Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ignore son's claims about not being able to hear?

139 replies

SpinningTopps · 17/03/2024 07:05

Ds is 5 and has started to say he can't hear properly. He says he thinks he is deaf. But if I whisper he appears to hear everything I say. I think his hearing is fine.
I've looked into children's hearing tests and it seems you need a referral which seems a step too far.
AIBU to just assume all is fine or can you have hearing loss where you can hear whispers but other things are affected?

OP posts:
SpanThatWorld · 17/03/2024 13:51

MargaretThursday · 17/03/2024 12:18

Ds had glue ear. At a bad time he was hearing less than 10%.

In all honesty he adapted so well I would never have known if it wasn't for the hearing test due to multiple infections. He could lip read, used subtitles and used other signs to respond.
As I realised there were little things, such as if he was listening to something it would be a little louder. He'd react strongly to loud noise.
Also (ENT pointed this out) he'd pat my cheek to turn my face for lipreading, and also he often wanted to be carried when talking to me. Which was simply having his ear near my mouth.

Even at his worst he would hear the word chocolate whispered behind him.

Get him tested.

People are often fooled by children responding to a word of high importance to them but its the same principle behind most adults hearing their own name in a busy room - sometimes called the Cocktail Party Effect.

When information is missing, our brain tries to fill the gaps. If chocolate is of high importance, the brain might hear the loud, low frequency vowels OhUh and recognise the key word in a familiar context. They might also turn to Doctor or Hotter which have a similar pattern of vowels with quiet, high pitch voiceless consonants.

This is why OP needs a clinical Pure Tone Audiometry session rather than whispering in a car.

JPGR · 17/03/2024 13:22

My granddaughter kept saying the same thing. Turns out she had an ear infection in both ears.

Rinoachicken · 17/03/2024 12:53

Probably worth also asking his teacher if they have noticed any difficulty with phonics and sounding out words

StripeyDeckchair · 17/03/2024 12:47

Hes 5 & you don't believe him & won't do anything about his problem.

What you're teaching him is what he experiences & tells you is unimportant & can be ignored
What he's learning is that you won't support him or believe him when he comes to you with a problem.

Hearing loss can happen at specific frequencies not consistently across all.
YABVVVU

Wheresthescissors · 17/03/2024 12:27

Ffs OP just go to the doctor

Tiddlywinks63 · 17/03/2024 12:25

As someone who’s mother refused to take her to the doctor when I had a raging ear infection while on holiday in Spain, and am now profoundly deaf, I shudder at you ignoring your son.
My mother ignored me, I got walloped for being attention seeking. When I took myself to the doctors (aged 8) on returning home, my mother was summonsed and told that permanent damage had been caused. I don’t think she ever cared.

bluelavender · 17/03/2024 12:20

We thought that our child couldn't hear properly and ended up with a hearing test. Their hearing was fine. We accessed speech and language support. A few years later we had an ASD diagnosis.

Maybe try to explore his hearing challenges to ensure that there is no wider needs?

MargaretThursday · 17/03/2024 12:18

Ds had glue ear. At a bad time he was hearing less than 10%.

In all honesty he adapted so well I would never have known if it wasn't for the hearing test due to multiple infections. He could lip read, used subtitles and used other signs to respond.
As I realised there were little things, such as if he was listening to something it would be a little louder. He'd react strongly to loud noise.
Also (ENT pointed this out) he'd pat my cheek to turn my face for lipreading, and also he often wanted to be carried when talking to me. Which was simply having his ear near my mouth.

Even at his worst he would hear the word chocolate whispered behind him.

Get him tested.

BookArt · 17/03/2024 12:09

Definitely get the referral. My son used to get lots of ear infections, now has glue ear and his hospital hearing test showed his hearing was affected, but he can hear a whisper and a packet rustling haha! But he really struggles when there is background noise.

AudiologistHere · 17/03/2024 12:04

viques · 17/03/2024 12:01

Yes sorry, my anatomy knowledge is a bit hazy. I think that’s what I meant, the Eustachian tube is more horizontal so can’t drain out residual gunk as an adult ear can. I do know that glue ear is not an infection, but thought it could be caused when gunk caused by an infection produced the blockage.

Yeah, that's right, it's usually in relation to a cold. Only correcting so that people can understand the issue, not to be an arse, sorry! Often when I tell a parent that their child has glue ear they question whether they need antibiotics (which they don't).
Glue ear is a strange one in that the hearing loss can fluctuate to the extent that parents just think their child is being ignorant as sometimes they can hear and other times they struggle.

viques · 17/03/2024 12:01

AudiologistHere · 17/03/2024 11:54

The ear canal is properly formed. The Eustachian Tube is more horizontal in younger children though. Glue ear is not an infection but is congestion.

Yes sorry, my anatomy knowledge is a bit hazy. I think that’s what I meant, the Eustachian tube is more horizontal so can’t drain out residual gunk as an adult ear can. I do know that glue ear is not an infection, but thought it could be caused when gunk caused by an infection produced the blockage.

AudiologistHere · 17/03/2024 11:54

viques · 17/03/2024 09:56

This, I was told that the ear canal isn’t properly formed until about seven or eight years, so there is more likelihood of a residual build up infection following a cold in a child’s ear.

OP please get him checked, if his hearing is reduced then he is missing out on vital early learning, phonics, vocabulary etc which could really harm his learning, and just as importantly hamper his social skills.

The ear canal is properly formed. The Eustachian Tube is more horizontal in younger children though. Glue ear is not an infection but is congestion.

Nn9011 · 17/03/2024 11:41

There is a difference between hearing and processing what's being said. For example I have issues with my hearing but I also have delayed processing. So sometimes I can hear ok but it takes me 20/30 seconds to understand what's being asked. Most of the time you wouldn't notice and even I only realised it was 2 separate things as an adult. I find I need subtitles when watching TV to help understand it too.
You might find it helpful to ask your son what he means by his hearing, where is the difficulty and when does he find it hard.
Also, is he neuro divergent? Have dyslexia or dyspraxia? You mentioned always being at the drs, there are so many comorbiddities that it's common.
You don't have to be Nd to be delayed processing and it doesn't make you slow thinking so can often be missed.

DoAWheelie · 17/03/2024 11:25

Get him a hearing test. I was born with genetic hearing loss and the things I can/can't hear confuse the fuck out of my own family (and all of us have it! Though it does present differently in us all).

There are times I can't hear a blaring alarm next to me and times where I can hear a soft cats meows from three rooms away. In general I really struggle to hear voices and have to lip-read a lot but some people just have magic voices and I can hear every word they say. The opposite also happens - some people I just can't understand at all no matter how much I try.

You can usually just phone your GP and ask for a referral to audiology - I've done it a few times as I've moved around the country and needed to register in new areas for hearing-aid services. I've never needed an actual GP appointment for it.

There can also be non-deafness related issues that affect hearing and it's good to try and figure out if something like that is going on too before he gets too deep into school and starts falling behind.

Surfandtruff · 17/03/2024 11:14

It is really easy to just ask for a referral to audiology for a hearing test. I have both been the parent of a child where it turned out to be unnecessary and where it turned out to be wholly necessary. They were really good with my DC, the one who did have hearing issues and the one who didn't. Very progressional. There was no judgement on me as a fussy parent. Same as when I took them to the opticians for an eye test (no eye problems). It feels like a bigger deal because you need referring, but that's only because they are highly specialised to do the hearing tests on uncooperative children! It is also the first step if you do think there is a neurodivergent cause of the 'hearing' issue, as it's part of the autism screening process and the first step in a diagnosis of auditory processing disorder, also.

TequilaNights · 17/03/2024 11:03

I recently had glue ear and it's not a nice feeling to feel like your going deaf, it changes your perception of hearing things, which is worried me, and understood what it was.

my gp sent me for a hearing test to be sure.

Justanything86 · 17/03/2024 11:00

Even if they say his hearing is fine or its an processing issue it might be helpful going forward for the psychiatrists doing the asd assessment.

My sister recently went for a hearing test and they told her that her hearing is fine and she has a processing issue and she should be referred for an adhd assessment. I have adhd so this would make perfect sense to be honest but because she didn't present in the same way that I do she may never have thought to do it.

I would think a sensory processing issue on file would be a fairly big help for psychiatrists making a diagnosis and deciding what support needs to put in place for him. If it turns out he does have hearing frequency issues instead that might explain some symptoms that look like asd too so I can't really see any negatives in getting this done.

I wouldn't worry about going to the doctors too much either. Sometimes people are just unlucky or its part of a bigger picture and gps should know this really.

stormywhethers321 · 17/03/2024 10:53

Definitely take him to a doctor.

When u was younger, I told my mother something was wrong with my eyes. I could still see, could still read, could even test fine on a vision test, no redness, etc, but I knew there was a problem. I have a chronically ill sibling, and she was tired of being constantly at doctors, so after a standard GP visit we never investigated further. Every time for the next year when I mentioned my eyes, I just got told to lay down with a wet washcloth over them.

I temporarily lost all vision in my left eye and partial vision in my right eye about a year after I started complaining. Luckily, most damage was reversible but that treatment was painful and invasive. It turns out I have a chronic eye condition that needs daily medication; had I been diagnosed earlier I would have much better vision now.

I'm not saying this is the case for your son, but please don't dismiss him off the bat. Kids really do often know when something is wrong, even if it's not immediately apparent to adults.

Beautiful3 · 17/03/2024 10:33

Just take him to see his gp. It might be a wax build up.

TigerRag · 17/03/2024 10:20

A friend's daughter (she's about 4 or 5) has Autism. She had to have a hearing test first.

Howdidtheydothat · 17/03/2024 10:16

Deafness can be mistaken for Autism. E.g behaviour of placing head against objects that vibrate, like a washing machine (frequency helps them to hear better), get him checked. He should be checked before the autism assessment

RandomMess · 17/03/2024 10:16

It makes months for their brains to relearn to hear 100% after the gunk has completely cleared. If he has glue ear frequently he's probably never hearing as well as he should be able to.

Grommets may be needed.

WisteriaLodge · 17/03/2024 10:10

He has had a recent ear infection and does get them a lot.

Even more reason to get him checked out, why wouldn't you?

viques · 17/03/2024 10:03

Also, you say he doesn’t hear in busy environments, this is true of many areas of hearing loss, my hearing of speech is poor, but becomes non existent if there is back ground noise like music or loud speaking , or if I can’t see the speakers face clearly ( I suspect I do a lot of lip reading!) . A busy classroom is a hard place to know where to focus your attention. If he does have some hearing loss , and it could well be that it is temporary due to glue ear, I would push very hard for grommets and also make sure the teacher understands the needs of a child with poor hearing, putting him where he can see her face clearly in good light for example.

Swipe left for the next trending thread