Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?

871 replies

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 15:56

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

‘Just now Labour MPs prevented debate on a new law to protect children and single sex spaces.

Instead they used parliamentary time to discuss ferret name choices.

@Keir_Starmer is terrified of debate on safeguarding & his MPs actively work to ignore the concerns of constituents’

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
WaterWeasel · 15/03/2024 18:06

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:35

Can I just check, this private member's bill, was introduced by the same Truss who is happy to sit through and support people who call Tommy Robinson a hero?

https://www.thenational.scot/news/24141610.liz-truss-silent-tommy-robinson-called-hero-steve-bannon-podcast/

What has this to do with anything?

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 18:05

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 18:01

OK I'm back, having skim read the debate

https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2024-03-15/debates/CD456FEB-9942-469A-9841-6A9224220284/AnimalWelfare(ImportOfDogsCatsAndFerrets)Bill

Bill debated for 4 hours, 9.30 to 1.30. There were 2 sections with lots of detail about ferrets, 1 quite close to the start (10.20 ish) and one right at the end. Both lasted 10 mins. One was Labour, one was Conservative.

Therefore my conclusion is the debate about ferrets is nothing to do with why Truss' bill wasn't reached.

It's always worth fact checking Badenoch because she has a particular relationship with accuracy

https://www.politico.eu/article/kemi-badenoch-vs-the-world-everyone-the-tory-rising-star-has-beefed-with/

I'm confused, I thought that Brexit meant that we had taken back control of our borders, and now I learn that ferrets with all manner of names are smuggling themselves into the country. Do they come on boats? Should they also be shipped to Rwanda?

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 18:04

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:59

Where should one have a debate about why rape has been decriminalised?

Our only chance is at the ballot box. Get the Tories out.

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 18:03

This isn’t correct you need to look up the GRA 2004

And you need to look up the GRA 2017.

ilovesooty · 15/03/2024 18:02

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 17:57

Badenoch's tweet is infuriating and misleading. She is a liar, like all the rest of the Tories.

The sainted Kemi??? 🙄

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 18:02

If the Tories want to change the law, they can. They didn't have to put it through as a PMB... they chose to do it like that, knowing that it would fail

Exactly! PMBs are normally basically used for member's niche interests, which is why they rarely pass.

Badenoch is giving the impression to the less well informed that this was a government bill which Labour has somehow prevented being heard.

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 18:01

OK I'm back, having skim read the debate

https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/2024-03-15/debates/CD456FEB-9942-469A-9841-6A9224220284/AnimalWelfare(ImportOfDogsCatsAndFerrets)Bill

Bill debated for 4 hours, 9.30 to 1.30. There were 2 sections with lots of detail about ferrets, 1 quite close to the start (10.20 ish) and one right at the end. Both lasted 10 mins. One was Labour, one was Conservative.

Therefore my conclusion is the debate about ferrets is nothing to do with why Truss' bill wasn't reached.

It's always worth fact checking Badenoch because she has a particular relationship with accuracy

https://www.politico.eu/article/kemi-badenoch-vs-the-world-everyone-the-tory-rising-star-has-beefed-with/

Kemi Badenoch vs the world: Everyone the Tory rising star has beefed with

… so far. POLITICO lists all the people Britain’s business sec has squared up against.

https://www.politico.eu/article/kemi-badenoch-vs-the-world-everyone-the-tory-rising-star-has-beefed-with

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:59

Riapia · 15/03/2024 17:52

You posted this on AIBU, that was your big mistake.
This is not a place for sensible discussion.

Where should one have a debate about why rape has been decriminalised?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 15/03/2024 17:59

OP, in case you hadn't noticed, the Tories are in government. They have been in government for the last 14 years. They have a majority in Parliament. If they want to change the law on single sex spaces, the Labour Party cannot stop them.

I share your frustration with the Labour Party on this issue, but for as long as they're in opposition, it doesn't matter. If the Tories want to change the law, they can. They didn't have to put it through as a PMB... they chose to do it like that, knowing that it would fail.

It seems to me that they're more interested in political point scoring rather than actually changing the law. And it's working... you have completely fallen for it.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 17:58

ginasevern · 15/03/2024 17:56

The Tories started the whole thing in the first place! Teresa May's Government proposed a bill to allow people to self identify as their chosen gender without any medical evidence or examination. The whole procedure was also made easier by putting it online, so anyone could effectively apply and for a nominal fee instead of the previous £140.

The whole thing was championed by the then Women and Equalities Minister, Liz Truss, who thought it was splendid. Below I have quoted what she said at the time:

In an attempt to combat lengthy NHS waiting lists for transgender people, Truss said the government was opening three new gender clinics this year. Truss said she was “deeply concerned at the distress” the long waiting lists could cause and the move should result in them being cut by about 1,600 patients by 2022.

Where were you OP when all this was happening? It's also worth noting that all the bad stuff has happened exclusively under the Tories' watch. You know, the 14 long painful years they've been in power. Where have you been all this time?

The Tories started the whole thing in the first place!

This isn’t correct you need to look up the GRA 2004

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 17:57

Badenoch's tweet is infuriating and misleading. She is a liar, like all the rest of the Tories.

ginasevern · 15/03/2024 17:56

The Tories started the whole thing in the first place! Teresa May's Government proposed a bill to allow people to self identify as their chosen gender without any medical evidence or examination. The whole procedure was also made easier by putting it online, so anyone could effectively apply and for a nominal fee instead of the previous £140.

The whole thing was championed by the then Women and Equalities Minister, Liz Truss, who thought it was splendid. Below I have quoted what she said at the time:

In an attempt to combat lengthy NHS waiting lists for transgender people, Truss said the government was opening three new gender clinics this year. Truss said she was “deeply concerned at the distress” the long waiting lists could cause and the move should result in them being cut by about 1,600 patients by 2022.

Where were you OP when all this was happening? It's also worth noting that all the bad stuff has happened exclusively under the Tories' watch. You know, the 14 long painful years they've been in power. Where have you been all this time?

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 17:56

AutumnCrow · 15/03/2024 17:50

She's on 74% right now.

I find this is usually the case with these kinds of Labour threads voting yanbu is high but posts go in other direction

pointythings · 15/03/2024 17:55

I actually have no issue with trans healthcare for adults only. We treat adults as adults in other areas of healthcare after all.

Conversion therapy is something I'm wary of - if someone identifies as transgender, there absolutely should be in depth assessment and therapy to address any mental health issues that are present, and if these are not addressed there should not be a recommendation to proceed. However, conversion therapy as in 'telling someone that they are not trans and that to say you are means you are mentally ill' isn't acceptable. It's not that far from conversion therapy for homosexuality. Having said that, I'm fundamentally opposed to banning things - any therapy in that direction however should only be given if the person in question actively wants it.

I want separate prison facilities for transmen and transwomen. For their safety as well as everyone else's. I want third spaces. I want safe spaces for biological women, but I do wonder about how we would test that without becoming extremely invasive - balancing that with the right to privacy could prove very difficult. I don't want men in women's sports - again separate events should be the norm.

But mostly what I want is for people to hold the people in power responsible for their failings, not a hypothetical government that we probably won't get until next year. We have a Conservative government, so why do I never see any threads about what they aren't doing to safeguard women?

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 17:53

Does anyone know why the bill wasn't debated while Truss was PM?

To be fair she was a bit busy crashing the economy and sacking highly respected senior officials.

Riapia · 15/03/2024 17:52

You posted this on AIBU, that was your big mistake.
This is not a place for sensible discussion.

ilovesooty · 15/03/2024 17:52

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 17:37

I guess words are cheap when women are picking up the tab for your luxury beliefs.

It would appear so. Currently one million children are living in destitution, rape’s basically been decriminalised because the conviction rate’s so low and women are waiting three weeks for a surgical termination. Obviously caring about those things is a luxury belief.

And the Children Not In School debate was below Liz Truss' and presumably wasn't debated either.

I doubt that the Conservatives care much about the safety of women, children or anyone who is vulnerable and costs money.

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:51

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 17:47

This is odd, this thread is here because the debate was meant to happen today

Maybe you were not aware but there was a PMB and the rest as op says

You may be ‘weary’ with women talking about their rights, you don’t have to join in if the threads are too much, there is a hide option btw but I and others want to have clarity and a debate is a way to get information

In the interests of factual accuracy I would like to point out that PMBs that are far down the list are often not debated, so to say that Truss' bill was meant to be debated today is untrue.

Does anyone know why the bill wasn't debated while Truss was PM?

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 17:51

I think a lot of posters here don't really understand what a PMB is and how the process works.

AutumnCrow · 15/03/2024 17:50

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 15/03/2024 15:59

You’re on a hiding to nothing on here, OP.

She's on 74% right now.

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:49

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 17:45

I didn't see it. How much time was spent "discussing ferret name choices" or was it a bit of bantz between colleagues? I'm going to look at Hansard.

It doesn't sound likely that that's the reason Truss' bill didn't get debated.

I amazed that Truss' bill even got close to being debated, given she was quite low down on the list of Private Members Bill's many of which don't get debated in every parliamentary session.

Perhaps those who are so exercised by it should write to their MPs suggesting changes to the parliamentary standing orders to ensure more Private Members bills get time to be debated.

IClaudine · 15/03/2024 17:49

It is ridiculous to criticise Labour for this. Private Member's Bill's very rarely pass and there is no reason why this one would be the exception.

If Badenoch really wants to do something, then why doesn't she in her capacity as minister? It is easy to posture over a PMB instead of putting your money where your moth is.

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 17:48

JessS1990 · 15/03/2024 17:31

Do you know why the current Equalities MInister wasn't in parliament to discuss this pressing issue today?

Who is the Equalities Minister?

Can you answer the questions about Labour? Rather than turning things to the tories?

I think we all see that no. No Labour can’t answer those questions.

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 17:47

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 17:44

😂🙈 Why aren’t Labour doing it? Instead of massaging the egos of men, and fcking women and children over?

You do realise you sound like a toddler having a tantrum? Why aren’t the Libdems, Greens, Reform doing it? Or even the party in power? Why is your footstamping reserved for Labour?

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 17:47

pointythings · 15/03/2024 17:43

The point here is that every time the polls look worse, one of these threads pops up. It's exhausting. It's as if a certain section of the population has forgotten who is actually in power. What Labour would do is not relevant right now, because we have a Conservative government who could do something but don't - but they get away scot free on these threads. And there's really only one rational explanation as to why that should be the case.

This is odd, this thread is here because the debate was meant to happen today

Maybe you were not aware but there was a PMB and the rest as op says

You may be ‘weary’ with women talking about their rights, you don’t have to join in if the threads are too much, there is a hide option btw but I and others want to have clarity and a debate is a way to get information