Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocking state of school dinners!

167 replies

dottiedodah · 16/03/2024 16:31

This week a headteacher asked how hard it was to cook a potato? Really grim offerings .Sad part is that some children only have that food.Do those old enough to remember traditional school meals feel they were better then ?

OP posts:
madnessitellyou · 16/03/2024 19:26

I'm in my mid-40s and primary school dinners were literally inedible. And you weren't allowed to leave the hall until you'd finished. I went onto packed lunches the day after I sat in there for well over an hour.

Secondary school wasn't much better. It was either chips, pizza, cheese sandwich, ham sandwich or tuna sandwich. Yoghurt for dessert. I think there might have been cake but I was only given £1 a day. I had school dinners as I didn't want to carry my lunch especially as my mum insisted on infant school style lunch boxes

Sixth Form hit the jackpot. Food was great there.

Anyway, I'm a teacher and we occasionally get to sample school kitchen fayre. Last INSET had more undone carbs on one plate than I thought possible. When I do a lunch duty I do despair at some of the portion sizes. Plus, the FSM allowance really doesn't go very far - it's all so expensive.

CoffeeWithCheese · 16/03/2024 19:24

I've had a couple (school governor and have had days where we've gone into schools) across different schools. One was really really nice... the other was vile (unfortunately DD2's current school) but the atmosphere during the meal was lovely as the older kids lead in supporting their peers serving out their portions and interacting.
DD1 seems to love the ones at secondary school but I suspect that's more the ability to choose combined with the fact they have a slushie machine (which is "well peng" apparently).

lemonmeringueno3 · 16/03/2024 19:22

Our pupils have a main choice, or vegetarian alternative, or jacket potato alternative, with a pudding.

They seem well received but there are clear favourites. I can see why a pp suggested a one-pot meal but we have very low uptake for those. To make a kitchen viable, on less than £3 per meal per day, you need a lot of children opting for a school lunch.

greglet · 16/03/2024 19:08

The food at my primary school (early-mid 90s) was great. Home cooked, not a huge amount of choice/variety but tasty and filling. There was always a queue for seconds!

Secondary school was rubbish in comparison. I lived off chips, cheese and gravy for three years. They actually sold Pot Noodles when I joined in Year 9!

The food at the (independent) school I work at is phenomenal. Every day they offer:

Baked potato, baked sweet potato, or pasta with cheese/beans/tuna/two sorts of topping (e.g. vegetables Provençal or Moroccan lamb)

Vegetarian main

Meat main

'Street food' (e.g. jerk chicken or jerk aubergine - always a vegetarian and meat option)

A full salad bar

A hot pudding

Yoghurts

Fruit (apples, pears, satsumas, plums, pineapple, melon)

Jelly

Tray bake (flapjacks etc)

That said, the number of kids who just have plain pasta with cheese every day is depressing. I eat like a king, though!

Kalevala · 16/03/2024 19:05

namechange55465 · 16/03/2024 19:00

Have you met many 5 year olds who would reliably eat stew? I'm not sure I have...

My child has never liked separate food, especially not when he was 5. He would only reliably eat veg in something like a stew or bolognese or curry. It didn't need to be hidden, just cooked together.

Chairwoman · 16/03/2024 19:05

In my son’s school, the juniors get to go up for seconds. My (very athletic) 8 year old goes up for extra dinner and double pudding every day 🤣 so I definitely get my moneys worth.
My 6 year old isn’t a massive fan. Next year when I’m paying for both I said they can have pack lunches on a Friday as they don’t really like the fish options.

Oakbeam · 16/03/2024 19:05

Do those old enough to remember traditional school meals feel they were better then ?

I have little experience of modern school meals but those I have seen seem pretty beige and unhealthy.

My experience of school dinners is from the 1960s and 1970s. The meals were traditional balance of protein, carbs and veg. Chips were served about once a month and the only meal choice was eat it or leave it. Nothing went to waste because if you didn’t eat it somebody else would.

Userxyd · 16/03/2024 19:05

Portion sizes are calorie controlled to meet govt requirements.
Prices of everything going up. So sad that schools are so pressured to get em in get em out so quickly. Kids need time and a rest in the day - glad I'm not in school anymore.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 19:05

LadyKenya · 16/03/2024 18:57

That is a good question@Kalevala . I was watching a couple of youtubers, and what they are feeding their families each week. To be honest I was watching more out of, dare I say, startled fascination. It was all, fish fingers, breaded nuggets, of one kind or another, sausage rolls, sausages, served with a potato shape, or waffle type thing, and very little veg. I fail to see how these children are going to be healthy, with a diet like that.

This doesn’t sound great (at all) but not all dc will have this

Kalevala · 16/03/2024 19:02

StaunchMomma · 16/03/2024 18:53

@Kalevala

Why are UK parents raising kids on beige food?

We're not.

School dinners don't represent foods eaten in the average home in the slightest.

Then schools could offer more nutritious one pot, or one pot plus carb, dinners and children would eat them then?

namechange55465 · 16/03/2024 19:00

TwylaSands · 16/03/2024 16:33

I feel schools should offer two meals. One vegan and one meat one-pot stew. Fill it with nutrients. Better quality ingredients. Warm. Kids get one good meal a day.

Have you met many 5 year olds who would reliably eat stew? I'm not sure I have...

LadyKenya · 16/03/2024 18:57

That is a good question@Kalevala . I was watching a couple of youtubers, and what they are feeding their families each week. To be honest I was watching more out of, dare I say, startled fascination. It was all, fish fingers, breaded nuggets, of one kind or another, sausage rolls, sausages, served with a potato shape, or waffle type thing, and very little veg. I fail to see how these children are going to be healthy, with a diet like that.

Octopuslethargy · 16/03/2024 18:57

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 16/03/2024 18:54

@Octopuslethargy are you an inspector of any type? The dinners we had when Ofsted came in were very different to our usual!

As far as baked potatoes go imagine ones that have gone cold in the tray sprinkled over with dry grated cheese. They were of a temperature where the cheese had no chance of melting and of course no butter. They used to go straight in the bin.

My favourite lunch I once saw was a child who had potato, rice and cake for pudding and because that wasn't much they were given a piece of bread!

No I am not an HMI. I have the same food as the children- honestly. The sandwiches in some secondary schools are in line with Pret (but not £7 each!)

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 16/03/2024 18:55

There is usually a choice so if kids don't like the hot offerings they can have a sandwich or baked potato.

Cold baked potatoes?! Bleeurch!

StaunchMomma · 16/03/2024 18:55

LadyKenya · 16/03/2024 18:44

Because that is how they may eat culturally. If that is how they are being raised, then that is normally what they will eat. A disservice is being done to the children here with the majority of food that is being presented to them, in school. And unfortunately many are being raised on a beige diet at home as well.

You think it's British culture to feed our kids school dinner type foods? 😂

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 16/03/2024 18:54

@Octopuslethargy are you an inspector of any type? The dinners we had when Ofsted came in were very different to our usual!

As far as baked potatoes go imagine ones that have gone cold in the tray sprinkled over with dry grated cheese. They were of a temperature where the cheese had no chance of melting and of course no butter. They used to go straight in the bin.

My favourite lunch I once saw was a child who had potato, rice and cake for pudding and because that wasn't much they were given a piece of bread!

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 16/03/2024 18:53

Incidentally, does anybody remember Scolarest? The company that pretty much hit the deck after Jamie Oliver exposed them and their turkey twizzlers and left their brand reputation in tatters?

A lot of schools switched from Scolarest to to Chartwells and were pleased to have made a big change ostensibly for the better. I don't know how many of them realised that the only difference between the two companies was a letterhead.

StaunchMomma · 16/03/2024 18:53

@Kalevala

Why are UK parents raising kids on beige food?

We're not.

School dinners don't represent foods eaten in the average home in the slightest.

InlikealionOutlikeahare · 16/03/2024 18:52

I eat at a primary school 3 days a week and I really rate the food there. It's freshly made, tasty (other than a lack of salt, but that's understandable) and good value. My dd gets the same at her school and enjoys it, so I now only feed a snack tea in the evening as I know she's already had a large meal.

Kalevala · 16/03/2024 18:51

LadyKenya · 16/03/2024 18:44

Because that is how they may eat culturally. If that is how they are being raised, then that is normally what they will eat. A disservice is being done to the children here with the majority of food that is being presented to them, in school. And unfortunately many are being raised on a beige diet at home as well.

Stew, casserole, curry, bolognese, soup etc are all normal foods eaten in the UK though. Why are UK parents raising kids on beige food?

ohdamnitjanet · 16/03/2024 18:50

I worked in a school kitchen about 10 years ago and although the staff all did their utmost the quality and portion sizes were poor because the budget was tiny.
The veg was left in those heated containers for ages and I’m sure the two tiny bits of broccoli served as a portion had no nutritional value as they were over cooked and had sat for so long.
The only vaguely decent offering was a baguette.

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 16/03/2024 18:50

AnnaBegins · 16/03/2024 17:11

It didn't surprise me to read that Chartwells is the caterer at that headteacher's school. They are the worst of the worst, profit above everything, and they deliberately serve tiny poor quality meals.

They also don't cater for allergies so the kids with allergies get a jacket potato with beans every single day.

Of course they show off nice sample food and quote tiny prices at tender, so they win, then they reduce the quality and up the price stating it's "unaffordable".

What can parents do? Well, they can contact their schools when any catering tenders are going out (usually done at academy trust level, and usually announced but you may need to ask in advance when the contract will be tendered), and implore them not to award to Chartwells.

Our school managed to terminate their contract due to the price rise requests, and went with a local company who are excellent.

I used to work for a company connected with Chartwells. They are brilliant at what they do: putting in great bids, winning contracts and making a great deal of money.

Unfortunately, that is all they are good at; the actual food quality and satisfaction is simply not a priority for them. Your average local cafe is infinitely better at providing delicious, filling, well-priced food; but, as in most things, big well-known brands are seen as automatically the best option every time.

StaunchMomma · 16/03/2024 18:49

School dinners were awful in the 80's. The only thing anyone ever says they enjoyed was a couple of puddings but most of those were vile, too.

Primary meals do seem inferior to secondary but I guess they are more 'set' meals.

Agree that whoever plans them in most schools is bonkers. Pizza with rice?! WTF? Although school pizza at DS's Primary is so bad that most shun it, so potentially the side carb is the only bit that gets eaten?

Octopuslethargy · 16/03/2024 18:47

Maybe I need to start photographing my lunch- some are really good- honestly.

StaunchMomma · 16/03/2024 18:46

TwylaSands · 16/03/2024 16:33

I feel schools should offer two meals. One vegan and one meat one-pot stew. Fill it with nutrients. Better quality ingredients. Warm. Kids get one good meal a day.

Will never happen as the vegan one will be left. They don't have money to waste.