Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same boys being chosen for sports

181 replies

Dantiger · 16/03/2024 13:04

Just before Christmas, 8yo DS (year 3) came home a bit sad as his PE teacher had chosen 6 boys from his class to participate in a football tournament. He wasn’t picked but wanted to do it. I told him it was ok and that I’m sure it’ll be his turn for something.

Then in January his school started a cross country team and 4 boys out of the 6 from the football tournament were chosen.

This Tuesday just gone, the year 4’s were having a football tournament. Apparently one of the same boys who got chosen for the year 3 tournament and the cross country team was picked to go with the year 4’s.

DS doesn’t hang around with any of these boys but I remember at sports day last summer they all won the categories.

I just feel with sports all children should have the chance to take part in events. I really don’t think it’s fair that the same boy gets chosen for all of them over and over again.

I probably am BU as it makes DS sad but I do think it’s unfair

OP posts:
Chickenrunning · 17/03/2024 08:51

I think @QuillBill has a very good point.

If all schools pick their best players, it has the best chance of being a fun and fair competition. I would have thought most schools want to give their students the best chance of doing well, hence picking a good team.

But suppose your school doesn’t, and picks a mixed ability team, potentially including your son. Two things will happen. Firstly, the team won’t do well. He won’t have that much fun when his team gets beaten game after game. Secondly, sadly, the players in the team who are good will get frustrated, especially if they know children who were better than your son weren’t picked. They will go back to school and say ‘it was rubbish. We lost because x is bad at football. We would have won if y was playing.’

The school would have several difficult situations to handle that wouldn’t have arisen otherwise.

Absolutely PE lessons should be inclusive and mixed ability. But competitions are different.

However, you should be able to find a football club with players the right level playing in the right league for your son to enjoy, if that is what he wants.

SantaBarbaraMonica · 17/03/2024 08:45

crikeycrumbsblimey · 17/03/2024 08:40

It isn't about picking the best kids though it is about picking the ones they know as it is easier. Same as my kids school

Welcome to life. If your kid wants to progress and get chosen, you need to help them get visibility. And get the skills to be visible.

PostItInABook · 17/03/2024 08:45

I excelled in sports, particularly netball, as a kid. Used to drive me mad being made to compete on a team with someone who was hopeless at it. In PE fine, I would do my best to include, pass the ball gently to the hopeless ones ect. But competing was different. I wanted to win. Once I was made to leave the court by the oppositions umpire/teacher and stand on the sideline because I ‘wasn’t letting them [the opposition] get the ball’. That’s the whole fucking point of the game. My headteacher was furious when he found out. I was basically made to feel like I had done something wrong for being better than the rest of them. I have never forgotten that. But the reason I was better was because I practiced endlessly and watched my mum playing in a competitive team all the time. I was (and still am) hopeless at anything music related so was never picked for anything involving that and didn’t care because I knew that wasn’t a strength of mine.

PuttingDownRoots · 17/03/2024 08:45

Both my DDs had sport disappointments at school.

With DD1 it was when she came top in the trial but wasn't picked. She's not sporty... but she can run long distance... she's like a duracell bunny. So she just does it out of school for fun. At Secondary she volunteered for house team but wasn't picked as shes quiet.

For DD2... she plays rugby out of school. Not brilliant, but reasonably promising. She wasn't picked for the rugby tournament as frankly, the boys at school couldn't accept a girl. They were all footballers. Shes looking forward to playing girls rugby next year as unfortunately its a not uncommon attitude. (Not all the boys.)

I think Primary schools are in an awkward position. They need both a reasonable level of confidence, and a team that will work together. So the teams end up getting picked on friendship lines as well.

crikeycrumbsblimey · 17/03/2024 08:40

It isn't about picking the best kids though it is about picking the ones they know as it is easier. Same as my kids school

Mintleafcocktail · 17/03/2024 08:39

If he loves football so much I don't know why you haven't put him in a club. The kids he is competing with for a place will be playing it constantly- both in clubs and in their spare time with their mates. It's no wonder they get good at it as they're playing it every single day and it shows- hence them being picked.

I don't necessarily agree that all talent is completely natural. Yes, some kids are obviously naturally talented and you can see it, but equally- persistent practice and doing something over and over again is what polishes skill. I know of people who arent "naturals" at certain subjects but they practice it daily and put the work in and are now are excellent at it- its become effortless to them because they are doing it over and over again. If he isnt doing this then you need to address this because he wont get better at something without practice and he wont be able to compete with the kids who are doing it very regularly for this reason.

DarkForces · 17/03/2024 08:37

Definitely enrol ds in a club. Think of the time to sports people spend training. They don't come out the womb wearing boots. Innate talent makes a difference but you can train and be decent in lots of cases.

Dd is a competitive athlete and I'm not sure if she'll ever 'relax' into it and flow like some of the absolute elite in her sport but she trains hard and has won local and regional competitions. More importantly has made friends and is really confident in what her body can do and learnt not to let a fall damage her confidence.

Definitely get him in a local group. Just make sure it's a good fit and don't be afraid to change and try a few. It took about 3 attempts to find the right club for dd and I watch to see the relationships between the coaches and teams in other groups. One I saw scold a little girl after a poor warm up while other teams have shared sweets with dd when she's been the only competitor from her team and lumped in with them. I always have options in my head if her team dynamic changes

BibbleandSqwauk · 17/03/2024 08:32

Just jumping on to say get him to a club now if he likes football. My DS wasn't interested at all until secondary school but now loves it. We're struggling to find a team that's the right (low,) level for his skills and he's had to leave one for being bullied for not being good enough / never getting on a match team. We've (I think) found him one now but it wasn't easy.

waterrat · 17/03/2024 08:28

final thought op - your son is definitely missing out if he actually wants to play football but you haven't put him in any sort of weekend activity for football!

also, do you have even one afternoon a week where you can take him and some friends to a park with a ball? that is just how my son has got good - hours and hours of playing.

my son has also made so many friends through football - you seem to think a child is just 'naturally good' ! this makes no sense.

WarningOfGails · 17/03/2024 08:27

Our secondary school streams for PE! I was surprised initially but actually it makes sense.

waterrat · 17/03/2024 08:25

we already 'stream' in secondary for academic subjects! nobody expects kids who are good at maths to dumb themselves down and go along at a lower level so that everyone feels included.

We need to do both - we need to increase fun and participation for those who are not talented/ particularly good at PE - and we need to allow competitive kids who are good at sport to enjoy competing.

We actually should I believe do PE every single day in school - one lesson a day and a huge huge amount more investment in time and money for physical activity in school.

waterrat · 17/03/2024 08:23

hi Op can I give another perspective. My son is really good at football and has found a lot of primary and secondary school sport very disappointing.

His main joy in life is sports - he commits hours at weekends, after school not just to playing in a team but going to the park, football cage, practising playing etc

In school he finds a lot of lessons boring - but LOVES pe!! here he actually is in the subject he loves - BUT - because it's not considered good in state schools to focus on competition in lessons - he is just bored in pe as well!

The competitions like this are the one moment he gets to show and enjoy at school the subject he loves and gives him so much pleasure.

He literally lives for those moments.

now - I have another child who is physically weak and crap at sport so I TOTALLY hear you - and I think there should be a lot more sport at school that focuses on enjoyment. We should encourage children to participate a lot more in sports for fun not just for competition.

but when there is a tournament - that is going to the kids who live this day to day and give it hours of their time.

Simonjt · 17/03/2024 08:21

DrCoconut · 16/03/2024 13:48

I bet the sporty lot would be screaming discrimination though if their kids weren't picked for the more brainy activities. It often seems to be the same popular kids who are chosen for everything. I really don't think highly competitive sports have any place in school. Education should be inclusive and about learning not one upmanship. Obviously games have a winner and that's ok but not the kind of competition that leaves people feeling crap and left out. There are plenty of sports clubs for those that want that sort of thing.

You would also have to either then ban competitions that are based on academic ability, or purposely choose children who aren’t good at maths etc, to represent the school, rather than the top five performing kids in maths, which is of course stupid.

Being good at something isn’t one upmanship, and thats the attitude that causes things like shame about being academically gifted.

I was playing rugby professionally when I was still at school, would you really have wanted me on the same team as someone who could barely hold a ball to have me running towards them for a tackle during school training?

What makes you think a child who isn’t gifted at certain sports can’t be academically gifted as well?

GuacamoleinmyDMs · 17/03/2024 08:20

I think there is something about there being kids who never have a place to shine. Not everyone can be top of the class academically or the winner at sports day.

And that is OK. These kids are often the ones with real resilience. The ones who keep plodding on. The number of threads I read where an 18 year old is devastated at not getting into Oxford or whatever as it’s the first failure they’ve ever had in life make me worry for society a bit. A crucial part of growing into a resilient adult is not getting picked, and failure. At the time these things can really upset you as a parent but I now look back on the disappointments and upsets my DC had (some significant, others not) and realise it was good that they experienced them.

curiousasacat · 17/03/2024 08:03

lotsofpeoplenametheirswords · 16/03/2024 13:42

My son is absolutely useless at sports he has never been picked for sporting team in 13 years and that's fine. Tournaments are competitive and should remain so. It's the kids have sporting prowess' time to shine.

My son however is always picked when it comes to anything science, maths or English based because that's what he's good at. That's his time to shine.

Same here! My son is not great at sports either and never gets picked but he is very intelligent and brilliant at programming, maths and science. I wouldnt expect the school to pick students for competitions who arent showing real skills for it- what's the point?- it would only end up in disappointment and loss when competing with kids who are showing natural skill.

If he really loves football then enrol him in a football club which will be great for his confidence and it will help him progress in the sport. I get that it's sad for him but we cannot all be great at everything we want to do- I'd love to be a singer but I sound like a cat being strangled. Thats ok- I am really good at other things instead. Everyone has their unique talents and it's about finding what area you shine in and focusing on that.

WarningOfGails · 17/03/2024 07:56

Scarydinosaurs re the number of children who can’t run a mile - this is a good point! I was frankly shocked at sports day last year, of course not everyone is a runner, but the number of overweight children who couldn’t run at all, let alone fast!

Fairyliz · 17/03/2024 06:47

I know you feel sad when it affects your child but please use this as a learning opportunity.
Life is full of disappointments for all of us. If you don’t learn how to deal with them as a child how can you cope with them as an adult.
I tried to ensure my children had a wonderful life with no upsets or bad experiences. Unfortunately it made them adults with little resilience.

XelaM · 17/03/2024 06:41

CheerfulYank · 17/03/2024 06:04

As far as what your DH said, at this age it may be hard to see if DS “has it” or not really!

My oldest DS is 16 now and plays 3 sports, 2 of them well 🤣 He wasn’t very good at them at all before puberty. There will always be some kids who show shocking ability very early, but there are lots who grow to be quite good who weren’t when they were very young. So if your DS likes going to football outside of school and is having fun, let him keep at it as long as he wants to.

That's very true, especially in sports like football. Those who show potential very young are often not those who end up making the U16/U18 academy teams.

CheerfulYank · 17/03/2024 06:04

As far as what your DH said, at this age it may be hard to see if DS “has it” or not really!

My oldest DS is 16 now and plays 3 sports, 2 of them well 🤣 He wasn’t very good at them at all before puberty. There will always be some kids who show shocking ability very early, but there are lots who grow to be quite good who weren’t when they were very young. So if your DS likes going to football outside of school and is having fun, let him keep at it as long as he wants to.

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 17/03/2024 05:58

Of course the best ones at sport are chosen for this, why wouldn’t they be?

Scarydinosaurs · 17/03/2024 05:50

I think the message that some people are smarter/faster/more agile than others is an important one for children to understand.

The pleasure you get out of sport isn’t the match/competition - it’s in the training. Enjoy the process of trying to improve.

At his age all that matters is having fun, moving his body, being active and being social. That’s how you have a life time love of sport/live a healthy lifestyle.

I find the same few kids get picked because being active and young for activities like running/football is actually quite unusual now. IME the number of children who can’t run a mile non-stop is shocking. Therefore as a teacher you have very little choice over who to take because there are only a few who could even give it a decent go.

As someone upthread said - imagine your son is taken to XC and finishes not just last, but absolutely miles behind everyone. That isn’t going to motivate him to do it again - it just gives him an awful experience of running. If you want him to be picked/he wants to go - take him to junior parkrun on a Sunday and get him used to running.

Toblerbone · 17/03/2024 05:39

I find it varies. In my DS1's primary school class, the kids who were best at sport also happened to be the brightest children academically. In my DD's class this wasn't the case at all - the sportiest girl was fairly average, while the sportiest boy was well below average academically. So I understand both arguments - "the same kids are picked for everything" and "it's x's one opportunity to shine". Either can be true!

pinklepea · 17/03/2024 05:22

Last 2 competitions were a science thing and a maths competition. Same child picked for them because they had best chance of representing the school. That child isn't on the football team

Dantiger · 17/03/2024 04:46

@araiwa Not really sure why you’ve mentioned a head teacher or getting “mummy” to complain. Never once said I have complained or was going to

OP posts:
VashtaNerada · 17/03/2024 04:37

At my school we tend to pick children who are pupil premium for this sort of thing. That could be why some children get picked repeatedly. My own DC frequently miss out on things and get really disappointed but I know it’s because PP children are being given opportunities (I obviously can’t communicate that to my own DC!)