Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To have phoned DH’s nephew twice to ask why me daughter and grandchildren aren’t invited to his wedding

533 replies

SlothsRUs · 17/03/2024 12:33

Husband is fucking angry with me. Received an invitation to his nephew’s wedding for us and our two daughters but not for my eldest daughter who is from a previous relationship.

Nephew’s response was that she was a step-relative who hadn’t been thought of but he didn’t think they were close.
He is closer in age to her and has known her longer than he has known the others.

I got his number off husband’s phone. He's furious with me.

Nephew is son of Brother-in-Law. The daughter of Sister-in-Law is invited with her toddler but my grandchildren aren’t invited.

When I found this out I rang him back asking how he felt closer to this family as they had grown up in different countries. He said he wasn’t willing to carry on the conversation.

BiL rang husband suggesting had I requested an invitation, one would be forthcoming, I don’t believe him. I get the sense it was more of control your wife.

I have no hope at all of my daughters not going, husband is definitely going.

I am fucking sick to my stomach. SiL rang me directly virtually threatening me saying I had upset people and not to involve my MiL.

Fucking furious.

People are going ask DD1 is 28, younger two are 19 and 20. Groom is 29.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
InterIgnis · 21/03/2024 09:47

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:19

You’ve misunderstood my comment. My comment was surrounding the interment that somehow the other sisters shouldn’t have an input as the older daughter is merely a ‘half-sister’. The wider situation being entirely separate to my comment!

They’ve had an input - they’re going.

InterIgnis · 21/03/2024 09:46

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:14

Erm… it’s hugely irrelevant. In the context of your post labelling & stressing, yet again, that the girls are ‘half-sisters’ was utterly needless.
You implied in your post that the girls should somehow be less ‘sisterly’ as their sister is merely their ‘half’ sister. The wider topic in that context is irrelevant. Siblings are siblings and labouring the ‘half’ when discussing their interaction is just plain weird.
I’ll carry on referring to my brothers as my ‘brothers’ (not just ‘half-brothers’!) regardless of the difficult family situations that occur - as if it’s some type of pass to bypass and treat them as lesser than the siblings that they are.

They are half sisters, which is entirely relevant because it means they don’t all share the same family. The younger two have a paternal family the eldest doesn’t, and they clearly don’t see why they should be obliged to sacrifice their own relationships with said paternal family because of their sister and mother’s preferences. Being forced to when they weren’t in a position to control that for themselves has only created resentment and cemented divisions, which is likely to have consequences for the sisterly, and maternal, relationships throughout their lives at this point. Ironic really, that OP’s refusing the accept the differences between them and attempting to force them as one package has achieved the exact opposite.

No one said you can’t consider your half brothers to be your brothers, but equally you can’t insist that anyone else has to consider their own half siblings to be the same as full siblings. This isn’t about you.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 21/03/2024 08:37

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:14

Erm… it’s hugely irrelevant. In the context of your post labelling & stressing, yet again, that the girls are ‘half-sisters’ was utterly needless.
You implied in your post that the girls should somehow be less ‘sisterly’ as their sister is merely their ‘half’ sister. The wider topic in that context is irrelevant. Siblings are siblings and labouring the ‘half’ when discussing their interaction is just plain weird.
I’ll carry on referring to my brothers as my ‘brothers’ (not just ‘half-brothers’!) regardless of the difficult family situations that occur - as if it’s some type of pass to bypass and treat them as lesser than the siblings that they are.

You’re being utterly ridiculous. It is in no way “needless” to point out that she’s their half-sister. It’s entirely relevant to the situation. They’re not treating her in a “less sisterly” way, as you put it; they’re simply going to their cousin’s wedding. Why would they protest about the lack of an invitation for her when she has a completely different relationship to the groom?

In any case, hasn’t it occurred to you, based on the OP’s posts, that they don’t feel particularly close to their older sister (half or otherwise)? That is allowed, you know. You can boast all you like about how you’ll carry on referring to your brothers as such - well, bully for you. How is it relevant to someone else’s life? I know plenty of close half-siblings, but also plenty of full siblings who aren’t close at all. This push to absolutely never acknowledge any potential difference in the relationship is what’s “needless”.

It’s bizarre how obsessed some people get with the idea that it’s somehow insulting to use the term “half” in relation to a sister or brother. It’s factual. There was an appalling story recently from Reddit that made the tabloids, where a father had forced his son to see therapists (three different ones!) in an attempt to force him to stop referring to his half-siblings as such. The selfish bastard was so blinkered over it that he had zero insight into how this was traumatising his son (and why two therapists had already refused to work with them any longer).

You see your brothers as full siblings. Great. That’s your choice. Don’t try to make that choice for others.

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 20/03/2024 23:46

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:19

You’ve misunderstood my comment. My comment was surrounding the interment that somehow the other sisters shouldn’t have an input as the older daughter is merely a ‘half-sister’. The wider situation being entirely separate to my comment!

No, I did understand dyou perfectly. I just disagree.
She is their half sister. And they are celebrating the half that she is not.

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:19

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 20/03/2024 17:24

Of course it does.
This is a wedding in their family. Not hers.

You’ve misunderstood my comment. My comment was surrounding the interment that somehow the other sisters shouldn’t have an input as the older daughter is merely a ‘half-sister’. The wider situation being entirely separate to my comment!

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 23:14

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 20/03/2024 17:33

Erm… it’s hugely relevant. It’s actually the key point of the entire thread.

OP thinks her eldest daughter should have been invited. Younger daughters who have been invited are related to the groom by blood. Eldest daughter is related by marriage. Eldest daughter isn’t close to groom, either in the literal sense of close family or in terms of how much time they’ve spent together. Hell, even the ones who have been invited aren’t that close to him (although how much of that is down to the OP, we don’t know).

I’ll ask again - why would they refuse to go if their half-sister isn’t invited?

Erm… it’s hugely irrelevant. In the context of your post labelling & stressing, yet again, that the girls are ‘half-sisters’ was utterly needless.
You implied in your post that the girls should somehow be less ‘sisterly’ as their sister is merely their ‘half’ sister. The wider topic in that context is irrelevant. Siblings are siblings and labouring the ‘half’ when discussing their interaction is just plain weird.
I’ll carry on referring to my brothers as my ‘brothers’ (not just ‘half-brothers’!) regardless of the difficult family situations that occur - as if it’s some type of pass to bypass and treat them as lesser than the siblings that they are.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 20/03/2024 17:33

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 16:10

Why is her being a half sister relevant? They were raised in the same home and are siblings. It doesn’t make them any less siblings. Weird comment.

Erm… it’s hugely relevant. It’s actually the key point of the entire thread.

OP thinks her eldest daughter should have been invited. Younger daughters who have been invited are related to the groom by blood. Eldest daughter is related by marriage. Eldest daughter isn’t close to groom, either in the literal sense of close family or in terms of how much time they’ve spent together. Hell, even the ones who have been invited aren’t that close to him (although how much of that is down to the OP, we don’t know).

I’ll ask again - why would they refuse to go if their half-sister isn’t invited?

Wibblywobblylikejelly · 20/03/2024 17:24

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 16:10

Why is her being a half sister relevant? They were raised in the same home and are siblings. It doesn’t make them any less siblings. Weird comment.

Of course it does.
This is a wedding in their family. Not hers.

Rosindub · 20/03/2024 16:39

OhmygodDont · 20/03/2024 16:21

Because the family who are inviting are not related to the sister. So the half matters why would you stage a protest for a sibling to attend a family event that’s not their family. Bonkers.

Add again they dislike/resent this sister because the mother has not allowed them to attend family events due to sister no way in hell can you expect them to fight her corner to their family.

Unsurprising as their mother has made it all about their oldest sister all their lives.

OhmygodDont · 20/03/2024 16:21

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 16:10

Why is her being a half sister relevant? They were raised in the same home and are siblings. It doesn’t make them any less siblings. Weird comment.

Because the family who are inviting are not related to the sister. So the half matters why would you stage a protest for a sibling to attend a family event that’s not their family. Bonkers.

Add again they dislike/resent this sister because the mother has not allowed them to attend family events due to sister no way in hell can you expect them to fight her corner to their family.

AlfrescoPotato · 20/03/2024 16:10

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 20/03/2024 15:22

Why? They are, as you say, adults - meaning they have independent adult relationships with the groom. Why would you expect them to stage a protest over the lack of an invitation for their half-sister, whom the groom barely knows?

