Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lending a car- who is right?

61 replies

Applescruffle · 15/03/2024 21:52

Who is right in this scenario?

A has an automatic only driving licence and an automatic car. She is a single mother with an autistic son. A decides to emigrate to Australia. On leaving she sells the car to a friend of her mum's.
Two years and 4 months later, the mum's friend puts the car up for sale as he is getting on a bit and can no longer handle it. He's disabled, and getting a bit forgetful and confused. A's sister (B) decides to buy the car as she's been offered a good price for it and it's a good family car. B is married with two young kids. B has just passed her test and has a full license. Her husband also drives but only has a van with three seats.

A comes back from Australia 5 months after the sale to visit her family and will be here for a month. A is very upset to learn the family friend no longer has the car and it now belongs to B. Apparently A had an agreement that when she came back to visit, she could borrow the car and she was relying on it. She now has no car to use while she is there and can't afford to hire one, and it's harder to find automatic cars and more expensive. She demands that B lend her the car for the duration of her stay. B says no. It's her car and she needs it and relies on it for school runs and work. She was not aware of nor did she enter into any agreement with A.
A cannot believe she is being left stranded and that her family would do this to her.

Who is right - morally.

YABU - A

YANBU - B

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Beautiful3 · 17/03/2024 15:00

This has been sold on twice now. She cannot expect to use it when ever she's back! If she wanted it then she should have stored it away, or hired one. What if the person who bought it died, it would have been sold off by family and long gone by now. A is being massively unreasonable.

HomeTheatreSystem · 17/03/2024 12:53

Alice's position on this does, on face value, seem a bit batshit. Once you sell your car, that's it.

However, if she sold the car to her mum's friend for a significantly below market value price, on condition she could use it when she was in the UK, then I can see her POV. She traded the value of the car she didn't receive for a future benefit. Mum's friend benefits by getting a better car than he would otherwise for the money.

If her sister likewise benefitted from a below market value price when she bought the car off their mum's old friend, then to Alice's mind, her sister is benefitting from the original premise of the deal but Alice isn't

It's odd that Alice's mum knew about the deal for Alice to have access to the car on her return but seems to have said nothing to daughter B about it nor to her friend, when he said he was going to sell it. It seems unlikely B didn't also know about the deal even though logistically she can't honour it. Why didn't Alice's mum tell Alice, before she returned to the UK, that her old car had been sold to her sister who wasn't in a position to let her use it and that she needed to budget for a rental car. Alice was silly to think the original plan would work: as PPs have said, the car might have been written off in the interim / developed some terminal mechanical failure and she was relying on someone else to help her avoid £x in car rental costs. Far better to have sold the car for its full market rate and left the money to one side to mitigate car rental costs as and when she returns. Bird in the hand and all that.

If the car was sold at market price to the mum's friend, Alice had no grounds to try and retain access to it which might explain why mum's friend forgot about it (filed it away under "instantly forgettable batshit idea, never going to happen") and why mum remembered ("Alice trying to have her cake and eat it, AGAIN").

DodgeDoggie · 17/03/2024 00:32

its Barbaras car and she can do what she likes with it. Alice will need to find her own solution to being carless. Maybe she could text round friends and family to see what f they know of a car she can borrow?

Neither the old chap or yourself knew about the agreement so how can you adhere to it?

WallaceinAnderland · 17/03/2024 00:19

If he had sold the car to completely unrelated C, A would not be expecting to borrow it. A is a CF.

viques · 17/03/2024 00:19

Suppose the car had been in an accident and written off. What would A have done then? Whatever A would have done in that situation is exactly what A needs to do now.

BioHive · 17/03/2024 00:12

@Applescruffle a contract should of been drawn up to include this then there is a paper trail to prove who is correct

steppemum · 16/03/2024 22:55

A is being ridiculous.
I accidentally voted for A and now can't change it!

But I can understand her point, if she did have this arrangement and has lost it.
But it is not Bs problem, the arrangement wasn't with her.

