Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know the condition DN is diagnosed with? Is there a way to find out?

656 replies

LovingPurpleBiscuits · 16/03/2024 11:19

Going through IVF at the moment, DP already has 2 DC from a previous relationship so it’s being funded privately and isn’t cheap.

My sister has a little girl from her marriage, now aged 10, but she is no longer with the father.

DN very obviously has some sort of condition, she struggles with talking and walking and all kinds of things I’d expect a 10 year old to do my DN can’t. But Sister has never shared her diagnosis with us, saying that it’s DNs information to give out and she only tells people who need to know. DN is lovely, polite, happy, well loved by my sister and is happy and settled at a fantastic school.

Now usually I’d respect this and not push it out of respect for my sister who will have her reasons for not telling us, but if it’s a genetic condition that I may carry the gene for my consultant would like to know so it can be tested for as early as possible, I also will not cope with a disabled DC so I want to mitigate the risk of that as much as I can – DP has said he would not cope with a disabled DC on top of his 2 already, so I’d be left to bring up a disabled child alone, I just cannot do it so would choose to end a pregnancy if it was discovered during pregnancy.

Have told Sister this and that I need to know for IVF and she just shrugged and said it wasn’t her place to tell me. I asked her Ex-Husband but he also said it’s not his place to tell me and it’s up to DN (the Ex-husband is involved with his DD, but not often so I’m not 100% certain he even knows as they split up when DN was tiny (under 2) so if DN was diagnosed it could have been after they split).

I’ve asked DN but she doesn’t seem to know what I’m talking about – so either Sister and Ex-BIL haven’t told her or for some reason DN doesn’t want me to know – I know there is definitely a condition of some sort (whether genetic or otherwise) as my sister would tell me if there wasn’t a condition to stop me asking, so there obviously is something.

My parents also don’t know and get the same answer from Sister when asked for the condition name.

I’ve asked sister for DNs doctors name but she just said she saw a general paediatrician and she can’t remember the person’s name. Is there any other way I can find out? Obviously, I know I can’t access DNs medical file, but I just want to know if theres a risk my own DC could be affected in the same way – I love DN and it would not change how I feel about her, but I also couldn’t cope with a disabled DC in the same way my sister does, she makes it look easy (which I’m sure it’s not). Sister also does it mostly alone as she won’t ask for help with DN saying DN is her responsibility – as in my parents babysit about twice a year for parents evening only, although Sister will ask her Ex-ILs more than my parents so maybe it’s just sister doesn’t want to ask my parents?

I just want to know so I can make a decision about moving forward with IVF

OP posts:
Upthelaganonabubble · 16/03/2024 18:22

Tahinii · 16/03/2024 18:19

You’ve clearly not read the thread. Many of us are in the same position as you. The OP’s approach is the problem, not her concerns about the risk.

Absolutely this. Worrying about increased chance of disability = normal. Asking a disabled 10 year old what is wrong with her so that OP can avoid having a child like her = appalling and offensive.

Viviennemary · 16/03/2024 18:22

Your sister is entitled to privacy. And also there are many disabling conditions that aren't diagnosed until after a birth. Also sadly children fall ill. I don't think IVF is the right thing for you taking into consideration what you have said in your post.

Tahinii · 16/03/2024 18:19

itsgettingweird · 16/03/2024 18:04

Exactly.

My ds has a dominant gene fault from me that means he has a 50% chance of having a child with the same condition. It's a degenerative condition and a cousin to MND.

I didn't know I carried the gene when I had him (there's some non penetrative with this condition) I decided not to have more children.

He's discussed with me about if he ever decides to have children what does he do and what are his options.

Funny how it seems all the outraged people on here aren't actually disabled or curriers of genetic faults.

They are outraged without actually having any full understanding of the situation, the risks and what decisions people have to face in reality.

Yes, anyone can become disabled or be born disabled.

But when you've faced disability and know there's a genetic risk of having a child with a disability it's a whole different ball game.

You’ve clearly not read the thread. Many of us are in the same position as you. The OP’s approach is the problem, not her concerns about the risk.

Doteycat · 16/03/2024 18:17

Dishwashersaurous · 16/03/2024 18:14

The reason that people are so appalled by the op is not actually about the genetic aspect.

It's because he partner has said that he will leave her if she has a disabled child. And yet she is planning on continuing with ivf to have a child with this man

Nope im pretty appalled at all of it tbh.
Why do people assume stuff?

Tahinii · 16/03/2024 18:17

SummerInSun · 16/03/2024 15:20

Haven't read the full thread, but I think all these PP who say you shouldn't have asked are idiots, and probably have no first hand experience of this. I had a genetic condition as a child which can either be random bad luck or highly hereditary. I had genetic testing and counselling before I had children and while I was at it I asked about the risk profile for my brother (who doesn't have what I have) and the chances of him passing it on when he had children, and got a very helpful email from the geneticist which I forwarded on to him. Families ought to help each other out that way, not try and hide important health info from each other.

I did the same with my sister but I knew there was a 25% chance of her having a child with the same condition. The sister of the OP may know this is not the case and therefore, she has chosen to keep the details private. Perhaps if the OP has asked if the condition is likely to be hereditary, rather than asking both an ex partner and a child, she’d have got the answer.

Thisgroupneverceasestoamazeme · 16/03/2024 18:16

@itsgettingweird thats a massive assumption to make about others on the thread.

Dishwashersaurous · 16/03/2024 18:14

The reason that people are so appalled by the op is not actually about the genetic aspect.

It's because he partner has said that he will leave her if she has a disabled child. And yet she is planning on continuing with ivf to have a child with this man

ACuriousHare · 16/03/2024 18:13

I understand your concern but you've really overstepped here and behaved really improperly in relation to your DN and those closest to her. Your worries and anxieties do not entitle you to access to her private medical information.

Thisgroupneverceasestoamazeme · 16/03/2024 18:12

Aside from the blatant ableism and naivety if you’re that bothered about the genetic side have IVF with PGS. Won’t negate all the other disabilities/health conditions that aren’t genetic but means you don’t have to invade your family members privacy

Sundaymorningatwork2 · 16/03/2024 18:12

Why don’t you and your husband go for pre-conception genetic tests. You can test for many risk factors this way…

godmum56 · 16/03/2024 18:11

Shouldn't you be discussing this with your IVF provider?

TruthorDie · 16/03/2024 18:09

Is your sister always so difficult and hard work? The doctor won’t tell you anything as legally they aren’t able to. You can have tests whilst you’re pregnant but they aren’t 100% reliable unfortunately

Doteycat · 16/03/2024 18:07

How do you know whos dealing with disability here?

LuluBlakey1 · 16/03/2024 18:07

You should not be contemplating having a child. You are not a person who has the qualities required of a good parent. Children can have a disability for a genetic reason and can also develop disabilities because of something that happens at birth or an accident or a health issue.

If you have a child and it develops a disability, what are you going to do? Dump him or her on the state and move on ?Your job as a parent is to do your best for your child, to love him or her unconditionally, to accept him/her for who they are and help them to live a happy, fulfilled life as much as they can, to fight for them.

Your actions are awful. You should be ashamed, asking a 10 year old disabled child what is wrong with her so that you don't risk having a child like her.

benjoin · 16/03/2024 18:06

itsgettingweird · 16/03/2024 18:04

Exactly.

My ds has a dominant gene fault from me that means he has a 50% chance of having a child with the same condition. It's a degenerative condition and a cousin to MND.

I didn't know I carried the gene when I had him (there's some non penetrative with this condition) I decided not to have more children.

He's discussed with me about if he ever decides to have children what does he do and what are his options.

Funny how it seems all the outraged people on here aren't actually disabled or curriers of genetic faults.

They are outraged without actually having any full understanding of the situation, the risks and what decisions people have to face in reality.

