Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be suspicious about his proposal plans?

137 replies

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 13:59

I've been with partner for 5.5 years.

We've had lengthy discussions for the past year about when to get married. He knows I want to get married. He tells me he wants it too.

We agreed we would like to get married in Autumn 2025.

I'm still waiting on a ring/proposal and as time goes on I wonder when this will happen if we're to stick to the 2025 date.

He knows how I feel about still having no proposal. He tells me to wait because he wants to do it 'right'...I'm nervous that we'll get to 2025 and it'll just be words still. I feel like I'm in some weird limbo where we've made a plan but we aren't actually following through.

I grew up with some things which I admit can make it hard for me to trust. I'm tying myself up in knots about it as so far I only have his words and being told to wait is making me tetchy.

OP posts:
Loopytiles · 16/03/2024 15:51

Stalling

Sasqwatch · 16/03/2024 15:50

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/03/2024 15:38

I think you should say to him, we have agreed to marry in autumn 2025 and I can't wait to marry you. I'm not willing to get married without a proper proposal, and I would need that by the 1st June this year (or whenever - your birthday if you have a summer birthday) etc. Without a proposal by this time, I will believe you not to be serious about wanting me as your wife, and so I will leave you. Say it nicely, firmly and sincerely, looking into his eyes. Then forget about it. Then either leave him on the 1st June, or say yes to his proposal.

It's important to be clear sometimes. Make your needs clear in this way and he will either step up, or not.

Whoever would want a proposal made under duress? 🙄

dottiedodah · 16/03/2024 15:49

He seems to be playing for time here.I agree with tiredfoxfliesatmidnight that you need to give him a firm time to propose by .A ring is normal for an engagement, If you have been together 5.5 years ,Christmas,new years day and Valentines have all come and gone .If as PP said 1st June comes and no ring ,then walk away

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/03/2024 15:49

I think it sounds like he really wants to do things properly, and propose to you in the right way. I wouldn't deny him that, it sounds like it's important to him. If he genuinely is concerned about choosing the right ring, you could always email him some links to styles you like (normally I think this would be too full on but he's clearly asking you for pointers!) I think yes he needs a bit of a nudge but he sounds like he just wants to do things properly.

sonjadog · 16/03/2024 15:47

I suspect that for all they have agreed, when it comes to actually setting a date and making the bookings etc. the OP will find him very reluctant to commit. I think she is very wise to insist on a proposal first, so she isn't wasting money on bookings that will end up being cancelled.

coldcallerbaiter · 16/03/2024 15:46

Me too, we agreed to marry and then went together to get a ring a few weeks after. We got married about 6 months after we got the ring.

Changingplace · 16/03/2024 15:42

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/03/2024 15:38

I think you should say to him, we have agreed to marry in autumn 2025 and I can't wait to marry you. I'm not willing to get married without a proper proposal, and I would need that by the 1st June this year (or whenever - your birthday if you have a summer birthday) etc. Without a proposal by this time, I will believe you not to be serious about wanting me as your wife, and so I will leave you. Say it nicely, firmly and sincerely, looking into his eyes. Then forget about it. Then either leave him on the 1st June, or say yes to his proposal.

It's important to be clear sometimes. Make your needs clear in this way and he will either step up, or not.

But the OP is happy to start planning without a ‘proper proposal’, it’s irrelevant and this is still weirdly putting all the decision making back on him when they’ve already agreed anyway.

NamelessNancy · 16/03/2024 15:42

The concept of a proposal seems like an anachronism to me putting the man (usually) in a position of power which is not right for the times. Surely a decision to marry is a joint decision rather than something controlled by one partner. Even if it's only symbolic I don't like the idea personally. DH and I had a chat about marriage, both agreed and that was that. (Disclaimer obviously my opinion is irrelevant to what others want to do!)

Zaxi · 16/03/2024 15:42

TheShellBeach · 16/03/2024 14:03

I don't think either of them considers that they're engaged, as there has been no proposal.

But if they have agreed to get married, and set a date (rough as it is) then they are engaged

Thats what engaged means - having formally agreed to marry.
"Keith and I had got engaged four months before"

People do keep them secret, so I'm not sure what formally would mean though

Theredfoxfliesatmidnight · 16/03/2024 15:38

I think you should say to him, we have agreed to marry in autumn 2025 and I can't wait to marry you. I'm not willing to get married without a proper proposal, and I would need that by the 1st June this year (or whenever - your birthday if you have a summer birthday) etc. Without a proposal by this time, I will believe you not to be serious about wanting me as your wife, and so I will leave you. Say it nicely, firmly and sincerely, looking into his eyes. Then forget about it. Then either leave him on the 1st June, or say yes to his proposal.

It's important to be clear sometimes. Make your needs clear in this way and he will either step up, or not.

Faithwonder · 16/03/2024 15:35

Wow! I am a woman. Very honest. What he said is EXACTLY what I would say to ANYONE I am letting down gently or with whom I do not want to have an honest convo over something.

I hope I am wrong OP. But come 2026, you will be back on here telling us, 2025 came and went.

Kwasi · 16/03/2024 15:34

He wants to propose with the ring so he doesn’t have to spend as much on it.

35965a · 16/03/2024 15:33

He’s future faking

sonjadog · 16/03/2024 15:33

Did your conversation stop there about it? To me that just sounds like the start of the conversation. Did you agree to go together to look at rings so he'd know what you would like? Did you tell him you need to book a venue now before they book up?

Goodadvice1980 · 16/03/2024 15:32

Yep he’s stalling OP

Seeingadistance · 16/03/2024 15:31

Have seen the update.

OP, you might want to reconsider marrying someone who is either very stupid or thinks you are very stupid.

Fairyliz · 16/03/2024 15:27

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 14:08

I said I was happy to buy a ring together. He said he didn't want to do that as he wants to propose to me in the 'right' way.

I don't understand why doesn't do it, in whatever this 'right' way is?

Because he doesn’t want to and is just stalling you.

Changingplace · 16/03/2024 15:25

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 15:08

We just sat down to have a coffee and I asked him about why he's said a proposal is so important to him (he doesn't know I have this thread going)

He said 'well it's what I've always thought about, even before I met you. It's my job to do it'. Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

Do you think he's got something in his head about proposals being the 'macho' thing to do?! Does he think he should be able to read my mind?!

Thanks for the ideas about just getting on with planning, that seems a good way to go...and yes, I agree need to take some control and stop wondering what is going on!

If that’s what he’d thought about why didn’t he do a proposal rather than have a general discussion where you agreed to get married? That makes no sense at all.

Just tell him no it’s not your job to do it and it’s irrelevant now because we’re agreed - and then go and look at some venues.

CharmedCult · 16/03/2024 15:13

Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

He really scrabbled for something there, didn’t he?

He doesn’t want you to choose a ring together, but he hasn’t bought a ring yet as he doesn’t know what type of ring you’d like, but he’s made no effort to find out?

Nah, he’s stalling.

burnoutbabe · 16/03/2024 15:13

Has he told his family you are marrying in autumn 2025? Or is it just a secret between you!

SuziQuinto · 16/03/2024 15:11

I'm glad you had a chat @daffolilly25 but he sounds like he's in a time warp! The ring - you've offered to go ring shopping together, so why is that a problem? It's not his "job" to propose - you've already agreed to marry? It's all a bit odd.

moderndilemma · 16/03/2024 15:08

Greydiamond · 16/03/2024 14:09

In the most polite way, I think you need to chill and perhaps try and refocus on whaf is most important to you. Marrying him? Or the date?

Without realising, you may end up spoiling any proposal plans he is making because you're so focused on the when.

It is positive you've had the discussion and are both on the same page. Now, let him take care of the proposal in his own way. It is one thing you can't and shouldn't be controlling.

Also consider: an autumn 2025 wedding is still possible. He could propose on 31st Dec 2024 and an autumn wedding would still be possible.

If you both love each other, then to be honest, even if it isn't Autumn 2025, you'll still be getting married (the most important part).

Start saving now incase you do have a shorter time scale to plan but try not to mention the word wedding or engagement too much. Remember why you're together and just enjoy that.

...and let him do it how he wants to.

Is this 1950?

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 15:08

We just sat down to have a coffee and I asked him about why he's said a proposal is so important to him (he doesn't know I have this thread going)

He said 'well it's what I've always thought about, even before I met you. It's my job to do it'. Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

Do you think he's got something in his head about proposals being the 'macho' thing to do?! Does he think he should be able to read my mind?!

Thanks for the ideas about just getting on with planning, that seems a good way to go...and yes, I agree need to take some control and stop wondering what is going on!

OP posts:
Toblerbone · 16/03/2024 14:59

I agree - start planning the wedding for autumn 2025, looking at venues etc. If he brings up the proposal again, say "don't worry, I'm not spoiling the proposal, you can do that when and how you want!" You seem a bit passive OP - you need to take back control.

CharmedCult · 16/03/2024 14:53

The cynic in me thinks that he’s waiting until it’s too late for you to get married in August 25.

Most of the venues in my area are booked up at least 12 months ahead.

Then he’ll find another reason to delay the proposal again.

Tell him he can propose whenever he likes, but you’re going to start looking at venues over the next few weekends and will need to get something booked and leave a deposit.

His response will tell you all you need to know.