Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think animal shelter charities push potential pet adopters towards breeders with their absurdly stringent adoption criteria?

347 replies

Thepeopleversuswork · 17/03/2024 10:55

OK so I’m probably being grumpy about this because I have had bad experiences and maybe unfair.

But I have just been turned down for a third time in five years trying the adopt a cat, apparently (as far as I can tell) because I have a job and live in a city.

I’m a middle aged woman living in a quiet street on the outskirts of SE London with my own home and a teenager and partner. I have sufficient income to support a cat. I have a large back garden. I am an animal lover who has had cats before.

The last two charities I have applied to had ridiculously detailed diligence procedures including several home visits and a dodgy quasi isometric test. Another agency which imports stray cats from overseas required me to send videos of the traffic on every street within a half mile radius and character references.

After weeks of consideration I was told in each case that I couldn’t adopt due to traffic risk.

I get that the volunteers at these places become very attached to their animals and of course it’s only right that people are vetted before taking an animal, especially one that has been mistreated. But the rigmarole in the application process is ludicrously over the top and it’s hard to avoid the conclusion that they basically don’t want you to adopt a cat unless you live in a huge rural stately home and don’t have a job. As soon as they hear the word “London“ or any indication that you work outside the home they basically rule you out in my experience.

I’ve now gone down the route of getting a cat via Gumtree but it makes me sad and it seems so self defeating; these charities are putting well meaning and committed animal lovers off applying and making it far easier for unscrupulous people to breed and sell animals.

Can anyone who works for one of these charities try to explain why it’s so difficult?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
8
Offcom · 17/03/2024 12:38

Growlybear83 · 17/03/2024 11:50

I've found Celia Hammond to be the very most difficult of the rehoming charities I've contacted over the years.

Friends were turned down by Celia Hammond – one of them was almost always working from home during the day and they have a rear garden, but were turned down because they didn't want to put a catflap in their conservatory door.

Obviously it's up to Celia Hammond what their policies are and it didn't drive my friends to a breeder (they just didn't bother getting a pet at all). But it did make me wonder who they deemed to be acceptable!

Soubriquet · 17/03/2024 12:32

Some rescues are very strict and do a disservice to their brand. They then wonder why they are over run and “no one wants to adopt anymore”

They need to be flexible and take applications one by one instead of discounting immediately

Iheartmysmart · 17/03/2024 12:26

I’ve now been turned down for three rescue dogs in the last couple of months. No reason given but I can only assume it’s because I live in a flat without a private garden. But I lived here quite happily with my spaniel for several years with no issues.

I work from home permanently, live alone so no children to take into account and have miles of lovely walks across the road. My flat is also in a block of just two with our own private entrance, the communal garden is literally 10 steps away.

I do find a bit irritating when I get the ‘thanks but no thanks’ email followed almost immediately by one asking for donations.

Cockapoopoopoo · 17/03/2024 12:19

We adopted from Battersea and had two meetings and sent pictures of our garden but that was it. We both worked out of the home at the time and I don't recall that even coming up. Very odd

stayathomer · 17/03/2024 12:17

PinkSparklyPussyCat
There are cases of you can’t win sometimes! We have one indoor, one outdoor, if we forced either into the other situation we literally would not escape with our lives😂

Echobelly · 17/03/2024 12:15

I do worry about this for next time we want a cat - thus far I have managed never to have to adopt because fate seems to have sent us a cat (once a family friend moving who couldn't take their cat with, current cat a friend found abandoned as a kitten but couldn't take her herself). So I worry a bit a shelter will decide we're too near a main road - despite the fact neither cat we've lived with has gone anywhere near it, probably because it's too noisy and too many people.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 17/03/2024 12:13

@stayathomer, I've been turned down because I won't remove the cat proofing as I want the cat to be safe. According to Battersea (and others) cats need to roam.

Justwingingit2005 · 17/03/2024 12:12

We are registered to foster/ adopt a dog and have got a match.
We both work FT and the first thing asked was do you both work in offices or at home. Luckily I wfh but one rescue charity said they do not rehome to working away from the home FT as its not fair on the dog and I do agree tbh. She explained around half of all dogs surrendered are due to FTs saying they have no time for the animal.

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 17/03/2024 12:10

LlynTegid · 17/03/2024 11:56

I'm sure it happens but welcome animal charities being strict.

There’s being strict and being over the top which many of the charities are. What’s better, being stuck in a pen or in a home that may not have a spare room but can provide love?

TheDefiant · 17/03/2024 12:08

Yes totally agree. It took us 3 years and 4 different cat rescues before we could adopt our rescue moggies.

Some of the reasons were ridiculous. One organisation turned us down because my DH hadn't ever had a pet in his life (I'd grown up with cats,dogs and hamsters)

How would you ever get your first pet with that sort of rule?

Ugh.

