Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be disgusted at what my DH has said.

431 replies

Sweetcherrypiee · 16/03/2024 01:39

My DH has very sadly just lost his DB after a long illness. His DBs wife has early onset dementia (mid 50s). They were together since they were 18 and my DH has known her since then.

Yesterday we went out for a meal to discuss things as a family. DH refused to have her there and his words were ‘she’s not my responsibility’. He has basically wiped his hands of her now his DB has passed away and has basically said after the funeral he won’t be there to support her going forward. I feel disgusted with his attitude towards her. They never had any issues or have argued. I know he is grieving but she has also just lost him and with having dementia needs extra support.

His DB would be so sad at this attitude also.

OP posts:
AmaryllisChorus · 16/03/2024 10:56

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/03/2024 10:47

The meal was "to discuss things as a family" - it wasn't just a social get together.

So? That's hardly saddling someone with long term responsibility. And people with dementia can have moments of lucidity. It's not unthinkable that she should be invited.

TDIAP · 16/03/2024 10:55

I think it was a callous comment, but I’m on the fence about it too.
Dementia is a hard thing to deal with and maybe he think there’s an expectation now his brother has died that he will have to step up and help and he doesn’t want to. He could have chosen better words to express that, but he’s lost his brother and there is probably underlying anger about that there which has made him react the way he did.

Unfortunately also a lot of families don’t see in-laws as family when their blood relative is no longer around. (my in-laws are like this). It could be he falls into that camp.

user1494250093 · 16/03/2024 10:49

When my father died I said some stuff that I bitterly regret. Grief is so painful that people react in unexpected ways. Be kind to him and see what the situation is like in six months. Sending love to you both - it must be so hard for you.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/03/2024 10:47

AmaryllisChorus · 16/03/2024 10:45

She was expecting him to invite the woman to lunch! That's not being coerced into 'taking responsibility.' It falls under 'showing compassion'!

The meal was "to discuss things as a family" - it wasn't just a social get together.

AmaryllisChorus · 16/03/2024 10:45

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/03/2024 07:14

What are you expecting him to do?

She was expecting him to invite the woman to lunch! That's not being coerced into 'taking responsibility.' It falls under 'showing compassion'!

Librarybooker · 16/03/2024 10:43

A sad situation OP. I suppose there is something about how grief can impact on these things and everyone copes differently.

I lost my bro 5 years ago. It brought my SIL and I closer. Both my elderly parents passed away recently and she has been a great support to them over the years. When the hospital phoned to say they thought my father had only hours left, she jumped in the car and drove straight over. My nephews are step nephews from her previous marriage but they are family just the same.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 16/03/2024 10:41

curiousasacat · 16/03/2024 07:47

But would you exclude them from family events

My dad had dementia and yes, there came a point where we no longer took him out with us for family meals. The reason for that was that he became very disorientated and confused/distressed in unfamiliar surroundings. He'd try to wander off multiple times, he would get confused over how to use cutlery, he'd refuse to dress appropriately etc It got to the point where actually taking him out was becoming cruel for both him and us.

Yes, but people with little or no direct experience of dementia so often fail to understand such issues. Heaven preserve us from such people when they try to tell those at the sharp end what they ought to be doing, or how they ought to be behaving.
There are alas an awful lot of clueless ‘experts’ trying to give the benefit of their superior ‘wisdom’ to people who are actually coping with dementia.

Manyandyoucanwalkover · 16/03/2024 10:36

Grief is horrible and affects everyone differently. Don’t judge him, give him time and space to grieve.

lifebeginsaftercoffee · 16/03/2024 10:35

Lassiata · 16/03/2024 10:08

It sounds to me like the OP is probably not talking about actually care, just visits, friendship and emotional support?

The problem is, what starts as friendship and emotional support can very, very quickly become caring responsibilities. Maybe he's worried about doing the former and getting sucked into doing the latter.

PlacidPenelope · 16/03/2024 10:32

I know he is grieving but she has also just lost him and with having dementia needs extra support.

What extra support are you thinking of here @Sweetcherrypiee ? Why do you see this as being the sole responsibility of your husband?

Whilst what your husband has said may sound brutal it is not, are you really expecting him to sign up to caring and supporting his SIL with dementia for the rest of her life? You could be talking about 30 plus years that is one hell of a commitment to place on someone shoulders. Dementia is dreadful and caring for someone who has dementia is all encompassing and soul sapping if he were to do this it would take a terrible toll not only on him but on your family life, is that what you want?

Your husband is correct SIL is not his responsibility other solutions and options need to be found. He has been honest that he cannot and will not take on that burden and that is to his credit.

DriftingDora · 16/03/2024 10:31

Is there something more behind this? Does he perhaps feel that she didn't treat his late brother well? Perhaps his brother confided in him about the marriage and this has affected his views?

She's sadly so young to have dementia that the road ahead will be very, very hard and maybe he feels that he doesn't want to take it on and then find he/you both can't continue to help. It's very easy to begin, but what if things happen in your lives, other family commitments, illness, etc. that make it impossible and place enormous stress on you both? How will you cope then? What if others don't 'rally round' and you are both doing it on your own?

It's probably still too early to make a final judgment on what will happen, but I do think it would be right to be cautious about what he/you both are taking on -and to have thought things through carefully.

Dibbydoos · 16/03/2024 10:27

It's possibly too painful for him to see her but that doesn't stop you from being there for her, she needs support.

From personal exp, losing your DH isn't just losing your BF and partner, you lose your future. For me that was and 9 years later, still is a very hard thing to work through.

slore · 16/03/2024 10:20

I agree with you OP. This must be incredibly hard for your SIL - one of my loved ones experienced a bereavement in the early-middle stages of Alzheimer's, and it was made worse by how confused and disorientated she was.

I think unless there are extenuating circumstances lie abuse or whatever, families have obligations to care for each other. I don't like the "not my responsibility" attitude.

No man is an island, and I'm sure if the situations were reversed and he was the grieving widower with Alzheimer's, he would appreciate family support.

Tomselleckhaskindeyes · 16/03/2024 10:18

My mum got selfish after losing my dad. Lasted a couple of years and I started to get her back. I did however have to call her out on a few things. I realised that my dad maybe pulled her up on things i the background.

teabooks · 16/03/2024 10:15

If its that much of a concern to you and your that disgusted with him why dont you do it.
You take responsibility for her.

He has made his choice tbh i dont blame him.
Her family should be stepping in not him hes lost his brother let him be let him grieve.
Ive seen first hand when someone takes responsibility for someone else and it turns life upside down.
Ive seen marriages end because of it its not all roses.
And seen the regret from it.

She needs professional support not your husband.

ItsallIeverwanted · 16/03/2024 10:14

When you are burned out from caring (it happens in the caring/nursing professions too), it does stop you feeling empathic to others. You think 'oh no, not another one'. That's why care has to be shared out and paid for if necessary. People can give what they can give. You can make your own decision though, leave him be for now, and visit her if that's your decision.

I would also say the men I know are spectacularly worse than the women I know at stepping up to care as well, even the nice ones. They tend to shut down emotionally, especially around death, I've noticed this recently myself. Not an excuse, not ok, just explaining what I've seen.

ItsallIeverwanted · 16/03/2024 10:12

My guess is he's burned out after the death of his brother. Also, he may worry that if he starts visiting/doing things, it will suck him into being a carer, and that isn't appropriate. It sounds like she needs outside support and support from her own family and 'meaning well' and calling in occasionally won't be enough, and he doesn't want to give more.

I kind of get it, after a decade or so, I'm very burned out of caring within my own immediate family and I'm afraid that if more peripheral people got sick, I wouldn't be rushing in to help myself.

Lassiata · 16/03/2024 10:08

It sounds to me like the OP is probably not talking about actually care, just visits, friendship and emotional support?

minthybobs · 16/03/2024 10:07

His DB would be so sad at this attitude also

If DB loved and cared that much about his wife’s welfare he would have put plans in place for her care. Rather than leaving it to just see who happened to step up at the time. Thats hardly caring and it’s unreasonable of him to leave it to chance.

user1471538283 · 16/03/2024 09:58

He's grieving and honestly after helping to care for my DGM but with professional and family support I wouldn't do it again.

Your life is on hold and weekends are eaten up. Doing that full time could destroy him and your family.

She needs professional support.

x2boys · 16/03/2024 09:44

What care do you expect him to provide?
I worked in Dementia care for many years it's really hard work particularly as sadly the disease progresses.

Createausername1970 · 16/03/2024 09:44

There is not enough information to comment.

What was the family meal about? To remember DB or discuss SIL?

If it was to discuss SIL, who else was there and what level of support was being discussed and did anyone else offer to assist or was there an assumption DH would just take over the mantle?

Does she have siblings or children?

On the face of it, the comment was not pleasant, but if my BIL were to die anytime soon, and my SIL had dementia, I wouldn't be offering to have her live with us. I would "care about" her and would want to help to get good care in place, but I wouldn't be willing to do the actual caring or foot a big bill.

betterangels · 16/03/2024 09:44

Usually, setting boundaries is applauded on here. That's all he's doing. During a period of grief, no less.

But sure, he must be callous and without empathy...

zingally · 16/03/2024 09:41

That, on the face of it, sounds incredibly callous, but people behave in very strange ways when they're grieving. Which your DH certainly will be.

Give it a bit of time, and then try again.

Zwellers · 16/03/2024 09:40

Starspangledrodeopony. Always good to see someone who knows the family and the exact situation coming to a coherent and thought out viewpoint. Oh wait. Its a man it must be callous and evil.

Not his family. Not his problem.

Swipe left for the next trending thread