Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

His comment about having children in his home country

90 replies

Ana25 · 17/03/2024 14:31

I'm 32 and my newish boyfriend is 31. It's only been 4 months but things are going well so far and he stated on date one he sought a serious relationship.

He's from another European country but his job will keep him here for at least another 2 years.

My cousin had a baby and we were casually discussing maternity rights in the UK. He said he'd want to have kids back in his country which has better maternity rights. I was shocked to hear this and told him as much. We talked a bit more, with him saying he'd 'like' to be closer to his parents in future and asked if I also wanted to stay close to family. Nothing seemed set in stone however.

Long term I'm open minded but would want to have a baby in the UK close to my own parents. I'm reconsidering whether this relationship has a future. Is this relationship ending or do I need to have another conversation?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Autumcolors · 18/03/2024 21:09

What @BoohooWoohoo says it totally correct. Look at The Hague Convention and child custody.
I know a few people who are stuck in a country they don’t want to be in because they had children and now they can leave - unless without the children

Newsenmum · 18/03/2024 21:06

If you loved Denmark would your parents move too? might be a much better place for you all! Although I can understand it might be quite difficult for them to get a visa.

Snugglemonkey · 18/03/2024 20:59

Ana25 · 17/03/2024 14:49

@SerendipityJane he's from Denmark.

I would want to go home to have children if I were him too.

LadyBird1973 · 18/03/2024 19:26

That's good @scandiinuk I always thought it was very unfair to make people choose between two countries that they belong to equally.
I knew they were doing it a few years ago, but thought it was for a limited period only.

scandiinuk · 18/03/2024 17:59

@LadyBird1973 Slightly OT but just for info - Denmark now allows dual citizenship (since 2014).

HoHoHoliday · 18/03/2024 12:25

Ana25 · 17/03/2024 14:49

@SerendipityJane he's from Denmark.

Having lived both here and in Denmark, I'd say he is correct and you would have a much better experience starting and raising your family in Denmark. Something to bear in mind... If you really couldn't contemplate moving away from your family though, then I'd cut your loses and end the relationship now. No point pushing on if you want different things.

gannett · 18/03/2024 12:12

Is this relationship ending or do I need to have another conversation?

It might be relationship ending but you won't know unless you have another (probably several more) conversations.

You've only been seeing him for 4 months so I doubt either of you have thought much about what a potential future together looks like in concrete terms. He's always assumed he'll have kids in Denmark, you've always assumed you'll have kids here - that's the start of a conversation, not the end of one. It may be that you get to know Denmark and change your mind. It may be that he changes his mind. Both of your careers will also be factors in terms of how they develop and where the opportunities are. It may be that you find some sort of compromise. And it may be that neither of you change your mind and end up separating over this.

Being able to communicate over big issues like this is fundamental to a healthy relationship - if you can't do that, then that will be a bigger problem than Denmark vs UK.

Ana25 · 18/03/2024 11:41

@Busyhedgehog and others who have suggested he might not actually move back, I think this is a real possibility. He has built his career here and I think that does matter. Obviously he can change careers later but there's no guarantee that he can get the same job there.

I have a few things to consider.

I will look at healthcare and rights etc in Denmark - I don't know much about it. I'm not against a move later necessarily but I want to have children here at first.

I have heard about people moving to a spouse's and then finding they can't move back with their children - that IS a potential concern.

We are at the giddy in love stage but we will need to have a proper talk again soon. He might be more flexible than I realise. As a PP said, I can't very well afford to waste years.

My ageing parents are also on my mind. The move would mean being close to his and not mine. Obviously this will be the case in either scenario, but I am an only child. His brother already lives near his parents.

I am getting my Irish citizenship this year so the European thing not so much an issue

OP posts:
Bagpussrules · 18/03/2024 11:03

I lived abroad and dated someone who was lovely but I knew full well I was always going to move home again. OP@Ana25 isnt it really obvious, if you would never choose to move abroad for love then you either just have a relationship "for now" or end it now. Have you asked him his opinion as he may be in the see how it goes camp....if you are a woman of a certain age who wants kids then sometimes you have to be realistic about your choices.

Busyhedgehog · 18/03/2024 10:24

Just because he said he'd like to move back to have kids that doesn't mean he will. I wouldn't stress about it but I would also keep an open mind.
I had DS in England and it was fine. However, I had considered moving back "home" before I got pregnant with him. It just wasn't practical at that point.
After Brexit, the maternity provision in my home country was one factor that made us move. It's much better than in the UK (never really got the hype about the NHS but then I am not British) and I get a lot more money during my parental leave than I did in England (as does DH). We also have more rights in terms of child sick days, for example, and our employers are more family-friendly.

We might move back to the UK at some point but certainly not while the kids are little.

Pacificisolated · 18/03/2024 09:59

I disagree with the posters saying this is a short relationship, you’re only four months in etc. At 32 you need to be decisive and settle down with someone with shared goals if you want kids.

paintingvenice · 18/03/2024 09:45

JFDIYOLO · 18/03/2024 09:18

  1. Research Danish quality of life and maternity practices and care.

Then compare to the shitshow the NHS has become.

Of course he's comparing the two. (This may be his point.)

  1. Research Danish parental rights.

Consider what a mess you'd be in if you had a baby there then split up.

Caught in limbo as a non European ex with a child whose father has rights.

Danish quality of life is an aggregated figure. The fact is long-term any one living in a country with limited language skills is going to struggle with feelings of isolation and have a poorer quality of life.

JFDIYOLO · 18/03/2024 09:18
  1. Research Danish quality of life and maternity practices and care.

Then compare to the shitshow the NHS has become.

Of course he's comparing the two. (This may be his point.)

  1. Research Danish parental rights.

Consider what a mess you'd be in if you had a baby there then split up.

Caught in limbo as a non European ex with a child whose father has rights.

AttaThat · 18/03/2024 07:51

I think you’ve been a little naive to date someone not from the UK and assume that their life is now fully in the UK.

You need a heart to heart on what life could look like in the future - children, aging parents etc. At some point you have to be able to agree for the relationship to be worth continuing to invest in. And being in an international relationship will continue to look different to a UK only relationship. For us it’s things like: maintaining the kids’ other citizenship, spending most of our holiday budget on visiting that country, and having an emergency fund for DH to drop everything and jump on a plane if his parents are ill, giving the kids the option to study in the other country. (Most of this slightly less impactful when it’s Europe rather than further afield!)

Anameisaname · 18/03/2024 07:41

I'm afraid if you both feel strongly on this issue, you may need to reconsider this relations. Don't invest time hoping he will change his mind. He's told you his hopes and dreams and they are different to yours

PomPomtheGreat · 18/03/2024 07:40

I lived in Denmark for more than a decade and had a child there. I didn't particularly enjoy it, particularly the weather! It's a very difficult country to integrate into, but there were definitely good parts and I made some good friends.

The Scandi model is probably better than many, but it comes with a lot of hidden difficulties for outsiders, and there's a lot of racism and far right nationalism. There's a reason for such a high number of Danes being on anti depressants.

What I would say though is that Danes almost universally insist on going home and staying there once they're thinking about having children. It's a running joke among most of the couples I know where one of them is Danish and one of them is not. It has led to many of them splitting or being unhappy that their Danish partner simply will not budge.

LipstickLil · 18/03/2024 07:34

I agree @paintingvenice - the only people who ever tell you that it's easy to 'pick up another language' have either never done it or have a particular aptitude for languages - which the vast majority of people don't.

It's bloody hard and really socially isolating to move to another country where you don't speak the language! And no, most people don't just 'pick it up' in a few months. It takes years and lots of hard work.

LadyBird1973 · 18/03/2024 07:23

My mil is Danish. She was living in the UK when she met fil but returned home to give birth.
Not sure if it's changed now but Denmark only used to allow dual citizenship until age 18, then kids had to choose. If they chose Danish, they were eligible for national service.
It's not only about maternity care, you have to consider how you will feel about your dc growing up to be a different nationality to you, possibly giving up their British citizenship or it not bro g meaningful to them in the same way it might be to you. Having and raising a family in a country which isn't yours, is a big thing to consider. I know there were some issues/conflict for my in-laws regarding this.
My brother is raising his dc in America (his wife is American). The kids have a good life out there, but it's a different life to the one my brother had. You would have to be actively willing to embrace that.

Maybe 4 months is too early for these conversations but I would have them sooner rather than later because you wouldn't want to waste childbearing years on someone who will ultimately leave you if he feels very strongly about this.

LadyBird1973 · 18/03/2024 07:15

He's going to struggle finding a partner in this country who would be willing to give up their life here and move to Denmark. Most women have family here, a career, friends etc. Few Brits speak Danish. Tbh, if he's set on raising a family in Denmark, he'd be better off moving home and finding a partner there.
Denmark is a nice place but I don't know many women who would be entirely happy giving birth in a place where their own language skills weren't fluent and where they didn't have their own mums/support system. At least, not women who hadn't actively chose to emigrate.

Naptimeagain · 18/03/2024 00:05

If you want to raise a family in the UK and he wants to raise a family in Denmark, then i think you should split up now, rather than dragging it out. This isn't a difference you can overcome.

Picklestop · 17/03/2024 22:41

I have lived overseas twice and also worked in multinationals where I have encountered many people that are living away from their home country. A significant number of them decide to move to their home country once they are ready to start a family. So I am very bemused that you or anyone would be shocked by this.

That said, I definitely agree that there could be an issue for you down the line.

moonfacer · 17/03/2024 22:37

You both want to have babies in your home countries. That’s not shocking. You are just incompatible. You are right to prefer not to have a baby there, you may not be able to move back with child if you split.

KTheGrey · 17/03/2024 22:34

I hear good things about childcare provision in Denmark. Worth seriously considering.

paintingvenice · 17/03/2024 22:09

PeloMom · 17/03/2024 22:04

You may want to bring it up again and discuss with him. Make your position clear and see where the discussion goes.
as someone who moved away(I didn’t feel strongly one way or another at the time) and gave birth in SO’s country, I underestimated how much I needed to be around familiar people, system etc at that vulnerable time. I believe it was a major contributor to my PPD.
Childcare falls mostly if not entirely on the woman, even more so in the early years, so what you’re comfortable with and your support network is what matters most.

There’s also a language issue. Where unless the OP is extraordinarily talented learning a new language to fluency takes years and is incredibly difficult. However great the standard of English is in the general population it is very isolating to have that language barrier and she will need to contend with that. I don’t think it is as simple as some people here seem to suggest.

PeloMom · 17/03/2024 22:08

tarheelbaby · 17/03/2024 18:33

Firstly, as PP have said, you're only a few months into this relationship. So chill 😁

FWIW, I moved to England with my British husband. We had kids here. We also took them to the US embassy and did the paperwork so that they are dual citizens. It's straightforward but has to be done before 6mos! Although I miss the US, I would not move back there until our DC are adults b/c the DCs' lives are here.

I have seen other posts about UK citizens and having children abroad. Check the rules carefully because birth location can affect UK citizenship. I have a British friend who was married to a Russian but came back here for their DC's birth.

I've never worried about DH refusing to let our DC travel but do look into the rules for Denmark.

No it won’t affect citizenship for the DC. However if DC’s kids are also born abroad, they wouldn’t be entitled to British citizenship.

Swipe left for the next trending thread