Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be involved in these contact arrangements?

290 replies

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 07:20

My husband works shifts and always has done. This can change week to week and it was agreed with his ex when they separated that he would let her know as soon as he had his timetable so they could plan the days he has their two DC. This happens a month in advance typically, sometimes a little more.

Now...I appreciate as someone who also shares a child with him that it can be frustrating month to month. His ex has decided she wants set days now going forward which obviously DH cannot agree to as he'll at some point be working on those days.

She has suggested we sort it out "as a family" I.e. I look after the DC when DH is working.

Aibu to say no I won't be getting involved? This arrangement was the official child contact arrangement set when they divorced years ago and she like me decided to have children with a shift worker so its just tough luck really? 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
WorkCleanRepeat · 16/03/2024 10:42

I think your DH needs a new job that's more compatible with his family life. People need to be able to plan more than a few weeks in advance.

Brabican · 16/03/2024 10:41

Most MN posters believe that if a husband acquires step children he treats them as his own. How many posters proclaim that any partner must treat her children as his own or he is is not worthy of being her partner.
Such a different attitude to step mothers and step children.
if you are truly a team you work together. presumably you benefit from his salary?
MN is also disproportionately full of WFH mothers who do not understand that nurses for example work 12 hour shifts. Quick to moan if HCP are not available but sneerily dismissive of shift work.

ABetterEra · 16/03/2024 10:39

He may need to change job to a community nhs role that is 9-5. There are so many vacancies right now.

Everydayimhuffling · 16/03/2024 10:34

It's not your problem, but also it would be worth him asking why it's become a problem. If it's particular clubs or childcare issues then you'd know what is needed and he might be able to accommodate better. Harder if she's just sick of it, in which case she will probably need to go back to court.

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2024 10:33

There is some information noticeable by its absence.

How long has this arrangement been in place?

How does the ex manage her own work?

Has your dh submitted a formal request to work to fix his days/shifts?

MintTwirl · 16/03/2024 10:31

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 10:24

Well surely it's not reasonable to have it all one way either? He pays more maintenance, has them often more than her during the week and we always accommodate social, holiday or whatever plans she needs to make.

The poster says it’s petty about the CMS because it is so obvious that you are saying it because you pissed off that she has requested set days. it seems that you wanted everyone to say how unreasonable she is being?
The current contact might be court ordered but life changes, kids get older and what once works for everyone might not be working any more. Your DH needs to step up here and have a proper adult conversation with his ex where instead of saying take me to court, he actually does some compromising. If it works out that CMS needs changing due to the contact changes sort it then instead of using it around as some kind of threat to shut her up.

Scarletttulips · 16/03/2024 10:30

I think you need to keep a diary of times and dates you have the children should she decide to go back to court.

CMS may well be an issue if he’s paying and still have the children more than 50% - she can’t have it both ways.

Nor can she request you do additional free childcare.

He needs a backbone and stick to the court order. She wants her cake and eat it.

And those days about the CMS - she has a new partner and clearly goes in child free holidays - bet OP doesn’t.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/03/2024 10:27

Don’t reduce CM though. What a petty thing to do. It’s for the kids on the ex wife.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 16/03/2024 10:26

Courts order all sorts that logical people might consider unreasonable.

It doesn’t sound good to me for the kids to only know where they’ll be two weeks in advance. As they get older, it’ll get more and more unsuitable.

I don’t think you have to be party to the plans or childcare at all, but I think he needs to sort it so that he has regular days with the kids. This could either be by changing his job or using childcare during the week.

Mumofteenandtween · 16/03/2024 10:26

Does she have to pay for childcare for every day of the week? As that is pretty rubbish for her. Or she can not commit to doing something on any day at all?

I think that you need to come up with a compromise here. He /you will always have the kids on a Wednesday for example. And the. She gets to choose two other days from the 4 available.

The court order may not say that but most of us know that courts are not always fair.

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 10:24

WhamBamThankU · 16/03/2024 10:16

That's seems a bit petty to reduce CMS. He needs to put in a flexible working request. Asap. If you were the ex in this scenario would you be happy with the set up? If they don't want court they could go to mediation. It sounds like things are amicable apart from this issue.

Well surely it's not reasonable to have it all one way either? He pays more maintenance, has them often more than her during the week and we always accommodate social, holiday or whatever plans she needs to make.

OP posts:
Velvian · 16/03/2024 10:17

It's good of you to cover ex's social plans @Julio56 . What is the issue that has prompted the complaint? Is it paid childcare, set activities...?

Is it that her new partner has to cover her working days when your DH is also working that day? As that is the flip side of what is being asked of you.

Could you agree to 1 set day a week to covers one of her working days to soften the additional burden that falls on her and her partner, due to your DH's shifts?

WhamBamThankU · 16/03/2024 10:16

That's seems a bit petty to reduce CMS. He needs to put in a flexible working request. Asap. If you were the ex in this scenario would you be happy with the set up? If they don't want court they could go to mediation. It sounds like things are amicable apart from this issue.

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 10:15

And as mentioned, this is all court ordered. The court thought it reasonable to only give her 2 weeks notice! Which he obviously doesn't do.

OP posts:
Julio56 · 16/03/2024 10:14

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2024 10:09

So he doesn't need to do more. He chooses to.

They're 50/50 so no CM changes hands?

She is limited by his shiftwork and changing work patterns.

I'm starting to get the picture...

No, he occasionally does another shift on the day he's not supposed to have the DSC.

He does actually pay more than the CM calculator which is based off his 3 nights a week (even though he often has them more than this).

Maybe he can suggest he stops doing that so he can use the money for the childcare needed for set days.

OP posts:
Testina · 16/03/2024 10:12

Honestly, I’d put money on him never having made a formal flexible working request, because if he had, you’d have mentioned it in your OP @Julio56

Which doesn’t make any of this your fault or your responsibility of course, and I think YANBU not wanting to pick up the childcare for him. Where you would be unreasonable, is if you thought she was unreasonable for expecting him to make that flexible working request.

Overthinking22 · 16/03/2024 10:12

Sounds like she's the one that has been accommodating long enough and it no longer works for her. Why should she continue to work around your DH shifts, it's of no benefit to her and she can't plan ahead.

user1492757084 · 16/03/2024 10:10

Maybe they can agree to a semi set pattern, where the child has every XXXteamsportXXX day with Mum etc. Is the reasoning about DSC needing to be more settled into a routine so to join a sport or hobby?
It would be annoying for the ex. but also disruptive for the child once they are old enough to have committments and jobs etc.

yourlobster · 16/03/2024 10:09

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 16/03/2024 07:35

It's not your issue and it's certainly not his ex's issue.

Your H needs to be a better parent and realise that some jobs just don't work around childcare responsibilities.

Women downgrade/change their careers and working hours ALL the time to fit in around school days and childcare responsibilities, he needs to do the same.

If his job is no longer compatible with raising the kids that he created, he needs to find a solution for that. If you're not going to be the solution and you're saying that childcare won't work either, then HE needs to make a change, so HE can look after his own kids in a stable way, that give both his children and his ex wife the solid structure of set days to work around.

This!

I sort of see the argument the OP is making that the ex chose to have a relationship and children with a shift worker but she's not in a relationship with him now so life is different and circumstances change.

He needs to sort this in a way that works for family like. It's not for the ex or the OP to organise his family commitments for him.

GabriellaMontez · 16/03/2024 10:09

So he doesn't need to do more. He chooses to.

They're 50/50 so no CM changes hands?

She is limited by his shiftwork and changing work patterns.

I'm starting to get the picture...

Elephantswillnever · 16/03/2024 10:07

I share 50/50 with my ex and shiftwork just isn’t possible so I got a different job where I work set hours and that was on a rolling 4on 4 off. It’s actually really difficult to plan out life when you don’t know what’s happening one month to the next .

Testina · 16/03/2024 10:06

“He has asked in the past for more set working shifts but unfortunately it's just not possible right now. His role is extremely short staffed (NHS).”

Does that mean he causally said, “any chance of fixed shifts?” or he actually made a formal flexible working request, and discussed any push back from that with his union rep? I know several people with fixed shifts in the NHS.

To not want to be involved in these contact arrangements?
MintTwirl · 16/03/2024 10:05

How old are the dc? Surely once school age it is better for them to have set days so they can do extra curriculars, arrange to see friends etc . DH needs to work with his ex on this, not just tell her to go to court, if you aren’t willing to look after them on his time(fair enough) then he has to arrange childcare.

NeedToChangeName · 16/03/2024 10:05

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 16/03/2024 07:35

It's not your issue and it's certainly not his ex's issue.

Your H needs to be a better parent and realise that some jobs just don't work around childcare responsibilities.

Women downgrade/change their careers and working hours ALL the time to fit in around school days and childcare responsibilities, he needs to do the same.

If his job is no longer compatible with raising the kids that he created, he needs to find a solution for that. If you're not going to be the solution and you're saying that childcare won't work either, then HE needs to make a change, so HE can look after his own kids in a stable way, that give both his children and his ex wife the solid structure of set days to work around.

I agree with this

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 10:02

Testina · 16/03/2024 10:00

“He works 3 long shifts most weeks, on occasions will need to do more depending on staffing levels.”

Does he need to do more? My sister is NHS (midwife, understaffed) and she says no. She simply cannot do more than her scheduled 3 long shifts because she doesn’t have childcare. There is no ex husband or second husband to do it. So she says no.

He's supposed to have the children 3 nights a week and always does in accordance with the shifts he's given and is given to his ex. Sometimes on the 4th day off, he works as they are understaffed. But if he doesn't, he often ends up having the DSC on this 4th day too.

OP posts: