Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?

871 replies

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 15:56

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

‘Just now Labour MPs prevented debate on a new law to protect children and single sex spaces.

Instead they used parliamentary time to discuss ferret name choices.

@Keir_Starmer is terrified of debate on safeguarding & his MPs actively work to ignore the concerns of constituents’

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:52

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:50

Two posters have explained why they think that this is the case.

It doesn’t support your assertion that Labour’s bad for women though. I’m very surprised you continue to show such admiration for her, surely she must be a traitor to your cause?

Redrosetat · 16/03/2024 10:51

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:48

You’ll vote for Labour whatever.

Just like Duffield then. She’s really inconvenient, isn’t she? A woman deified by the gender critical who continues as a Labour MP.

Rosie Duffield is not ‘inconvenient’ at all. She’s a warrior. I admire her, sticking around in the current cess pit, must be bloody awful.

As I said above in response to your questions:

Why would you base a voting decision on Labour’s treatment of Duffield when she continues to be a Labour MP?

I wouldn’t, the treatment of Rosie Duffield is a symptom of the misogynism of the Labour Party.

Why would you be more upset about it than she is? She clearly believes Labour is a better party for women than any of the others, why not believe her?

I can’t speak on behalf of RD but perhaps she thinks it is better to try and fight the issue from within, rather than leave the Labour Party to their woman hating selves.

OP posts:
WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:50

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:48

You’ll vote for Labour whatever.

Just like Duffield then. She’s really inconvenient, isn’t she? A woman deified by the gender critical who continues as a Labour MP.

Two posters have explained why they think that this is the case.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:49

If people are committed to Labour no matter what go for it

Don’t tune in when they provide clarity

For women who want to get that then let’s hear it.

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:48

You’ll vote for Labour whatever.

Just like Duffield then. She’s really inconvenient, isn’t she? A woman deified by the gender critical who continues as a Labour MP.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:45

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:44

We do know. And we like what we’re being promised, almost as much as we detest what the current government is giving us. I really wish you’d all stop talking about “women” as if we were some amorphous mass with a hive mind. None of you speak for me and I’m not less of a woman because I disagree with you.

Edited

You do. You’ll vote for Labour whatever.

Others don’t hence these threads

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:44

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:40

Yes and it MUST be dragged out in to the sunlight somehow so that women understand exactly what they are getting when they vote Labour.

We do know. And we like what we’re being promised, almost as much as we detest what the current government is giving us. I really wish you’d all stop talking about “women” as if we were some amorphous mass with a hive mind. None of you speak for me and I’m not less of a woman because I disagree with you.

bombastix · 16/03/2024 10:43

@WaterWeasel - yes I am not convinced by the 200 plus Labour majority predictions. I don't agree with that. But the Conservatives are high risk all the time now. The more they play this culture war ticket while people feel poor the angrier and more disconnected the voter gets. The polls reflect this. My guess is 140 plus for Labour. And I don't know about Reform. Another thread though

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:42

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:40

Yes and it MUST be dragged out in to the sunlight somehow so that women understand exactly what they are getting when they vote Labour.

Yep.

If people still vote knowing then at least it’s informed and they can take ownership of the outcome wrt women and children

Clarity and information from Starmer and co. Let’s hear it, then we can decide.

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:40

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:39

Labour’s best bet is avoiding this issue as they are not able to speak plainly

It’s obviously what they are their supporters are committed to

It doesn’t mean women will be happy with TRA lobbyists influencing post GE

Starmer and co are aware of who they ignoring and why.

Yes and it MUST be dragged out in to the sunlight somehow so that women understand exactly what they are getting when they vote Labour.

Redrosetat · 16/03/2024 10:40

Why would you base a voting decision on Labour’s treatment of Duffield when she continues to be a Labour MP?

I wouldn’t, the treatment of Rosie Duffield is a symptom of the misogynism of the Labour Party.

Why would you be more upset about it than she is? She clearly believes Labour is a better party for women than any of the others, why not believe her?

I can’t speak on behalf of RD but perhaps she thinks it is better to try and fight the issue from within, rather than leave the Labour Party to their woman hating selves.

OP posts:
WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:39

bombastix · 16/03/2024 10:36

@WaterWeasel - you and I are not going to agree but I have put my own money on it.

The Conservatives can play games on this point if they like here, but outside in the country it is very different.

I believe that I'm going to make my money back and then some on election day. I did not even plan for some of figures that are being touted now for the Conservatives which are close to 100 seats.

Left wing parties are often accused of being captured by special interests and small groups. But it seems that really, it is the Conservatives who are dementing themselves on this to no end, and not getting electoral benefit. You see the same posters here, former Labour activists enraged by their leadership but that is not enough to influence or engage a majority of Mumsnet or a wider women's vote.

My money is safe. The Conservatives are going to lose because of the economy and public services.

I don't doubt the Tories will lose - they fully deserve to. But Labour will not get the thumping majority they are assuming that they will imo.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:39

Labour’s best bet is avoiding this issue as they are not able to speak plainly

It’s obviously what they are their supporters are committed to

It doesn’t mean women will be happy with TRA lobbyists influencing post GE

Starmer and co are aware of who they ignoring and why.

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:37

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:32

I wasn’t, I should probably have added “anyone?” to my post. But I’d be delighted if you felt moved to share your view.

I have given you my opinion above - was editing as you posted I think.

bombastix · 16/03/2024 10:36

@WaterWeasel - you and I are not going to agree but I have put my own money on it.

The Conservatives can play games on this point if they like here, but outside in the country it is very different.

I believe that I'm going to make my money back and then some on election day. I did not even plan for some of figures that are being touted now for the Conservatives which are close to 100 seats.

Left wing parties are often accused of being captured by special interests and small groups. But it seems that really, it is the Conservatives who are dementing themselves on this to no end, and not getting electoral benefit. You see the same posters here, former Labour activists enraged by their leadership but that is not enough to influence or engage a majority of Mumsnet or a wider women's vote.

My money is safe. The Conservatives are going to lose because of the economy and public services.

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:35

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 08:54

Why would you base a voting decision on Labour’s treatment of Duffield when she continues to be a Labour MP? Why would you be more upset about it than she is? She clearly believes Labour is a better party for women than any of the others, why not believe her?

Here you go @Redrosetat.

Redrosetat · 16/03/2024 10:34

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:32

I wasn’t, I should probably have added “anyone?” to my post. But I’d be delighted if you felt moved to share your view.

Sorry so many posts. What is the question about RD?

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:32

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:30

I was not aware that you were asking me specifically about Rosie Duffield?
I know that she has been very open about considering leaving the party after the harassment from Labour males. I suppose it's progress of sorts that Streeting apologised to her recently.

If I was her I would have left but I am clearly not as strong or as bloody minded as she is. I imagine she stays because she wants to represent women who care about safeguarding of women and girls and to try to hold the party to account on these issues in the face of unimaginable daily threats. She is amazing imo and I wish that more MPs had her backbone and conviction.

Edited

I wasn’t, I should probably have added “anyone?” to my post. But I’d be delighted if you felt moved to share your view.

literalviolence · 16/03/2024 10:31

AdamRyan · 15/03/2024 20:57

I'm going to ask you, as an ultra GC:

What space.. How would "they" keep men out?

It's a stupid question. If men want to access women's spaces they will. Self-ID breaks the social contract where men can be challenged, but self ID is not on the table now.

So I am unclear as to what your concern is?

"The law" can't deal with rapists. Making "a law to keep males with GRC out" means sweet fanny Adams.

That doesn't mean we should not have an expectation of no males in female spaces just as we should be able to have an expectation to not be raped. The fact that policing something is a challenge does not mean we just accept the harms which it causes.

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:30

I was not aware that you were asking me specifically about Rosie Duffield?
I know that she has been very open about considering leaving the party after the harassment from Labour males. I suppose it's progress of sorts that Streeting apologised to her recently.

If I was her I would have left but I am clearly not as strong or as bloody minded as she is. I imagine she stays because she wants to represent women who care about safeguarding of women and girls and to try to hold the party to account on these issues in the face of unimaginable daily threats. She is amazing imo and I wish that more MPs had her backbone and conviction.

Redrosetat · 16/03/2024 10:29

An older article but the ‘high levels of misunderstanding’ are still there. This helps Labour kill their responsibility towards biological women (and so theirs and children’s safe spaces) enormously and they know it.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?
OP posts:
EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 10:29

The claims that no one cares don’t stack up

If Labour politicians thought that was the case they wouldn’t shift from promoting self ID

Of course they are still gender driven but use poor statements now. These prompt ‘unanswerable’ questions, because they too don’t stack up legally or practically

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:25

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:25

I suspect that the GE is not going to go the way that many think that it is.

😂

Still no response to my question about Duffield?

WaterWeasel · 16/03/2024 10:25

bombastix · 16/03/2024 10:15

I am not from the Labour Party. But it is important to reflect that women overall vote Labour more commonly than men; that their intent to vote Labour is increasing, not decreasing.

In other words there are quite a lot of women who are content or neutral on this issue sufficient that they will support them.

This is important context when there is any claim about whether Labour's stance on transgenderism makes a difference to their vote. The evidence is not there that it does. It has affected many former female activists in Labour who have disagreed with their leadership but these two things are different in terms of impact for actually winning an election. And in that sense, a lot of this thread appears to miss that is the point of politics, as any good Tory will tell you.

I suspect that the GE is not going to go the way that many think that it is.

literalviolence · 16/03/2024 10:24

AdamRyan · 16/03/2024 08:45

There are plenty of other "culture wars" issues the Tories are also inflating. Islamists running London springs to mind (or wider anti Islam bollocks)
Immigrants overrunning the NHS
Lazy people claiming benefits
Threats to our "culture" from a falling birth rate/lack of integration
A new one appears to be the need to protect our Christian values

The "trans" culture war is also not about women. Its a vehicle to allow the Tories to recycle tired old tropes about gay people being a threat, schools corrupting our children by sex education and socialists infiltrating the civil service.

I've seen nothing claiming gay people are a threat. Can you share some of those incidents? Regardless though, the concerns of women here are safeguarding concerns and when you let males into women's spaces obviously the women are at risk. Its also anti equality.