Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Same boys being chosen for sports

181 replies

Dantiger · 16/03/2024 13:04

Just before Christmas, 8yo DS (year 3) came home a bit sad as his PE teacher had chosen 6 boys from his class to participate in a football tournament. He wasn’t picked but wanted to do it. I told him it was ok and that I’m sure it’ll be his turn for something.

Then in January his school started a cross country team and 4 boys out of the 6 from the football tournament were chosen.

This Tuesday just gone, the year 4’s were having a football tournament. Apparently one of the same boys who got chosen for the year 3 tournament and the cross country team was picked to go with the year 4’s.

DS doesn’t hang around with any of these boys but I remember at sports day last summer they all won the categories.

I just feel with sports all children should have the chance to take part in events. I really don’t think it’s fair that the same boy gets chosen for all of them over and over again.

I probably am BU as it makes DS sad but I do think it’s unfair

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Stressfordays · 19/03/2024 07:28

He won't struggle to find a team at 8. My middle son has just joined his first team at 8 and just joined a lower level to build skills and confidence.

My eldest joined his first team at 11 when I was told by a professional footballer watching him have a kick around that I must get him in a team. After a season at a low level team, he's just been signed for the local academy. It's not impossible to get them into football later if they have natural ability.

Wooloohooloo · 18/03/2024 21:49

@Northernparent68 no one is writing him off, simply pointing out that at the age of 8, a lot of boys would have been having regular coaching and experience of games for half their life so would obviously have an advantage.

m00rfarm · 18/03/2024 20:31

Dantiger · 16/03/2024 13:13

Fair points, I think it’s just because I know it bothers DS.

@WASZPy He doesn’t play anything out of school but I have been thinking of joining him into some kind of club

Until you do this, then there is little chance he will be picked for the school squads, and this wll simply get less likely as he gets older. Put him in a junior football team - he will probably not get picked for the first team, but at least will get some more football coaching and possibly picked for the second team.

whiteboardking · 18/03/2024 20:15

Northernparent68 · 18/03/2024 07:43

people Writing off an 8 year old just prove he’d be better off at a rubgy or basketball club

No one has written him off. They've said a lot of the boys will have started age 3/4 so shop around. Some clubs are very very competitive and select the best at an early age. Plenty don't.

elizabethdraper · 18/03/2024 09:20

NoKnit · 17/03/2024 19:54

I don't think a km in under 5 minutes even cross country is particularly fast for a child of that age. I'd say most active 9 year olds could do that. However keeping it up for 5km might be a different matter.

I agree, but he finished. Some of the kids didnt. We do park run so I know he can do it

But should children who can't manage 1km be picked for cross country for inclusion

Northernparent68 · 18/03/2024 07:43

people Writing off an 8 year old just prove he’d be better off at a rubgy or basketball club

Fizbosshoes · 18/03/2024 07:38

DS is good at tennis.
In his primary school when there was a school football competition the boys best at football (who played for a local team) were picked.

When there was a netball competition the girls that were best at netball (and played out of school) were picked.

Then they had a tennis competition and he wasnt picked because he played for a club.
That was a really difficult one to explain!!

GoingOverToTheDarkSide · 18/03/2024 07:26

he might not be the earliest to join a foot ball club but he’s definitely not ‘too late’. Watch a few little YouTube or CBeebies videos perhaps and get him along to a club for a taster session - any decent coach should make him feel included and set exercises he can do.

Crazycrazylady · 17/03/2024 21:30

Honestly Op. I think that at 8 he's on the old side for join a soccer club unless he is playing a lot himself in the park etc as most kids are playing 3 or 4 years at this stage. Some clubs are very competitive and some are more relaxed. Definitely enquire with coaches first.
I think Pe needs to be inclusive but absolutely for inter school competitions the best team will be chosen and it's only fair that they should be .
It would simply be carnage if they took the everyone gets a turn approach.

Delatron · 17/03/2024 20:19

Yeah they will have been doing clubs since about 4. 8 isn’t young really. There’s Little Kickers from about 3, rugby Tots etc.

He will get a lot of confidence and hopefully enjoy clubs out of school. School teams get more competitive as they go in to secondary so it’s good to try a wide range of sports and accept they may not be on the school team. And yes they have A,B and C teams so often most can get a go.

Our school football team is really competitive but DS2 plays for a local team so gets his enjoyment there and accepts he’s not good enough for the school team. He’s on the school team for hockey though. There’s loads of sports to try and he sounds keen so hopefully you can find him some good clubs. Then school teams matter less.

NoKnit · 17/03/2024 19:54

elizabethdraper · 17/03/2024 19:34

My 9 year old is an average football player. He has been going to training since he was about 3

Your son will struggle at 8 to join a team and learn the basics of football

He has also been chosen for cross country but he had to qualify. He run a km in under 5 mins. He came third in his trials

Can your son do this? He lapped some kids twice doing this

I don't think a km in under 5 minutes even cross country is particularly fast for a child of that age. I'd say most active 9 year olds could do that. However keeping it up for 5km might be a different matter.

Dantiger · 17/03/2024 19:35

I don’t think it’s so much as he’s woken up one morning and decided he thinks he’s good enough to be part of the team. The said tournament was being held at the training ground of the club he supports so I reckon that’s what’s started it all and then since speaking to him about it it’s come about him being interested in starting.

I didn’t realise how competitive it was, I think in my head they’re all still so young so I guess I just presumed at this age it was more on the fun side of things where all children were to have a turn

OP posts:
elizabethdraper · 17/03/2024 19:34

My 9 year old is an average football player. He has been going to training since he was about 3

Your son will struggle at 8 to join a team and learn the basics of football

He has also been chosen for cross country but he had to qualify. He run a km in under 5 mins. He came third in his trials

Can your son do this? He lapped some kids twice doing this

Ange1233556 · 17/03/2024 19:24

Of course it’s not unreasonable to pick the kids who are best at the particular sport. My son isn’t academic so is never top of the class but is incredibly sporty and excels in different sports. He’s on every school sports team and rightly so - he’s also in clubs for swimming, football l, cricket and running outside of school. If your son isn’t even in any sports clubs outside of school he’s clearly not that sporty. He can’t decide he suddenly fancies being in the football team

Longma · 17/03/2024 19:04

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

Longma · 17/03/2024 19:00

This reply has been withdrawn

This has been withdrawn by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines. at the request of it's author.

JADS · 17/03/2024 18:55

I haven't read the whole thread, but can I suggest if your ds is genuinely interested in cross country, you take him to junior park run on a Sunday AM? It's free and very inclusive - ours has several kids with SEN including my own ds. He will never be last and he will be able to see the improvement in his times.

The other thing that seems very inclusive is cricket. The Allstars program is good value and worth looking into. I wouldn't limit him to football.

Northernparent68 · 17/03/2024 18:46

Mamimoo · 17/03/2024 10:27

I’d ask the parent what they plan on doing to help their child develop.

Primary school PE teachers aren’t PE teachers, they’re just class teachers. In our school, different teachers take responsibility for different sports. There’s only so much they can do in the short time allocated.

My reply would be you’re the one making PE compulsory and organising school teams, so I expect you to teach

waterrat · 17/03/2024 18:01

Year 6 obesity levels will not be resolved by twice weekly 30 minutes of pe in an otherwise sedentary week

Its is criminally negligent that we sit kids down all day from year one onwards

Children should have hours of physical activity daily much of it freely chosen and playful..sport and pe are just a minor part of that.

And issues like this would be less stressful for kids if they got to play lots of freely chosen games like football rather than having to do clubs etc to play

Dogmum45 · 17/03/2024 17:48

Our School pick the best players for their A team and we have a B team that gets rotated so other boys get a chance. Most of the boys in my sons year play football for teams outside school and we have some fabulous skilled kids.

The school use the same A team as they are reknowned for winning.
Some parents kicked off about their little Ronaldo not being picked so there were trials held and surprise, surprise… little Ronaldo got picked.
He ended up being subbed for the majority of the game as he isn’t a strong player and the rest of the team weren’t happy to have a weak link so sadly it backfired.

Leave the school to pick their players and encourage your son to play for a team outside school and to look at other sports that are going to give him a chance of getting a place in the team… eg, basketball, hockey, cricket etc… as he may have a natural ability at one of those.

Vistada · 17/03/2024 17:24

YABU

Kids need to learn that, as much as they might want to be, they can't be the best at everything, that there will always be someone that bit better .

We shyed away from this for far too long which is now why, imo, we have an influx of gen z in the workplace who are genuinely shocked and horrified to learn they're not the best, brightest and best paid on day one.

MetalFences · 17/03/2024 17:11

What is it was a musical performance and your son couldn't play an instrument?

He'd just messed around with the glockenspiel in music like all of the other children in the class. Would he be disappointed that it's always Grace that gets picked because she can play the violin?

converseandjeans · 17/03/2024 16:58

@Dantiger

I wouldn’t say he’s being entitled as he’s never kicked up a fuss over it, just was a bit sad once

So it is likely you who has more of an issue. It's always parents wanting their kids on the footie team. Nobody ever expects their child to go into chess competitions or spelling bee or maths competitions if their child has shown no interest previously in those things. So why football? Is it because parents perceive that as a way to be more popular?

Honestly some kids are only really good at or interested in sport. If the teacher picks someone who has never played over someone who is mad on footie & they lose then they will all blame the player with no previous experience.

Some people on here are really scathing about groups of sports Mums - they just know each other from seeing each other at matches, giving other kids lifts, socials. We were doing footie tours by that age.

Would you want the team to lose just so your son had chance to play?

It doesn't sound like DH has any interest either. Has he never kicked a ball with him?

Twilightstarbright · 17/03/2024 16:39

I’m a U7 grassroots football coach. Contact your county FA and ask for the details of your lower league teams. Be polite and go on a waiting list if there’s not spaces. Better still offer to volunteer and you’ll find space quickly!

I truly believe sport should be for all at the correct level the team I coach has a mix of players from top division to lowest, we play in a middle division and most aren’t happy and you be better in a more appropriate division team (both higher and lower). However our club ethos is equal game time so that’s what they all get, even the boy that picks daisies mid match.

Sport is brilliant for building resilience and introducing competition but I think it also teaches that hard work and dedication counts for a lot of success. I never practiced the violin so I wasn’t very good.

My DS is a late July boy with motor skill delays. He’s only as good at sports as he is because of practice.

The one thing I recommend to any parent is junior parkrun- free and for all abilities, even teaching about volunteering and supporting others. Great for fitness and confidence.

Oh and like a PP said, the kids never pass to each other. Nothing to do with your son!

Wooloohooloo · 17/03/2024 13:52

My DS has been playing football for a team at the weekend since he was 4 and also tried other sports- cricket, gymnastics etc. He was a naturally sporty kid but playing sports out of school regularly definitely helped him improve. He was always chosen for sporting stuff at primary but this seemed fair based on his natural talent and efforts out of school. Get him enrolled on some classes/teams out of school if he loves sport.