Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Playing hard to get really does work, it seems :(

161 replies

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 17:19

So I got to know someone through a shared activity. Felt he was interested, he remembered everything I say, he spoke to a couple of people about me positively, he teased me, mild flirting, I saw him looking at me a few times then look away, 2 others at this activity told me he liked me.
I'd already met him around 7 times and we had each others' numbers, we started texting a lot, and at the end of the day he'd say 'talk to you tomorrow '
I'm fully aware men and women can be just good friends but I could see a difference between him and other men.
I suggested coffee one day just the two of us and he was keen, said he'd really liked talking to me and wanted to moreso.
I felt a bit shy when we met, but there were no lulls in the conversation at all, it flew really well. He didn't seem to flirt as such, but he seemed a bit nervous too.
Anyway at the end he told me it had been great and we'd definitely do it after the activity again.
I wasn't sure if I'd given just friends vibes or more, I had completely matched his energy but because I'd been a little shy maybe he thought I wasn't interested.
On the (bad) advice of friends, I texted him the next day, suggesting I'd love to go on more of a date.
He changed like night and day. Said he'd let me know, I said that was fine, and he never did.
Seen him once at the hobby but we don't text now.
Honestly feel like I gave too much away. I should've waited for him to ask me again, it's my fault. Can anyone offer advice? I am kicking myself tbh.

OP posts:
PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/03/2024 18:53

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:37

I could understand the feeling in control, but I left him the 'control' of organising a date. It's weird because prior to his sudden disinterest I felt totally relaxed because he was texting me a lot. Even at some points, even I thought he seemed keen because he would message me so much. But I liked it.

I think we've all been there. It sucks, you feel a but rubbish for a bit and you move on.

It's a compatability/wanting different things issues, not anything you did wrong.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:51

I really feel inexperienced with dating. Why can't they invent time machines. I'll never ask a man out again.

OP posts:
PersephonePomegranate23 · 16/03/2024 18:49

I honestly don't think you texting him would have bothered him (or men on general) if he were interested. The ones that do enjoy the pursuit soon get bored, anyway and are not really keepers.

WhateverMate · 16/03/2024 18:49

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 16/03/2024 17:24

There's someone else on here who has almost the exact same situation, but its at work rather than a hobby.

She has posted multiple tines and had lots and lots of advice so it may be worth trying to find those threads.

Generally though, you felt he was interested, and he's not. It happens, it stings for a bit, but you'll move on.

Agreed! I had to check the date as I thought it was the same OP.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:48

cunningartificer · 16/03/2024 18:45

To be honest I think that it might have been better if you'd gone for coffee a couple of times before taking it further. I don't mean playing hard to get, but just taking it slowly. If you were both nervous, as you say, then it would have given you time to get to know each other outside the text and hobby context and then a date might have come up more naturally. I think in the same situation where someone's a fairly new friend I might be a bit disconcerted by a sudden date request so I'm not surprised he didn't jump at it even if he liked you. You said he didn't flirt over coffee so perhaps he was just a bit uncertain and then you asking made him worried you wanted different things. If you'd waited longer you might have had a more solid foundation... or perhaps the same thing would have happened. I don't think he's a game player or unkind... just a human being!

Maybe :( i only thought of saying it as we'd already known each other a couple of months prior to the coffee and spoke all the time. So it wasn't like we'd just met sort of thing.
I see what you mean, definitely.
I guess in my mind I just wanted to show interest. I'm not very experienced with dating and I just thought that if you leave it too long then it ends up just becoming more like friends. But honestly what do I know! I just feel like an idiot all the same.

OP posts:
cunningartificer · 16/03/2024 18:45

To be honest I think that it might have been better if you'd gone for coffee a couple of times before taking it further. I don't mean playing hard to get, but just taking it slowly. If you were both nervous, as you say, then it would have given you time to get to know each other outside the text and hobby context and then a date might have come up more naturally. I think in the same situation where someone's a fairly new friend I might be a bit disconcerted by a sudden date request so I'm not surprised he didn't jump at it even if he liked you. You said he didn't flirt over coffee so perhaps he was just a bit uncertain and then you asking made him worried you wanted different things. If you'd waited longer you might have had a more solid foundation... or perhaps the same thing would have happened. I don't think he's a game player or unkind... just a human being!

WigglyVonWaggly · 16/03/2024 18:45

What you said isn’t remotely over the top or too keen! That’s how people organise a second meeting - ‘I had a great night. Fancy putting another date in the diary?’ If he decided he just wanted to stay friends after the first night out, he should reply in a way that makes it clear, not panic and run off like a coward. Anyone who goes completely cold over the very simple message you sent is a bit odd, surely. I wouldn’t kick yourself, I’d consider it a lucky escape.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:39

tacosforbreakfast · 16/03/2024 18:38

I don't know what I'd think - I'd probably just think he went for a coffee with you but wasn't feeling it and doesn't want to take it further.

I don't think it's anything to do with playing hard to get.

I hope so. I can totally accept the spark thing. Still, it's put me off asking any future men for a date! It's sad I feel I have to play these games at 33.

OP posts:
MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:38

In my mind, if I had texted him nothing at all, he might have thought, 'right she's not really interested, I'll leave it . It's all so stupid.

OP posts:
tacosforbreakfast · 16/03/2024 18:38

I don't know what I'd think - I'd probably just think he went for a coffee with you but wasn't feeling it and doesn't want to take it further.

I don't think it's anything to do with playing hard to get.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:37

I could understand the feeling in control, but I left him the 'control' of organising a date. It's weird because prior to his sudden disinterest I felt totally relaxed because he was texting me a lot. Even at some points, even I thought he seemed keen because he would message me so much. But I liked it.

OP posts:
MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:33

EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 16/03/2024 18:31

You’ve just expedited the sleeping with him and him ghosting you afterwards. So consider this a positive.

Possibly! I'll try to tell myself :)

OP posts:
Rosiiee · 16/03/2024 18:33

I don’t think it’s an experiment. Some men really like feeling in control. There was a post here a few weeks ago about a woman whose husband said it wasn’t attractive when she initiated intimacy. I think that’s the kind of guy who likes to ‘lead’/be in charge and hence might enjoy ‘chasing’. It’s not for me but I’m not surprised there’s guys like that out there.

Evolutionarygoals · 16/03/2024 18:32

I can't imagine wanting to be with a man that that I had to treat carefully and reel in gently like some sort of fish. If he's not honest, open and enthusiastic he doesn't deserve your time. I know it's dispiriting, but you really deserve someone who doesn't want to play games. Just think, all that energy could go into enjoying your time together and mutually discovering whether you're long term comparable.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:32

My ex who I left but still friends with has gone very quiet the last few days. It hasn't made me think I made a mistake and made me want to be with him again, it's just made me worry if he's ok.
When I think of the men who I wasn't into in the past, likely because I wasn't attracted, when they went distant I didn't start crushing on them, I just missed their friendship.

OP posts:
EvangelicalAboutButteredToast · 16/03/2024 18:31

You’ve just expedited the sleeping with him and him ghosting you afterwards. So consider this a positive.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:30

innerdesign · 16/03/2024 18:27

What 'experiment', playing games? I wouldn't recommend it, it doesn't work. At best you'd get yourself a situationship. I agree with the PP who said if he was interested he wouldn't have been put off. Maybe you could have played it all perfectly, did all the right things. In the end, he still wouldn't have been interested. I know it's hurtful, you'll be embarrassed and upset and your ego will be bruised. Give yourself the weekend to lick your wounds, and then let it go. Seriously. Don't obsess about it.

Edited

Thank you. Well I'm gonna try and tell myself that only game players/immature men will be forevermore out off because the woman asked for a date.
Even if they were slightly put out, like you say, if they were interested surely they'd still go and see how it went? Not decide that this can never go anywhere.

OP posts:
innerdesign · 16/03/2024 18:27

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 17:56

Nevertheless, if I meet anyone else in the future I'm gonna try this 'experiment'!

What 'experiment', playing games? I wouldn't recommend it, it doesn't work. At best you'd get yourself a situationship. I agree with the PP who said if he was interested he wouldn't have been put off. Maybe you could have played it all perfectly, did all the right things. In the end, he still wouldn't have been interested. I know it's hurtful, you'll be embarrassed and upset and your ego will be bruised. Give yourself the weekend to lick your wounds, and then let it go. Seriously. Don't obsess about it.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:26

Rosiiee · 16/03/2024 18:25

What I define as the chase is never make the first move, always say you’re busy when you’re not, play hard to get etc. Exhausting stuff but I really think some guys get off on it- it’s like they’re in a dominant position.

Honestly don't think I could do it, it's just not in my nature :(
I'd feel guilty if I kept saying I was busy, and they'd probably just think I wasn't interested.

OP posts:
Rosiiee · 16/03/2024 18:25

What I define as the chase is never make the first move, always say you’re busy when you’re not, play hard to get etc. Exhausting stuff but I really think some guys get off on it- it’s like they’re in a dominant position.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:23

I don't even know what the chase looks like? Let's imagine I didn't text him and he ended up asking me out. Then we meet up, then I decide to ask him and he reacts the same? Or am I supposed to not ask him anything until we're established?

OP posts:
CherryBlossom321 · 16/03/2024 18:22

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 17:26

It's been 3 weeks. Maybe I'm naive but I honestly think if I'd ignored him afterwards he'd have wanted me more

But hopefully you wouldn’t want to be with someone who only wants someone who ignores them? That wouldn’t be healthy at all.

MintAnt · 16/03/2024 18:22

Lovingitallnow · 16/03/2024 18:20

I don't know- I don't think it's definitive evidence. Against the advice of friends I texted my now dh the morning after our first date and asked if he wanted to go for a coffee. It obviously worked out. I suppose in some ways it's a short cut to find out how everyone feels.

That's good it worked out :)
I don't know what goes on in their minds. Did he think I had zero interest whatsoever in him prior to meeting up outside of the hobby the first time? Why would I want someone who is put off by someone being attracted?

OP posts:
Rosiiee · 16/03/2024 18:21

Some men do like the chase! Either that or he realised he didn’t want to pursue anything. Maybe he was seeing you and another and went for the other? That’s what I would assume.

Lovingitallnow · 16/03/2024 18:20

I don't know- I don't think it's definitive evidence. Against the advice of friends I texted my now dh the morning after our first date and asked if he wanted to go for a coffee. It obviously worked out. I suppose in some ways it's a short cut to find out how everyone feels.