungry. If your H isnt hungry but you, you could add a healthy and filling snack such as greek yogurt with fresh fruit and honey for around 250 cal. You would still be well under 1500 cals per day.

DailySnail · 17/03/2024 22:23

I have nothing further to add in relation to the portion size. But I just wanted to say good for you having the self-awareness to question if your childhood experiences were colouring what you were feeling rather than just lashing out at DH.
That's a really challenging thing for most adults to do.

moonfacer · 17/03/2024 22:21

BakedPotato10 · 17/03/2024 19:15

Name changed

My Husband's done all the cooking today as I'm working on a project - not unusual, we share the life stuff depending who is free.

He made me sourdough and egg this morning for breakfast, around 500 calories I'd say. I've not eaten since and then he made this for dinner at 5ish.
For context, I used to have a physically active job and so have gained weight since being desk based. Peri menopause and increased stress have further cemented bad habits but I am actively working on better routines.

I had a 'feast or famine' childhood with periods of food shortage and food not always equally shared (not abusive, just not positive relationships with food) and so I'm very open to the possibility I'm projecting as I know I struggle with food shortages and dislike greed - maybe I just haven't noticed it in myself until now? But I am also conscious that I don't want further food issues, I eat a lot of fruit and veg and value a good relationship with food. Lately it's feeling quite stressful when I'm with DH.

I do feel that DH portions and attitude to food (increasingly smaller portions, usually only ever 2 meals a day at weekend, referring to food as 'naughty' etc) have only begun since I put on weight. But I'm aware my appetite might just have crept right up and I'm the one who's changed, not him. I feel like I'm being dieted and it's triggering food issues. So I'd like a little perspective please.

YABU - That's plenty of food for a day. Sourdough and egg, jacket potato with chickpea in mayo (a veggie version of tuna mayo) with salad

YANBU - That's not much food for a day.

That wouldn’t be enough for me.

I am currently 10.5 stone and losing weight at a rate of two pounds a week, and I would need to have at least the same for lunch and dinner. If skipping lunch, then I would need a bigger dinner.

Edit: didn’t mean to quote the opening post.

Isitbedtimeyet3 · 17/03/2024 22:19

It needs more protein. It’s very carb heavy which isn’t going to help weight loss. And you need to have a lunch.

JudgeJ · 17/03/2024 22:16

Merrow · 17/03/2024 19:22

How old is your DH? I've noticed with my relatives that their hunger has nosedived with age and they very commonly just eat two meals a day.

Edited

If they are like me they possibly get up late, have breakfast around 10 30 or 11 then eat something in the evening.

SingCat · 17/03/2024 22:11

I

Tagyoureit · 17/03/2024 22:02

For fucks sake, you're an adult!!

Eat the bloody food and if you're still hungry, have some bloody fruit!!

How is this even a fucking thread??? Please grow up!

Freakinfraser · 17/03/2024 21:58

I know he's not a person who would deliberately cause pain but none the less, he is.

im afraid the issue is you. Not him. Your eating and your reaction to food is very unhealthy. Sitting there waiting to be fed, missing lunch, complaining, looking for hidden actions like dieting uou, and taking exception to words.

its you. Get some therapy if you cannot move on from your childhood, it happens and it’s ok. Understandable even, but accept it’s you and you need help instead of behaving in a punitive manner to,your husband, he doesn’t need having a word with.

msmatcha · 17/03/2024 21:57

The food looks and sounds lovely. Portions are fine... but only if you have three meals a day. You needed lunch - like most of us!