Why is her being a half sister relevant? They were raised in the same home and are siblings. It doesn’t make them any less siblings. Weird comment.

HotChocolateNotCocoa · 20/03/2024 15:22

Bellaboo01 · 20/03/2024 11:41

I find it more odd that the ' youngest two' who are both adults would even contemplate going if their sister wasnt invited!

Why? They are, as you say, adults - meaning they have independent adult relationships with the groom. Why would you expect them to stage a protest over the lack of an invitation for their half-sister, whom the groom barely knows?

InterIgnis · 20/03/2024 13:10

justasking111 · 20/03/2024 12:59

Exactly @SlothsRUs started all this

I doubt she’ll see that, rather it will be everyone else’s fault for ‘being mean’. Even on here she’s been told to cut off her husband’s family, as if 1, they won’t enthusiastically welcome that, and 2, doing so won’t serve to further isolate OP from any family member that isn’t her oldest daughter.

I imagine she assumed that her daughters would naturally agree with her as adults, like they wouldn’t develop their own opinions and end up resenting her, and their sister, for missing out on their paternal family.

justasking111 · 20/03/2024 12:59

OhmygodDont · 20/03/2024 11:50

Because they don’t like her much due to all this batshittery

Exactly @SlothsRUs started all this

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 20/03/2024 12:48

DD1’s dad chased a music career rather than a relationship with his daughter. I don’t expect the in-laws to replace him. I just expected kindness and to be invited to a wedding where other cousins are invited who she has known longer than her sisters.

Yes you did expect your in laws to replace him because you said yourself they were always kind to her (so they offered the kindness you say is all you wanted) and you fully admit you wanted them to treat her exactly the same as a grandchild or niece / nephew - what is that then if not expecting them to replace her father’s family? Even now you’re saying “other cousins” even though they’re not cousins.

Also you declined a previous wedding invitation where your eldest was invited but not asked to be flower girl (there is a significant age gap). In my family, we’re all full biological siblings but even so, there were various weddings where some of us were in the wedding parties & others weren’t because of our ages - that’s perfectly normal. Even with family sleepovers & activities, my parents certainly didn’t expect all of us to be included in every single thing just because we were siblings.

Bellaboo01 · 20/03/2024 11:57

OhmygodDont · 20/03/2024 11:50

Because they don’t like her much due to all this batshittery

Oh sorry - i didnt read the whole post (which i know is a crime on Mumsnet - lol!)

So that makes sense then, if the 2 adult youngest children dont get like/get on well with the eldest one then i dont blame them from going and trying to keep a relationship with their family.

OhmygodDont · 20/03/2024 11:50

Bellaboo01 · 20/03/2024 11:41

I find it more odd that the ' youngest two' who are both adults would even contemplate going if their sister wasnt invited!

Because they don’t like her much due to all this batshittery

Bellaboo01 · 20/03/2024 11:41

SlothsRUs · 18/03/2024 18:18

I appreciate posters’ responses.

I never stopped my younger daughters seeing their father’s family, I didn’t however, facilitate the relationship I.e. take them there myself. DH could have taken them and I couldn’t have stopped him.

We, as a family saw DH’s family a few times a year but not on special occasions as my eldest would have been sidelined.

It is this BiL who lived the ex-pat life but they have been back years and know my eldest girl quite as well as the younger two.

Had none of them been invited I might have been upset but would not have raised it as an issue at all as they all would have been equal. As for my grandchildren, they should be invited as the equivalent child I.e. SiL’s grandchild has been invited. The only difference being DNA and ‘blood.’

As for being upset with my younger two for going to the wedding, those who say they shouldn’t go how would I stop them? They already blame me (not their dad) for their infrequent relationship with this exclusionary family.

DD1’s dad chased a music career rather than a relationship with his daughter. I don’t expect the in-laws to replace him. I just expected kindness and to be invited to a wedding where other cousins are invited who she has known longer than her sisters.

I find it more odd that the ' youngest two' who are both adults would even contemplate going if their sister wasnt invited!

Damnedidont · 20/03/2024 11:03

LadeOde · 17/03/2024 19:46

A 28 year old 'child' who is a mother herself and doesn't even live with OP anymore? OK.

