Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be suspicious about his proposal plans?

137 replies

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 13:59

I've been with partner for 5.5 years.

We've had lengthy discussions for the past year about when to get married. He knows I want to get married. He tells me he wants it too.

We agreed we would like to get married in Autumn 2025.

I'm still waiting on a ring/proposal and as time goes on I wonder when this will happen if we're to stick to the 2025 date.

He knows how I feel about still having no proposal. He tells me to wait because he wants to do it 'right'...I'm nervous that we'll get to 2025 and it'll just be words still. I feel like I'm in some weird limbo where we've made a plan but we aren't actually following through.

I grew up with some things which I admit can make it hard for me to trust. I'm tying myself up in knots about it as so far I only have his words and being told to wait is making me tetchy.

OP posts:
Anahenzaris · 17/03/2024 08:18

what’s your plan if he isn’t actually interested in marrying you Autumn 2025? You need to think through your responses to his possible actions.
1 not actually on board with getting married atm and stalling because doesn’t want to say “no”
2 wants to get married but not on that timeline and wants stuff delayed
3 wants to get married then but is wanting full control of the timeline and wedding and is using the proposal to do so (marriage no real wedding and this way you can’t book anything anyway)
4 wants to get married then and just doesn’t get it that the wedding you both want is fast becoming impossible because stuff isn’t booked.

If you know how you’d respond to each of these then I think you’re in a better position for a frank conversation. If your answer is we need to be engaged and wedding booked or you’ll move on - then just say we’ve talked about holding the wedding at this time and having this sort of wedding - are we booking or is that not the plan? Because for me I need this to move forward or move on elsewhere. It is ok to say we’ve discussed this numerous times and your answer is always yes but we won’t actually take steps in that direction - so it really just a no?

If your plan is to just keep begging him to move on knowing your plan is to stay no matter what - then you can ask him if his intent is to control everything about the engagement and wedding because that’s what he’s doing and it’s making you unhappy and will he change?

Loopytiles · 17/03/2024 08:01

On those other threads it’s often said that a couple is not engaged until the (legal) wedding is booked, and that some men not actually intending to marry use ‘engagement’ to ‘buy time’.

eg OP’s partner could string her along for a good while longer, ‘propose’ in 2025 then say ‘not enough time now to organise things - let’s do it next year’. Whilst considering his other options.

SuziQuinto · 17/03/2024 07:55

I agree, Vicky - it's a common theme on here- "why won't he propose?"
Stop waiting for a man's permission to get on with your life. As pp have said, you've agreed to marry, just make the plans. Talk to him again, just discuss wedding arrangements, not a "proposal" or a ring.

VickyEadieofThigh · 16/03/2024 20:48

This is not the first of these we've seen on here.

He's stalling.

Rosetrout · 16/03/2024 19:59

Does anyone else know the plan for 2025? Id broach the subject again and say you want to tell your parents the date because they’re planning a holiday or something. And gauge his reaction. It sounds like he’s stalling. You could have a lovely day out ring shopping together, him doing the proposal is just giving him all the power isn’t it.

TotalAbsenceOfImperialRaiment · 16/03/2024 19:53

Loopytiles · 16/03/2024 15:51

Stalling

One hundred per cent.

Ladyritacircumference · 16/03/2024 19:35

He is stalling on the proposal as he can keep fobbing you off as circumstances will never be quite ‘perfect’ enough for him to propose. He will drag this on for years hoping you forget about marriage.

if you propose to him, he will accept and then spin out the engagement for years. Again, circumstances will never be quite right for the actual wedding.

He will never marry you. Men who want to be married actively work towards making it happen.

Until the penny drops… do not have a child with him or buy a house with him.

Chances are that once your relationship is over he will very quickly move on and be married and have a child with someone else within a couple of years.

This story is as old as the hills.

coxesorangepippin · 16/03/2024 19:27

5 years???

He's not interested op

How old are you??

Greydiamond · 16/03/2024 19:25

m00rfarm · 16/03/2024 17:42

Why should his delaying things mean that the OP should treat him with kid gloves?

I'm sorry, I don't quite understand the saying of kid gloves.

Just to reiterate the point of my post is the actual marrying part is what truly matters.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 16/03/2024 18:19

I've been saying the same things as you all re planning, it is him who brings back the idea of a proposal each time

Well yes, but it's a lot easier to "delay" a proposal (as indeed he is doing) than to halt expensive bookings, etc.

After 5 years he knows if he actually wants to marry you, and I'd be asking about that rather than wedding planning - though you might want to ready yourself for unwelcome news

Richard1985 · 16/03/2024 18:07

It’s a shame you allowed the 29th February to bypass you without taking some control of things.

It’s a silly tradition but it would have broken the ice on the situation and you’d have known whether he is just being indecisive (in which case he’d have been pleased you asked) or is spinning you a tale because he has no intention of getting married to you

diddl · 16/03/2024 18:01

My husband asked me to marry him, we got up & went ring shopping.

Showed parents the ring & told them when we were thinking of getting married.

We've been married nearly 30yrs & I still doubt he could choose a ring for me!

WhoaJayShettybambalam · 16/03/2024 17:45

Show him what rings you like and tell him what size you are.

TBH I wouldn’t want to marry someone that made it such a chore.

m00rfarm · 16/03/2024 17:42

Greydiamond · 16/03/2024 14:09

In the most polite way, I think you need to chill and perhaps try and refocus on whaf is most important to you. Marrying him? Or the date?

Without realising, you may end up spoiling any proposal plans he is making because you're so focused on the when.

It is positive you've had the discussion and are both on the same page. Now, let him take care of the proposal in his own way. It is one thing you can't and shouldn't be controlling.

Also consider: an autumn 2025 wedding is still possible. He could propose on 31st Dec 2024 and an autumn wedding would still be possible.

If you both love each other, then to be honest, even if it isn't Autumn 2025, you'll still be getting married (the most important part).

Start saving now incase you do have a shorter time scale to plan but try not to mention the word wedding or engagement too much. Remember why you're together and just enjoy that.

...and let him do it how he wants to.

Why should his delaying things mean that the OP should treat him with kid gloves?

Changingplace · 16/03/2024 17:40

PaminaMozart · 16/03/2024 16:17

All those saying they are engaged because he has agreed to get married........

18 months from now
After lots of talks, discussions, pushing from the OP
but still no ring or a formal proposal...

He does not want to get married to her.
He is merely kicking the can down the road.

Don't let him mess you around, @daffolilly25
You have a difficult decision to make, but don't get sucked in by the sunk cost fallacy.
After all this time together, if he really wanted to marry you, you'd know.

How does the OP wearing a new piece of jewellery or repeating the same discussion with a formal unnecessary proposal make it any more of a decision? You don’t actually need a ring to be engaged, it’s just a joint decision that’s been made.

If he wants to get married they can just go and start setting a date and looking at venues, but nothing of what you’ve suggested makes it any more likely to happen if he really doesn’t want to get married.

Ihadenough22 · 16/03/2024 17:34

I think that he is telling you what you want to hear. He telling you he will propose but has not done this yet. He probably is quiet happy to have a girlfriend with regular sex but after a few years together it time to piss in the pot or get off.
If you want to get married in 2025 you need to be looking at venues, making a list for invites and discussing how your going to pay for it like adults.
At this stage I say to him that you want to go ring shopping next Saturday and then start to look at venues for a wedding in 2025.

If he is not willing to bring you ring shopping you have your answer their if he is stalling for more time. Perhaps he thinks you do until someone better comes along in his eyes.
The truth is that if you been a couple for a few years depending on your ages it time to decide if you get married or split up. It not fair to stay with someone when you know long term you may not be interested in getting married or having a family with them. A lot of my friends wanted to be married before having children as well.

I would not be waiting any longer for this man to grow up. I know several couples who either got married abroad or had small family only weddings because their priority was buying a home rather than a big wedding. I know several woman as well that told boyfriends it was over because he was not willing to marry her. These woman went on to meet a men who wanted marriage and kids.

Aspergallus · 16/03/2024 17:33

I grew up with some things which I admit can make it hard for me to trust.

These are the lies we tell ourselves when our partners aren't trustworthy, their words and actions aren't matching up.

"It's me, it's my past, I need to be more trusting." blah blah blah...

It's rarely us @daffolilly25. If he was straightforward, if his actions matched his words, if he didn't weasel around the questions with stalling words and explanations, I expect you'd be just fine.

Blaming our natural reactions on our past experiences rather than what is happening right in front of us is the biggest lie we tell ourselves...

ZanzibarIsland · 16/03/2024 17:29

Could you say you don't want a proposal any more and can you go ring shopping and start planning the wedding or do you not want to continue the relationship.
How old are you both as that makes a difference

mammaCh · 16/03/2024 17:15

If you've agreed to get married and even set a rough date of when, then you're engaged - surely?!
Getting engaged is asking "will you marry me?" Clearly you will, as you've agreed to do so.
I don't get why people want the big proposal, if they already know they're marrying.
Do you really need that?
Why not just book the venue together?

Mix56 · 16/03/2024 16:59

If you already live together this is the problem, there is no advantage for him to tie the knot.
I would say. "I understand you want to do it "right", but from my standpoint I am in limbo. I love you & want to be married to you.
It feels as though you are simply stringing me along.
I think I should move out."

Topjoe19 · 16/03/2024 16:57

I went to a jewellery shop & picked out a few options that I liked. DH went & looked & chose the one he wanted to get me. Then he proposed a few weeks later. I suggest doing that, then you'll know if he is true to his word.

MmePoppySeedDefage · 16/03/2024 16:56

Do you want an engagement ring? Or as a previous poster said do you have better things to spend your money on?

Marriage is a relationship, which needs to be right for you. The proposal/ring/Day are peripheral.

MissConductUS · 16/03/2024 16:54

daffolilly25 · 16/03/2024 15:08

We just sat down to have a coffee and I asked him about why he's said a proposal is so important to him (he doesn't know I have this thread going)

He said 'well it's what I've always thought about, even before I met you. It's my job to do it'. Then I asked him why he hasn't done it he said 'I don't know what sort of ring you will like. I know you said we could go together but I'm supposed to know what you will like'

Do you think he's got something in his head about proposals being the 'macho' thing to do?! Does he think he should be able to read my mind?!

Thanks for the ideas about just getting on with planning, that seems a good way to go...and yes, I agree need to take some control and stop wondering what is going on!

The fixation on the proposal is an obvious subterfuge. He's terrified of getting married.

Some men nurture this inner fantasy that a supermodel will fall into their laps someday and throw herself at him. He wants to leave his options open in case someone better comes along.

TotalDramarama24 · 16/03/2024 16:54

He sounds like he's buying time OP and doesn't really want to get married. If he hasn't done it after this long then he's not fussed about doing it. It sounds like he gave you a date far in advance to placate you but now it's getting near to when you want to start planning a wedding he is starting to back track.

PastorCarrBonarra · 16/03/2024 16:48

I’m in my early fifties and have seen too many women in their twenties and thirties get strung along by men (“I’ll propose when the time is right”). The men often end up married to someone else eventually. I wish that people - men and women alike - who don’t want to make a commitment would be brave and set the other party free as soon as they realise that they’re not really “feeling it”.

This may or may not be true here.

Tell him that you want to start making arrangements for the last Saturday in September 2025 (or whatever). Make bookings to visit some venues, browse travel sites for honeymoon destinations. His reaction to paying deposits etc will tell you what you need to know.

Swipe left for the next trending thread