Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be fuming at my mum over birthday present?

419 replies

SilverSeat · 17/03/2024 16:37

DDs birthday on Wednesday. My mum asked me ages ago what she wanted and I said “well all she keeps going on about is this princess castle so I’m getting her that”. My mum said “oh can I get her that? I don’t know what else to get her”. I said “it’s expensive though, £80” my mum said “oh that’s fine!”.

now my mum has form for buying the complete opposite of what you’ve told her so I showed her a picture of it, the make, where to buy it etc - she said that’s fine. I said “ok if you’re definitely getting her that exact castle (it had to be that one as her cousin has it and DD is obsessed with it, as I explained) I’ll get her the electric car”.

i bought the car £80. My mum called yesterday and said she’d got the castle - great. She then added “it was a bargain! It was only £25!” My heart sank … I said “it can’t have been, where did you get it from??” And she told me the name of this shop. I asked her to send me a photo?” So she did …

it’s the complete opposite of what I showed her. It’s a grey medieval castle with soldiers and cannons etc. I said “I told you it was the pink princess castle!” And she said “Her dolls will fit in it though”

FFS

DD thinks she’s getting the princess castle and is so excited, now I have to go out and buy the bloody thing after already buying the car. My mum is “upset” that I’m replacing her present. She used to do this kind of shit to me when I was a kid and I’m not allowing DD to go through it. She cocked up one of her Christmas presents in the same manner. AIBU to be really fucking annoyed and AIBU to replace the present?

Id rather she didn’t buy her a present at all then at least I’d know what to buy!!

OP posts:
IngridPrice · 19/03/2024 18:18

I wouldn’t have told her she was getting it or trusted my mother to buy something so expensive knowing she would do something like that! Not that mine would! But common sense in future tells you tell your mother something cheaper you know she can afford and go with her!
Anything so expensive you buy, then no confusion no tears and tantrums, but £80 for a plastic castle 😱for a child’s birthday! Christmas maybe? unless they had been undually ill and made a spectacular recovery or something? Why not suggest going halves instead and you get it something else!? But maybe make sure she has the share of cost? Don’t forget you do this once you’re daughter is going to expect this and bigger things every year im assuming at the moment she is your only child and maybe not your mother’s only grandchild?

Daffy88 · 19/03/2024 17:14

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 19/03/2024 17:02

I'm sure there are some parents out there who are deliberately looking for excuses to sadden and disappoint their children, by passing it off as 'discipline'. Poor little mites.

Yep! I can only assume that some posters on here don't actually have children of their own (or at least I hope they don't!). What sad childhoods they must have had themselves if they really believe that such unnecessary, awful treatment is the norm. 😩

Lookingatthesunset · 19/03/2024 17:08

Bearbooandmiska · 19/03/2024 15:40

Why tell her that's what she's getting. Kids don't have to have everything all at once. They don't need to have everything the same as cousins etc.

How do you compute ONE TOY into "everything"????!!

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 19/03/2024 17:02

I'm sure there are some parents out there who are deliberately looking for excuses to sadden and disappoint their children, by passing it off as 'discipline'. Poor little mites.

Daffy88 · 19/03/2024 16:56

Bearbooandmiska · 19/03/2024 15:40

Why tell her that's what she's getting. Kids don't have to have everything all at once. They don't need to have everything the same as cousins etc.

Because that is what she really wanted for her birthday. She is five! Giving her the one present that she has been wanting for ages and loves playing with is hardly giving her "everything all at once" and yes, sometimes children do want what their friends or relatives have. Again, ONE present the same as her cousin's is not having EVERYTHING the same. 🙄

x2boys · 19/03/2024 15:43

Bearbooandmiska · 19/03/2024 15:40

Why tell her that's what she's getting. Kids don't have to have everything all at once. They don't need to have everything the same as cousins etc.

Because shes five and its her birthday 🙄

Bearbooandmiska · 19/03/2024 15:40

Why tell her that's what she's getting. Kids don't have to have everything all at once. They don't need to have everything the same as cousins etc.

Cazareeto1 · 19/03/2024 14:15

SilverSeat · 17/03/2024 17:49

Bit busy now but for those insisting that I’m brainwashing her into pink stuff … I was so into boys stuff when I was a kid that the adults used to joke that I’d turn into a boy (quite topical these days!). I liked He-Man and skeletor, ninja turtles, WWE …

One year I was desperate for castle Grayskull and despite my mum telling me she was getting it for Christmas - she got me a Cindy House instead. She likes to bring it up now and again about how much she’d spent on this Cindy House and I never bothered with it … instead using the box it came in to build a den.

Believe me - I’ve not encouraged girly stuff at all. I’d love to buy her castle grayskull (then I could play with it!!!) but she likes what she likes.

