Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know the condition DN is diagnosed with? Is there a way to find out?

656 replies

LovingPurpleBiscuits · 16/03/2024 11:19

Going through IVF at the moment, DP already has 2 DC from a previous relationship so it’s being funded privately and isn’t cheap.

My sister has a little girl from her marriage, now aged 10, but she is no longer with the father.

DN very obviously has some sort of condition, she struggles with talking and walking and all kinds of things I’d expect a 10 year old to do my DN can’t. But Sister has never shared her diagnosis with us, saying that it’s DNs information to give out and she only tells people who need to know. DN is lovely, polite, happy, well loved by my sister and is happy and settled at a fantastic school.

Now usually I’d respect this and not push it out of respect for my sister who will have her reasons for not telling us, but if it’s a genetic condition that I may carry the gene for my consultant would like to know so it can be tested for as early as possible, I also will not cope with a disabled DC so I want to mitigate the risk of that as much as I can – DP has said he would not cope with a disabled DC on top of his 2 already, so I’d be left to bring up a disabled child alone, I just cannot do it so would choose to end a pregnancy if it was discovered during pregnancy.

Have told Sister this and that I need to know for IVF and she just shrugged and said it wasn’t her place to tell me. I asked her Ex-Husband but he also said it’s not his place to tell me and it’s up to DN (the Ex-husband is involved with his DD, but not often so I’m not 100% certain he even knows as they split up when DN was tiny (under 2) so if DN was diagnosed it could have been after they split).

I’ve asked DN but she doesn’t seem to know what I’m talking about – so either Sister and Ex-BIL haven’t told her or for some reason DN doesn’t want me to know – I know there is definitely a condition of some sort (whether genetic or otherwise) as my sister would tell me if there wasn’t a condition to stop me asking, so there obviously is something.

My parents also don’t know and get the same answer from Sister when asked for the condition name.

I’ve asked sister for DNs doctors name but she just said she saw a general paediatrician and she can’t remember the person’s name. Is there any other way I can find out? Obviously, I know I can’t access DNs medical file, but I just want to know if theres a risk my own DC could be affected in the same way – I love DN and it would not change how I feel about her, but I also couldn’t cope with a disabled DC in the same way my sister does, she makes it look easy (which I’m sure it’s not). Sister also does it mostly alone as she won’t ask for help with DN saying DN is her responsibility – as in my parents babysit about twice a year for parents evening only, although Sister will ask her Ex-ILs more than my parents so maybe it’s just sister doesn’t want to ask my parents?

I just want to know so I can make a decision about moving forward with IVF

OP posts:
TooOldForThisNonsense · 16/03/2024 15:49

Hmm. I can see why you would want to know. When I was pregnant (not IVF) we were asked if there were any conditions in either family. My husband’s late uncle had severe learning disabilities and the MW told us to try and find out what it was. It was hard to find out as most family members were either dead or had dementia but we did eventually find out it was not genetic. I had all the tests etc clear for both kids but my youngest one is autistic something that wouldn’t be picked up in utero. So even knowing doesn’t mean you won’t have a disabled child. Also think of it from your sister’s perspective - you want to know so you don’t give birth to a child like hers. Surely you can see how hurtful that is?

Whereareallthemillionaires · 16/03/2024 15:48

I wonder if there are any MNs here who may be able to offer suggestions based on professional or/and other experience.
Perhaps a list of things you’ve noticed.
You have mentioned walking and speaking difficulties.

Then you could do some further research. It would be a terrible shame to give up on the idea of having a child when there may be no genetic link.

Alaina7 · 16/03/2024 15:45

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/03/2024 15:31

This crossed my mind too. Or something similar.

Glad it’s not just me thinking this, that it’s something the sister feels ashamed of or responsible for, either rightly or wrongly.

justasking111 · 16/03/2024 15:45

I had an amniocentesis test privately which tested for a lot more than the NHS did. But you will be facing a late termination.

Sasqwatch · 16/03/2024 15:43

LovingPurpleBiscuits · 16/03/2024 11:24

Yes I asked my DN as my sister said it was up to DN to tell me that information

Bloody hell, you overstepped the mark spectacularly there @LovingPurpleBiscuits. Surely your sister meant your niece can choose to give you that information when she’s an adult.

lilsupersparks · 16/03/2024 15:42

On the one hand, my nephew has a severe genetic condition that is pretty unpleasant. My husband and I were screened to see if we were carriers and we may have opted for an IVF route to avoid the condition if we were at risk.

On the other hand, my son has now developed epilepsy in his teens with no family history. I don’t think it’s possible to hand him back now so 🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️

You’ve asked if it’s genetic - the answer has not been forthcoming, you are going to have to make your decision and balance the risk with what you know.

Maybe just stick with something with a bit less commitment than a whole human tbh!

Mrspopper · 16/03/2024 15:41

Primefungus · 16/03/2024 11:26

How did you ask your niece -"hey sweetie what's wrong with you, as if I have a child like you I would abort". FFS just when you think people can't be any more disgusting.

ANY child can have a condition. If you can't deal with that possibility then don't have a baby.

Yes this!!!

Whatevershallidowithmylife · 16/03/2024 15:38

What would happen if your child had an accident and was disabled - you would have to cope.

Mumof2teens79 · 16/03/2024 15:37

Lisagreasa · 16/03/2024 14:55

Some of you are being obtuse. I've got a disability and have been open about it to partners because I imagine having a disabled child - while you love them - is really, really hard. My sister also informed medics before having children. It's looking at statistics and knowing the reality of what might happen and if you feel you want to embark on that. And, yes, children can still become disabled but when there is a 20pc chance - that's different.

But without knowing it his heritable we have no idea its a 20/25% chance.
It's far more likely DN has CP or GDD with no heritable cause. Or even if it is recessive gene its so rare as to be highly unlikely to affect OP unless her OH is DN father or another relative.

Skippingabeat · 16/03/2024 15:37

I'm trying to say this is the kindest possible way: if you know that you really can't handle having disabled children, you shouldn't have them.

Both my boys, conceived through IVF, have profound autism. Daily life is hard to extremely hard. The last few months have been hell because of extreme aggressions from one of them. The only way I'm coping is because I have daily caregivers and I have them for just 50% of the time, so I can still work full time and have some sort of life. It's still very hard.

And we've done genetic tests and didn't find anything.

My eldest daughters knows she will never have children because she can't risk having disabled ones.

CarpetSlipper · 16/03/2024 15:37

Your sister sounds sensible and responsible.
If you only want a “perfect” baby then perhaps don’t have one.
Lots of conditions are screened for in pregnancy, lots occur during birth/following illness or aren’t apparent until the child is older. If nobody else in your family is affected, then it’s likely that DN’s condition is not hereditary and is none of your business.

Mumof2teens79 · 16/03/2024 15:34

LovingPurpleBiscuits · 16/03/2024 11:37

I genuinely thought thats what my sister meant when she said it's for DN to tell me.

I think I will go away and have a think about whether not knowing i can proceed.

I may also ask Sister to write to my consultant or ask about a genetic link, but I'm not sure she'd tell me.

I think you are being ridiculous
Although genetics have come on so much and we now know we can identify "the gene" for a number of different conditions the number that are actually inherited in a way that means your child has a significant chance of being affected, and also can be tested for in utero is still tiny.

Your future baby has a greater combined risk of any other condition than the specific condition you seem to think must be genetic that your DN has.

Teajenny7 · 16/03/2024 15:34

ComtesseDeSpair · 16/03/2024 11:24

Your niece’s diagnosis is her private business. Ultimately if neither you nor DP would want to raise a disabled DC, the only option is to stay childfree. Plenty of disabilities cannot be diagnosed in utero or are acquired. There are absolutely no guarantees how your child turns out.

Edited

Exactly

Gwenhwyfar · 16/03/2024 15:33

Sirzy · 16/03/2024 11:29

Everyone is entitled to privacy.

any pregnancy runs the risk of the child being born disabled, any of us can become disabled during life. That is a risk you have to be willing to take.

Well, the risk is different for different people. If there is a genetic condition in the family, the risk is higher for OP so I don't blame her for wanting to know.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/03/2024 15:31

Semeliner · 16/03/2024 15:30

Maybe she has FAS and your sister is embarrassed

This crossed my mind too. Or something similar.

wurtle · 16/03/2024 15:30

My sisters first was born without eyes and also has autism. By the time I was pregnant I had genetic consultation and check my baby had indeed eyes by NHS. My sister who lives abroad would have provided more information if required. I had two dc with eyes. Later my sister got pregnant again but miscarried. The fetus didn't have eyes. Different dads. So it seems my sister has some gene mutation going on.

Semeliner · 16/03/2024 15:30

Maybe she has FAS and your sister is embarrassed

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 16/03/2024 15:26

housethatbuiltme · 16/03/2024 15:09

Wow you are literally saying you 'need' to know because if your kid was disabled like DN you would kill them rather than be 'burdened' with them and you can't see why that would upset your sister?

Ableism is fucking abhorrent.

Come on, that's not quite what she's saying. Please don't equate abortion with murder. I have said above that if she cannot cope with any disability that she should rethink TTC because who knows what can happen but saying she wants to 'kill' a disabled baby is loaded language that isn't helpful.

Magnoliasarelovely · 16/03/2024 15:26

I do think there must be more of a backstory to this. Are you quite negative about disabled people before this?

Maybe your sister has been worried about how you will treat your neice? I can’t imagine not being able to tell my sister about something like that.

Anyway, it must be hard going through ivf and i don’t want to bash on you but your neice probably needs cheerleaders op.

I think it’s good if you are honest and thinking things through about having kids, I think that’s a good thing but remember your sister probably needs kindness too.

WonderingWanda · 16/03/2024 15:25

It's not your business and quite frankly with your attitude towards having a disabled child I would suggest you don't become a parent.

Any number of things can happen during conception, and birth and you really need to be prepared for that.

Any anyway, if you are so concerned why don't you pay privately for yourself and your dh to have genetic testing.

CurlyhairedAssassin · 16/03/2024 15:24

that some parents don’t tell their child they are “different” and some children don’t know they are “different”.

So you tihnk it's kind to let them come to their own realisation when they are older children, do you? Do you not think that sudden realisation that they ARE different to others may damage their self-esteem? When other children start asking them questions and all they can do is shrug? What about when the child themselves start asking questions like "why can't I run as fast as my friends?", or "why do I have to visit the hospital so often, none of my friends do", are you as a parent going to lie to them? Whereas if it had been spoken about openly since toddlerhood, and accepted fully as the status quo, there is no dramatic realisation that they have this condition that means x, y or z.

DaoineSidhe · 16/03/2024 15:24

MultiPolarista · 16/03/2024 15:20

How incredibly weird of your sister. Does she often play power games like this?

I think it sounds like she is ashamed of her child.

Universalsnail · 16/03/2024 15:23

Truthfully if you know fully that you and your partner would not cope with a disabled child you should just not have any. You can't screen all risks and even with screening some screened for diagnosises get missed.

User35352662 · 16/03/2024 15:23

The problem here seems to be that both OP and her sister's way of dealing with the situation doesn't sound fully neurotypical. There is a lot of black and white thinking and inflexible boundaries that don't make much sense in the larger picture. OP seems to have convinced herself she cannot proceed with IVF unless she knows the name of a very rare condition from a child that probably only shares 25% of genetics with her.

The sister had made a valid but fairly limited rule of not disclosing something that would under normal circumstances be acceptable information within the immediate family. Sticking to a rule seems more important that what social impact that rule might have. And when she said "to ask DN herself", the OP literally went and asked a 10 year child which is bonkers on so many levels.

So the real issue here is for OP to decide whether the unusual and literal way both she and her sister deals with important decision is potentially (and far more likely) hereditary. If that were the case, would she be equipped to deal with a child who has the same issues?

Tattletwat · 16/03/2024 15:22

Slippery slope letting other people know about medical issues. May as well put it in there that any future partner gets to know your gynaecology history after all they should know.

Whether people think sister should tell her or not. The OP has behaved disgustingly and thinks she has a right to see them, she doesn't.

There really is more to this story and I bet this isn't first time the OP has invaded her sisters privacy.

And for a few of you calling the sister vile names and such, you are calling a single mother raising a disabled child these names, frankly you are disgusting.