Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be suspicious about his proposal plans?

137 replies

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 13:59

I've been with partner for 5.5 years.

We've had lengthy discussions for the past year about when to get married. He knows I want to get married. He tells me he wants it too.

We agreed we would like to get married in Autumn 2025.

I'm still waiting on a ring/proposal and as time goes on I wonder when this will happen if we're to stick to the 2025 date.

He knows how I feel about still having no proposal. He tells me to wait because he wants to do it 'right'...I'm nervous that we'll get to 2025 and it'll just be words still. I feel like I'm in some weird limbo where we've made a plan but we aren't actually following through.

I grew up with some things which I admit can make it hard for me to trust. I'm tying myself up in knots about it as so far I only have his words and being told to wait is making me tetchy.

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 16/03/2024 16:46

You've set a wedding date.

You are therefore betrothed to be married.

Doesn't need a big proposal or a ring to be engaged.

Just get on with wedding planning, visit venues etc

sonjadog · 16/03/2024 16:40

Changingplace · 16/03/2024 16:00

Did you miss the part where he’s agreed to get married in autumn 2025? There doesn’t need to be a proposal once the conversation has been had and it’s so weird that people still get hung up on the concept.

No, I didn't miss it. That is why I started off my post with "I suspect for all they have agreed..." He agreed to a date a long time in the future and since then has done nothing towards making that date happen. I would be uncertain about him too if I were the OP. Of course there doesn't have to be a proposal, but the OP obviously would like one, so why hasn't he done anything about it? It is hardly a massive ask of someone who should be excited about getting married to you.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 16/03/2024 16:34

Good update OP. We got engaged in October and got married August the following year …. We picked the ring together in May! But he wanted his moment!! Drove me nuts waiting !!

SuziQuinto · 16/03/2024 16:26

@Windwwwash - you're right and it's just bizarre that anyone needs a man's say so for a decision about marriage! He's either stalling because he doesn't want to get married or he's living in the past. Or both.

Windwwwash · 16/03/2024 16:24

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 14:12

Thank you, I don't think you're being impolite.

I have had people let me down before in my life and I think this can make me worry that I'm not good enough. He's not let me down before, so I need to focus on that :)

Why does she have to “chill”, and why does an adult woman have to put her life plans on hold for “his proposal” as if his asking is a magical delicate spell that can only be spoken in very particular circumstances?

This is so unbelievably old fashioned, the tiptoeing around men’s fragile emotions in case the terrifying ring-hungry woman scares him off. Marriage is about both parties wanting to marry each other at this point in both their lives. If you can agree that, then you’re engaged. Congratulations. Everything else feeds into the wedding industrial complex and is fucking nonsense.

Good luck, OP.

TheShellBeach · 16/03/2024 16:20

After all this time together, if he really wanted to marry you, you'd know

Yes. Sadly, I agree with this.

PaminaMozart · 16/03/2024 16:17

All those saying they are engaged because he has agreed to get married........

18 months from now
After lots of talks, discussions, pushing from the OP
but still no ring or a formal proposal...

He does not want to get married to her.
He is merely kicking the can down the road.

Don't let him mess you around, @daffolilly25
You have a difficult decision to make, but don't get sucked in by the sunk cost fallacy.
After all this time together, if he really wanted to marry you, you'd know.

Alwaystired23 · 16/03/2024 16:11

Nevermindtheteacaps · 16/03/2024 16:04

This is AWFUL advice,

DO NOT indulge his need to control this, this is your future, he doesn't get to hold you random to the 'right time' and he doesn't get to gate keep marriage just because he has a penis,

You've agreed to get married, just book it. Or better still don't marry this controlling and flaky guy!

I agree with you completely. PP posters' advice is awful. The OP should hang around, not nagging the man to propose 🙄🙄. My ex was flaky, I wasted 6 years waiting to get a proposal. Saw sense, broke up with him, and was married within 2 years to my now dh of 13 years.

TalkSomeSense1 · 16/03/2024 16:09

NamelessNancy · 16/03/2024 15:42

The concept of a proposal seems like an anachronism to me putting the man (usually) in a position of power which is not right for the times. Surely a decision to marry is a joint decision rather than something controlled by one partner. Even if it's only symbolic I don't like the idea personally. DH and I had a chat about marriage, both agreed and that was that. (Disclaimer obviously my opinion is irrelevant to what others want to do!)

This!

Nevermindtheteacaps · 16/03/2024 16:07

His job to do it?

He's an old fashioned sexist. I'd fix that before getting married, lest he has similarly old fashioned ideas on what 'your' jobs are.

Like washing socks.

TalkSomeSense1 · 16/03/2024 16:07

My DH said 'lets get married' so we did, eight weeks later. No engagement ring (better things to spend money on) Church wedding with all of the people we wanted. I don't get the whole big production. It's about the marriage. Just agree a date and get on with it!

gannett · 16/03/2024 16:06

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 15:08

We just sat down to have a coffee and I asked him about why he's said a proposal is so important to him (he doesn't know I have this thread going)

He said 'well it's what I've always thought about, even before I met you. It's my job to do it'. Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

Do you think he's got something in his head about proposals being the 'macho' thing to do?! Does he think he should be able to read my mind?!

Thanks for the ideas about just getting on with planning, that seems a good way to go...and yes, I agree need to take some control and stop wondering what is going on!

Those are the follow-up questions for him, not us! What did you say after he said "I'm supposed to know what you'll like" - I'd have replied "why on earth are you supposed to know that, you're not telepathic".

The whole "it's my job to do it" - I'd have said "no it's not, those traditional macho roles are silly and I have no time for them".

RuthW · 16/03/2024 16:06

DisplayPurposesOnly · 16/03/2024 14:01

We agreed we would like to get married in Autumn 2025.

You're engaged. Agree a date and what sort of wedding you'd like/can afford.

This. No need for a proposal. It's all been sorted.

SuziQuinto · 16/03/2024 16:06

@Nevermindtheteacaps - I agree! Plus what's the nonsense about him "taking care of the proposal"? They've already agreed!

citrinetrilogy · 16/03/2024 16:05

DH went down on one knee and proposed on the spur of the moment. He didn't have a ring to present me with; we went out later that day and chose one together.

Nevermindtheteacaps · 16/03/2024 16:04

Greydiamond · 16/03/2024 14:09

In the most polite way, I think you need to chill and perhaps try and refocus on whaf is most important to you. Marrying him? Or the date?

Without realising, you may end up spoiling any proposal plans he is making because you're so focused on the when.

It is positive you've had the discussion and are both on the same page. Now, let him take care of the proposal in his own way. It is one thing you can't and shouldn't be controlling.

Also consider: an autumn 2025 wedding is still possible. He could propose on 31st Dec 2024 and an autumn wedding would still be possible.

If you both love each other, then to be honest, even if it isn't Autumn 2025, you'll still be getting married (the most important part).

Start saving now incase you do have a shorter time scale to plan but try not to mention the word wedding or engagement too much. Remember why you're together and just enjoy that.

...and let him do it how he wants to.

This is AWFUL advice,

DO NOT indulge his need to control this, this is your future, he doesn't get to hold you random to the 'right time' and he doesn't get to gate keep marriage just because he has a penis,

You've agreed to get married, just book it. Or better still don't marry this controlling and flaky guy!

Echobelly · 16/03/2024 16:03

Could he be just feeling (unnecessary) pressure, either from you or from just... society in general that he has to put on a big show for you engagement wise?

In your position I'd have a chat with him and say he doesn't have to feel under pressure to do something big for you. Honestly, my DH proposed to me on the spur of the moment after we'd just been to an exhibition on a wet Tuesday in January and I do not feel I was let down. In fact I find it more romantic in many ways as it wasn't planned.

Modestandatinybitsexy · 16/03/2024 16:00

Do you know what kind of ring you want? Could you send him some options and some definitely nots and he can have some help in the shop?

But aside from the ring I would consider myself engaged. You have a promise, you have a date. I would start planning if you wanted to.

Changingplace · 16/03/2024 16:00

sonjadog · 16/03/2024 15:47

I suspect that for all they have agreed, when it comes to actually setting a date and making the bookings etc. the OP will find him very reluctant to commit. I think she is very wise to insist on a proposal first, so she isn't wasting money on bookings that will end up being cancelled.

Did you miss the part where he’s agreed to get married in autumn 2025? There doesn’t need to be a proposal once the conversation has been had and it’s so weird that people still get hung up on the concept.

psfiaqplffsa · 16/03/2024 15:59

Honestly OP he doesn't sound very enthusiastic!
DH and I did the same, he sent me rings suggestions, nothing for 6 months and then he proposed - on our anniversary. This was before the deadline though i said I wanted to be engaged within a year.
Give him 3 months and if it hasn't happened yet dump him.

Prydddan · 16/03/2024 15:58

MiltonNorthern · 16/03/2024 15:54

All you people advising her to break up with him if he doesn't 'propose' by a certain date are you mad?! They have agreed to get married, they want to get married. Breaking up would be absurd.

Whether he wants to get married is actually the hot debate topic. A fair few of us believe he's stalling.

benjoin · 16/03/2024 15:55

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 15:08

We just sat down to have a coffee and I asked him about why he's said a proposal is so important to him (he doesn't know I have this thread going)

He said 'well it's what I've always thought about, even before I met you. It's my job to do it'. Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

Do you think he's got something in his head about proposals being the 'macho' thing to do?! Does he think he should be able to read my mind?!

Thanks for the ideas about just getting on with planning, that seems a good way to go...and yes, I agree need to take some control and stop wondering what is going on!

Then wtf is he going to do about the ring though? Maybe start sending him links to ones you like.

This is getting silly he needs to shit or get off the pot

MiltonNorthern · 16/03/2024 15:54

All you people advising her to break up with him if he doesn't 'propose' by a certain date are you mad?! They have agreed to get married, they want to get married. Breaking up would be absurd.

SuziQuinto · 16/03/2024 15:54

MiltonNorthern · 16/03/2024 15:53

Just go shopping for a ring together! You're already engaged, there is no 'proposal' because he's not proposing anything you haven't already agreed to.

This is what you should say to him OP. It's not the 1950s, you're adults who have made a decision about your future - now get on with it!

MiltonNorthern · 16/03/2024 15:53

Just go shopping for a ring together! You're already engaged, there is no 'proposal' because he's not proposing anything you haven't already agreed to.