Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be involved in these contact arrangements?

290 replies

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 07:20

My husband works shifts and always has done. This can change week to week and it was agreed with his ex when they separated that he would let her know as soon as he had his timetable so they could plan the days he has their two DC. This happens a month in advance typically, sometimes a little more.

Now...I appreciate as someone who also shares a child with him that it can be frustrating month to month. His ex has decided she wants set days now going forward which obviously DH cannot agree to as he'll at some point be working on those days.

She has suggested we sort it out "as a family" I.e. I look after the DC when DH is working.

Aibu to say no I won't be getting involved? This arrangement was the official child contact arrangement set when they divorced years ago and she like me decided to have children with a shift worker so its just tough luck really? 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
TheColdest · 16/03/2024 17:07

I just want to point out to you OP that you don't have to organise your life around your DH either OP. Your DH may manipulate you into thinking this way but it is not true. You are just as entitled to a full life as your oh so very important DH. He earns more than enough to organise childcare to cover his 50% of parenting. Please don't waste your life propping him up.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/03/2024 16:57

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 16:45

How is it shit? They know weeks in advance?

And they get to see their dad?

How is seeing their dad less, better?

The only person this would be better for is the mum.

As children get to secondary school, they generally want more autonomy and want to be able to plan things with their mates. If they know (for example) that on Wednesday, Thursday and Sunday they'll be at dad's, they can plan around that. If they don't know from one month to the next where they'll be on any given day, it makes things harder.

They wouldn't necessarily need to see dad less under new arrangements either. Just on set days - even one week of abc and one week of xyz would be easier than the current set-up.

TheColdest · 16/03/2024 16:52

Fixed days are reasonable and what most courts would order. I'm sure as a doctor he is more than capable of organising and paying for childcare. If he really is incapable of doing that, maybe it is time for a career change. Ex should not have to work her whole life around your DH.

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 16:45

PegasusReturns · 16/03/2024 16:39

@Scarletttulips

Why has she asked to change?

Presumably because young pre school/infant school children don’t care if they’re at mum or dads at any given time.

once they’re moving into secondary, making their own plans, concentrating on study/hobbies/friends they need a little more autonomy and want to know where they are going to be from one week to the next.

the current arrangement is shit for the DC.

How is it shit? They know weeks in advance?

And they get to see their dad?

How is seeing their dad less, better?

The only person this would be better for is the mum.

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 16:44

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 16/03/2024 16:05

Surely even A&E drs could ask for flexible working? What if he was a full time parent, what would he do then? I'm not saying he has to give up his job but at least request set shifts?

How long has this court order been in place OP?

Course they can ask. And get told no. Very easy business case to make as to why they can't offer that.

PegasusReturns · 16/03/2024 16:39

@Scarletttulips

Why has she asked to change?

Presumably because young pre school/infant school children don’t care if they’re at mum or dads at any given time.

once they’re moving into secondary, making their own plans, concentrating on study/hobbies/friends they need a little more autonomy and want to know where they are going to be from one week to the next.

the current arrangement is shit for the DC.

Justkeepingplatesspinning · 16/03/2024 16:35

I think she's probably got to the stage where she's fed up of working her life around 4 weeks notice of her ex's shifts. Unfortunately, she now expects you to step in and accommodate so the children are with you set days/nights.
Perhaps unfairly, it feels as though your husband has expected his ex to work around his shifts, and now expects you to take your turn. What's he actually said when you told him 'no way?'
I would go with her request for fixed days / nights and make it 50/50 (and no child maintenance in that case), as it's not for ever, but get the child access order changed to reflect this.

rookiemere · 16/03/2024 16:25

With your update OP, it does seem odd that she is questioning the arrangement now, just at the point when the DCs are getting more independent and don't need after school care.

I know it's not your problem but i wonder if it's worth DH trying to understand where this request is coming from - perhaps the DCs themselves want a more stable routine, or maybe the DM has a new DP and wants to plan the odd weekend away without being made to feel she is being granted a favour.

If he could understand then perhaps they could agree something that works for both parties, although this may involve some compromise on his part.

MotherofChaosandDestruction · 16/03/2024 16:05

Surely even A&E drs could ask for flexible working? What if he was a full time parent, what would he do then? I'm not saying he has to give up his job but at least request set shifts?

How long has this court order been in place OP?

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 15:39

he does an extra shift if they are short staffed - again a conscious choice and doesn't seem to increase the CM he is paying

I think you're confused. He only ever works an extra shift on the 1 day a week he has off where he isn't supposed to have the DC. And a lot of the time he will have them on that day anyway making it 4 days a week a lot of the time that he ends up having them.

And I've already said he pays maintenance (more than the calculator) based on having the DC 3 nights a week (even though he often has them 4 nights a week).

To answer some questions:

  • mum works in a 9-5 job.
  • the children are in school, one in last year of primary and one just started secondary. Often the secondary DC collects the younger from primary and walk home together. They stay by themselves either at mums or at ours until we are home (I work 9-5 too).
  • previously when after school care was needed, they paid half each for this. DH also covers school dinners now for the eldest in secondary.
  • she can make plans whenever she wants (for the next week, for the next 3 months or whatever) we have always accommodated any holiday or night out or whatever she's wanted to do, often meaning I look after them if DH ends up being at work that day.
  • DH is a doctor working in A&E so it isn't always possible for him to leave straight away when his shift ends. He does most of the time but understandably if he's in the middle of an emergency he can't.
  • he won't change career. He is very passionate and good at his job.
  • yes I accept that if we ever separated I'd end up having to do the same probably. I know his job and I know the situation and i decided to have children with him.
OP posts:
Elephantswillnever · 16/03/2024 15:30

I do think ex has a right to feel aggrieved. It’s really hard to progress at work if you don’t have hours you are regularly available for. I get he wants to see his dc but it shouldn’t be solely at his convenience.

Whilst 50:50 with two weeks notice might of been possible at the time of separation, it isn’t working now.

rookiemere · 16/03/2024 14:17

ACuriousHare · 16/03/2024 13:51

His work sounds incompatible with being a 50/50 (or near that) parent.

He either needs to change jobs or go to EOW with maybe one evening/dinner a week.

His poor children. Not only do they have to contend with a shared care arrangement, but they also don't know which days/nights they will be spending with each parent.

To clarify - I'm not against shared care or 50/50 arrangements. I think with both parents on board they can work fine. But I don't think it's acceptable that the kids don't even know, for example, whether Monday or Thursday will be spent with Mum or Dad and in which house.

Yes I'm amazed a judge agreed that arrangement. Rubbish for the DM and rubbish for the DC particularly once they start having after school and weekend activities.

It seems astounding that it's impossible to get a role within the NHS with set shifts.

TeaGinandFags · 16/03/2024 13:54

This is between the ex and DH. You should not only keep out of it, but be kept out of it. If you become the de facto babysitter then how does this affect your life? What about your working hours and down time?

Whatever position you choose to adopt, make it clear and stick to it. If, and when, this goes to court you will need to speak with the solicitor to protect your own back. Ask what rights taking responsibility for the step children grant you and take it from there. (If you have no rights, you should have no responsibilities.)

ACuriousHare · 16/03/2024 13:51

His work sounds incompatible with being a 50/50 (or near that) parent.

He either needs to change jobs or go to EOW with maybe one evening/dinner a week.

His poor children. Not only do they have to contend with a shared care arrangement, but they also don't know which days/nights they will be spending with each parent.

To clarify - I'm not against shared care or 50/50 arrangements. I think with both parents on board they can work fine. But I don't think it's acceptable that the kids don't even know, for example, whether Monday or Thursday will be spent with Mum or Dad and in which house.

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 13:15

Springtime43 · 16/03/2024 13:07

I’m not entirely sure what a fair and equitable solution would look like, given the circumstances?

Imo it would look like what they're already doing.

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 13:15

I do tend to think if you marry someone who works shifts you're kind of agreeing to dealing with it whether you're together or not.

I say this as someone who's dh has worked shifts.

Chocolatebuttonns · 16/03/2024 13:12

Dogscanteatonions · 16/03/2024 07:34

I think she has the right to want a set pattern, and it's better for the kids to have a set structure to their time with each parent. It's down to your partner to work it out

It's not better if it means they spend most of the time they're supposed to be with their dad in childcare or not seeing him though is it?

Springtime43 · 16/03/2024 13:07

I’m not entirely sure what a fair and equitable solution would look like, given the circumstances?

Scarletttulips · 16/03/2024 13:07

He can only work shifts because his XW is forced to accommodate them

Why has she asked to change?

Let’s say she works 9-5 and he has the child 4 nights a week? What is she doing then?

What is she needing to do on the days she has the child and Clare can’t?

If they did 3 days 2 days pattern that seems popular - then she has them 3 days 2 off 2 on so 5 days the first week then 3 off 3 on 2 off so 3 days the following week giving 50/50 time.

Same as she has now.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 16/03/2024 13:01

If you break up with you OH would you feel it was reasonable for your life years later still be massively impacted by your Ex because he work shifts? Ultimately that's what it comes down to. He can only work shifts because his XW is forced to accommodate them.

EliflurtleAndTheInfiniteMadness · 16/03/2024 12:50

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 16/03/2024 07:35

It's not your issue and it's certainly not his ex's issue.

Your H needs to be a better parent and realise that some jobs just don't work around childcare responsibilities.

Women downgrade/change their careers and working hours ALL the time to fit in around school days and childcare responsibilities, he needs to do the same.

If his job is no longer compatible with raising the kids that he created, he needs to find a solution for that. If you're not going to be the solution and you're saying that childcare won't work either, then HE needs to make a change, so HE can look after his own kids in a stable way, that give both his children and his ex wife the solid structure of set days to work around.

This. HE needs to make changes so he can commit to a set schedule. Its not reasonable for him to expect his XW and child arrangements to go on working around his shifts.

KTheGrey · 16/03/2024 12:40

Well let her go back to court. Mumsnet is unlikely to be able to tell you if this is reasonable or not given we don't have any idea what she does workwise, or how old the children are and what school pick ups etc are required or what he pays in CMS.

On the face of it, she wants to renegotiate the arrangement for her convenience, and looking after children is not convenient because it's full time and so is life. He appears to do his share, abide by the court's ruling, accommodate her requests for flexibility and make a payment for the single "extra" day a week she has them. I don't know what more he can do.

If her circumstances have changed - her working hours, for example, she can take it back to court. But unless she has a reason she needs to wind her neck in. And no, it shouldn't fall on you.

PegasusReturns · 16/03/2024 12:36

So she wants to change to agreed structure to suit her now. A pity she didn't bring this up during the divorce

perhaps she did and she had an arsehole judge

perhaps she did and she decided it was in her DCs best interests to be accommodating

perhaps she did as it was what suited her and the DC at that time

perhaps the passage of time has meant the DCs need have changed

she’s perfectly entitled to seek a variation to an order that was impose years ago. Good luck to her!

losthj · 16/03/2024 12:30

I don't think you are unreasonable.

You help where you can but don't want to be part of a formal plan.

If she goes to court she would have to show the arrangement was no longer in the child's best interests.

DH has status quo in his favour, and taking it to the line the court can't comply you to do it.

JudgeJ · 16/03/2024 12:29

Obeast · 16/03/2024 10:01

Telling her to go to court because he refuses to adjust his life to accommodate the kids that he chose to keep having is taking the piss. Expecting women to scamper along after him to raise his kids for him is unattractive.

Does this man enhance your life?

The ex is refusing to abide by the divorce agreement and is now expecting her ex to bend over backwards to suit her. If he lets her get away with this she'll be back constantly wanting more from him. She chose to marry a shift worker and have children with him and now it doesn't suit her. Tough!

Swipe left for the next trending thread