As I effectively said that twice in my post I think it's safe to assume that is my position! What you do with those feelings is a separate issue on

StockpotSoup · 20/03/2024 09:53

I think this is a “Chicken or Egg?” situation. OP admits herself that her in-laws were always nice to her daughter. Maybe if she hadn’t expected them to instantly treat a stranger as a grandchild and had given them time for a natural bond to build, it would have happened. Would it necessarily have been the same as a “typical” grandparent-grandchild bond? Maybe not - but it could still have been there. I’m not as close to my cousins as my siblings, but that doesn’t devalue the relationship I have with my cousins.

An awful lot of this seems to have been caused by OP’s “all or nothing” approach. Most people wouldn’t expect a teenage girl to be invited to be a flower girl alongside much younger siblings - yet according to OP, this was serious enough to pull her entire family from the wedding. Perhaps if she hadn’t gone for such extreme measures, the step cousins would have seen more of one another and bonded naturally as friends - and OP’s eldest would be going to the wedding on THAT basis.

Crazycrazylady · 20/03/2024 09:22

SlothsRUs · 18/03/2024 18:18

I appreciate posters’ responses.

I never stopped my younger daughters seeing their father’s family, I didn’t however, facilitate the relationship I.e. take them there myself. DH could have taken them and I couldn’t have stopped him.

We, as a family saw DH’s family a few times a year but not on special occasions as my eldest would have been sidelined.

It is this BiL who lived the ex-pat life but they have been back years and know my eldest girl quite as well as the younger two.

Had none of them been invited I might have been upset but would not have raised it as an issue at all as they all would have been equal. As for my grandchildren, they should be invited as the equivalent child I.e. SiL’s grandchild has been invited. The only difference being DNA and ‘blood.’

As for being upset with my younger two for going to the wedding, those who say they shouldn’t go how would I stop them? They already blame me (not their dad) for their infrequent relationship with this exclusionary family.

DD1’s dad chased a music career rather than a relationship with his daughter. I don’t expect the in-laws to replace him. I just expected kindness and to be invited to a wedding where other cousins are invited who she has known longer than her sisters.

Honestly op.

I know that this has been hard for you to accept but your husbands wider family do not see your dd as the same as your husbands children.

You keep saying 'you would never exclude based on blood or Dna' but not everyone is the same and while of course your dh made the decision to take her on as a daughter in all ways, his wider family didn't make the that choice.

Would it be kind of them to adopt her as one of them, of course it would but not all blended families are the same and I think if your dd was away at weekends visiting her own dad and grandparents, and cousins then this would all sting less for you, which I think means at some level you were expecting your husbands family 'to pick up the slack for your daughters deadbeat dad' which probably isn't strictly fair either.

It's clear that they don't see your daughter as a biological member of the family and you can't force them to, restricting your other daughters relationship with them as a result was a mistake , two wrongs never make a right .ultimately you can hope at the start that they incorporate her fully into their family, but you don't get to insist because ultimately she is not their cousin or grandchild and if you have your dh ever split. They would probably never see her again. Some people can be wary or blending fully for that reason.

I suppose I'm surprised you're so distraught when all along you knew they didn't view her the same as a cousin. It's almost like this is a total shock to you which is why you acted so poorly.

Step back from his family now and be honest with your dd in that her sisters relationship with her fathers family will be a bit different to hers. Honesty here is the best policy so as to protect her a bit from being gutted when she isn't treated the exact same .

justasking111 · 19/03/2024 15:11

Well she'll be smarting now so don't expect to hear from her again

QueenOfTheLabyrinth · 19/03/2024 14:48

crockofshite · 18/03/2024 21:18

The younger girls' father didn't facilitate a relationship with his own family either. There's got to be a good reason for the distance between him and his 'blood' family.

Well look at the drama OP has caused here, do you really think she would have let him take the younger two to see his family quietly? And OP has categorically said she didn’t allow them to go for special occasions because of the eldest so birthdays, Christmas, weddings etc.

Also note OP’s language, she says she couldn’t stop him, not that she wouldn’t.

HunterHearstHelmsley · 19/03/2024 08:01

justasking111 · 18/03/2024 22:01

Because he just wanted a quiet life

I thought OP saying she COULDN'T stop him taking the younger two, not WOULDN'T was quite telling.

LimeAnkles · 18/03/2024 23:24

Cas112 · 17/03/2024 12:52

He can invite who he wants op

He should probably uninvite you 😂

😂😂😂