5 years old hope she has had a happy birthday and you have had fun to. I have 3 kids 1 girl and 2 boys, when my daughter was 5 she loved the pink castles and pink things in general, always thought she would be godly girly by her choices at that age group. 😂 she is now 12 and if I bought her anything pink now she would probably throw it at me, she skateboards now and is a little punk 😂 but at 5 years old with the built up anticipation of a pink castle for her birthday she would have been hugely disappointed getting a gray boys style instead. I get it. I don’t know why your mum has not learned that a child likes what they like and 5 years old we spent the first 3 years getting them excited and learn how to open presents she a little too young to understand we don’t always get what we want when it is a main present. Hope your mum learns from this one tbh next time I would give her the list of things that can be anything like little extras like play doh

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 19/03/2024 09:28

A little girl wants a pink fairy castle, not a grey soldier fort which is what I would buy my ds when he was young

When I was a little girl, I'd have wanted the grey soldier fort (in fact, I got a Lego one).

You've inadvertently done the same thing as OP's mum, and generalised about the specific child's wishes.

I read that as THIS little girl wants a pink fairy castle - the one that she has specifically asked for - and not that ALL little girls would automatically choose that over a grey battle fort.

He watched Foreman Sam

Ooh, that sounds booooring! Grin

"Make sure you've completed your health & safety risk assessments before commencing work, people; and get your signed off timesheets in to me by lunchtime on Thursday."

RhubarbAndFlustered · 19/03/2024 08:53

I would use this as a teaching opportunity.

No, not for the child but for the controlling granny. Let your DD open grandma's present first, let grandma see your little girl's WTF face at getting a battle fort and then let your little girl open her present if the actual thing she f#%ing wanted and squeal with happiness. And if grandma looks offended then she should be. If she takes issue with it, tell her clearly that your DD is acting like that because THAT is the castle she wanted, not some cheap boys battle fort and you didn't want to let your daughter down.

And yes, girls may enjoy a battle fort too but let's not pretend that boys and girls toys aren't a thing. I raised my son with everything pink thanks to him having sisters and while he did play with them initially, he naturally gravitated towards Batman, cars, guns, monsters, dinosaurs, battle forts, Spider-Man and things like that. He watched Foreman Sam and Cars and couldn't GAF about Sofia the First or Barbie and the Mermaid, Princess, Fairy, Butterfly or whatever shite it was.

angela1952 · 19/03/2024 08:39

My daughter would be livid if I did this. What is the point of buying a present if it isn't what she's asked for? If there isn't anything she actually wants I buy her a small present and give her mum some money to buy something if she sees something she likes.
My DiL prefers her children to have vouchers as her children are older and usually want clothes.

Daffy88 · 19/03/2024 08:27

It is interesting how many posters can still remember the big disappointments from their childhood birthdays and Christmases. My DH still talks about the one (inexpensive) thing that he kept asking for as a child but never got. Children are affected by the thoughtlessness of adults and the negative experiences tend to stay at the forefront of our memories even when many more positive ones are in there too somewhere.
I hope your little girl has a lovely birthday today OP.

Cherryberryy · 19/03/2024 07:58

To this day, I still remember asking my mum for Hollywood hair Barbie for my birthday. I was about 6. I got given a glitter glue barbie. I was sooo upset!! I never understood why she got me the wrong one as she had always got me the 'correct' presents before. My mum just said she thought that Barbie would be more fun 🥴
Definitely get your daughter the right castle 😄

thecatsthecats · 19/03/2024 07:53

suburburban · 17/03/2024 16:55

I would be upset too

A little girl wants a pink fairy castle, not a grey soldier fort which is what I would buy my ds when he was young

Even a 2nd hand one would have been better

When I was a little girl, I'd have wanted the grey soldier fort (in fact, I got a Lego one).

You've inadvertently done the same thing as OP's mum, and generalised about the specific child's wishes.

OP - you know this already, but you have to stop expecting your mum to heal the way she treated you via the way she treats your daughter!

(I have a similar mum, and although I happily have an almost entirely secondhand wardrobe for my son, it does sting a little on his behalf that she's not bought him anything new specially for him.)

Toomuch2019 · 19/03/2024 07:43

Yellowcar2 · 17/03/2024 16:46

I think if I knew my mum had form for this sort of thing and my DD was desperate for a certain castle I wouldn't have trusted her to buy it and would have just got it myself.

This. MIL does the same so we don’t farm out any of the big presents anymore

MNIsBatshit · 19/03/2024 07:01

TwylaSands · 19/03/2024 06:08

Did you give them her back to change or take him to the shop to exchange them?

She gave me the receipt and told me to "just swap them then" but by that point, the stuff he'd wanted had sold out.

This made me angry because it was done deliberately in a petty attempt to annoy and inconvenience me, but she used my DS to do it.

TwylaSands · 19/03/2024 06:08

MNIsBatshit · 18/03/2024 21:28

My DM does this.

My DS wanted some specific clothes Xmas just gone. She asked for his sizes, so gave them to her. She presents the gifts - not the same colours or brands and two sizes too small. Apparently she didn't think I'd got his sizes or choices right and said "I thought, no way does he want those clothes! And she's definitely sent me the wrong sizes!" Then got all huffy when I said "why wouldn't I know what my DS likes or what his sizes are?! I've been shopping for his clothes since he was born...why didn't you ring me to double check if you thought I'd got it wrong?"

She didn't ring me to double check because she knows full well I wasn't wrong, she's just a control freak who won't allow people to tell her what to do (as she sees it), even though she pestered and got angry at me for not giving her gift ideas soon enough.

I won't be doing it any more in future. The clothes weren't expensive or designer, just some average stuff from Sports Direct that were on sale. But still, his little face when he got the opposite and they didn't even fit. He tried to fake gratitude, but I was quite angry because she always does it.

I think it's because me and her were never close, she had me young and clueless. We were more like bickering sisters who didn't like each other. No affection or care. But my DS and I are really close and I think it pisses her off, so she does stuff like this. Still acting like the mean sister deliberately trying to wind me up.

Did you give them her back to change or take him to the shop to exchange them?

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 19/03/2024 00:56

Angrywife · 18/03/2024 23:21

That's not what birthday celebrations are for.

Indeed - it sounds positively Dickensian and designed to prevent anybody getting above their station by daring to hope for happiness.

A little girl sets her heart on a specific toy that she already knows she loves and asks for it for her big birthday present; you'd have to have a heart of stone to be desperately searching for arbitrary reasons why she shouldn't have it, even though it is affordable and achievable for her adult loved ones, 'just because'.

Angrywife · 18/03/2024 23:21

BloodTestsHelpPlease · 17/03/2024 16:43

Teaching moment for dd here that we don't always get what we want I guess.

That's not what birthday celebrations are for.

MNIsBatshit · 18/03/2024 21:28

My DM does this.

My DS wanted some specific clothes Xmas just gone. She asked for his sizes, so gave them to her. She presents the gifts - not the same colours or brands and two sizes too small. Apparently she didn't think I'd got his sizes or choices right and said "I thought, no way does he want those clothes! And she's definitely sent me the wrong sizes!" Then got all huffy when I said "why wouldn't I know what my DS likes or what his sizes are?! I've been shopping for his clothes since he was born...why didn't you ring me to double check if you thought I'd got it wrong?"

She didn't ring me to double check because she knows full well I wasn't wrong, she's just a control freak who won't allow people to tell her what to do (as she sees it), even though she pestered and got angry at me for not giving her gift ideas soon enough.

I won't be doing it any more in future. The clothes weren't expensive or designer, just some average stuff from Sports Direct that were on sale. But still, his little face when he got the opposite and they didn't even fit. He tried to fake gratitude, but I was quite angry because she always does it.

I think it's because me and her were never close, she had me young and clueless. We were more like bickering sisters who didn't like each other. No affection or care. But my DS and I are really close and I think it pisses her off, so she does stuff like this. Still acting like the mean sister deliberately trying to wind me up.

Tengreenbottles2 · 18/03/2024 21:27

BloodTestsHelpPlease · 17/03/2024 16:43

Teaching moment for dd here that we don't always get what we want I guess.

Teaching moment for mum that if she doesn't bloody listen despite being told 50 million times then people are going to be very annoyed with her and not include her in their plans.

Woahthehorsey · 18/03/2024 21:25

My mum did this all the time. She'd give me a budget for a gift (mine, DHs, or the kids etc) and ask what we wanted. Id send her a link to an exact item, I'd explain why that specific one etc and it was always under or at budget and yet every single time she would buy a different one. So if I said a Blue Pokémon t shirt for DS, she'd get him a green Asda t shirt, she would then also get a second gift to make up to the budget When questioned she'd always say the one she got was 'a bargain' or the one we wanted wasn't good value. Drove me nuts. So now I just tell her a generic thing and let her get whatever. I never trust her with an exact item.

TitaniasAss · 18/03/2024 21:15

MIL did this years ago with a present for DS. She asked me what we were getting him for his birthday and I told her a cozy coupe. She asked if she could get it for him and I said no, it's OK it'll be our main present for him. She insisted that she get it as he was her only grandchild and she really wanted to get him something that he would love. I offered to get it for her but she said no. She got him a trike. He already had a trike. She said that when she saw it, she decided a trike would be better. No idea why. He didn't know he was going to get it so I went out and bought him the thing he really wanted anyway, so I was well out of pocket because I had bought him other things for his birthday.

AnotherEmma · 18/03/2024 21:09

SquareCrumpets · 18/03/2024 21:07

@AnotherEmma my dad always thought that mum knew best when dealing with daughters.

My mum was desperate for me to conform to being the “girly” girl that she wanted. Mum got a lot of use out of the bike. Me, not so much…

Sad Flowers

bigvig · 18/03/2024 21:07

If I was you OP I would never tell her anything your child really wanted again. Just give her - doesn’t matter if she gets it wrong - sort of ideas. it’s a shame but I’d also wonder if this is partly deliberate if she keeps doing it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread