Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?

871 replies

Redrosetat · 15/03/2024 15:56

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

‘Just now Labour MPs prevented debate on a new law to protect children and single sex spaces.

Instead they used parliamentary time to discuss ferret name choices.

@Keir_Starmer is terrified of debate on safeguarding & his MPs actively work to ignore the concerns of constituents’

https://twitter.com/KemiBadenoch/status/1768647056111861760?s=19&t=wqgtbWPG_X1xZDMhuF871A

OP posts:
Thread gallery
34
Redrosetat · 18/03/2024 11:24

IanCurtisdancing · 18/03/2024 10:25

Disgraceful what has been allowed to happen under Tory leadership.

Fantastic that they closed that house of unregulated disrepute, and have enabled the banning of drugs that would affect poor children for ever - in unknown ways.

OP posts:
EasternStandard · 18/03/2024 10:28

Those who claim no one cares and it’s a privilege etc are you pro puberty blockers and self ID?

IanCurtisdancing · 18/03/2024 10:25

Redrosetat · 18/03/2024 10:18

But of course

Disgraceful what has been allowed to happen under Tory leadership.

Redrosetat · 18/03/2024 10:18

But of course

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?
OP posts:
Redrosetat · 18/03/2024 08:52

It is actually disgusting that they insist on using the term ‘conversion therapy’ for what is essentially talking therapy or psychological help for people who may - or may not - be confused and or have significant psychological issues.

Everyone’s heard of the horrific ‘conversion therapy’ used by religious groups in America, to ‘turn gay people straight’, and this is nothing like that. Obviously.

Yet another lie from Labour.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?
OP posts:
EasternStandard · 18/03/2024 08:13

IanCurtisdancing · 18/03/2024 08:04

Is it a lot of people who care enough to make it a priority as a vote though?

Labour are not going to spearhead a campaign saying “people can change sex and use whatever toilet they like” so it’s never going to feature high on the list of things people care about.

Maybe it will maybe it won’t, whatever, Labour may as well be clear and women can decide

If it will have zero impact on votes they can rest easy and not do the avoiding

lifeturnsonadime · 18/03/2024 08:09

Link with the evidence of the date this was said, last month just after the conference regarding promises to the LGBT community.

https://twitter.com/AnnelieseDodds/status/1752662455791075823

https://twitter.com/AnnelieseDodds/status/1752662455791075823

IanCurtisdancing · 18/03/2024 08:04

WaterWeasel · 18/03/2024 07:57

The thing is that 'GC voters' you seem to think are a rarity. Everyone in the country however knows that no human being can change sex and most understand that women and girls should not be discriminated against. That's a lot of people.
Yes there is a hardcore of vile hard left men who want us kept in our place and this and are using genderism to do this. This is why sunlight needs to be shone where they don't want it to go. Labour must be questioned on and be made to defend their policies and let's see how they go down.

Edited

Is it a lot of people who care enough to make it a priority as a vote though?

Labour are not going to spearhead a campaign saying “people can change sex and use whatever toilet they like” so it’s never going to feature high on the list of things people care about.

lifeturnsonadime · 18/03/2024 08:03

On X day after Keir Starmer spoke at the conference from Anneleise Dodds.

‘Tackling health inequalities ‘ . Other than waiting times for gender affirming ‘care’ what health inequalities are specific to the LGBT community I wonder?

if LGBT people are facing discrimination in relation to access to healthcare because they are they would be able to bring claims under the Equality Act , but this really isn’t what Dodds is referring to.

it is clear that this refers to ‘gender affirming care’ which is what the TRAs are lobbying for speedy access to despite the lack of evidence base.

To think that Labour have just shot themselves in the foot?
WaterWeasel · 18/03/2024 07:57

KattyBoomBoom95 · 17/03/2024 22:41

How much difference will losing the support of GC voters actually make in the real world?

I defo agree with them on a lot of things but outside of twitter/mumsnet I've never heard anyone talking about it. None of my friends seem to care about it at all.

The thing is that 'GC voters' you seem to think are a rarity. Everyone in the country however knows that no human being can change sex and most understand that women and girls should not be discriminated against. That's a lot of people.
Yes there is a hardcore of vile hard left men who want us kept in our place and this and are using genderism to do this. This is why sunlight needs to be shone where they don't want it to go. Labour must be questioned on and be made to defend their policies and let's see how they go down.

EasternStandard · 18/03/2024 07:28

And they probably didn’t even talk about puberty blockers or ‘gender affirming care’ for children which is a woefully inadequate phrase for what happens

Again not just here, where ever the legislation underpins it. The U.K. has joined a few countries who have stopped puberty blockers

EasternStandard · 18/03/2024 06:57

KattyBoomBoom95 · 18/03/2024 00:55

Is it that many men though, really?

It takes a disproportionally small amount mostly because GRA legislation underpins the lobbying

Without that law no a minority of males would not get the outcomes from politicians

All this is not just on mn, it’s not even just U.K. - if people look at Riley Gaines in US, a 70 year old woman punched in NZ, parents speaking up against a teacher with distorted appearance in Canada - basically those countries with similar law have similar issues

Then also not on mn Maya Forstater who won a big court case, Sharron Davies who likely gets loads of abuse (more than the ‘bubble’ accusation you sometimes see on here)

Along with that small number of men are lobbying groups, some media, many organisations including international and many who make a living from it - likely on here too

It’s interesting when the GRA was created Hansard cites someone who was for it

Let me make it clear that it will not be possible for a man simply to declare that he is of the opposite gender and then compete in women's competitions.

They really did get it wrong.

JessS1990 · 18/03/2024 06:47

lifeturnsonadime · 17/03/2024 21:32

What I am taking from this is no one actually knows what Starmer means or intends.

We are all second guessing.

Perhaps Starmer might want to clarify if he wants women who have our doubts about his intentions towards our spaces and our children wrt harmful experimental drugs?

He knows that many women are asking these questions. If he could give satisfactory answers many women will vote Labour.

So I do wonder why it was, if Starmer is on the same side regarding experimental drugs there were Labour MPs trying to prevent open discussion. by stopping the Private Members Bill on the subject?

Fortunately we know exactly what Sunak stands for, as he has repeatedly demonstrated in his time in government.

Staying in power as long as possible in order to enrich himself, his father in law and others who already have more money than anyone could possibly need.

JessS1990 · 18/03/2024 06:45

EasternStandard · 17/03/2024 20:48

Crap gifs really should go. They don’t add much

What about crap Ministers?

This thread has so many posts I haven't had a chance to check.
Do we know why the Equalities Minister was in parliament on Friday to lend her weight to the debate that she tweeted about?
Indeed do we know why she hasn't introduced a bill on behalf of the government on the subject?

IanCurtisdancing · 18/03/2024 03:37

bombastix · 17/03/2024 23:25

Your surmise correctly. The number of women intending to vote Labour is actually up from the last election.

I saw a post on the feminism board which genuinely asked why there wasn’t huge mass protests and it didn’t seem to occur to them that outside of their GC bubble, on a day to day basis most people do not consider it a top priority in terms of policy or see how it’s going to effect the mass majority of women on a day to day basis.

it doesn’t help that - taking the board here for example - they don’t aeem to care about wanting to “win” people to their cause anyway - calling other women a handmaiden or dick panderer etc etc. if you wanted a mass protest you need to think like a politician and get people on your side, not angrily cuss them down if their view does not exactly align with yours.

KattyBoomBoom95 · 18/03/2024 00:55

EasternStandard · 17/03/2024 23:30

If they get the mandate to erode rights further I guess we’ll see who complains.

There’s a whole segment of males hoping it’s the case and some are helping them out nicely.

Is it that many men though, really?

EasternStandard · 17/03/2024 23:30

If they get the mandate to erode rights further I guess we’ll see who complains.

There’s a whole segment of males hoping it’s the case and some are helping them out nicely.

bombastix · 17/03/2024 23:25

KattyBoomBoom95 · 17/03/2024 22:41

How much difference will losing the support of GC voters actually make in the real world?

I defo agree with them on a lot of things but outside of twitter/mumsnet I've never heard anyone talking about it. None of my friends seem to care about it at all.

Your surmise correctly. The number of women intending to vote Labour is actually up from the last election.

KattyBoomBoom95 · 17/03/2024 22:41

How much difference will losing the support of GC voters actually make in the real world?

I defo agree with them on a lot of things but outside of twitter/mumsnet I've never heard anyone talking about it. None of my friends seem to care about it at all.

EasternStandard · 17/03/2024 22:14

lifeturnsonadime · 17/03/2024 21:51

No he isn't stupid, he's a lawyer, good with words and using one's that are open to multiple interpretations, so think you a right.

I think he will lose quite a lot of votes over the fence sitting though. Probably from both 'sides' of the women's rights / children's safety divide.

I’m not sure either, politicians can be smart but they also should be clear. Lawyerly statements that avoid clarity aren’t that great generally. And Starmer seems to rely on the method a fair bit, especially when it comes to this issue

It’s another form of spin to avoid
not speaking wrt Labour voters who don’t care and prefer less info

cardibach · 17/03/2024 22:03

lifeturnsonadime · 17/03/2024 21:13

So which urgent care for trans people is he cutting waiting lists for if it is isn't trans health care.
I mean this is exactly the problem isn't it?

He sits so firmly on the fence it is stuck up his backside.

I'm desperate to be proved wrong on all of these things so why the fuck doesn't someone in the Labour Party actually say what they mean?

The problem is that he is trying to appease the TRAs and women who want to protect children and single sex spaces. Not one person can actually work out what the intentions are!

So he could end up losing swathes of voters because no one has a clue what he actually stands for .

Starmer if you don't mean that you will cut waiting lists for experimental trans health care will you just say so? If you don't intend to ban talking therapy for gender non conforming kids, will you just say so? If you intend to protect women's single sex spaces by amending the Equality Act, will you just say so? If you don't intend to compel speech and treat non-compliant women as though we have committed a hate crime will you just say so?

Ta very muchly, If you can't even have a conversation with us about this without having front benchers calling women bigots / rights hoarding dinosaurs or people like Lloyd Russel moyle being aggressive to dissident women then that might help. Oh and an apology to Rosie might help too.

Edited

He didn’t say trans people.

BIossomtoes · 17/03/2024 21:56

Most of the reporting press, have interpreted it as 1,

Why can’t I find it then? My research skills are pretty advanced and I can’t find any news source that says that.

It’s as clear as day that he means 2. And he specified that group because he was addressing them at the time.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/03/2024 21:51

bombastix · 17/03/2024 21:39

Now whether you like Starmer or not he doesn't strike me as a stupid man.

And given this thread, he would be most foolish to do anything now beyond what he had said. He is a politician. Conspicuous lack of upside and serious downside.

But equally, I think the same applies to the Conservatives. So that's where it will stay until post the election.

No he isn't stupid, he's a lawyer, good with words and using one's that are open to multiple interpretations, so think you a right.

I think he will lose quite a lot of votes over the fence sitting though. Probably from both 'sides' of the women's rights / children's safety divide.

lifeturnsonadime · 17/03/2024 21:47

Oh and Blossoms of course I know that other people get sick, which is why I can't get my head round why he was telling LGBT groups that he was cutting waiting lists for them? If he meant for all people why was he suggesting it was a benefit to that group , he could have said I am cutting waiting lists for all, but he said he cutting them specifically for LGBTQ people.

  1. So does he mean he is cutting waiting times for trans health care (this is a reasonable interpretation given that that care is specific to that group as there is no specific care in relation to LGB people) or
  2. does he mean he is cutting it for all people - if so why did he tell LGBT people that he was cutting lists for LGBT people, rather than for everyone? And why say that in a discussion about specific benefits of a Labour government to that group?
  3. Or does he mean that he is generally priortising LGBT people by cutting their waiting lists over and above other in respect of non LGBT specific care (this is the least likely interpretation) given the fact that there would be very little political appetite were LGBT people to jump waiting lists for cancer care for example.

Most of the reporting press, have interpreted it as 1, which is what I think he means and what you have called me intellectually dishonest over.

If this is wrong it is very easy for him to clarify and I will be more than happy to be proven wrong.

bombastix · 17/03/2024 21:39

Now whether you like Starmer or not he doesn't strike me as a stupid man.

And given this thread, he would be most foolish to do anything now beyond what he had said. He is a politician. Conspicuous lack of upside and serious downside.

But equally, I think the same applies to the Conservatives. So that's where it will stay until post the election.