Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?

871 replies

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 15:56

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

‘Just now Labour MPs prevented debate on a new law to protect children and single sex spaces.

Instead they used parliamentary time to discuss ferret name choices.

@Keir_Starmer is terrified of debate on safeguarding & his MPs actively work to ignore the concerns of constituents’

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 21:09

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 21:08

She asked a question, it wasn't condescending. I'd be interested in your opinions too.

And me.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 21:08

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 21:03

I'm pro-sex based rights and I support Labour's position

I have no issues with "Males with a GRC" being treated as women in some circumstances (public toilets, polite conversation)

You disagree. That's why you are ultra and I am lite.

Labour and the Tories represent GC lite. Reform/SDP represent GC Ultra. Your choice who you vote for. I'm not telling you what to think.

No those are your terms.

You can apply them to you if you want. But not for me. ‘Ultra’ is a nonsense

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 21:08

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 21:07

Do you mean to be condescending with experts or literal? I’d say either way you’re missing that it’s just women who are informed and care, some do know a lot it is true, I’ve learned from reading on here.

Do you look at FWR you’ll find a fair bit there. Posters tend to be clear and reasoned

She asked a question, it wasn't condescending. I'd be interested in your opinions too.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 21:07

pointythings · 15/03/2024 21:04

@EasternStandard so what is your solution? I haven't heard any solutions from the GC people on MN, and they're the experts.

Do you mean to be condescending with experts or literal? I’d say either way you’re missing that it’s just women who are informed and care, some do know a lot it is true, I’ve learned from reading on here.

Do you look at FWR you’ll find a fair bit there. Posters tend to be clear and reasoned

pointythings · 15/03/2024 21:04

@EasternStandard so what is your solution? I haven't heard any solutions from the GC people on MN, and they're the experts.

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 21:03

I'm pro-sex based rights and I support Labour's position

I have no issues with "Males with a GRC" being treated as women in some circumstances (public toilets, polite conversation)

You disagree. That's why you are ultra and I am lite.

Labour and the Tories represent GC lite. Reform/SDP represent GC Ultra. Your choice who you vote for. I'm not telling you what to think.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:58

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:57

I'm going to ask you, as an ultra GC:

What space.. How would "they" keep men out?

It's a stupid question. If men want to access women's spaces they will. Self-ID breaks the social contract where men can be challenged, but self ID is not on the table now.

So I am unclear as to what your concern is?

"The law" can't deal with rapists. Making "a law to keep males with GRC out" means sweet fanny Adams.

You can ask me as someone who is pro sex based rights not ‘ultra’ nonsense

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:57

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:51

Because it doesn’t answer this

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

I'm going to ask you, as an ultra GC:

What space.. How would "they" keep men out?

It's a stupid question. If men want to access women's spaces they will. Self-ID breaks the social contract where men can be challenged, but self ID is not on the table now.

So I am unclear as to what your concern is?

"The law" can't deal with rapists. Making "a law to keep males with GRC out" means sweet fanny Adams.

bombastix · 15/03/2024 20:55

pointythings · 15/03/2024 20:43

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

Well, there's a question, isn't it? How indeed, without breaching a person's right to privacy? Genital inspections? On the spot DNA analysis? Both extremely problematic. I haven't yet seen any answers to that little conundrum from anyone on any side in this debate.

Bah. That's why it's a PMB. No human rights sign off required

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:55

It can’t be ‘unanswerable’ as women need to actually know what it means. Which spaces will have males in them?

That people think it is ‘unanswerable’ shows how terrible it is. It doesn’t stack up legally or practically.

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:52

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:49

I think Dodds made that statement last year and sent Duffield on the rounds the next day rather than show up

The fact that no one can answer that question on here or from Labour shows the incredible stalling tactic used

Oh as if Rosie Duffield got "sent out". Rosie Duffield is a woman of conviction. She wouldn't have given statements if she didn't believe them.

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 20:52

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:49

I think Dodds made that statement last year and sent Duffield on the rounds the next day rather than show up

The fact that no one can answer that question on here or from Labour shows the incredible stalling tactic used

No it doesn’t. It’s an unanswerable question. I’d have thought you’d be delighted Duffield did the media calls, she’s a bit of a GC heroine, isn’t she?

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:51

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:50

How is protecting single sex spaces for biological women only, and woman=adult female a "poor statement"?? Confused

Because it doesn’t answer this

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:50

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:44

A PMB debate, Dodds after her statement, Starmer anywhere

Take your pick I don’t care where it is I’d like Labour to stop relying on poor statements and answering direct questions such as the one below -

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

How is protecting single sex spaces for biological women only, and woman=adult female a "poor statement"?? Confused

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:49

I think Dodds made that statement last year and sent Duffield on the rounds the next day rather than show up

The fact that no one can answer that question on here or from Labour shows the incredible stalling tactic used

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 20:48

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:44

A PMB debate, Dodds after her statement, Starmer anywhere

Take your pick I don’t care where it is I’d like Labour to stop relying on poor statements and answering direct questions such as the one below -

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

I’d have quite liked Badenoch to turn up today. I’d also like her to answer your question because I can’t see how such a thing could be possible.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:44

A PMB debate, Dodds after her statement, Starmer anywhere

Take your pick I don’t care where it is I’d like Labour to stop relying on poor statements and answering direct questions such as the one below -

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

pointythings · 15/03/2024 20:43

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

Well, there's a question, isn't it? How indeed, without breaching a person's right to privacy? Genital inspections? On the spot DNA analysis? Both extremely problematic. I haven't yet seen any answers to that little conundrum from anyone on any side in this debate.

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:41

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:38

Turning up and answering questions would be a start. Rather than top level avoidance.

One good one for example on single sex spaces

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

Eh? Turning up to what??

You have lost me.

Meanwhile the Tories have a majority and can't get a bill on the order. The minister for women and Equalities takes 12 hours to make a mealy mouthed statement about forgiving racism and can't even he arsed to turn up to a debate on a subject close to her heart.

GC Ultra women are basically screwed. Not voting, reform or SDP are the options.

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:38

pointythings · 15/03/2024 20:29

@AdamRyan nails it. The posters constantly going on about Labour being 100% in the grip of the trans movement will never believe anything they say - and that is only going to make the rest of us think they have other reasons for posting endless swathes of these threads. My question, given what has been posted above, is: Would anything convince you?

Turning up and answering questions would be a start. Rather than top level avoidance.

One good one for example on single sex spaces

What space.. How legally would they keep men with a GRC out?

bombastix · 15/03/2024 20:37

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 19:49

This is interesting.

The Telegraph understands that Ms Badenoch, the equalities minister, had wanted to back large sections of the Bill but was prevented from doing so by Cabinet colleagues.

Gillian Keegan, the Education Secretary, and Victoria Atkins, the Health Secretary, had raised concerns with the legislation.

Government sources denied claims that some Tory MPs had been urged to keep talking on the earlier private members’ Bill, which was about the import of dogs, cats and ferrets.

Her old mentor is Gove. Why doesn't Badenoch just directly write this for the Telegraph? I mean really. Isn't this a dynamic future leader?

pointythings · 15/03/2024 20:29

@AdamRyan nails it. The posters constantly going on about Labour being 100% in the grip of the trans movement will never believe anything they say - and that is only going to make the rest of us think they have other reasons for posting endless swathes of these threads. My question, given what has been posted above, is: Would anything convince you?

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:29

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:21

You've been on these threads long enough to know exactly what they think.

We will make sure that nothing in our modernised gender recognition process would override the single-sex exemptions in the Equality Act. Put simply, this means that there will always be places where it is reasonable for biological women only to have access. Labour will defend those spaces, providing legal clarity for the providers of single-sex services.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/24/labour-will-lead-on-reform-of-transgender-rights-and-we-wont-take-lectures-from-the-divisive-tories

A self-identification system to allow transgender people to legally identify as their chosen gender without a medical diagnosis is not the “right way forward”, Sir Keir Starmer has said.

The Labour leader....also said that in his view “a woman is an adult female, so let’s clear that one up”.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/keir-starmer-labour-woman-anneliese-dodds-b2382675.html

What more clarity do you want?

You don't believe them, so nothing they say will ever be good enough.

Of course not.

I know you are loyal and satisfied with their stance I and others are not.

I want direct questions not hiding behind waffle. You can bow out if you have enough, I don’t.

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:21

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:12

I assume there are Labour supporters who think they have ‘u turned’ on gender in which case why not encourage clarity?

Others may feel they are pro gender still and actively back Labour’s gender stance and not want it to become clear for whatever reason

Either way it’s better for women to hear what Labour think re gender

You've been on these threads long enough to know exactly what they think.

We will make sure that nothing in our modernised gender recognition process would override the single-sex exemptions in the Equality Act. Put simply, this means that there will always be places where it is reasonable for biological women only to have access. Labour will defend those spaces, providing legal clarity for the providers of single-sex services.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/24/labour-will-lead-on-reform-of-transgender-rights-and-we-wont-take-lectures-from-the-divisive-tories

A self-identification system to allow transgender people to legally identify as their chosen gender without a medical diagnosis is not the “right way forward”, Sir Keir Starmer has said.

The Labour leader....also said that in his view “a woman is an adult female, so let’s clear that one up”.

https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/keir-starmer-labour-woman-anneliese-dodds-b2382675.html

What more clarity do you want?

You don't believe them, so nothing they say will ever be good enough.

Labour will lead on reform of transgender rights – and we won’t take lectures from the Tories | Anneliese Dodds

We will modernise, simplify and reform gender recognition law. Our policies won’t please everyone but we will do what’s right

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2023/jul/24/labour-will-lead-on-reform-of-transgender-rights-and-we-wont-take-lectures-from-the-divisive-tories

EasternStandard · 15/03/2024 20:12

I assume there are Labour supporters who think they have ‘u turned’ on gender in which case why not encourage clarity?

Others may feel they are pro gender still and actively back Labour’s gender stance and not want it to become clear for whatever reason

Either way it’s better for women to hear what Labour think re gender