Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say 'enough' and just get rid of it all?

88 replies

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 07:59

I know I am in a very fortunate position to have a nice house, lots of toys and clothes for my children, all the streaming platforms etc but I think it’s damaging us.

I dream of having a simple life, of my kids (ages 5 and 8) playing outside for hours and coming in when they're tired to do some reading or drawing, of eating simple meals, spending time together.

I do my best to limit their exposure to streaming platforms, online games etc but when I'm tired and overwhelmed with housework I capitulate and they know it. Also I spend too long on my phone (right now as a prime example, with kids sat in front of Disney+ while I type away). I want to get rid of Facebook etc but don't want to lose the ability to connect to the many people I've met through my life who I'm not close to but still fond of.

Older DC will read a bit to please me but I know she'd rather be playing on the ipad, or watching god-awful tween dramas where all the characters have mobile phones and fight with each other all the time. She loves buying stuff though and has a shelf full of books that she has chosen because they are shiny and cute but that she has never read. When I was her age I remember getting two books for my birthday and they were absolutely treasured and read over and over.

Younger DC is less interested in the TV and will happily come out for a walk with me but he, like his sister, has terrible concentration and struggles to get down to anything that isn't fascinating for him (thanks 24-hour entertainment on demand). His teacher has told me he is the same at school.

It all seems so simple to just take it all away (DH is very pro-technology and a spendthrift as well but he would do it to support me). But I actually feel scared to do it, which is ridiculous.

Please can you give me your opinions and your experience on this? Particularly keen to hear from those who have downsized in the same way! Thanks all 🌞

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Windwwwash · 17/03/2024 18:55

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 08:35

This is beautifully put. Thank you 😊

Children might have had short attention spans around some things, but research is mounting that tech is definitely making it worse across a wider range of things, and making short attention spans shorter.

It comforts us as parents to pretend it’s always been this way, and tech is fine, but that’s because we’re all hooked on our tech too (I know I have been). Silicon Valley CEOs don’t let their kids have smartphones of tablets until they are way older, because they know exactly how harmful it is, to our learning, development, emotional regulation, socialising, attention spans, and focus.

Try it for a month, all of you, to massively reduce your tech use and just use it when you choose to, not when your addiction tells you should. You’ll have withdrawals, but it makes a huge difference, I promise.

Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 14:25

Oh and about the cleaning, yes I work ft with a fairly long commute so once I'm done with making dinner and helping DC with homework of an evening, it doesn't leave me much time for cleaning, laundry etc. DH gives the house a good going over on a Saturday morning but works late during the week so I'm on my own

OP posts:
Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 14:22

Ohhbaby · 17/03/2024 12:07

We are a no tv time/screens family. Honestly I don't know how to word it because it's so normal to me. We don't have a tv because we didn't get one after we married. We spend time with each other in the evenings etc. once we had kids I obviously didn't want to expose them to tv too early (I mean we didn't have it growing up so its not a necessity) but then as my children grew and made more friends and I got exposed to childrens programmes I thought 'whats the harm?'
So we started an episode of thomas the tank engine on you tube once every 3 days. Not even for me to have some me time. I thought I was doing it as a treat. (🙈I know)
Then obv every time I put in off, they wanted more. We suddenly had fights we've never had before. And because it was an option I would use it more. And it made me lazy, because now they were on screens so I started spending more time on my phone too. I also started noticing the kids couldn't play as independently as before. Like they'd be under my feet and ask 'mom what can we do?' and my children were great at playing alone. My 20 month old can play with blocks for 30-45 minutes without needing any input from me. My 3.5 year old can spend 2 hours building duplo or playing outside in the sand without needing an adult. And the older ones don't need any input at all .
I honestly never understood parents who said 'i put the tv on so I can get a break or get something done'
I was like 'surely you just send them out to play?'
Only once I introduced tv did I understand that it's the norm in other households that toddlers can't play alone.
We just stopped it cold turkey. I mean what do they really gain from it? Don't tell me 'awhh you can't shield your children from tech for ever'
It's not tech. They're not programming or inventing something.
They're mindlessly watching absolute bogus.

Then you gate parents that say 'ahh yes but ist educational, it teaches them language'etc. That's also bull
Do you think a tv is better at teaching a child language than a responsive parent?
No.
A one dimensional game better at teaching shapes than touching, feeling and using your own body to draw shapes?
No

I also think cold turkey is easier. Think about if you have a slab of chocolate and you tell yourself you can only eat one block. Much harder than not having the block at all. Now I end up thinking about the block the whole time!
Same with kids, if there is no sweets in the house the kids accept it easily. Of there is a packet and you only give one each, how much harder do you have to fight them?

Also to the people saying it's not realistic, why not?
Why do you think a tv is so integral to your life that it's not realistic to get rid of it?
I would just cut screens cold turkey.
As with social media, my first suggestion would be to delete the apps of your phone and only access them via your laptop. That way you'll spend less time on them.

I think this is exactly what I mean... it often feels like they are just killing time until screen time again, rather than really enjoying the moment they are in. If streaming/ Internet wasn't an option for them then they wouldn't miss it in the same way, I don't think.

OP posts:
Downdowndownsize · 17/03/2024 14:19

StoatofDisarray · 17/03/2024 12:35

Maybe you could lead by example/satisfy your "simple life" urges by cooking all your meals from scratch using only local, seasonal and sustainable ingredients?

That opens another can of worms! We have a great farm shop in the village selling only local produce, and I'd be delighted to buy all our food there, but of course my children much prefer berries and avocados to local wintery produce. That'll get easier in the summer though!

OP posts:
Bloom15 · 17/03/2024 13:20

KERALA1 · 17/03/2024 08:03

It’s the world they live in though so not sure going off grid is entirely fair. Definitely limiting tech for younger children is a good idea. Our now teens didn’t have any screens except some telly after tea and did lots of playing in the garden and reading as a result.

Completely agree!

DS is 8 and aside from reading his book all his homework is done online. So we'd NEED a laptop, tablet or smartphone.

OP just needs to limit the time DC are on 'things' if she feels it's too much.

With regards to streaming shows and films, when I was primary aged (43 now so eons ago!) I would watch videos of films I liked

StoatofDisarray · 17/03/2024 12:35

Maybe you could lead by example/satisfy your "simple life" urges by cooking all your meals from scratch using only local, seasonal and sustainable ingredients?

Itsonlymashadow · 17/03/2024 12:26

Ohhbaby · 17/03/2024 12:11

I'm a young mum and we don't have a tv, ipad or anything. Obv we have phones but children don't access them
I honestly don't think it's hard, parents just don't want to do it. They're using it as childcare which has short term gain but long term loss as kids can't play independently anymore .
You just have to decide.
I don't feel any external pressure to give my kids screens, but I think most people internally thi k they wouldn't cope if the didn't have screens.
Just my experience and I know this will sound harsh but I think parents don't have the balls to take it away

How old are your kids?

RoberttPostesChild · 17/03/2024 12:21

zaxxon · 17/03/2024 10:29

Congratulations to all those posters whose children play outdoors, are indifferent to screens, enjoy a wide range of activities, volunteer to spend time with their parents, etc

Your comments have made me feel a hundred times worse, as I think about my own screen-addicted teenage DC. So thanks for that.

And yes, we rationed TV (tightly!) all through primary school, didn't get them smartphones till year 7, offered all kinds of activities and outings and fun stuff ... we did everything that people always recommend on these threads. It didn't make any difference.

Don't feel bad, it's very tough to go against the grain. There's a huge societal push towards tech + the products themselves are designed to be addictive. I mean there's a thread somewhere by someone 'from Silicon Valley' about their 'robotic childcare' app project and people think it's a really interesting idea apparently, on another thread a poster said after school club consists of DCs plonked in front of a screen, etc. it's mad.
Circumstances vary, there's only so much you can do.
No phones before year 7, a range of activities, etc. are a really good basis, in the long term it makes a huge difference. Even if they go through a phase of being obsessed with screens as a teenager and all seems lost for a while, they have the resources for something else.

Ohhbaby · 17/03/2024 12:11

RoberttPostesChild · 17/03/2024 09:49

You are in charge @Downdowndownsize My children had that childhood, it's a choice. It's only difficult when you consider other people's expectations, which I didn't, I only did what I thought was right for my children.

I embraced the mud, dirt and mess, but I also had cleaners. They had a garden, great outdoor things; the trampoline, wooden wagon, trees to climb. Dogs. Tech was present but ridiculously restricted; the internet was Ted talks, TV was a huge choice of carefully chosen DVDs. Masses of amazing books and games and toys. It all takes time, money and knowledge.

This was only a few years ago but I think it's much more difficult to do now, mostly because of external pressure. It's so easy to give in, most people do and will not help you feel good about doing your own thing.
I am so happy and proud, actually, that I held firm, that's probably the one thing I did right, in life. They have great memories of their 'deprived' childhood and it has served them well.

I always found the argument that children have to grow up with tech to be well-rounded learners totally nonsensical; it's a tool. Children have to grow their own brain. They don't need to be plugged int the matrix, it's the matrix who needs their brains (literally now, with AI).
Also, tech has been with us for about 2 generations and I've never met a child that had any difficulties catching up with it.

I'm a young mum and we don't have a tv, ipad or anything. Obv we have phones but children don't access them
I honestly don't think it's hard, parents just don't want to do it. They're using it as childcare which has short term gain but long term loss as kids can't play independently anymore .
You just have to decide.
I don't feel any external pressure to give my kids screens, but I think most people internally thi k they wouldn't cope if the didn't have screens.
Just my experience and I know this will sound harsh but I think parents don't have the balls to take it away

Theinjuredcleaner · 17/03/2024 12:09

I think the ideal you're chasing doesn't exist. The rise of 'cottagecore' on Instagram and tiktok showing happy families collecting eggs, baking bread, and walking through flower meadows is as fake as a promise from the Tory party. Those creators spend DAYS on their smartphones, computers, cameras, and editing software to create the perfect 10 second video. They dont live the life they portray, its all a money making enterprise. Playing out before the Internet also wasn't a bed of roses. I grew up in the 80s and was kicked out until the streetlamps came on. I remember bullying, creepy men, and a whole host of dangerous situations that never should have been allowed. Let your kids have their technology but also schedule in some outdoor stuff. Don't feel guilty for adapting to the world we live in.

Ohhbaby · 17/03/2024 12:07

We are a no tv time/screens family. Honestly I don't know how to word it because it's so normal to me. We don't have a tv because we didn't get one after we married. We spend time with each other in the evenings etc. once we had kids I obviously didn't want to expose them to tv too early (I mean we didn't have it growing up so its not a necessity) but then as my children grew and made more friends and I got exposed to childrens programmes I thought 'whats the harm?'
So we started an episode of thomas the tank engine on you tube once every 3 days. Not even for me to have some me time. I thought I was doing it as a treat. (🙈I know)
Then obv every time I put in off, they wanted more. We suddenly had fights we've never had before. And because it was an option I would use it more. And it made me lazy, because now they were on screens so I started spending more time on my phone too. I also started noticing the kids couldn't play as independently as before. Like they'd be under my feet and ask 'mom what can we do?' and my children were great at playing alone. My 20 month old can play with blocks for 30-45 minutes without needing any input from me. My 3.5 year old can spend 2 hours building duplo or playing outside in the sand without needing an adult. And the older ones don't need any input at all .
I honestly never understood parents who said 'i put the tv on so I can get a break or get something done'
I was like 'surely you just send them out to play?'
Only once I introduced tv did I understand that it's the norm in other households that toddlers can't play alone.
We just stopped it cold turkey. I mean what do they really gain from it? Don't tell me 'awhh you can't shield your children from tech for ever'
It's not tech. They're not programming or inventing something.
They're mindlessly watching absolute bogus.

Then you gate parents that say 'ahh yes but ist educational, it teaches them language'etc. That's also bull
Do you think a tv is better at teaching a child language than a responsive parent?
No.
A one dimensional game better at teaching shapes than touching, feeling and using your own body to draw shapes?
No

I also think cold turkey is easier. Think about if you have a slab of chocolate and you tell yourself you can only eat one block. Much harder than not having the block at all. Now I end up thinking about the block the whole time!
Same with kids, if there is no sweets in the house the kids accept it easily. Of there is a packet and you only give one each, how much harder do you have to fight them?

Also to the people saying it's not realistic, why not?
Why do you think a tv is so integral to your life that it's not realistic to get rid of it?
I would just cut screens cold turkey.
As with social media, my first suggestion would be to delete the apps of your phone and only access them via your laptop. That way you'll spend less time on them.

zaxxon · 17/03/2024 12:07

Thanks @Blanketpolicy . I agree that even in the past 10 years, it has become more of a problem. When my DCs were preschoolers, I didn't even have a smartphone myself, and we never had a tablet, still don't.

I guess my point from my rather bitter post above is that you can create the perfect balance with screen time and other activities for your DCs when they are young, and that's a really good thing to do ... but just be warned, when the gloom and withdrawal and dopamine-seeking behaviour of adolescence starts to manifest itself, all that can very quickly go out the window.

MillshakePickle · 17/03/2024 11:17

I have very strict screen times rules. No screens ever at the table. Dinners are always at the table as well. Screens during the week for school work only. And maybe the odd tv show on one of the apps. Weekends are a bit more relaxed with gaming and screens, but a max of 3 hrs spread out through the day. This can include the odd family movie.

We don't have a cable/satellite package, nor Netflix, Disney + subscription is up this month, and we aren't renewing. We have amazon Prime but won't renew in October. We also don't have Spotify.

Cutting back on all of the above will save us around £600/Yr.

With Disney + and Netflix, you can dip in and out any time. We will get Netflix for a month here and there, for example, over Christmas or summer hols. Plus, with the smart TV apps for bbc, itv, etc, there's always plenty to watch.

Meals are well balanced and can be on the more expensive side because we buy the best we can afford. I'm trying to limit upf as much as possible which is a struggle.

I'd rather put the money saved on family days out, holidays or kids clubs.

We schedule (otherwise, it's hard to get out sometimes) walks, national trust visits, and bike rides in for the weekends. After homework and dinner, we do family board games and stealth learning, reading, and all the cuddles.

I've been very strict with tech from day one and dh does follow suit. We do allow gaming, laptops, pads whatever to be used because they need to know how they work but also they are really good at asking and being told to do something else.

When feeling overwhelmed by the household tasks and life instead of letting the kids use screens, I'll set up a game, crafts or something in the garden and use that time have a coffee and read my kindle for a reset.

It works for us but understand it may not work for everyone.

takemeawayagain · 17/03/2024 11:15

I think the key is that you have to be living that life with them. So you can tell them to go do something else but as you say they will just be waiting until they can get back on a screen. But if you're playing a board game with them, planting some vegetables, baking a cake, reading a story, geocaching, making a birthday card for their dad - or whatever - then they will get into it as much as you do.

I still read to my 18 year old! We still play card games and board games, he hates gardening so that one didn't work out - but find the things that do work and go with them.

Screens take away the need for parents to put the effort in, especially after a long day at work. Kids don't 'need' technology, it's much more likely to expose them to bullying and inappropriate content then anything positive. You can learn how to use technology very quickly it's not some skill you need to develop from a young age and being in constant contact with friends just isn't necessary, certainly not at primary school, it's all just FOMO.

Blanketpolicy · 17/03/2024 11:05

zaxxon · 17/03/2024 10:29

Congratulations to all those posters whose children play outdoors, are indifferent to screens, enjoy a wide range of activities, volunteer to spend time with their parents, etc

Your comments have made me feel a hundred times worse, as I think about my own screen-addicted teenage DC. So thanks for that.

And yes, we rationed TV (tightly!) all through primary school, didn't get them smartphones till year 7, offered all kinds of activities and outings and fun stuff ... we did everything that people always recommend on these threads. It didn't make any difference.

I am one of those posters. But I was fortune smartphones/tablets were not really mainstream until ds(20) was around 9-10ish so he had already learned pleasure from social interaction and other activities. He learned how to behave in a restaurant without them, or the pleasure of board games, he had friends who were also not connected to screens etc.

If he has been born just 3-4 years later when screens exploded into our lives and were much more popular, I admit ds is likely to have go sucked into to them and I would have been unlikely to have noticed it taking over until it became an issue. Kids and screens and the negative impact is really just starting to be seen/known in the last few years and understandably some parents have been caught out with it.

I have no idea how I would have parented ds in his early years in this new screen orientated world.

Heronwatcher · 17/03/2024 11:02

In your position I’d go for a full digital detox for a couple of weeks, maybe even a month, and then bring it back in gradually and see what happens. If it’s too hard you could allow a bit of CBBC etc or a movie. But no hand held/ internet type devices for everyone.

We do this once a year and it’s great, breaks toxic habits and just gives a bit of breathing space.

Annielou67 · 17/03/2024 10:55

I’m with you op. It is so difficult, but is down to you. Restrict screens to 1 hr a day for all of you. When on your phone concentrate on contacting your close friends. Invite people round.
To have a simpler life, you just need to change your priorities ( actually there is no just about it, it’s bloody hard and I still fall into rabbit holes on my iPad when left to myself)

  1. buy consciously. Do I really need this/ can I buy it second hand/ is this a impulse buy?

  2. can you work less or prioritise family time more? Go for walks, collect leaves, teach them about nature. Or stay in and play games, do crafting. It involves parental time input.
    can you get your family involved in your community, whether it’s litter picks, or jumble sales - getting out and doing stuff for others.

  3. Involve your kids in food prep. As you said, eat simple. Make bread together, have homemade bread, homemade jam, cheese and maybe homegrown salad for tea every night. Go foraging for berries etc and then make something together.

  4. consider getting an allotment, or turning some of your garden to veggies. Make sure your children are involved and learn.

As someone said, very Enid Blyton. It’s about finding the right balance for your family. I started too late, my kids were too old, and too under the influence of screens. When they were younger I was working all the time. Now I live my ,more Beatrix Potter life, they are seeing this as adults and my daughter 23 months is better at controlling her screen time than I am - but she knits and crafts instead.

MothralovesGojira · 17/03/2024 10:43

I see where you're coming from but it's 2024 and not the 70's/80's and life just isn't like your imagination anymore - that horse well and truly bolted over a decade ago.
Firstly get a cleaner again to free up some time for you if you can afford it.
We used to have a games night once a week. We played a couple of games - the DC chose one each. Occasionally we'd do a jigsaw and used the time just for chatting about all sorts of stuff we wouldn't normally get time for.
On Sunday afternoons we would often do crafts like decopatch. I bought a selection of papers on Ebay/Hobbycraft, glue and papier-mâché animals/letters etc - it doesn't matter what they look like and any age can do it and it's fun. I also bought Sticker Dolly Dressing books and we'd do one of those on a weekend afternoon etc.
We'd do it less in the summer as we live near some great parks and some with paddling pools (all free).

HappyAsASandboy · 17/03/2024 10:39

I haven't ever limited screen time in general, though they do have parental controls that shut off phones from bedtime until morning.

We go through periods where one or more DC will seem obsessed with a screen for a while. I talk to them, explain why screens feel so good but that's it's temporary, and offer/suggest other activities. They often choose to do those activities, and agree that they feel better when they have a more balanced day.

I want them to be able to self regulate (like I struggle to do, I think because it was all so strictly managed by my mum when I was little). My eldest has spent far far far too much time on a games console over the last three weeks, but has cooked every meal this weekend and spent hours entertaining a preschooler on the garden, as well as an hour or two of gaming with his friends. Last night, unprompted, he said he felt so much better today for having spent time outside and with me/siblings. This is the reflection I am aiming for, and it felt so so good to finally get it!

RedMark · 17/03/2024 10:36

It's hard, op. I actually have the same vision as you, maybe it's the era we grew up in?

I can only share what we do. I have a 3.7 year old and a 13 month old. Unless sick, the 3 year old only gets 60-90 minutes of TV a day, and only when his brother is sleeping as the 13 month old rarely sees the tv on. Obviously in times of sickness for me or the 3 year old, I do no TV restrictions. Or some days I will pop a movie on together even if he's had his TV quota but that's not so often (I can imagine this becoming more often when he gets older).
We have no iPads / tablets and I don't want to buy any for the reasons you've mentioned above. And there's no watching anything on phones / laptops. I want to keep to this for as long as possible.

I try to get out as much as we can...even just the garden. But this could be more, I'm hoping with spring now we'll get out more. I'm not a natural outdoorsy person so I keep it simple. Walks in the rain to splash in puddles, the garden to play in the sandpit, a hour running around the park. Holidays are in mobile homes at camping sites.

I'm on my phone way too much. I'm trying my best to curb this. I hate I'm on it so much so I can't really help it.

It's so hard with technology everywhere. Our neighbours are very nature orientated /outdoorsy. They have two small children and don't even own a TV. I wish I could just get rid of everything too and hate that I feel I can't.

zaxxon · 17/03/2024 10:29

Congratulations to all those posters whose children play outdoors, are indifferent to screens, enjoy a wide range of activities, volunteer to spend time with their parents, etc

Your comments have made me feel a hundred times worse, as I think about my own screen-addicted teenage DC. So thanks for that.

And yes, we rationed TV (tightly!) all through primary school, didn't get them smartphones till year 7, offered all kinds of activities and outings and fun stuff ... we did everything that people always recommend on these threads. It didn't make any difference.

CharlotteBog · 17/03/2024 10:12

Do you work OP, or SAHM? I ask because you say you default to devices etc when you're overwhelmed with housework. What's causing the housework to be overwhelming?

KitchenSinkLlama · 17/03/2024 10:06

You aren't wrong OP. There are numerous articles available online that discuss how tech giants (Steve Jobs, Bill Gates etc) limited their children's use of tech and didn't permit phones until 12/13. They know the effects of tech on children's developing brains.

I'm glad my DC was born before 30 years ago when this wasn't a very big issue - it must be a minefield to navigate now for parents.

BigBoysDontCry · 17/03/2024 10:05

There wasn't so much tech when mine were that age but more so when they were teenagers. I think you just need to have times when you set that they can't use it. My two weren't allowed on screens on weekend afternoons (even when teenagers) . They either had to be out doing stuff or reading, playing board games etc. In the end they didn't even moan about it.

Sharptonguedwoman · 17/03/2024 10:02

ChannelyourinnerElsa · 17/03/2024 08:02

I feel like taking it all away is extreme and not actually the solution.

balance and moderation are the solution, technology is a wonderful thing used appropriately.

the solution here is to have more boundaries around appropriate use, surely? Otherwise as soon as they are old enough they will just make their own decisions and go back to it without ever learning to balance its use with other activities in life.

Yes, completely agree. Balance is key. Limit the time you and your children are on screen. I'm pretty sure my concentration isn't what it was-too much scrolling and skim reading. Facebook-10 minutes and do something else. Children, 30 minute or similar. These are just thoughts. If they have ipads, you can time limit the use.

I used to turn the router off in the days of 3G and once took it to bed with me to get my daughter off screen.