Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Shocking state of school dinners!

167 replies

dottiedodah · 16/03/2024 16:31

This week a headteacher asked how hard it was to cook a potato? Really grim offerings .Sad part is that some children only have that food.Do those old enough to remember traditional school meals feel they were better then ?

OP posts:
OutOfTheHouse · 17/03/2024 08:48

MissyB1 · 17/03/2024 08:37

Well this is what happens when the Government encourages outsourcing to private companies for everything. They don’t like the public sector (never have). It’s happened in healthcare too. And quality always goes down, of course it will, that’s a no brainer.

Exactly. Teachers could see it coming. I brought it up on here several times but no one cared.

GettingStuffed · 17/03/2024 08:46

When I was in primary school, aeons ago, school dinners had nutritional standards. I remember my favourite was braised beef and onions, we had fish and chips about once a month.
Other items were things like shepherds pie.

Perfect28 · 17/03/2024 08:40

@StaunchMomma 'one pot's meals are easier to make, cheaper, and you can put all sorts in them, different vegetables and pulses for example. Therefore, more nutritious than just putting one vegetable on the side. A school canteen has to be efficient, they aren't going to be farting about plating several smaller dishes.

sashh · 17/03/2024 08:37

I'm 57 so went through the evolution of school dinners.

Primary there was one dinner and one pudding and you had to eat it. I went to three different primaries and that was the same at them all.

Sometimes it was good, others, not so. Second primary did spam fritters on a fairly regular basis that I hated and at school 3 there was a weird stew they served with a slice of pastry, we all called it spew.

That school also served milky coffee in the winter.

At secondary we got a choice of two meals and two puddings, still meat potatoes and 2 veg type meals.

Then the rules changed and we got a choice of the main meal or 'soup and a sandwich' which was actually a fairly decent meal. No I didn't grow up in Ireland but the school was run by Irish nuns.

When I got into my final year it changed again and it was basically 'chips with everything'.

We also had a couple of students who went home for lunch.

I actually think the soup and sandwich could work for a lot of children. Hide the veg in the soup and have an assortment of sandwiches / rolls / baguettes.

We need a total rethink. Food should be something that contributes to education. I did supply at one school that had a French chef and compulsory (free) breakfast - you didn't have to eat but you had to go with your class to the dining area.

Classes were often a nightmare before breakfast, mainly due to students wanting to know what time breakfast was that day.

Breakfast was porridge or cereal, beans on toast, spaghetti on toast (tinned stuff) hot and cold drinks.

MissyB1 · 17/03/2024 08:37

OutOfTheHouse · 17/03/2024 08:19

They shouldn’t be making any kind of profit. This is the nub of the problem.

We should go back to school kitchens being run by the school with an actual cook running it properly. Given a budget at the beginning of the week and catering accordingly. There are too many middle men all creaming off money and at the bottom the children are the ones suffering.

Well this is what happens when the Government encourages outsourcing to private companies for everything. They don’t like the public sector (never have). It’s happened in healthcare too. And quality always goes down, of course it will, that’s a no brainer.

LegoDeathTrap · 17/03/2024 08:28

My kids’ nursery was very strict about food - every meal had veggies, they had to try a bit, food was pretty adventurous (fajitas, tagines, stews, mince and dumplings…) and real food. Kids (and these are little kids, aged 1-4) ate it.

Then they went to school and suddenly it’s “kids could not possibly eat this”, and they get junk food every day. Even something real like a chicken dinner comes essentially without veg. There is a salad bar with croutons, corn and raisins. I despair.

OutOfTheHouse · 17/03/2024 08:19

SignoraVolpe · 17/03/2024 07:10

Dsil used to manage a school kitchen run by Chartwells.
She is a trained chef and served nutritious meals to over a 1000 dc in less than 2 hours every single day!
However Chartwells expected dsil to make 60% profit a week!
I think a lot of kitchen managers would struggle with this.
Dsil has worked in huge hotels so understands getting good food out quickly.

She always worked 2 hours a day extra unpaid as she was also expected to do all paperwork involved too.
They had a freezer pantry that broke down continuously and refused to replace it.
There are very strict rules so no salt allowed ever, can’t imagine Jamie Oliver cooking at home with no salt.

Dsil has now left and works at a school where she has half the pupils, no Chartwells and doesn’t have to spend hours on paperwork.
She loves it.
The first school were upset she left and the new school think she’s amazing.
She is.

Oh and all of your dc would eat chips everyday if allowed. 😂

They shouldn’t be making any kind of profit. This is the nub of the problem.

We should go back to school kitchens being run by the school with an actual cook running it properly. Given a budget at the beginning of the week and catering accordingly. There are too many middle men all creaming off money and at the bottom the children are the ones suffering.

MissyB1 · 17/03/2024 08:13

Perfect28 · 17/03/2024 07:52

In my school the common argument is that if you served healthier one pot type meals (chilli's, stews, pies etc) then the kids wouldn't eat it. I think we need to take a 'well tough' stance. If they don't like it they can bring a packed lunch with junk (I'm secondary). We owe it to the children who will only get this one meal for it to be decent and nutritious. Most meals should be vegetarian too, but a minimum of twice a week.

Agreed. Why would the assumption be that kids are incapable of eating a casserole or veggie chilli? What are they being fed at home I wonder?

Perfect28 · 17/03/2024 07:52

In my school the common argument is that if you served healthier one pot type meals (chilli's, stews, pies etc) then the kids wouldn't eat it. I think we need to take a 'well tough' stance. If they don't like it they can bring a packed lunch with junk (I'm secondary). We owe it to the children who will only get this one meal for it to be decent and nutritious. Most meals should be vegetarian too, but a minimum of twice a week.

blackteaplease · 17/03/2024 07:32

Leah5678 · 16/03/2024 20:40

I'm not sure tbh the person who was telling me this didn't say but they did say a lot of the kids could taste the difference and really didn't like it.

I also forgot to add on my first comment that the no exceptions to ordering online includes the kids in key stage one and the poor ones who would get it free anyway. Sooo literally playing jobsworths with some kids nutrition. The dinner ladies literally aren't allowed to deviate from the online ordering stuff so no giving a hungry kid who's parents forgot to order any food.

At my dc primary We order at least a week in advance but lunch orders are checked by the teacher first thing and admin call the parent if there no lunch order. Usually I've been able to deliver a packed lunch but there have been occasions where school have bunged in an extra jacket potato for my kid that I then pay for later

SignoraVolpe · 17/03/2024 07:10

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 16/03/2024 18:50

I used to work for a company connected with Chartwells. They are brilliant at what they do: putting in great bids, winning contracts and making a great deal of money.

Unfortunately, that is all they are good at; the actual food quality and satisfaction is simply not a priority for them. Your average local cafe is infinitely better at providing delicious, filling, well-priced food; but, as in most things, big well-known brands are seen as automatically the best option every time.

Dsil used to manage a school kitchen run by Chartwells.
She is a trained chef and served nutritious meals to over a 1000 dc in less than 2 hours every single day!
However Chartwells expected dsil to make 60% profit a week!
I think a lot of kitchen managers would struggle with this.
Dsil has worked in huge hotels so understands getting good food out quickly.

She always worked 2 hours a day extra unpaid as she was also expected to do all paperwork involved too.
They had a freezer pantry that broke down continuously and refused to replace it.
There are very strict rules so no salt allowed ever, can’t imagine Jamie Oliver cooking at home with no salt.

Dsil has now left and works at a school where she has half the pupils, no Chartwells and doesn’t have to spend hours on paperwork.
She loves it.
The first school were upset she left and the new school think she’s amazing.
She is.

Oh and all of your dc would eat chips everyday if allowed. 😂

Fairyliz · 17/03/2024 07:07

School dinners were terrible when I was at school in the 1960’s terrible when my children were at school in the 1990’s and terrible when I worked in schools in the 2000’s.
Unfortunately there is no point in preparing healthy meals as most children won’t eat vegetables.
Much easier to send them in with a packed lunch and prepare a hot meal at night; at least then they get some nutritious food.

Horaced · 17/03/2024 06:50

Kalevala · 17/03/2024 05:21

They are frequently recommended on budget threads on here. Cheap and nutritious, easy way to bulk out meat with veg and legumes. Common in community kitchen settings as they are suitable for serving large numbers and the food stays hot.

I agree these are good meals but unfortunately they do tend to be the ones that are left by the children. I'd say on pasta and curry days at least 50% ask for the meal with no sauce - so they just have the pasta or rice plain with the protein on the side (it's separate anyway). There's a beef stew day that's a disaster as so few children will even touch it! I just don't know how you get round that as all these children have had free meals in KS1 and we only do one option (vegetarian meal available is ordered specifically beforehand) so the children have grown up with these meals in school at least but they still refuse them - they would rather be hungry.

beAsensible1 · 17/03/2024 05:41

This reply has been deleted

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

It’s so annoying! I hate fake cheese it tastes awful.
the short lived Linda McCartney pizza 😭😭😭

Kalevala · 17/03/2024 05:21

StaunchMomma · 17/03/2024 01:17

What's the obsession with 'one-pot' meals? Very odd.

They are frequently recommended on budget threads on here. Cheap and nutritious, easy way to bulk out meat with veg and legumes. Common in community kitchen settings as they are suitable for serving large numbers and the food stays hot.

bananamum13 · 17/03/2024 04:33

DD is in y6 and hasn't like school dinners from the start - her school is fan and cooks them in house and has a varied menu etc, and while in the infants and getting free school meals, she had them! But often didn't enjoy them. Then the provider changed the quality of the foster on 'fish Friday' and the dinner on Weds (normally a proper dinner), she refused full stop.
I'd rather send her in with decent food (we have some insulated containers too) that are healthy & she will eat for way less than £3.30/day

coxesorangepippin · 17/03/2024 01:30

I do a packed lunch

Sandwiches/Thermos stuff
Cut fruit and/or cut veggies
Biscuits
Yogurt
Crackers
Homemade Banana bread or a muffin
Apple sauce
Cheese sticks
Dried fruit

Yes it's tedious to prepare but better than the rubbish in the school café

StaunchMomma · 17/03/2024 01:17

Kalevala · 16/03/2024 19:02

Then schools could offer more nutritious one pot, or one pot plus carb, dinners and children would eat them then?

What's the obsession with 'one-pot' meals? Very odd.

BloodandGlitter · 16/03/2024 22:41

Our local academy has been in the papers several times for the state of the food. Last time it was raw chicken. DS will be packed lunches. Mind the food is probably the least of the schools issues.

HollyKnight · 16/03/2024 21:48

I hated dinners in primary school. A scoop of waxy potato, mince n gravy, and turnip. And you couldn't leave until you had eaten it.

High school was great though. Chips upon chips. Curry. Fish. Breaded chicken. Soup for starters. Baked potato and a salad bar. My favourite day was Lasagna and chocolate cake day.

It's not that difficult to mass produce tasty food, but obviously, it isn't going to be the healthiest. Schools need a bit more imagination.

DiscoBeat · 16/03/2024 21:39

x2boys · 16/03/2024 16:38

I'm 50 and school dinners were compulsory at my primary school
They were excellent as i recall all cooked on site with very decent portions the meals were very traditional but very appetising.

Exactly the same here. The food was really good.

MaybeRevisitYourWipingT3chnique · 16/03/2024 21:35

Portion sizes are calorie controlled to meet govt requirements.

Surely the government understands the very basic differences between a 4yo and a 16yo, though?

Shiveringinthecountry · 16/03/2024 21:31

ThrallsWife · 16/03/2024 18:05

This thread reminds me of this primary school food blogger from many years ago. She first started posting images of her own school food, then, in the later posts, showed images of school lunches from around the world. UK school food is embarrassing by comparison.

http://neverseconds.blogspot.com/2012/05/

Thanks for this! It's a great read 😁

Octopuslethargy · 16/03/2024 21:03

TrustPenguins · 16/03/2024 20:53

The best school meal I've eaten recently (I work with schools) was in a secondary school where there were no options at lunchtime. Everyone ate the same meal (aside from those with allergies / medical diets). Vegetarian. Cooked from scratch with fresh ingredients. No junk food on the menu. Dessert was fruit.

sikh schools have good meals usually -vegetarian -no eggs

x2boys · 16/03/2024 21:01

Previousreligion · 16/03/2024 20:55

I had school dinners in the 80s. I don't remember them being great or healthy. Horrible mash, rice pudding... I did like cornflake tart!

Me to!
I went to primary school.from 1978 /1985 there was no vegetarian option and it was a very middle class white British school so the options I guess.were limited but they were as I recall ample and tasty as long g as you didn't have any requirements.