Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say 'enough' and just get rid of it all?

88 replies

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 07:59

I know I am in a very fortunate position to have a nice house, lots of toys and clothes for my children, all the streaming platforms etc but I think it’s damaging us.

I dream of having a simple life, of my kids (ages 5 and 8) playing outside for hours and coming in when they're tired to do some reading or drawing, of eating simple meals, spending time together.

I do my best to limit their exposure to streaming platforms, online games etc but when I'm tired and overwhelmed with housework I capitulate and they know it. Also I spend too long on my phone (right now as a prime example, with kids sat in front of Disney+ while I type away). I want to get rid of Facebook etc but don't want to lose the ability to connect to the many people I've met through my life who I'm not close to but still fond of.

Older DC will read a bit to please me but I know she'd rather be playing on the ipad, or watching god-awful tween dramas where all the characters have mobile phones and fight with each other all the time. She loves buying stuff though and has a shelf full of books that she has chosen because they are shiny and cute but that she has never read. When I was her age I remember getting two books for my birthday and they were absolutely treasured and read over and over.

Younger DC is less interested in the TV and will happily come out for a walk with me but he, like his sister, has terrible concentration and struggles to get down to anything that isn't fascinating for him (thanks 24-hour entertainment on demand). His teacher has told me he is the same at school.

It all seems so simple to just take it all away (DH is very pro-technology and a spendthrift as well but he would do it to support me). But I actually feel scared to do it, which is ridiculous.

Please can you give me your opinions and your experience on this? Particularly keen to hear from those who have downsized in the same way! Thanks all 🌞

OP posts:
Grapesandcheesetwo · 17/03/2024 08:42

If they are really having only one hour a weekday and two at weekends, that sounds fine.
We have 2 hours max per day screen time. They need to set a timer themselves. Only BBC iplayer works on our TV and they have to watch from their profile so age appropriate. No Neflix, etc. Also have a Switch and older child has a tablet but wouldn't replace if it broke. Younger child's broke and we haven't replaced it and that has stopped lots of inappropriate rubbish. Good modelling would be if I cut down phone use too and I mean to but haven't yet.

NotSmallButFunSize · 17/03/2024 08:40

There's a really good episode of the Motherkind podcast about screen time, have a listen - it talks about how you can balance it with other things and it not being the enemy when used appropriately, I found it really helpful

Octavia64 · 17/03/2024 08:40

Getting rid of screens will not fix concentration issues.

Me and my brother grew up in the 1980s. We had no screens because my mum disapproved of TV and there were very few computers in those days.

I was a real bookworm. My brother never read anything.

We still annoyed the crap out of our parents because that is what small children do - we played out on the street and had water fights in the summer. I remember constantly whinging to my mum that we were bored.

Small children have very short concentration spans. That's why at reception they teach in very short segments and then have a rotation of adult led and child led activities.

dudsville · 17/03/2024 08:39

You're harking back to a time they don't know, none of their friends know it, so it would be an extreme and isolating position to take especially as they've had all their lives so far in the current way of being a child. There are people who live the way you fantasise about but they do live a greatly different lifestyle. Whilst I do think my childhood was great, as you say, playing out for hours, no Internet, it's a big cultural shift you want to make here.

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:38

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 08:29

Yesterday mine were out of the house from 8am-12pm playing football. They then cooked lunch. They had an hour of (online!) tutoring, did some music practice then played a board game for 2 hours. Watched the football as a family then spent the evening/night online with their friends.

They're older than yours (12 & 14) but at no point have I been strict with their online time; they’ve reached this equilibrium quite naturally without me having to manage it heavily.

This would be a dream. Have your kids had unlimited access to tech their whole lives?

OP posts:
Createausername1970 · 17/03/2024 08:37

I hour after school and 2 hours each weekend day is not excessive.

My DS had about that amount, more on wet weekends. But it was the main TV screen, he didn't have a personal device until he was about 10. He is ND, so some of the popular activities, like soft play or indoor sports were too busy or to noisy so we did spend more time at home.

Do you make plans in advance to play board games or play with their toys with them or do you just let the days happen, based around your chores? I assumed play was the main order of the day and I fitted chores around him.

If you can reinstate your cleaner and just be more available to get down on the floor and play with them, then that might be a good compromise.

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:37

MissyB1 · 17/03/2024 08:22

5 & 8 crikey why have they got all this tech? My ds is 15, but at your kids ages his weekends were about swimming, bike rides etc he didn’t own a device of his own but was allowed to play the occasional Lego game on the PC. He read books because we didn’t provide much screen opportunities. At 8 he was working his way through the Famous Five books. Obviously he watched some kids TV but we supervised his choices.

You and your Dh have created this situation. If you want to change it you will have to work together. Arrange family activities for the weekends and hide the tech!

It's arrived gradually. Eg got the iPad for DD as she had homework on it, then she wanted a few games, then DS wanted what his sister had...

OP posts:
Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:35

Itsonlymashadow · 17/03/2024 08:33

I think you are just navel gazing to be honest. And I don’t mean that in a bad way.

Kids often aren’t really interested in things unless it’s fascinating. Short attention spans in children have always been a thing. It’s not entertainment in demand that cause this.

You are in a position where you can change your lifestyle if you want. You are in the privileged position of having so much you yearn for the ‘simple life’. But if you had to live the ‘simple life’ (lack of tech, streaming services etc), through no choice of your own, you wouldn’t be happy either.

I think you have a fairytale version of what life should be and it’s not stacking up. So you blame stuff and the modern world. Removing everything doesn’t mean it does exist. The wider world won’t change because you want it to.

This is beautifully put. Thank you 😊

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 17/03/2024 08:34

They are very young still, so should have strong limits of screen time.

How much are they having each day?

Cut down rather than stop.

It's also getting to spring, summer so much easier to be outside. I find.that we are all off screens in the summer and play in the garden. Whereas in winter when it's dark and cold the screens come out

Itsonlymashadow · 17/03/2024 08:33

I think you are just navel gazing to be honest. And I don’t mean that in a bad way.

Kids often aren’t really interested in things unless it’s fascinating. Short attention spans in children have always been a thing. It’s not entertainment in demand that cause this.

You are in a position where you can change your lifestyle if you want. You are in the privileged position of having so much you yearn for the ‘simple life’. But if you had to live the ‘simple life’ (lack of tech, streaming services etc), through no choice of your own, you wouldn’t be happy either.

I think you have a fairytale version of what life should be and it’s not stacking up. So you blame stuff and the modern world. Removing everything doesn’t mean it does exist. The wider world won’t change because you want it to.

colourfulcrochet · 17/03/2024 08:32

Read this article and do it. Phones, ipads, unending screen time, all damaging to kids.

www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2024/03/teen-childhood-smartphone-use-mental-health-effects/677722/

Autienotnaughtie · 17/03/2024 08:31

Dd has an hour after school and two hours at weekends of switch time. Tv he will sometimes watch a bit after school until tea. and maybe an hour or so at weekends. We have unfortunately developed a habit of ipad in the car which I regret. He sometimes plays on it a bit in the house but not loads. Odd 15 minutes here and there so I've not bothered to regulate it. The rest of the time we play board games or card games, he reads, we go to the park, trampoline parks, play golf, he loves maths so will do maths sums.

But he does often want to be entertained (only child)

Nannyfannybanny · 17/03/2024 08:29

You say you are overwhelmed by cleaning,do you work long hours? Trouble is, parents these days use tech/screens as babysitters. My youngest DD got her first phone at 14. She strictly limits screen time and tech for her DKs, 12 and 14. I have just this phone, which I only got because we wanted to volunteer during COVID, you you have to have a smart phone. Nokia for 8 years, only because there was no landline here. Was nursing,staff would be dealing with the patients and scrolling/texting on their phone at the same time.a PC, and one TV in the living room. I think it's a case of "Physician,heal thyself". You can't use tech all the time and tell kids not to.

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 08:29

Yesterday mine were out of the house from 8am-12pm playing football. They then cooked lunch. They had an hour of (online!) tutoring, did some music practice then played a board game for 2 hours. Watched the football as a family then spent the evening/night online with their friends.

They're older than yours (12 & 14) but at no point have I been strict with their online time; they’ve reached this equilibrium quite naturally without me having to manage it heavily.

Halfemptyhalfling · 17/03/2024 08:27

They are old enough to help with the housework or have their own chores. That way you are all more physically active and you get less tired yourself and less likely to succumb to sitting with phone.

Stainglasses · 17/03/2024 08:24

Restrict rather than remove.

Josette77 · 17/03/2024 08:24

Am I understanding correctly that they get one hour a day, and two hours Sat & Sun?

If so I don't see a problem?

Also if your 5 yo is struggling to focus at school this is unlikely to be the issue.

VestibuleVirgin · 17/03/2024 08:22

You want to live in an Enid Blyton novel.
Don't we all? We want kids who;
are seen and not heard
sit at the table to eat
converse about topics of the day
clear the table and wash-up without tantrums.
read voraciously, thus making them imaginative, independent, erudite and articulate (actually, the one single thing I wish kids did today)
But we are where we are...

MissyB1 · 17/03/2024 08:22

5 & 8 crikey why have they got all this tech? My ds is 15, but at your kids ages his weekends were about swimming, bike rides etc he didn’t own a device of his own but was allowed to play the occasional Lego game on the PC. He read books because we didn’t provide much screen opportunities. At 8 he was working his way through the Famous Five books. Obviously he watched some kids TV but we supervised his choices.

You and your Dh have created this situation. If you want to change it you will have to work together. Arrange family activities for the weekends and hide the tech!

Hannahoo · 17/03/2024 08:21

There's no way I'd do this. They only have an hour a day as it is and you want to remove that too? Times have changed, we don't live in the 1980's now.

XelaM · 17/03/2024 08:21

OP - sign your kids up for horse riding lessons (or similar fun outdoors pursuits). It completely changed my (now teen) daughter's childhood. She's still on her phone and on social media but spends all her time after school and on weekends at the stables in all weathers. It's done wonders for her mental and physical health and she's turned into a super teen. Also, it's a fantastic way to make friends outside school.

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:19

I won't let either of them on YouTube at all

OP posts:
Calamitousness · 17/03/2024 08:18

it’s unreasonable to want your children to relive your childhood. Life has changed so much. When I did my degree there was no internet. Hideous. Doing my post grad many years later was so much easier because there was internet by then. Progress has a lot of plus points. Screens can be educational. My son is currently learning multiple languages on duolingo. It’s fun. I think setting boundaries will work for you. No screens during daytime and for an hour at night sort of thing. As your children get older you’ll find they want to connect with friends online as well as out playing and that can be good too. But they are little. Go with what they need just now and move your boundaries as they grow. Unplugged is fine but it’s not better. Your best option is a bit of both. Nothing to stop you from taking screens out of your own life if you don’t want to watch tv etc for yourself. Just have tv in kids room/playroom or switch off when it’s you and dh at night and kids asleep. Again put your phone down after an hour and either put it in another room or switch it off. No need to stop having any access altogether.

roundcork · 17/03/2024 08:18

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ at the request of the user.

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 08:16

But you aren’t living in the 1970s, any more than you are living in the 17th century. Technology has moved on and this is the world now.

If you deny them access to the modern world, your children are likely eventually to resent you and rebel against your approach. As they get older it will be harder and harder to enforce; all of my DC’s homework is set and submitted via Teams. Their social lives are arranged via WhatsApp and in part conducted online too (when it comes to gaming).

Much better to aim for balance. Time away from screens and allowing room for creativity via boredom is important. But you also need to think about how to make the alternatives appealing in their own right, which won’t happen if you’re scrolling on your own phone.

We’ve been interactive with our kids to show them how to achieve balance. Lots of in-person board games, cooking together, family sports (tennis, paddle boarding etc), online art classes together, discussing the news, politics etc. They actively want to do stuff with us and in turn that has led to offshoots of independent non-screen activity as they’ve got older. It’s far from a simple wireless life but is rich, sociable and happy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread