Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have phoned DH’s nephew twice to ask why me daughter and grandchildren aren’t invited to his wedding

533 replies

SlothsRUs · 17/03/2024 12:33

Husband is fucking angry with me. Received an invitation to his nephew’s wedding for us and our two daughters but not for my eldest daughter who is from a previous relationship.

Nephew’s response was that she was a step-relative who hadn’t been thought of but he didn’t think they were close.
He is closer in age to her and has known her longer than he has known the others.

I got his number off husband’s phone. He's furious with me.

Nephew is son of Brother-in-Law. The daughter of Sister-in-Law is invited with her toddler but my grandchildren aren’t invited.

When I found this out I rang him back asking how he felt closer to this family as they had grown up in different countries. He said he wasn’t willing to carry on the conversation.

BiL rang husband suggesting had I requested an invitation, one would be forthcoming, I don’t believe him. I get the sense it was more of control your wife.

I have no hope at all of my daughters not going, husband is definitely going.

I am fucking sick to my stomach. SiL rang me directly virtually threatening me saying I had upset people and not to involve my MiL.

Fucking furious.

People are going ask DD1 is 28, younger two are 19 and 20. Groom is 29.

OP posts:
TwigletsAndRadishes · 17/03/2024 18:56

she wasn't a grandchild was she, she is a step grandchild in that there is no blood relation between her and the deceased ? the only tie between her and him is your marriage certificate to your husband ?

That shouldn't really matter though, if the ILs have known the DD1 since she was little more than a toddler. One of my DCs grandmas is actually their step grandma because DH's mum died and his dad remarried. when my eldest was tiny. She's not blood but she's still the only grandma on that side of the family that they've ever known and she's never treated them any differently to her biological grandchildren. Likewise my FIL treats her GDC as his own.

If step GDC don't count, are we going to start suggesting that adopted grandchildren and sperm donor grandchildren don't count as they 'are not blood' either?

I know there are other contributing factors to this whole sorry mess, where the OP has probably made things worse in the long run, but the argument that it's okay to single out one child that your son ihas chosen to bringing up as his own, and treat her differently to his other daughters because she's not blood is not very kind. She was only 3 years old.

EineReiseDurchDieZeit · 17/03/2024 18:56

being put into a limousine

It was a funeral not a treat she was missing out on.

You seem to have deeply internalised that life has been unfair to your eldest but by going to extremes in her favour you've created two younger children who are rightly resentful of all they've lost out on.

diddl · 17/03/2024 18:56

you refused to allow your two younger children to have any contact with your DH’s side of the family. Your DH had to visit his side of the family by himself because you wouldn’t let the children go.

How on earth did you make him go without his kids Op?

And why did he?

What a shitshow!

I really can't believe that you think your husband's nephew should invite your daughter & her kids!

OhmygodDont · 17/03/2024 18:56

I think a lot of tongue biting has been going on in dh’s family. Always waiting for the next thing to tip op over the edge.

I wouldn’t be surprised if the dh has been having to basically try and convince his family she’s not terrible all the time. Probably been told by his family that they will
be ready on hand for a separation.

In fact the youngest child now going off to uni means you picked a very bad time to suddenly kick off yet again. Your children are adults. He doesn’t need to stay with you and try to keep you on side to now have a relationship with his girls.

As the girls have shown you by now wanting as much time with their fathers family as they can now get after being denied for so long. Your dh has a lovely relationship with your oldest and her children. You might well be on very very borrowed time.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 17/03/2024 18:56

I grew up with hand brothers. We lived together, but sometimes our "own" families did things that did not involve the other siblings. It seemed reasonable enough at the time.

theduchessofspork · 17/03/2024 18:55

What I would do is write him an email saying you are extremely sorry - you were totally out of line and there is no excuse. However, like a lot of parents of blended families you are sensitive to kids not being included in everything.

You appreciate it’s entirely up to him who he asks to his wedding, and if you did want to raise it, this was the worst way to do so.

You value them as part of your family and apologise deeply for causing them distress.

Please don’t make a drama out of a minor crisis and start saying your relationship is over OP. If you admit you were a dick and apologise for it, there is no reason everyone shouldn’t move on.

There would have been nothing wrong with sounding out gently, via your husband (if he was OK with that) whether an invite for your daughter might have been possible - although you would need to have been clear that if the answer was no that was fine.

InterIgnis · 17/03/2024 18:52

SlothsRUs · 17/03/2024 18:18

My children are adults and the two youngest are going no matter what I say,

I am overwrought. I admit it. I want to scream.

Husband is going to actually carry our neighbour over as she has had knee replacement to eat with us so I will have distraction.

I know what I am presenting as but it’s not me usually but I would never exclude on the basis of blood. Just so upset.

What you would or wouldn’t do is irrelevant. It’s not your wedding and you don’t get to decide who they invite. You get to decide whether to accept or decline your own invite, that’s it.

noodlesfortea · 17/03/2024 18:49

You are very unreasonable to act how you have, but I understand why you're upset.

You could have politely asked whether it would be possible to get an invite for your daughter too, as you'd like to come as a family. If not, and you were still upset, you could have declined the invite for yourself.

He's absolutely not obliged to invite her and you've acted quite entitled. He obviously doesn't feel they are close, regardless of what you think he should feel. Most probably he doesn't feel close to your other children either but feels he must invite them as they're blood.

Saschka · 17/03/2024 18:48

OP, reading your other thread, you refused to allow your two younger children to have any contact with your DH’s side of the family. Your DH had to visit his side of the family by himself because you wouldn’t let the children go. You prevented them from attending family weddings, or seeing their grandparents at Christmas. Your younger two children no longer speak to you as a result.

Given that, I am astonished that you were invited yourself. I cannot believe you are surprised that your older daughter and her children aren’t invited - presumably your oldest daughter has not met your DH’s nephew for 20 years, and has never met the bride at all? Whereas your younger two have been trying to rebuild relationships with that side of the family.

Be honest, this is just another excuse for you to kick off about your in laws.

MississippiAF · 17/03/2024 18:46

soupfiend · 17/03/2024 18:36

She wasnt his grandchild though?

Am I missing something here?

Nope. OP had her eldest with someone who’s apparently been given a free pass at being a shit dad, but her DH’s family were very much expected to jump in and make up the difference. And when they didn’t, it cost them the relationship with their actual DGC/nieces/cousins.

Mind boggling.

CarterBeatsTheDevil · 17/03/2024 18:46

I didn't get invited to several of my first cousins' birthdays, as in people I am actually related to by blood and who I spent a lot of time with when I was small. Really didn't mind at all. Still very fond of them but we see each other once a year at most, they're very far away and weddings are too expensive to invite everyone you care about.

LovelyTheresa · 17/03/2024 18:44

I think that ESH. Of course, it was rude of you to ring up and harangue your husband's nephew, that is never appropriate. However, I also think that it was rather rude of the nephew to include his blood cousins but not his step cousin, so I get why you were upset.

Owl55 · 17/03/2024 18:39

I can understand you are hurt and angry that your eldest daughter was not invited but I would not have expected them to invite grandchildren . Weddings are expensive and they can invite who they like really . Out of line ringing him!

Teenangels · 17/03/2024 18:39

SlothsRUs · 17/03/2024 18:09

I admit that I did stop facilitating a relationship with my in-laws because of the effect their behaviour had on my eldest child, and she was a child. My husband could have taken the other two and I couldn’t have stopped him.
We still saw the in-laws a few times a year but as a family.
My eldest had to watch her younger sisters being put into a limousine at FiL’s funeral, have a priest read a eulogy that mentioned every grandchild but her and her cousins and sisters reading bidding prayers. They all thought her tears were for the only grandfather she had but it was because she was humiliated .
Nephew hasn’t invited her and some posters say he doesn’t know her and that was my fault but he knows her as much as the others and I don’t think he knows his aunt’s kids any better.

Behave, you stopped them being flower girls at a family wedding.

Flower girls usually under 7, because your eldest was not included.

Newsflash I was not included in a wedding where a younger sibling was, no long term effects.

When your daughter did see her father did you make all of them see him, they are all family after all!

You are batshit crazy.

Misthios · 17/03/2024 18:39

Another day, another happy blended family story.

soupfiend · 17/03/2024 18:36

SlothsRUs · 17/03/2024 18:09

I admit that I did stop facilitating a relationship with my in-laws because of the effect their behaviour had on my eldest child, and she was a child. My husband could have taken the other two and I couldn’t have stopped him.
We still saw the in-laws a few times a year but as a family.
My eldest had to watch her younger sisters being put into a limousine at FiL’s funeral, have a priest read a eulogy that mentioned every grandchild but her and her cousins and sisters reading bidding prayers. They all thought her tears were for the only grandfather she had but it was because she was humiliated .
Nephew hasn’t invited her and some posters say he doesn’t know her and that was my fault but he knows her as much as the others and I don’t think he knows his aunt’s kids any better.

She wasnt his grandchild though?

Am I missing something here?

diddl · 17/03/2024 18:34

I think if you already have a child when you marry you have to be careful what expectations you put on the family you are marrying into.

To expect your spouse to treat your child as their own-of course.

But how many members of their family should that extend to?

If the child has no relationship with the other half of their birth family-should others be expected to step in & make up for that?

Silvers11 · 17/03/2024 18:31

@SlothsRUs - It is very sad that your eldest daughter was never treated the same as your 2 younger children, when she was young and if you were posting this on Mumsnet 20 years ago when your eldest was 8, lots of people on here would have been sympathetic to you and giving you advice about how to navigate the situation.

Blended families are hard to deal with, but from reading your other thread, it wasn't handled very well, according to your comments. How it was handled then, in many ways, has a direct bearing on things now. I think your husband is also partly responsible for where you all find yourselves now. He should perhaps have stood his ground with both you and his parents back then. But what's done is done.

So I understand you being upset as this is a continuation of the situation over the years ( made worse by you refusing to basically let your younger children get to properly know the other side of the extended family). I can understand why your younger children have had a go at you ( your other thread) and I imagine that they have a great deal of resentment to your eldest too

But you are getting such a very hard time here, because phoning the nephew TWICE never mind once kicking off at him, was totally OTT and very ill-advised: simply not-on, however much you are upset. You have created an absolute family shit-storm. Your BIL has also said that you can still go yourself, if you change your mind in a few weeks, so he has been very kind, given what you did.

martinisforeveryone · 17/03/2024 18:31

Another way of looking at it @SlothsRUs is if your oldest DD was getting married, would she invite your nephew and his soon to be wife, if indeed she knows the soon to be wife, and any children they might have by then?

soupfiend · 17/03/2024 18:31

I wonder if your husband will be able to get past this.

Its not a good thing you've done OP

Feelingstrange2 · 17/03/2024 18:28

You should not have rung. It's not your wedding.

You could have turned the invite down though. That's the only thing rightly in your control.

We had a very random set of people at our main wedding because my parents simply couldn't afford it and neither could we. Some were invited because we knew they physically couldn't make the evening do - which was bigger because it was cheaper per head (£8ph at night v £24ph lunchtime...1992 prices!)

Thank goodness everyone didn't start on me. My parents would have been mortified they couldn't afford more to the main sit down dinner.

MississippiAF · 17/03/2024 18:27

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 17/03/2024 18:23

' My eldest had to watch her younger sisters being put into a limousine at FiL’s funeral, have a priest read a eulogy that mentioned every grandchild but her and her cousins and sisters reading bidding prayers. '

but

she wasn't a grandchild was she, she is a step grandchild in that there is no blood relation between her and the deceased ? the only tie between her and him is your marriage certificate to your husband ?

The issue is actually OP’s IMO… she hadn’t explained the difference in parentage to her eldest. Leading to needless confusion and upset.

Cornflakes44 · 17/03/2024 18:26

But your daughter is no relation to him. It annoys me when people make out that step children and blood relations are exactly the same. They aren't. Also regardless of all that you don't phone people and kick off because you don't agree with their wedding guest list. You sound entitled AF.

martinisforeveryone · 17/03/2024 18:23

I actually think that the majority of your anger OP @SlothsRUs should be directed at your oldest DD's father and her grandparents on his side.

You've looked to DH's family to fully step into that role, which, of course, they could, but things didn't go that way and it sounds like some of that was because of your own input. None of us here can judge on the entire rights and wrongs of the history there.

Personally I think you should look at ways for you and your daughter to make peace with the situation rather than adding more mayhem, for your own well being if nothing else.

OlderGlaswegianLivingInDevon · 17/03/2024 18:23

' My eldest had to watch her younger sisters being put into a limousine at FiL’s funeral, have a priest read a eulogy that mentioned every grandchild but her and her cousins and sisters reading bidding prayers. '

but

she wasn't a grandchild was she, she is a step grandchild in that there is no blood relation between her and the deceased ? the only tie between her and him is your marriage certificate to your husband ?