Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU for not knowing how to handle this living arrangement?

32 replies

Stressedhahaajsk · 15/03/2024 22:01

When I met DP, he lived in City A and I lived in City B (which is more expensive). I would mainly stay at his as he had his own place whereas I was renting in a house share.

A year after meeting, I then rented my own flat in City B and he lived with me while paying his mortgage. I then moved jobs and we briefly lived together at his in City A.

i now have a job offer back in City B and he is suggesting I stay in City A and commute to B. There is very little scope for remote working and my commute will be over 3 hours a day, all in.

i really want to move back to City B (which was always the plan) to be closer to work. The job is stressful and demanding and I think a 3 hour commute would be stressful. I would also be far from friends.

The thing is, as he has his own flat, he obviously won’t be able to pay half the rent on a property to share but also doesn’t want to live with others. I will struggle to pay rent on somewhere for both of us.

the only compromise I see is that I live elsewhere on a m-f basis and live at his on weekends. He could maybe stay a night or two as well. We could then look to buy somewhere together.

he will see this as taking a step backwards but I just can’t afford to pay rent for two people in a more expensive location.

aibu?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
moonfacer · 16/03/2024 17:41

dammit88 · 16/03/2024 13:59

Yes he has? he lived in his flat in city A to start. Then moved to the OP flat in city B with her. Then they both moved back to his? That's quite a lot of chopping and changing in one year I think?

But his base has remained the same throughout.

And presumably he stayed rent free with OP in the city he works in, so hardly a huge sacrifice.

Whereas he is asking OP to commute 3 hours round trip daily.

gannett · 16/03/2024 15:45

dammit88 · 16/03/2024 13:59

Yes he has? he lived in his flat in city A to start. Then moved to the OP flat in city B with her. Then they both moved back to his? That's quite a lot of chopping and changing in one year I think?

The timescale suggests an insane amount of chopping and changing.

They've been dating just over a year. For a year of that OP was in a City B houseshare so spent most of her time at the bf's City A flat. Then she rents her own City B flat (and bf moves in - why would he do this?) then she changes job and they move to his City A flat and then she now has another job offer in City B all in the space of a few months?

dammit88 · 16/03/2024 13:59

moonfacer · 16/03/2024 06:53

He hasn’t moved though. He’s had the same place throughout.

Yes he has? he lived in his flat in city A to start. Then moved to the OP flat in city B with her. Then they both moved back to his? That's quite a lot of chopping and changing in one year I think?

NuffSaidSam · 16/03/2024 10:07

I can totally see his point, it's been a year and quite a lot of changing in living arrangements, it's understandable he doesn't want to commit to anything yet.

You should do what you suggest in your OP, rent somewhere M-F and stay with him at the weekend.

Make a more permanent decision down the line.

Hankunamatata · 16/03/2024 10:01

I think it depends what plans are moving forward and timescale. Kids? Marriage? Buying property together?

Toblerbone · 16/03/2024 09:48

I think the best solution is the one suggested in your OP. You rent somewhere in City B and spend the weekends at his. He stays at yours one night mid week. Yes it's sort of a 'step backwards' but it just seems like the only practical solution for now. Then see how things pan out in terms of jobs, houses etc.

PicaK · 16/03/2024 09:30

You both work in City B. It makes sense to reside there. He might not always have the wfh option he does now.
Tbh what you have been doing for the last 12 months is irrelevant. Look forward.
1h commute (one way) is norm for London but 1.5h pushes it into uncomfortable territory. It is def a consideration.

gannett · 16/03/2024 09:21

Couple of things I don't understand.

You say moving back to City B was "always the plan". Was it his plan as well? When you planned it what timeframe did you discuss? And was his plan to sell his City A flat and for you to both buy in City B?

And what was your plan when you applied for the City B job? I assume this hasn't been suddenly sprung on you and there's been some time between application and getting it - have there been no discussions between you as to how you'd make it work?

Because as things stand neither of you are unreasonable not to give ground, especially as it's still a very new relationship - but the bigger problem seems to be a combination of being bad at a) planning, b) communicating your plans to each other.

Scarletttulips · 16/03/2024 07:29

Of coarse she can apply for any job she likes.

OK so he owns his own home, no doubt OP is contributing to his costs and he likes having his mortgage shared. Anything other than OP commuting means he has to make an effort - during the week or weekends - he also loses his cooker and cleaner

There’s no benefit to him you working in another city so I don’t expect he’ll stay around long.

Loopytiles · 16/03/2024 07:22

‘You shouldn’t have applied for other job unless you had discussed how you would make it work together first’

When she’d dated him for one year?

TheOccupier · 16/03/2024 07:21

Stressedhahaajsk · 15/03/2024 22:14

We have been together just over a year and both 30

This is nothing! Do what works best for you.

ohdamnitjanet · 16/03/2024 07:20

Stressedhahaajsk · 15/03/2024 22:08

I have suggested this and he is reluctant. He’ll look into it but it’s not his first choice. He said it will take a few months to sort which is a fair point. I’m just not sure what to do in the meantime.

He’s happy for you to do the 3 commute though.

Calamitousness · 16/03/2024 07:18

I see his point of view more. He owns a home. Why would he want to sell so he can rent with you. I wouldn’t. You shouldn’t have applied for other job unless you had discussed how you would make it work together first. Unless you’re not in the relationship for long run which I guess may be the case here. I’d say have a conversation along the lines of, commute initially with maybe a couple of nights overnight like Tues/Wed to reduce the load, but with a view to consider buying somewhere together between A and B. Move out of cities and find somewhere in the middle if your job works out and you like it.

Doingmybest12 · 16/03/2024 07:09

Is there anywhere between the two cities that would work for you both? I couldn't contemplate commuting 3 hours a day. If he is staying put then rent somewhere for you in the week and go to his at weekends.

Loopytiles · 16/03/2024 06:58

You’ve only been together a year: would do what works best for you personally.

commuting 5 days a week or the Monday to Friday away options sound bad for you. Him suggesting them doesn’t reflect well on him IMO.

would rent somewhere you can afford in the city you’ll work in, presumably in a share. Visit your boyfriend only as often as he visits you or, say, 60/40.

your place having flatmates doesn’t justify you doing most of the travelling etc.

longer term wouldn’t be keen on the commuter town unless there are numerous job options for you with 2 days+ working from home. IME commuting is exhausting.

erinaceus · 16/03/2024 06:55

A full-time working pattern with three hours per day of commuting would not be possible for me, although some people do it.

I would sort yourself out I think: rent a place in City B big enough for yourself (not necessarily big enough for both of you full time but definitely able to allow him to stay over) and agree to split weekends - half each in City B and City A.

This means you cannot contribute financially to his place in City A for the time being but I think this is alright for now. Perhaps agree to review the situation in one year’s time.

I think if you live with him in City B and commute you’ll end up resenting him; I would find Mon-Fri lodging too stressful personally although others might be able to do it.

moonfacer · 16/03/2024 06:53

dammit88 · 16/03/2024 06:50

A third move for him in a year is a lot .... I can understand why he is reluctant to move again when he has his own place to be honest unless its going to be a permanent move.

He hasn’t moved though. He’s had the same place throughout.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/03/2024 06:53

CuriousGeorge80 · 15/03/2024 22:04

Any reason why he can’t rent his out and then also rent with you, as a starting point?

Do you not have to have a special mortgage for this? Also the costs to be a landlord are huge!

moonfacer · 16/03/2024 06:51

He needs to move to city B as you both work there. Do not move to city A. The excuse about how long it takes to rent out a place is a poor one.

He is asking you to do all the compromise and commuting which doesn’t bode well.

dammit88 · 16/03/2024 06:50

A third move for him in a year is a lot .... I can understand why he is reluctant to move again when he has his own place to be honest unless its going to be a permanent move.

benjoin · 16/03/2024 06:43

Stressedhahaajsk · 15/03/2024 22:14

We have been together just over a year and both 30

That's hardly any time. Just go to the city you want. Yolo

Autienotnaughtie · 16/03/2024 06:41

If you both work in city B it makes sense to live there. Can't he rent his place and you rent together. I would not do a commute like that.

Alainlechat · 15/03/2024 22:33

3hr commute is something I did from 2001 till the pandemic barring mat leave. I still do it 2-3 days a week. It's not uncommon around London.

Of course it's up to you but you could give it a go depending on how many days you have to do in the office.

telestrations · 15/03/2024 22:26

I'm guessing the more expensive city has more work and he has lucked out making living in a less expensive one work, which doesn't apply to you, but which he's expecting you to make work for him

Honestly one year in I'd go and let him follow you or not

Stressedhahaajsk · 15/03/2024 22:21

we actually both work in city B but he is able to come in a lot less. My job also requires a bit more time at the office than his.

so it just wasn’t an option for me to work significantly closer

OP posts: