Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?

871 replies

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 15:56

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

‘Just now Labour MPs prevented debate on a new law to protect children and single sex spaces.

Instead they used parliamentary time to discuss ferret name choices.

@Keir_Starmer is terrified of debate on safeguarding & his MPs actively work to ignore the concerns of constituents’

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 16:20

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:20

I didn’t say it was a privileged belief, I said it was a movement dominated by privileged white women.

Out of interests which women are you referring to here?

What are their 'anti-trans' views?

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:20

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 16:17

It's not though, you posted on here in response to a trans activist that women who are 'anti trans' hold privileged beliefs.

I am asking you what you consider to be anti -trans?

i am asking you if you can see the conflict between the demands of that poster and the safeguarding of women and children?

I am still not clear what point you were trying to make.

Which beliefs that women who are 'anti - trans' hold do you believe are privileged?

Edited

I didn’t say it was a privileged belief, I said it was a movement dominated by privileged white women.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 16:17

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:15

That’s irrelevant to my point.

It's not though, you posted on here in response to a trans activist that women who are 'anti trans' hold privileged beliefs.

I am asking you what you consider to be anti -trans?

i am asking you if you can see the conflict between the demands of that poster and the safeguarding of women and children?

I am still not clear what point you were trying to make.

Which beliefs that women who are 'anti - trans' hold do you believe are privileged?

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:15

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 16:12

So can you see the conflict between what the trans activists want (the removal of single sex spaces and sports) and what is needed for the safeguarding and the dignity of women from all males?

Can you see the conflict with regards to the safeguarding of vulnerable children who are questioning their gender?

Can you see that women who are saying no to all males (including the ones who identify as trans women) being in single sex spaces is necessary to safeguard women in vulnerable situations , such as women's shelters and prisons from males who might harm them, are not saying this because we hold bigoted beliefs, but because trans women are male and offend at the same rate as any other males?

This is not because of being anti - trans, it is because we want to put women and vulnerable children first.

That’s irrelevant to my point.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 16:12

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:01

My comment was directed as part of the conversation describing the anti trans movement - it’s predominantly occupied by WW.

GC and anti trans are two different things, although I’ve yet to met someone who was anti trans and not also GC.

So can you see the conflict between what the trans activists want (the removal of single sex spaces and sports) and what is needed for the safeguarding and the dignity of women from all males?

Can you see the conflict with regards to the safeguarding of vulnerable children who are questioning their gender?

Can you see that women who are saying no to all males (including the ones who identify as trans women) being in single sex spaces is necessary to safeguard women in vulnerable situations , such as women's shelters and prisons from males who might harm them, are not saying this because we hold bigoted beliefs, but because trans women are male and offend at the same rate as any other males?

This is not because of being anti - trans, it is because we want to put women and vulnerable children first.

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 16:01

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:57

Apologies if I have, but I've read back and can't see what I have misconstrued.

What are you saying is 'a movement by predominantly privileged women', if it is not women who are objecting to the removal of the safeguarding of women and children?

My comment was directed as part of the conversation describing the anti trans movement - it’s predominantly occupied by WW.

GC and anti trans are two different things, although I’ve yet to met someone who was anti trans and not also GC.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:58

pointythings · 16/03/2024 15:43

@izimbra you make a good point about gender checkers. I mean, how is this going to work? The moment someone walks in looking a bit androgynous, you've got trouble. I mean, I've been mistaken for a man when dressed a certain way and I'm XX all the way. I can see privacy lawsuits and other disasters looming.

That women need to say ok to males in their sports and allow males access wherever just because some women have short hair and wear jeans or whatever is the androgynous element has to be the most bizarre reason yet.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:57

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 15:54

You have misconstrued what I said.

Apologies if I have, but I've read back and can't see what I have misconstrued.

What are you saying is 'a movement by predominantly privileged women', if it is not women who are objecting to the removal of the safeguarding of women and children?

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 15:54

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:52

Oh dear I think you're confused.

It is mostly vulnerable women who are harmed by the removal of single sex spaces.

It is gender ideology that is the privileged belief which is why it is an phenomenon found mostly in the Western/ Developed world.

Notice how women/ girls in the developing world can't use gender to opt into the benefits of being male such as education. I wonder why that might be? But then even here the rules of primogeniture can't be circumvented by a woman identifying as a trans man.

One might consider this to be men's rights activism, if you really think about it.

Women don't get stand to gain, we lose words and rights in favour of males. There is literally nothing in it for women. Not one thing. Yet we shouldn't even talk about it.

You have misconstrued what I said.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:52

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 15:43

Only much more annoying. A movement by predominantly privileged white women.

Oh dear I think you're confused.

It is mostly vulnerable women who are harmed by the removal of single sex spaces.

It is gender ideology that is the privileged belief which is why it is an phenomenon found mostly in the Western/ Developed world.

Notice how women/ girls in the developing world can't use gender to opt into the benefits of being male such as education. I wonder why that might be? But then even here the rules of primogeniture can't be circumvented by a woman identifying as a trans man.

One might consider this to be men's rights activism, if you really think about it.

Women don't get stand to gain, we lose words and rights in favour of males. There is literally nothing in it for women. Not one thing. Yet we shouldn't even talk about it.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:51

@lifeturnsonadime just answered it. It’s not hard.

It’s a nonsense distraction to talk about females who are androgynous

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 15:48

pointythings · 16/03/2024 15:43

@izimbra you make a good point about gender checkers. I mean, how is this going to work? The moment someone walks in looking a bit androgynous, you've got trouble. I mean, I've been mistaken for a man when dressed a certain way and I'm XX all the way. I can see privacy lawsuits and other disasters looming.

That’s the $64k question and nobody has an answer to it.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:45

pointythings · 16/03/2024 15:43

@izimbra you make a good point about gender checkers. I mean, how is this going to work? The moment someone walks in looking a bit androgynous, you've got trouble. I mean, I've been mistaken for a man when dressed a certain way and I'm XX all the way. I can see privacy lawsuits and other disasters looming.

Or males could just stay out.

Women are saying we need single sex spaces for dignity and safety.

In the light of that decent males would stay out.

Males who respect women would stay out.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:44

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 15:43

Only much more annoying. A movement by predominantly privileged white women.

Are you for self ID, males in female sports and puberty blockers for dc?

pointythings · 16/03/2024 15:43

@izimbra you make a good point about gender checkers. I mean, how is this going to work? The moment someone walks in looking a bit androgynous, you've got trouble. I mean, I've been mistaken for a man when dressed a certain way and I'm XX all the way. I can see privacy lawsuits and other disasters looming.

IanCurtisdancing · 16/03/2024 15:43

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:34

Anti-trans activists are the feminist version of Tommy Robinson and Lawrence Fox.

Only much more annoying. A movement by predominantly privileged white women.

dannyufcfan · 16/03/2024 15:43

I'm convinced the people who start these threads here are just looking for an excuse to vote tory.

GCinHE · 16/03/2024 15:39

It was on both sides of the floor, and on both sides this was reprehensible parliamentary conduct. I am so enraged by this that I've decided to join Kellie-Jay Keen's Party Of Women (despite some of my misgivings about her approach, as I am a Socialist). You can do so here if you like:

https://www.partyofwomen.org/

Party Of Women | POW

This is the home page for Party Of Women. Join us in the fight for women's rights.

https://www.partyofwomen.org

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:38

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:34

Anti-trans activists are the feminist version of Tommy Robinson and Lawrence Fox.

Sure. Women who pro sex based rights do tend to threaten males who want access for some reason. Just for saying no.

We’re aware of how much it provokes. They spend enough time attacking women, threatening and using violence when women dare to speak up

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:35

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:32

"How do you not understand yet?

If you let in anyone that says they are a woman, you let in ANY man."

Let in where?

Are you talking about toilets/changing rooms?

You think if we don't pass laws to ban trans women from women's spaces (and presumably have these laws policed by gender checkers on the doors) we'll have predatory cis gender men capitalising on this by constantly pushing into women's spaces to assault women under the guise of 'I'm allowed to do this because I identify as a woman'?

Because predatory cisgender men pretending to be trans to predate on women has been a significant problem up to this point? Hmm

This reminds me of 'we need to stop immigration from Muslim countries because otherwise the UK will soon be overflowing with Muslims forcing sharia on us, and gang raping children all over the place.

We don't want any man in women's toilets, even the nice ones, even the ones who identify as trans women.

This is to protect the safety and dignity of women.

Women matter, we exist.

Our role is not to act as props/ validation or protection for a group of males.

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:34

Anti-trans activists are the feminist version of Tommy Robinson and Lawrence Fox.

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:32

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:23

"Roll your eyes all you want not everyone wants the gender ideology you are pushing.

From puberty blockers to males in female sports it’s a no."

Nobody is forcing you to be transgender.

Of course no one is forcing women to be trans gender.

Some of the behaviours towards children, often vulnerable autistic or gay children is questionable, some might say akin to grooming in the light of the Cass report which points out that most children grow out of feelings of being the wrong gender post puberty.

I question anyone who thinks that puberty blockers are appropriate for gender non conforming children in the light of the Cass review and the leaks Wpath files.

In whose interests is it for children to be harmed by these drugs? And they are harmed. The evidence is there. This is in spite of the fact that we KNOW that most children who experience gender distress pre-puberty grow out of it.

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:32

"How do you not understand yet?

If you let in anyone that says they are a woman, you let in ANY man."

Let in where?

Are you talking about toilets/changing rooms?

You think if we don't pass laws to ban trans women from women's spaces (and presumably have these laws policed by gender checkers on the doors) we'll have predatory cis gender men capitalising on this by constantly pushing into women's spaces to assault women under the guise of 'I'm allowed to do this because I identify as a woman'?

Because predatory cisgender men pretending to be trans to predate on women has been a significant problem up to this point? Hmm

This reminds me of 'we need to stop immigration from Muslim countries because otherwise the UK will soon be overflowing with Muslims forcing sharia on us, and gang raping children all over the place.

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:31

lifeturnsonadime · 16/03/2024 15:27

If you let in anyone that says they are a woman, you let in ANY man.
Think about the worst man you've ever met, well now he can get changed next to you and claim he's a woman and there's nothing you can do about it.
He doesn't need to do anything to himself, just think the thought that he's a woman.

This brings to mind these dreadful posters popping up in what used to be women's toilets in universities.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-bristol-47213433

What a message to give our young women. It's literally telling them that they can't have normal safeguarding because men might want to be in there and that's OK because those men might identify as trans.

Women and girls have been attacked by males claiming to be trans women in what should be single sex spaces.

If you can't see the issues with this then women's safeguarding really doesn't matter to you.

These posters are insanity

What adult thought that was a good idea to enforce this on young women?

EasternStandard · 16/03/2024 15:28

izimbra · 16/03/2024 15:23

"Roll your eyes all you want not everyone wants the gender ideology you are pushing.

From puberty blockers to males in female sports it’s a no."

Nobody is forcing you to be transgender.

I’m fairly aware of that. I still prefer single sex spaces and a stop of drugs that harm dc.

You might want males competing with women and puberty blockers for dc but not everyone does. And it’s women that males want access to as validation. You’ll need our consent.