Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to be involved in these contact arrangements?

290 replies

Julio56 · 16/03/2024 07:20

My husband works shifts and always has done. This can change week to week and it was agreed with his ex when they separated that he would let her know as soon as he had his timetable so they could plan the days he has their two DC. This happens a month in advance typically, sometimes a little more.

Now...I appreciate as someone who also shares a child with him that it can be frustrating month to month. His ex has decided she wants set days now going forward which obviously DH cannot agree to as he'll at some point be working on those days.

She has suggested we sort it out "as a family" I.e. I look after the DC when DH is working.

Aibu to say no I won't be getting involved? This arrangement was the official child contact arrangement set when they divorced years ago and she like me decided to have children with a shift worker so its just tough luck really? 🤷‍♀️

OP posts:
Hopingitsahornyfinger · 17/03/2024 13:44

Totally agree @Herdinggoats

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/03/2024 13:37

GabriellaMontez · 17/03/2024 12:14

But it's not the Mum. I don't know any Mum's in this situation? Why?

Because the Mums I know, have altered their jobs/roles/careers to meet the needs of their families.

They're not relying on an ex and new partner to facilitate their unpredictable working hours.

This man hasn't even put in a formal request for fixed shifts.

Agreed.

It's always the mum and indeed the new wives who have to fit their schedules around the ex/dh never vice versa. The level of entitlement that some men have is so tiresome.

crockofshite · 17/03/2024 13:32

This arrangement sounds like its for the ex wife's convenience. So she gets her child free days with free childcare because there's no parenting available.

Don't agree to it.

The parents have to parent themselves, or they can agree to arrange and pay for childcare.

Have they considered putting the kid in boarding school?

Herdinggoats · 17/03/2024 13:18

KTheGrey · 17/03/2024 11:58

@Chocolatebuttonns

I agree entirely. The kids are old enough to sort themselves out for an hour or two after school, and the guy's a doctor. He works hard and complies with the court and it's just not enough for some posters. He IS looking after his kids, he DOES pay his ex and nothing is good enough. Sheesh.

Just because you’re a doctor doesn’t give you a free pass to treat others like shit. It is a crap situation for the ex-wife to be beholden to an ex-partner for years.

His career doesn’t work with his family responsibilities, he either needs to give up on the 50:50 contact, pay for childcare on his days, request flexible working, find another job, or take a career break. There are lots of options that women choose to do day in day out. This situation doesn’t work for the ex, and she’s given it a fair go. It prevents her from being able to build any regular commitments on her childfree days. I’d say the fact that he isn’t prepared to find or work towards a solution is actually quite controlling.

I can’t believe how much the tone has changed since the OP said “he’s a doctor”. Doctors can be arseholes too…just like the rest of us.

Missamyp · 17/03/2024 12:27

A couple of points.

Meet and marry a man with children then you will have to assimilate and deal with the ex-his kids-and his job. This works the other way round for women.
Court order contact is fine-however flexibility is needed, both DP and I have exes with work obligations that are outside of the routine 9-5.
Divorce isn't the end of a relationship when one has children with the other.
It's ongoing albeit sometimes mentally tiring trying to juggle life with the other person.

GabriellaMontez · 17/03/2024 12:14

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 08:28

And actually if it was the other way round. As in mum was an a&e doctor I can GUARANTEE that it would be

Well dad only has a pathetic 9-5 why can't he work around this absolute earth angel who saves lives for a living. The kids need to see their mum they shouldn't be in childcare. Why should mum have to pay for childcare when dad is available..

This website is laughable sometimes.

But it's not the Mum. I don't know any Mum's in this situation? Why?

Because the Mums I know, have altered their jobs/roles/careers to meet the needs of their families.

They're not relying on an ex and new partner to facilitate their unpredictable working hours.

This man hasn't even put in a formal request for fixed shifts.

Hopingitsahornyfinger · 17/03/2024 12:04

p1ppyL0ngstocking · 16/03/2024 07:35

It's not your issue and it's certainly not his ex's issue.

Your H needs to be a better parent and realise that some jobs just don't work around childcare responsibilities.

Women downgrade/change their careers and working hours ALL the time to fit in around school days and childcare responsibilities, he needs to do the same.

If his job is no longer compatible with raising the kids that he created, he needs to find a solution for that. If you're not going to be the solution and you're saying that childcare won't work either, then HE needs to make a change, so HE can look after his own kids in a stable way, that give both his children and his ex wife the solid structure of set days to work around.

This!

KTheGrey · 17/03/2024 11:58

@Chocolatebuttonns

I agree entirely. The kids are old enough to sort themselves out for an hour or two after school, and the guy's a doctor. He works hard and complies with the court and it's just not enough for some posters. He IS looking after his kids, he DOES pay his ex and nothing is good enough. Sheesh.

ACuriousHare · 17/03/2024 11:53

Scarletttulips · 17/03/2024 11:35

With children age 10-12, surely the obvious thing would be to ask them what they want

What offer them something they can’t have?

Why can't they have stable predictable contact arrangements if that's what they want? They could do EOW with dad and then see him during the week for evenings/dinner as much as his schedule allows - they don't need to miss out on quality time with him.

In any case, if the matter went to court the court would probably give a lot of weight to what the children would prefer, given their ages.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/03/2024 11:36

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 11:23

And that's better for them? OK.

Why do you think it's a problem? I don't know anyone in that age group who doesn't go home to an empty house after school unless they have a SAHP.

11-12 year olds are quite capable of coming home, making a snack, watching TV and getting started on homework without an adult hovering over them.

Scarletttulips · 17/03/2024 11:35

With children age 10-12, surely the obvious thing would be to ask them what they want

What offer them something they can’t have?

ACuriousHare · 17/03/2024 11:33

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 11:25

Ah okay so when they've got loads of homework it'll be so much better to be doing it in an empty house with no support rather than being at their dads with their dad for support.

The mum works 9-5. The longest they're going to be by themselves is a couple of hours. Depending on the school, they may have clubs or be able to study in the library.

But how people expect older children to thrive without a stable base is beyond me. Most adults don't cope well without this.

For younger kids, at least it's the parents who get the annoyed call from school when the reading book doesn't turn up or the packed lunch for a trip is forgotten, rather than the child being picked out, told off and put in detention.

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 11:25

ACuriousHare · 17/03/2024 11:20

With children age 10-12, surely the obvious thing would be to ask them what they want.

Personally there's no way I'd be happy about children that age living between two households without set days, though I'd accept that if it's what the kids wanted.

The stresses and academic demands are going to start ramping up soon for both of them, but especially the older one. They're at the age where they're gaining greater independence and will be expected to take responsibility for their own learning, schedule and belongings. How can they do this successfully if there's no consistency and they don't know whether they're coming or going? Talk about hobbling your children's life chances for your own gratification.

Ah okay so when they've got loads of homework it'll be so much better to be doing it in an empty house with no support rather than being at their dads with their dad for support.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/03/2024 11:24

ACuriousHare · 17/03/2024 11:20

With children age 10-12, surely the obvious thing would be to ask them what they want.

Personally there's no way I'd be happy about children that age living between two households without set days, though I'd accept that if it's what the kids wanted.

The stresses and academic demands are going to start ramping up soon for both of them, but especially the older one. They're at the age where they're gaining greater independence and will be expected to take responsibility for their own learning, schedule and belongings. How can they do this successfully if there's no consistency and they don't know whether they're coming or going? Talk about hobbling your children's life chances for your own gratification.

This is so true.

One of my dc is of a similar age and they simply wouldn't cope with it. It's very unfair on them.

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 11:23

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/03/2024 10:46

How am I supposed to know? I was answering a hypothetical question.

And what childcare do you think they'll need? One is in secondary school and one is in year six. They can come home alone and be alone after school if mum has to work.

And that's better for them? OK.

ACuriousHare · 17/03/2024 11:20

With children age 10-12, surely the obvious thing would be to ask them what they want.

Personally there's no way I'd be happy about children that age living between two households without set days, though I'd accept that if it's what the kids wanted.

The stresses and academic demands are going to start ramping up soon for both of them, but especially the older one. They're at the age where they're gaining greater independence and will be expected to take responsibility for their own learning, schedule and belongings. How can they do this successfully if there's no consistency and they don't know whether they're coming or going? Talk about hobbling your children's life chances for your own gratification.

LiveLaughCryalot · 17/03/2024 10:57

This is for your DH and his ex to sort out amongst themselves @Julio56 I would imagine you have enough on your plate with your own children, working around your DH's shifts. I have been there myself. So they need to come to an agreement together that doesn't end in piling more work on you. Good luck.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/03/2024 10:46

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 10:38

But are they? Because that hasn't been said. Mum wants it to change.

How am I supposed to know? I was answering a hypothetical question.

And what childcare do you think they'll need? One is in secondary school and one is in year six. They can come home alone and be alone after school if mum has to work.

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 10:43

And if the kids do want change do they realise that they'd probably be alone / in childcare more?

If they want change and are happy with that by all means she should go to court.

But we don't know if the kids want change. We just know the ex does.

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 10:38

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 10:38

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/03/2024 10:37

Just because something is court-ordered, doesn't mean it's what's best for the kids.

If my kids were telling me they were unhappy with the arrangements, I would go with what they wanted and tell dad to take me back to court if he was unhappy with me putting my DC's interests and feelings first.

But are they? Because that hasn't been said. Mum wants it to change.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 17/03/2024 10:37

Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 09:28

So are you saying she shouldn't follow court ordered access and do what's best for her kids?

What should she do?

Just because something is court-ordered, doesn't mean it's what's best for the kids.

If my kids were telling me they were unhappy with the arrangements, I would go with what they wanted and tell dad to take me back to court if he was unhappy with me putting my DC's interests and feelings first.

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/03/2024 10:32

CoffeeCup14 · 17/03/2024 10:23

I was in the position of the ex-wife. My ex wasn't doing shift work when we got together. He chose to leave when the children were small. I got 3-4 weeks notice of availability for his contact with the children. He was in an NHS/emergency services role, with lots of weekend work. It was really stressful and unpleasant. It's very difficult not being able to plan ahead for anything and being dependent on someone you likely don't have a great relationship with. It's just very tiring having to factor in someone else for everything. It's very different to being in a relationship with someone in that kind of role, where there is a sense of working together and you can see the benefit for the whole family.

  • It isn't reasonable to expect someone to live like that. There may not be alternatives, it may be necessary, but it's still not a reasonable expectation and ex-wife is reasonable to be annoyed by it.
  • When the children are young it's easier to manage. You can tell them far enough in advance where they will be. As they get older they want to be more independent and have more control over their lives and their free time. It might well be possible to do this within this situation by changing how things are framed and allowing more control (a shared google calendar, letting the children have more of a lead in how things are devided, deliberately talking about it in these terms).
  • Yes, OP's husband could change careers to accommodate the children and ex-wife. It's probably not reasonable or desirable to expect it though. However, has he explored all the options for more stability and predictability (e.g requesting some kind of fixed time off, shift swaps with colleagues etc)? It's really easy for him to say he can't do anything about his situation, because that would require more effort from him and the impact currently falls on other people.
  • 50-50 in these circumstances is probably not helping - it's increasing the amount of uncertainty and negotiation required.
  • No, OP, you shouldn't be expected to get involved. It sounds like you are already helping out by being available for holidays/nights out etc.

This.

Well said.

CoffeeCup14 · 17/03/2024 10:23

I was in the position of the ex-wife. My ex wasn't doing shift work when we got together. He chose to leave when the children were small. I got 3-4 weeks notice of availability for his contact with the children. He was in an NHS/emergency services role, with lots of weekend work. It was really stressful and unpleasant. It's very difficult not being able to plan ahead for anything and being dependent on someone you likely don't have a great relationship with. It's just very tiring having to factor in someone else for everything. It's very different to being in a relationship with someone in that kind of role, where there is a sense of working together and you can see the benefit for the whole family.

  • It isn't reasonable to expect someone to live like that. There may not be alternatives, it may be necessary, but it's still not a reasonable expectation and ex-wife is reasonable to be annoyed by it.
  • When the children are young it's easier to manage. You can tell them far enough in advance where they will be. As they get older they want to be more independent and have more control over their lives and their free time. It might well be possible to do this within this situation by changing how things are framed and allowing more control (a shared google calendar, letting the children have more of a lead in how things are devided, deliberately talking about it in these terms).
  • Yes, OP's husband could change careers to accommodate the children and ex-wife. It's probably not reasonable or desirable to expect it though. However, has he explored all the options for more stability and predictability (e.g requesting some kind of fixed time off, shift swaps with colleagues etc)? It's really easy for him to say he can't do anything about his situation, because that would require more effort from him and the impact currently falls on other people.
  • 50-50 in these circumstances is probably not helping - it's increasing the amount of uncertainty and negotiation required.
  • No, OP, you shouldn't be expected to get involved. It sounds like you are already helping out by being available for holidays/nights out etc.
Chocolatebuttonns · 17/03/2024 09:28

Willyoujustbequiet · 17/03/2024 09:26

She absolutely shouldn't. No wonder she's fed up.

So are you saying she shouldn't follow court ordered access and do what's best for her kids?

What should she do?