Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

His comment about having children in his home country

90 replies

Ana25 · 17/03/2024 14:31

I'm 32 and my newish boyfriend is 31. It's only been 4 months but things are going well so far and he stated on date one he sought a serious relationship.

He's from another European country but his job will keep him here for at least another 2 years.

My cousin had a baby and we were casually discussing maternity rights in the UK. He said he'd want to have kids back in his country which has better maternity rights. I was shocked to hear this and told him as much. We talked a bit more, with him saying he'd 'like' to be closer to his parents in future and asked if I also wanted to stay close to family. Nothing seemed set in stone however.

Long term I'm open minded but would want to have a baby in the UK close to my own parents. I'm reconsidering whether this relationship has a future. Is this relationship ending or do I need to have another conversation?

OP posts:
Herdinggoats · 17/03/2024 22:06

LadyBird1973 · 17/03/2024 21:59

I think the person actually giving birth should get final say on where that birth takes place.
I would never give birth abroad because I would worry about being trapped in another country if it all goes pear shaped.
My dh is half Danish - their culture seems to be that after mat leave, children go to state subsidised child care and both parents return to work (although work/life balance seems good). Could you work there? Would you want to be a sahp?

All great until she wastes a couple of childbearing years on this fellow only for him to decide when push comes to shove to go back home and she is left either trying to start over with the clock ticking or giving up on the principle of “the one giving birth gets final say”

sixthvestibule · 17/03/2024 22:04

I can see his point. If I happened to get pregnant, I’d consider having the baby in my European country of origin, because healthcare is better there than here in the UK and I prefer the education system.

PeloMom · 17/03/2024 22:04

You may want to bring it up again and discuss with him. Make your position clear and see where the discussion goes.
as someone who moved away(I didn’t feel strongly one way or another at the time) and gave birth in SO’s country, I underestimated how much I needed to be around familiar people, system etc at that vulnerable time. I believe it was a major contributor to my PPD.
Childcare falls mostly if not entirely on the woman, even more so in the early years, so what you’re comfortable with and your support network is what matters most.

LadyBird1973 · 17/03/2024 21:59

I think the person actually giving birth should get final say on where that birth takes place.
I would never give birth abroad because I would worry about being trapped in another country if it all goes pear shaped.
My dh is half Danish - their culture seems to be that after mat leave, children go to state subsidised child care and both parents return to work (although work/life balance seems good). Could you work there? Would you want to be a sahp?

AGoingConcern · 17/03/2024 20:18

Neither of you is wrong or being unreasonable here in any way, but yes it may be relationship ending. Unfortunately if you both feel like having & raising babies near your families is a priority to you and those families are in separate countries, then you simply may not be compatible. It's good that you're exploring this early.

betterangels · 17/03/2024 20:03

Barms155 · 17/03/2024 19:06

To be fair you can't just move to Denmark now anyway...due to brexit you need a visa and these are not so easy to get.

And immigration rules are actually pretty strict in general.

Barms155 · 17/03/2024 19:06

To be fair you can't just move to Denmark now anyway...due to brexit you need a visa and these are not so easy to get.

stayathomer · 17/03/2024 18:43

sorry But I’d say from how shocked you were that you’re on totally different pages. I think the biggest deal breaker is people wanting to live/raise their child in a different area. I have friends that are so homesick but don’t feel they can leave the countries they’re in because healthcare, job etc etc are so good where they are. The thing is I always think if they’re miserable what is the point?!

tarheelbaby · 17/03/2024 18:33

Firstly, as PP have said, you're only a few months into this relationship. So chill 😁

FWIW, I moved to England with my British husband. We had kids here. We also took them to the US embassy and did the paperwork so that they are dual citizens. It's straightforward but has to be done before 6mos! Although I miss the US, I would not move back there until our DC are adults b/c the DCs' lives are here.

I have seen other posts about UK citizens and having children abroad. Check the rules carefully because birth location can affect UK citizenship. I have a British friend who was married to a Russian but came back here for their DC's birth.

I've never worried about DH refusing to let our DC travel but do look into the rules for Denmark.

LipstickLil · 17/03/2024 18:33

Had you just assumed that because you met here that this is where you would always live OP, without discussing what he might want? Because if so, you've been very naive. Getting into a relationship with someone from another country and having DC with them is anything but simple and you should never assume that they'll want the same things that you do. Should you reconsider the relationship? Well, the two of you certainly need to start communicating better and discussing what you both want from the relationship, if it gets more serious. And if you don't agree on the basics - number one being which country you will live in - then yes, you should definitely throw this one back.

InfoComet · 17/03/2024 18:26

I'm married to a Dane and living in the UK. We don't have children but we would have definitely moved to Denmark if we'd wanted to start a family.

PrimaniTu · 17/03/2024 18:19

I have a friend who is stuck in the country of her ex partner's because they had a child together in his country.

It's in the EU and it's next door to her country, she speaks the language but dislikes the country and there's nothing she could do about it whilst her dc was young as obviously she didn't want to leave her dc.

She could move back now as her dc is a young adult but she wants to be close to her dc and her dc wouldn't countenance a move to her dm's home country as she doesn't know the country as well as her own.

allthemiddlechildrenoftheworld · 17/03/2024 18:19

@Ana25 you need to have your children in this country or you might not be allowed to bring them back here if you split up!!

soupfiend · 17/03/2024 18:14

I dont quite understand the shock either, most people want to bring up chidlren in their home country, unless there is a significant reason why they wouldnt.

EveSix · 17/03/2024 18:13

Both maternity and paternity arrangements and services in general are likely more generous and together in Denmark if they're anything like those in its northern Scandinavian sibling nations. Childhood is idealised and treasured, as is early parenthood. A wonderful place to raise a family.

But it's not your home.
I'm a Scandi raising children in the UK because I was you and followed DP.
I love being here, but am aware of the many ways in which I am short-changing my DC by bringing them up in the political climate of austerity and conservatism which prevails in Britain, when they could be benefiting from growing up in a society shaped by more centrist, social democratic values and services to match.

CrappySack · 17/03/2024 18:12

BotterMon · 17/03/2024 18:07

You've been together for 4 months! Chill.

FWIW I gave birth in my husband's home country (also a European country) as living there at the time and it was a far far better experience then the UK. He moved to the UK and we go between both countries.

Denmark isn't exactly far away!

I don't think OP needs to chill. She doesn't want to have a baby in another country and if he does what's the point of them wasting more of their time?

OdeToBarney · 17/03/2024 18:12

I love Denmark and was actually googling residency requirements last week after a trip, but there's no way I'd be continuing this relationship. Relationships can and do break down, and there's not a cat in hells chance I'd risk not being able to leave with my children. Or being able to leave but not being able to get maintenance.

BotterMon · 17/03/2024 18:07

You've been together for 4 months! Chill.

FWIW I gave birth in my husband's home country (also a European country) as living there at the time and it was a far far better experience then the UK. He moved to the UK and we go between both countries.

Denmark isn't exactly far away!

Searchingforthelight · 17/03/2024 18:01

Ana25 · 17/03/2024 14:59

Curious to hear more @AdriftAbroad1 ?!

That's what I'm saying anyway. I'm 32. He's working here for at least another 2 years minimum. I don't want to be having a baby in several years time and I'd 100% want family and NHS support in my own country.

You need to consider how dreadful NHS maternity services are ( through years of tories deliberately running them down). The majority are inadequate- much publicised recently. Denmark and most of the western world generally have far superior ( safer) outcomes.

CrappySack · 17/03/2024 18:00

Bobbotgegrinch · 17/03/2024 17:48

My best friend is currently going through a messy divorce in a foreign country after she moved there to marry someone born there. She obviously wants to move back home but faces not being able to bring her child with her if she doesn't win custody.

I'd be very wary about having a child with someone in their home country rather than your own.

This. It's not something I'd risk.

I think you should have another conversation and make it clear that you'd never want to move to another country. If he's set on wanting to move back to his country, then the only answer is to call it a day really.

KalaMush · 17/03/2024 17:56

Maternity care may well be great in Denmark, but the thing that would worry me is if you split up, you wouldn't be able to move back here with the kids (unless he agreed).

I have two friends currently "stuck" living abroad when they would like to come home. In one case she has split up with her partner and isn't allowed to bring the kids home without his permission (which he won't give, as he wants to stay there).

In the other case, they're still together, but the kids are happily settled in schools and speak the language - to them, moving to the UK would be moving to a foreign country, and my friend doesn't want to disrupt their lives.

anon4net · 17/03/2024 17:56

@Ana25 I follow a few Mums who moved to Denmark with their husbands, and either had some dc before and some after the move, or had them there. DM me if you want their handles.

I'd say this is always something that has to be worked out as a couple who are not both born/from the same country. Four months is very early days in a relationship but it's probably wise to figure out if either of you have flexibility and what that looks like. One of you has to compromise and it's a big compromise to make.

Crumpleton · 17/03/2024 17:53

ColleenDonaghy · 17/03/2024 14:44

I think a lot of people who move away for work when young plan to move home to start a family, so his position isn't unusual or anything.

If you, understandably, don't want to move then I think you should consider calling it a day now rather than running into real problems down the line.

This...

Or are you of the thinking that he'll change his mind, there's a chance he's giving conflicting info to you inorder for you to keep things as they are.

If it's only been a few months and that's the case I'd bow out now.

Bobbotgegrinch · 17/03/2024 17:48

My best friend is currently going through a messy divorce in a foreign country after she moved there to marry someone born there. She obviously wants to move back home but faces not being able to bring her child with her if she doesn't win custody.

I'd be very wary about having a child with someone in their home country rather than your own.

andyindurham · 17/03/2024 17:47

I was pretty much your OH in my relationship - had been living in another country for a long time, could have remained indefinitely but was thinking about moving on. It was probably about 4-6 months in that I started discussing this seriously with my future wife and, in the end, we moved to the UK and started a family here. But only after a lot of soul searching and discussion.

It's not always been easy. Of course, it helps me a lot that I can deal with schools and things in my own language (while I speak her language pretty well and use it extensively in my professional life, there's a big difference between day to day chat and official bureaucracy). But she sometimes feels isolated and, of course, that puts pressure on me to support her with stuff that wouldn't need the same level of support if I was married to a Brit (or possibly a long-term UK resident who was established here before meeting me). OTOH, if we'd stayed in her country that additional support would have to come from her since she had the local knowledge, especially in terms of accessing services, benefits etc.

In the end, it works for us because we make it work and because we want it to work. But that's about us as a couple, not about our respective nationalities nor our current country of residence. Circumstances have also proved me correct about both my father's need for someone close at hand to support him in his later years, and my fears that her country was lurching rapidly down a hugely undesirable and dangerous political course that would leave me vulnerable as a foreigner working there in my industry. But I couldn't have blamed her for saying that she wanted to stay home and remain close to her family, even though I doubt that would have persuaded me to stay with her in her home city.