Yes, anyone can become disabled or be born disabled.

But when you've faced disability and know there's a genetic risk of having a child with a disability it's a whole different ball game.

How do you know who's living with disability and who isn't?

itsgettingweird · 16/03/2024 18:04

Lisagreasa · 16/03/2024 14:55

Some of you are being obtuse. I've got a disability and have been open about it to partners because I imagine having a disabled child - while you love them - is really, really hard. My sister also informed medics before having children. It's looking at statistics and knowing the reality of what might happen and if you feel you want to embark on that. And, yes, children can still become disabled but when there is a 20pc chance - that's different.

Exactly.

My ds has a dominant gene fault from me that means he has a 50% chance of having a child with the same condition. It's a degenerative condition and a cousin to MND.

I didn't know I carried the gene when I had him (there's some non penetrative with this condition) I decided not to have more children.

He's discussed with me about if he ever decides to have children what does he do and what are his options.

Funny how it seems all the outraged people on here aren't actually disabled or curriers of genetic faults.

They are outraged without actually having any full understanding of the situation, the risks and what decisions people have to face in reality.

Yes, anyone can become disabled or be born disabled.

But when you've faced disability and know there's a genetic risk of having a child with a disability it's a whole different ball game.

Citrusandginger · 16/03/2024 18:01

Oh and paying a lot of money for IVF does not mean you are more entitled. to a perfect child.

NiceUnusualDifferent · 16/03/2024 17:56

You've told your sister you need to know what DN has because you will abort I'd your baby does?? Wow

PyongyangKipperbang · 16/03/2024 17:56

Also....... why the HELL are you looking to havea child with a man who has made it quite clear that if things get difficult he will be off?

He has very clearly stated that he will walk away from his own child if it is disabled, that is not someone fit to be a parent! I am genuinely gobsmacked that you are considering him as the father for your child!

Avatartar · 16/03/2024 17:55

I think you have a complete lack of boundaries and empathy asking a 10 year old what is wrong with them- quite incredulous and for you to admit that by posting such n MN - especially after DSis and her ex would not tell you

Whitemale24 · 16/03/2024 17:55

YTA just get a screen yourself. Surely more relevant to your situation SMH...

Citrusandginger · 16/03/2024 17:55

Wow. If this is real, it is one of the worst things I have read on here. You are being very, very unreasonable OP.

I also will not cope with a disabled DC so I want to mitigate the risk of that as much as I can – DP has said he would not cope with a disabled DC on top of his 2 already, so I’d be left to bring up a disabled child alone, I just cannot do it so would choose to end a pregnancy if it was discovered during pregnancy.

What a vile comment.

TheCoolOliveBalonz · 16/03/2024 17:53

@clingon1012 I agree that perhaps she hasn't gone about this the right way. However, I can understand her worry so sympathise. Inheritable conditions aren't always obvious, no. We didn't know in our family until one person had it badly enough to pursue a diagnosis. Cystic Fibrosis is another case in point. I actually think its important that the OP finds out whether this is an inheritable disease or not. I would be annoyed with a relative who refused to simply confirm or deny that point.

TinyTyrantsSnackb1tch · 16/03/2024 17:51

I think you should consider pausing the IVF and working on your relationship and yourself first. Your husband sounds like a dick and you sound like you're getting obsessive- which I do get, it's stressful and anxiety inducing trying for a baby and going through IVF ...

But you crossed a line asking DN and I genuinely feel like you should pause and work on yourself for a little bit cause that was an awful thing to do.

Widgets · 16/03/2024 17:50

So you have basically said to your sister, tell me everything about DN diagnosis so that your consultant can make sure your baby doesn’t have the same condition because you absolutely do not want a baby/child like your DN.
Wow, you sound obsessed with your IVF journey and ensuring that your consultant makes you a perfect baby (impossible to predict, doesn’t exist!!) , you’re in a dream world!!
Disgusting to keep asking your sister and DN, stop, just STOP