Our cats now live a life of luxury: private health care, private door, 4 staff at their beck and call etc

NC03 · 17/03/2024 12:08

I used a small local rescue
My first boy came from cats protection, i rang his old fosterer to tell her he had passed Sad
She said she had set up her own rescue and weirdly she had been thinking about him that day as she had another cuddly, daft black male cat come in but of course it was way too soon...
I adopted him Smile
Basically after having my first boy it turns out she had said to the rehoming woman "give her any cat she wants because they will be living in luxury" Grin

To think animal shelter charities push potential pet adopters towards breeders with their absurdly stringent adoption criteria?
stayathomer · 17/03/2024 12:07

When you are looking for an animal yourself you can’t see outside of how much you want one but it’s only after you get one you see their sense. Two of our cats were knocked down and killed. I have known of people who have brought dogs or cats back because the dog/cat attacked them/their kids. People laugh about charities asking how high their walls are etc but we’ve all seen dogs wandering in traffic, heard of dogs killing sheep etc. And sorry but it is unfair in some cases animals living in apartments without a garden, or dogs being left for too long while the owner is at work with no other animal. The charity people know at some stage they could have that cat or dog brought right back to them but now with extra issues because it didn’t work out.

zendeveloper · 17/03/2024 12:03

CruCru · 17/03/2024 11:54

A friend adopted a couple of podencos and a cat from “Dog & Cat Rescue - Almeria to UK” (it’s their Facebook page). They get a lot of animals which have been treated cruelly (the podencos were dumped after hunting season ended).

I can't, of course, speak for all overseas adoption charities (have no idea about this one), but I've seen how this business works from the "other side", i.e. the overseas side, in one particular case. I don't doubt that the British side is genuine, btw, but the other side is... let's say, I just wish that some brave journalist did an undercover reporting of where those dogs actually came from.

Newsflash: if you adopted a young purebred dog from the "street" in a third world country, it was likely either stolen, or a leftover from a breeder there.

Seashor · 17/03/2024 12:00

I absolutely agree with you. We lived on the New Forest but were refused by the RSPCA because their home checker driving around in a 4 x4 with three overweight Labradors in the back decided our garden was too small.
Went to Dogs Trust instead.
p.s overweight is relevant because they looked like they could do with a run over the forest.

LlynTegid · 17/03/2024 11:56

I'm sure it happens but welcome animal charities being strict.

GinForBreakfast · 17/03/2024 11:56

Agree OP.

PilgorTheGoat · 17/03/2024 11:54

This is very cynical of me but I think a lot of smaller “rescues” actually really run as a charity to allow the owners to afford to keep several cats. There are some near me with a ridiculous list of criteria.

There are also many legitimate rescues who are realistic and keen to rehome to cats in their care.

CruCru · 17/03/2024 11:54

A friend adopted a couple of podencos and a cat from “Dog & Cat Rescue - Almeria to UK” (it’s their Facebook page). They get a lot of animals which have been treated cruelly (the podencos were dumped after hunting season ended).

soupfiend · 17/03/2024 11:53

Totally agree OP

zendeveloper · 17/03/2024 11:53

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/03/2024 11:49

Have you tried Celia Hammond OP? They rehome very sensibly I hear. They might only rehome in pairs if they think you won’t be home often enough.

But this is nuts - just ascribing human behaviour to animals. All cats I ever had or known really dgaf if someone spends extended time with them, they are not pack animals. As long as the food is there.

Thementalloadisreal · 17/03/2024 11:51

This happened to me when we lived in a quiet residential area but both had full time jobs. We were turned down by lots of shelters because we wouldn’t be at home all day?!

Growlybear83 · 17/03/2024 11:50

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/03/2024 11:49

Have you tried Celia Hammond OP? They rehome very sensibly I hear. They might only rehome in pairs if they think you won’t be home often enough.

I've found Celia Hammond to be the very most difficult of the rehoming charities I've contacted over the years.

zendeveloper · 17/03/2024 11:50

PinkSparklyPussyCat · 17/03/2024 11:02

I've had a similar problem but many of the rescues won't adopt to me because my garden is cat proofed and I won't let a cat roam. Another excuse for not allowing me to adopt is that I don't have a spare room (one rescue said surely I must have a room I don't use, as if I didn't know!). Another I didn't even bother applying to as although they were happy with cat proofing, it had to be done professionally. DH did ours and it's worked fine for years but I presumed they'd want proof. They also wanted to know whether we'd be trying for children in the next 10 years!

There are good rescues out there, I know that, but many seem to have too many tick box questions.

We must have gone to the same charity - I was turned down because I did not have a spare room as well, I worked full-time and the cat would be LONELY. Another charity thought that children (not toddler age, sensible and used to cats) is a danger, and that it was suspicious that our previous cat died aged 15, as cats are supposed to live much longer.

I got my cat from a breeder who is well known in the breed, and she did not ask even a tenth of the questions. I let her have kittens (mixed breed) once for all the people who don't want to buy a purebred for £0000 or go to the backyard for-profit breeders. All went for free, to families who similarly struggled to adopt.

ClaudiaWankleman · 17/03/2024 11:49

Have you tried Celia Hammond OP? They rehome very sensibly I hear. They might only rehome in pairs if they think you won’t be home often enough.

Growlybear83 · 17/03/2024 11:43

@CeratopsofthePharoahs I contacted the main Battersea branch as we don't live very far away. I was amazed by their response. I was less surprised by Celia Hammond refusing us a cat on the grounds of our road because a number of other people on our road have been refused too. I've lived in this road for almost 50 years and can only remember three cats having been run over in that time. Most people in the road are in our street WhatsApp group and there have been no injured cats in the four years it's been going.