Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To choose heart over head when buying a house?

67 replies

VeryWeirdBarbie · 17/03/2024 18:42

It's just DH and me and we're moving house - trying to choose between two good options. We're in our 50s and DH is about to retire. I'll still be working.

House 1 is a small modern 3 bedroom detached in a nice estate with its own private drive. It's on at £350k and needs about £30k of work. It's a practical house - it has a garage, it's near a small park for walking the dog, great neighbourhood, lots of shops nearby. It's an estate mostly full of young families. The house is maybe a bit boring but also quiet and calm and very practical.

House 2 is a slightly larger 3 bedroom but is less quiet and private. It's a Victorian end terraced with a residents parking scheme and no front garden so people would be walking right past the living room window. It's on a cul de sac and there's a pub with live music a couple of streets away. It's also a great convenient neighbourhood with lots of shops but younger - lots of renters in their 20s live on the street.There always seem to be parking spots available.

The thing we love about house 2 is that it's right by the canal (not the towpath side). There's a lovely extension with big windows over the canal and a pretty canalside garden, and views of the canal from many other windows. Pretty canal boats pass by. It has a shed but no garage. It's on at £300k and probably needs £10k of work.

So do we choose house 1 (head) or house 2 (heart)? We'd be cash buyers for either, but house 2 would leave us with money spare for lots of nice holidays. House 1 would mean tightening our belts a little bit.

Which would you choose please?
YABU = buy House 1 don't buy an impractical house, that would be stressful
YANBU = but House 2 it would be more interesting and charming and you only live once

OP posts:
ErinAoife · 17/03/2024 20:23

Option 1 for me, just because I lived near a canal and house got flood. We were only rented but it really put it me off buying near a river/canal.

NahNeedsGarlic · 17/03/2024 20:16

Neither house, keep looking until you find one that covers both head and heart, to some degree.

BlackboardMonitorVimes · 17/03/2024 20:10

If you like the pub then surely the decision is made Wink

VeryWeirdBarbie · 17/03/2024 20:08

The pub looks really nice and friendly. We're planning on going this Friday night when they'll have live music on. In the name of research, of course!

OP posts:
BendingSpoons · 17/03/2024 19:58

I like the sound of no. 2 and more money left for holidays. But I would buy no.1. For me, the privacy and practicality would win.

BlackboardMonitorVimes · 17/03/2024 19:58

What's the pub like? Is it a locals only dive bar, loud youngsters place or somewhere that you would go? If the third option, then I'd see it as a plus point myself.

Championfancy · 17/03/2024 19:51

Always do what sets your heart on fire

user8800 · 17/03/2024 19:50

Detached.
No brainer.

HeddaGarbled · 17/03/2024 19:47

Neither. You don’t love 1 and house 2 has too many drawbacks. Keep looking.

Kismet79 · 17/03/2024 19:45

I often get persuaded to go with my head... And then regret it!!

Definitely go with your heart, you'll forgive the inconveniences.

The first house sounds a bit dull tbh. The second sounds wonderful!

Zippedydoodahday · 17/03/2024 19:42

House one sounds uninspiring and a bit depressing. I say follow your heart and go with the lovely charming canal side property.

Keeprejoining · 17/03/2024 19:40

If the canal floods, where does the runoff go?

GreekDogRescue · 17/03/2024 19:39

I’d go with my heart

Mmhmmn · 17/03/2024 19:37

YOLO

BlackboardMonitorVimes · 17/03/2024 19:36

I've already mentally moved into house number two.... house number one sounds safe and boring, do that in 20 years.

PurpleFlower1983 · 17/03/2024 19:31

House 2! But I live in a Victorian end terrace that I love so I may be biased.

Shetlands · 17/03/2024 19:28

I'd look at other houses because neither sounds right. Number 1 doesn't grab you and number 2 would probably drive you mad with renting neighbours in their 20s, street parking and people walking past your living room window.

Are you in a rush to move because if not, I'd bide your time and wait for other properties to come on the market.

GoingOnHol · 17/03/2024 19:20

Re: the canal never flooding, we had really horrendous flooding on 20th Oct the likes of which hadn't been seen for about 70 years. So it could happen even if very, very unlikely.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12658021/Storm-Babet-leaves-entire-village-underwater-floods-devastate-swathes-Britain-travel-disruption-expected-continue-today.html

I would never choose to live somewhere noisy even if the canal wasn't close by, the pub/semi-detached would put me off after having a bad experience with noisy neighbours. I'd never go back to on street parking either, we rarely had an issue getting a spot on the road but our own drive is sooo much easier.

Storm Babet leaves entire village underwater

Images revealed family cars in Yorkshire being swallowed whole in dirty waters and Derbyshire homes immersed in a seemingly endless reservoir.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-12658021/Storm-Babet-leaves-entire-village-underwater-floods-devastate-swathes-Britain-travel-disruption-expected-continue-today.html

VeryWeirdBarbie · 17/03/2024 19:09

I've always had my own drive except when I lived in flats and didn't have a car. That's my #1 concern I would say. In terms of heating an old house, our last house was a larger Victorian money pit and was expensive to heat, so we're used to that and don't like to have the house very warm anyway (18 is the upper limit of how warm we'd want to be).

OP posts:
alwayslearning789 · 17/03/2024 19:09

Scottishskifun · 17/03/2024 19:05

I don't like new builds so would chose house 2 but I would warn you that 10k on a old house is a drop in the ocean. There is always something which needs doing.

I absolutely love my victorian cottage but it is a money pit and we usually save double to what a quote is as we know there will be something encountered.

Our house isn't cold but because we have a wood burner which heats the house. Even with wall insulation our heating struggles to get above 18 degrees in winter. So if you don't have a wood burner etc in it then also factor in higher fuel bills.

Would also cost up house insurance even though it doesn't flood it can be difficult to get insurance near water.

This.

Hasn't flooded - yet - but near water means insurance will be priced accordingly.

Given the issues you have mentioned re- Age Proofing, would definitely recommend Head over Heart at this stage of the game.

Scottishskifun · 17/03/2024 19:05

I don't like new builds so would chose house 2 but I would warn you that 10k on a old house is a drop in the ocean. There is always something which needs doing.

I absolutely love my victorian cottage but it is a money pit and we usually save double to what a quote is as we know there will be something encountered.

Our house isn't cold but because we have a wood burner which heats the house. Even with wall insulation our heating struggles to get above 18 degrees in winter. So if you don't have a wood burner etc in it then also factor in higher fuel bills.

Would also cost up house insurance even though it doesn't flood it can be difficult to get insurance near water.

TwigletsAndRadishes · 17/03/2024 19:02

If house 2 had its own off street parking I'd pick that every time, because I am a sucker for character and period homes with lovely features and beautiful outlooks and I will put up with a certain amount of impracticality to have that. But if you've been used to a private driveway I think it will drive you absolutely potty not to have one. Especially if you are hoping to live there into your old age.

ChazsBrilliantAttitude · 17/03/2024 19:02

How well do you know the canal area? Does it get a lot of insects in the summer?

Boring practical stuff
Have you considered proximity of shops, public transport, GP, clubs and sports etc.

What might you need to access as you get older? DH and I are in our 50’s and we are having to start thinking practically about what we might want as we get older and when we stop work.

DrJoanAllenby · 17/03/2024 19:02

Location is key.

Mumdiva99 · 17/03/2024 19:01

Canal every time. (If the head house was more expensive there may be a dilemma - but it isn't.)

Of you get old and infirm and can't go out much - which has a better outlook? Surely a garden overlooking the canal and lovely windows to look out of would win every time.