Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say 'enough' and just get rid of it all?

88 replies

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 07:59

I know I am in a very fortunate position to have a nice house, lots of toys and clothes for my children, all the streaming platforms etc but I think it’s damaging us.

I dream of having a simple life, of my kids (ages 5 and 8) playing outside for hours and coming in when they're tired to do some reading or drawing, of eating simple meals, spending time together.

I do my best to limit their exposure to streaming platforms, online games etc but when I'm tired and overwhelmed with housework I capitulate and they know it. Also I spend too long on my phone (right now as a prime example, with kids sat in front of Disney+ while I type away). I want to get rid of Facebook etc but don't want to lose the ability to connect to the many people I've met through my life who I'm not close to but still fond of.

Older DC will read a bit to please me but I know she'd rather be playing on the ipad, or watching god-awful tween dramas where all the characters have mobile phones and fight with each other all the time. She loves buying stuff though and has a shelf full of books that she has chosen because they are shiny and cute but that she has never read. When I was her age I remember getting two books for my birthday and they were absolutely treasured and read over and over.

Younger DC is less interested in the TV and will happily come out for a walk with me but he, like his sister, has terrible concentration and struggles to get down to anything that isn't fascinating for him (thanks 24-hour entertainment on demand). His teacher has told me he is the same at school.

It all seems so simple to just take it all away (DH is very pro-technology and a spendthrift as well but he would do it to support me). But I actually feel scared to do it, which is ridiculous.

Please can you give me your opinions and your experience on this? Particularly keen to hear from those who have downsized in the same way! Thanks all 🌞

OP posts:
minipie · 17/03/2024 09:57

We have very limited screen time

Each child has one day a week where they can have 1hr screen time

Friday and weekends they are allowed about 2hrs in the evening if not out/busy - but often are busy.

It helps that they do a lot of activities and have a long ish school day plus homework so there isn’t a lot of spare time at home to fill.

One is good at coming up with non screen stuff to do (she loves drawing and reading) the other one not so much.

There is a fair amount of squabbling and mess creation when they are both at home and not allowed on screens. But I’m damned if I’m letting them veg on screens just because of that!

anxioussister · 17/03/2024 09:56

The advice I give my students parents, and that I try very hard myself to adhere to is two fold

  1. limit your own tech use as much as possible around them - this is so hard as a parent - reaching for your phone is the easiest way to check out / snatch some ‘me time’ (but ultimately it’s a short circuit because it doesn’t actually fill your ‘me time’ bucket - it just zones you out for a moment) - I try to have a book or magazine or a sketch book on the go that I can sneak a moment to myself with while still modelling not-relying-on-tech

  2. instead of saying ‘no’ to tech - say yes to everything else - even if it’s a bit inconvenient or messy. They suggest a cake? Let’s make it now! They mention it’s sunny - let’s race round the garden now! Etc etc

also lots of good advice above about having tech free times for everyone at meals / before bed etc

you got this!

RoberttPostesChild · 17/03/2024 09:55

XelaM · 17/03/2024 09:20

Just to say, my brother had a huge problem with gaming throughout school. This hobby turned into a career. He got a Masters in Advanced Computer Science from Cambridge, a PhD from Harvard and an unbelievably high-flying career in IT working for the largest banks and tech giants for ridiculously high money - all in his 20's. So don't dismiss your kids gaming hobbies as all bad 😂

That's completely valid of course, but this only happens to people who have the right dispositions in the first place, one in millions.

BeyondMyWits · 17/03/2024 09:55

What do you do? When you have downtime... do you sit on your phone? watch telly? Coming down to it... are you the default do-er? Do the kids help with laundry, cleaning, cooking? Do you get them involved, or just leave them to their screens whilst you skivvy for the family?

We are a tech heavy household - both I and dh worked in computing as a career.... but my girls play hockey... because I did. They play piano, because my Dh does. They sit and read a book because we do... sometimes on a device (my eyes aren't as good as they were). They are at uni now and cook, clean, do everything to stay clean and healthy - as they have always done it.

A lot of this requires parental involvement, engaging the kids so that they have less time... you will too.

Model the behaviour you want them to follow and take on to their future lives. That will include a lot of technology, some of which is purely for entertainment, some for learning, some to make other jobs easier.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/03/2024 09:54

BringMeSunshineAllDayLong · 17/03/2024 09:25

I HR per day of NO tech! Really. That's awful.
At your kids age we did the following:
3 days a week no tech/screens (usually Tues, weds, Thurs)
1 hour on Monday and Friday
2 hours at the weekend

Huge improvement in their behaviour, they read much more, played more, were nicer to each other. 3 of them are ND (ADHD &ASD) and screens were the easy go to for calming them down, but we worked out it meant they failed to learn other ways to self regulate and became more and more reliant.
The change was amazing. Harder now they are late teens as it's up to them more but we encourage days off still

I don't know I think on a school day that's not too bad... My younger kids are out from 8.30 until 4. Watch TV for an hour after school. They only have an hour screen free as the rest of the time they're eating, getting dressed, in the bath, asleep. If we had no TV at all on a weekday they'd have 2 hours screen free time.

KetchupKangaroo · 17/03/2024 09:54

I think there is a middle ground. I don't think isolating them totally when they are older is a good thing as they will miss references to popular culture and in their working lives it will be good to have some common ground.

You could encourage in a positive way, by encouraging them to learn to programme etc.

ZippyZappyZoo · 17/03/2024 09:53

I have similar fantasies. Instead I have deleted all social media apps, so I have to use my browser to go on them, turn my phone off 6pm-8am every day and my children aren’t allowed to go on tv until after dinner and bath so for around 45-60 minutes a day. No iPads / phones. They do use a laptop for homework 3x per week but that is literally homework only.

it can be done.

have seen massive differences in sleep, temperament and quality time.

PrincessTeaSet · 17/03/2024 09:50

I disagree with most on here. Screens are nothing but bad for primary aged children and letting your child use a screen is taking the easy option however you justify it to yourself. I strongly believe that most of the current mental health problems and behavioural problems are due to excessive screen use in young children.

For primary kids a good balance is 2 or 3 hours a week of TV on the family television. No iPad etc. I really disagree with schools encouraging screen use by setting primary aged children homework tasks that require screen use.

Every hour a child spends staring at a screen is an hour wasted. Wasting some time is obviously fine but the default for many children seems to be unlimited TV when they are not at school. There's no way that this doesn't harm their development.

When kids are not watching TV they don't need entertaining but there will be more mess, noise, arguing, needing to get things out for them etc.

RoberttPostesChild · 17/03/2024 09:49

You are in charge @Downdowndownsize My children had that childhood, it's a choice. It's only difficult when you consider other people's expectations, which I didn't, I only did what I thought was right for my children.

I embraced the mud, dirt and mess, but I also had cleaners. They had a garden, great outdoor things; the trampoline, wooden wagon, trees to climb. Dogs. Tech was present but ridiculously restricted; the internet was Ted talks, TV was a huge choice of carefully chosen DVDs. Masses of amazing books and games and toys. It all takes time, money and knowledge.

This was only a few years ago but I think it's much more difficult to do now, mostly because of external pressure. It's so easy to give in, most people do and will not help you feel good about doing your own thing.
I am so happy and proud, actually, that I held firm, that's probably the one thing I did right, in life. They have great memories of their 'deprived' childhood and it has served them well.

I always found the argument that children have to grow up with tech to be well-rounded learners totally nonsensical; it's a tool. Children have to grow their own brain. They don't need to be plugged int the matrix, it's the matrix who needs their brains (literally now, with AI).
Also, tech has been with us for about 2 generations and I've never met a child that had any difficulties catching up with it.

Tatumm · 17/03/2024 09:34

Do it, it is easy to reverse so if it doesn’t work you can reinstate them with more restrictions.

This generation will need more practical skills so the sooner you can start the better.

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 09:29

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 09:16

Not unlimited, but pretty generous. iPads have been around and accessible since they were toddlers, they’ve had Nintendos and a Xbox.

I haven’t really set rules and just hoick them off when I think I’ve not seen them enough, we’re off out or I want to play a game, or there’s homework etc to be done.

But that can often have been many hours on an evening or weekend. And now they’ll moderate themselves, take themselves off when they’re bored or want to spend time with us, and they’ll suggest things to do together or with their friends.

I should also add that their patterns ebb and flow. Today is wet so they’ll be outside less, and online more. We’re out for brunch together as a family and will walk the dog together this morning, but the afternoon is theirs to manage.

As long as their homework is done and their clothes are organised, I’ll leave it to them to decide how to spend their time. I’m happy we’ve had a good balance overall. Much less stressful for me too not to have to manage their time!

I suspect we will play another game as that’s something we all enjoy - would highly recommend that as a great way of interacting with them and they are happy to drop their phones for. Can recommend some corkers (for younger kids) if you’re interested.

BringMeSunshineAllDayLong · 17/03/2024 09:25

parietal · 17/03/2024 08:06

I'd put the tech away more often. Have 1 hr per day of no-tech time when you & kids all put away devices.

And for non tech toys, have them out on rotation. So have one week with (say) all the brio and wooden blocks out and play with those. Then put them away properly and get out Lego for a week etc. it means each toy seems new when you get it out and you & kids can set it up together etc.

I HR per day of NO tech! Really. That's awful.
At your kids age we did the following:
3 days a week no tech/screens (usually Tues, weds, Thurs)
1 hour on Monday and Friday
2 hours at the weekend

Huge improvement in their behaviour, they read much more, played more, were nicer to each other. 3 of them are ND (ADHD &ASD) and screens were the easy go to for calming them down, but we worked out it meant they failed to learn other ways to self regulate and became more and more reliant.
The change was amazing. Harder now they are late teens as it's up to them more but we encourage days off still

LegoDeathTrap · 17/03/2024 09:24

We have a rule of screens are for weekends only, but also plan things to do during the weekend that take them away (sport, parties, chores, family activities).

You can’t just ban them - you replace them
with something more engaging. That’s a very young age to be addicted to screens.

XelaM · 17/03/2024 09:20

Just to say, my brother had a huge problem with gaming throughout school. This hobby turned into a career. He got a Masters in Advanced Computer Science from Cambridge, a PhD from Harvard and an unbelievably high-flying career in IT working for the largest banks and tech giants for ridiculously high money - all in his 20's. So don't dismiss your kids gaming hobbies as all bad 😂

ComfyBoobs · 17/03/2024 09:16

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:38

This would be a dream. Have your kids had unlimited access to tech their whole lives?

Not unlimited, but pretty generous. iPads have been around and accessible since they were toddlers, they’ve had Nintendos and a Xbox.

I haven’t really set rules and just hoick them off when I think I’ve not seen them enough, we’re off out or I want to play a game, or there’s homework etc to be done.

But that can often have been many hours on an evening or weekend. And now they’ll moderate themselves, take themselves off when they’re bored or want to spend time with us, and they’ll suggest things to do together or with their friends.

Wishimaywishimight · 17/03/2024 09:11

What you want is to bring your children up in the 70s / 80s (not unreasonably), not sure how practical that is to achieve these days!

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 09:06

GreenWheat · 17/03/2024 08:51

My 12 year old DS has just taught himself how to build a computer using YouTube videos. It's not all bad. I think it's rather lazy parenting to dismiss it all, instead of doing a bit of research, imposing limits and living in the modern world.

They sometimes watch drawing tutorials on YouTube when supervised but, as a general rule, they don't get it. Might be lazy on my part but it's not realistic for me to sit with them for an hour while they watch to check the quality and content of each short video they watch.

Also, this thread is not going as I expected 😅 I never thought I'd be accused of laziness because I don't let them on YouTube

OP posts:
Justrolledmyeyesoutloud · 17/03/2024 09:05

bubblebutt88 · 17/03/2024 08:06

Look, technology is part of life now. It just is. My ds spends hours gaming or gawping at his phone. I don't particularly enjoy it but I let it slide and don't have time restrictions on these things because he has a very balanced lifestyle (plays lots of sports, spends time outside, reads, draws and likes being out with friends) so if he chooses to wind down by playing PS or watching mindless crap on his phone it's fine. I do it too so who am I to tell him it's wrong?

I think we are obsessed with screen time and sure it can be a bad thing if it's all a child ever does or they are neglecting school/social life etc because they'd rather be on a screen. But otherwise I don't an issue. My son plays with his friends online and it's actually nice to hear them chatting and laughing together.

If your dc have balanced well rounded lives I wouldn't beat yourself up over screen time and I certainly wouldn't be taking it all away.

You are spot on with this reply x

Itsonlymashadow · 17/03/2024 08:53

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:35

This is beautifully put. Thank you 😊

Just to reassure you. My older brother is 47.

His gaming cause arguments in our house for as long as I can remember. Him rushing dinner, barely chewing it, to get more game time. Getting in from football and going straight in. Family days out had strips from him because he wanted to be over sooner and get home to the computer. This was a Commodore 64. When we got the mega drive it really peaked. His friends would come round an all sit in his room shouting and playing. This was the late 80s/early 90s. He continued to game for ages, until he met and moved in with his now wife.

They had kids and he didn’t want his children being the same over games as he was. So they have been really strict. They didn’t get access to a gaming computer until they were in high school, lots of time outside, loads of hobbies, very little screen time etc. And they are having the exact same problems with their ds. Who is now 14.

They got him a gaming computer as all his friends had one and it was becoming isolating as his friends all played. But he followed in his dad’s footsteps. The arguments are a repeat of dbros teenage years. Nephew pretty much ruined their recent trip away because it coincided with game coming out.

Dbro did everything ‘right’ in regards to limiting these things. But it’s still turned out to be a pain in the arse. I was more relaxed and lucky enough that Ds (13) can take it or leave it. Last night he opted to sit and watch a movie with me, rather than go game. He wanted to take the dogs on a long walk yesterday so that’s what we did and had lunch out. I even play the games with him sometimes. But he definitely isn’t obsessive. I don’t think I did it right, it’s just worked out that way. Being relaxed won’t work for everyone.

My point being you do the best you can and it will turn out how it turns out. But it doesn’t mean you need to scrap your life and start again. And that it’s not a completely new thing. I would guess that previous generations also saw similar in their teens but over other things.

GreenWheat · 17/03/2024 08:51

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:19

I won't let either of them on YouTube at all

My 12 year old DS has just taught himself how to build a computer using YouTube videos. It's not all bad. I think it's rather lazy parenting to dismiss it all, instead of doing a bit of research, imposing limits and living in the modern world.

WandaWonder · 17/03/2024 08:47

I know us parents shape our children to a certain extent but I think it is unfair to make a massive change immediately

It does feel very dictorial, sure have discussions and make some changes but a blanket 'it is all going' seems dramatic

Dishwashersaurous · 17/03/2024 08:46

Two hours is not vary much, that's not even the length of a film.

Also don't make screens a reward for doing things as that just makes them more attractive.

They are just part of the things that can happen each day. Don't make them the ultimate goal

Octavia64 · 17/03/2024 08:46

Commenting on the second part of your post:

As an adult I chose to give my kids screen time and consoles although I didn't have them.

I had problems socially at school and not knowing the TV series that other children were talking about didn't help me at all.

My mum chose for me to have a childhood cut off from tween culture. It was horrible. I did not want my children to have that as I felt so excluded from friendships as a result.

My kids were able to talk about the latest fad with their friends. My son got into Pokémon and it helped him make friends at school.

Tv, computer games etc are important to building friendships in tweens and teens.

Even my parents say I turned out strange and they blame it on the lack of TV.

Meadowfinch · 17/03/2024 08:46

The trouble is you are in danger of isolating your dcs, especially the older one. All her friends will be talking about their tween dramas, and she won't be able to join in.

Her world is not the same as your childhood and she needs to navigate it with relevant knowledge.

That's not to say there can't be a balance, but they have limited screen time as it is.

Dishwashersaurous · 17/03/2024 08:44

Also on the reading side, they are still young. Are you reading every single night to them? At that age still read every night for half s hour to the children. Then they could carry on reading if they wanted to.

Need to make reading normal, but it's not something in the middle of the day. It's a bedtime thing normally.

Think it might help you to have a routine and feel like you are in control.

So everyone goes for.a.walk, swim, family activities in the morning. Then lunch. Then craft . Then can have screen time.while you tidy up. Then all make dinner together etc