SD1978 · 16/03/2024 22:46

A and b is confusing as hell, and unnecessary. She can't be that close with her sister if she doesn't know that the car was sold to her. And no, it's up to her to secure transport whilst she's on holiday if she wants it

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/03/2024 22:16

UpsideLeft · 15/03/2024 22:05

A is deluded and slightly unhinged

A is completely deluded and hugely unhinged!

jelly79 · 16/03/2024 22:12

Ridiculous arrangement and arrogant of A to think it would be in place with original owner let alone anyone it was sold to

A needs to behave

HunterHearstHelmsley · 16/03/2024 22:04

HomeTheatreSystem · 16/03/2024 13:49

This point is very relevant.

How is it relevant? The car was sold to someone. Someone else has now bought the car. That person doesn't need to honour an agreement by two other individuals.

I suppose, if there is a written agreement, the original car owner could pursue their purchaser for costs but it's absolutely nothing to do with the subsequent purchaser.

Emptyheadlock · 16/03/2024 16:35

A is a fucking idiot.

mirror245 · 16/03/2024 16:30

B is right. Doesn't matter if the agreement in place with the old man. Did they also discuss that the old man could never sell the car?

WeAreWarriorsWeAreWarriors · 16/03/2024 15:10

B is right. A wouldn't expect to use car if it was sold to C. Did she sell it on the condition that old man never sold it on? Either way, not B's problem. Also not B's fault A only has a license for automatics. That's A's problem.

Can the mum lend her car to B so the automatic car can be used by A? It would still be a kindness by B rather than what she should be doing.

iamjustwinginglife · 16/03/2024 15:08

The car belongs to B but maybe she'd have helped out if A had asked properly!

Stressybetty · 16/03/2024 15:08

Sorry but if A can afford the flights back from Australia to visit family they can afford to rent a car FFS. Surely she wouldn't be insured on the car still and it's been years, cheeky cow.

Iloveacurry · 16/03/2024 15:05

It’s now B’s car. Whatever arrangement A had with elderly friend is now irrelevant.

iwafs · 16/03/2024 15:04

B is in the right. B bought a car in good faith and needs and uses it.

A had an agreement with someone who is forgetful and confused. That person has let A down, probably due to being forgetful and confused.

The only thing I'm wondering is whether B took advantage of someone forgetful and confused, by getting this "good price".

TempleOfBloom · 16/03/2024 15:03

Applescruffle · 15/03/2024 23:17

The mum of both sisters has confirmed that there was an arrangement.

Old boy himself does not remember.

Well what a shame the Mum did not raise this with B when B was buying it.

Guavafish1 · 16/03/2024 15:01

This whole scenario can't be true. Its ridiculous

TempleOfBloom · 16/03/2024 14:57

There is no way the original buyer could have realistically committed to still
owning the car to lend out 2.5 years later, nor could they be expected to keep up the expense of a car once they could no longer drive.

If the original buyer had sold it on with the caveat that there was a longstanding loan agreement B would probably have refused to buy it. Who would buy a car with the agreement that you hand it over for unspecified lengths of time at potentially the moment you need it most?

Not B’s problem, A is holding an unreasonable expectation.

NoTouch · 16/03/2024 14:11

Applescruffle · 15/03/2024 22:26

I'm genuinely not.

But "subterfuge" is an amazing word. Thank you very much for this

If you are A - you are being utterly ridiculous.

If you are C,D,E,F,G,H,I,J or K - MYOB

Mix56 · 16/03/2024 14:09

Calamitousness · 16/03/2024 14:02

A is being an arse. But she’s family. I would probably try and help her and let her drive it whenever I don’t need it.

I agree

Calamitousness · 16/03/2024 14:02

A is being an arse. But she’s family. I would probably try and help her and let her drive it whenever I don’t need it.

HomeTheatreSystem · 16/03/2024 13:49

MargaretThursday · 16/03/2024 13:23

Did she sell it cheap on that basis though?

Because I can imagine the situation where someone puts it on the market for say £5k, a friend asks if they'd take £2.5k and they say if they can borrow it when they come back once a year, or similar. Both gain from that arrangement. One gets only half the money, but then saves on hiring a car when coming back and it's easier for them, and the other gets a car for half price.

This point is very relevant.