Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if other Drs surgeries are as shit as mine

108 replies

Ohmegerd · 15/03/2024 12:57

I've been unwell since January. Horrible hacking cough, burning lungs and i suspected it's a chest infection. Managed to make a doctors appointment at the time but they could only offer a phone consultation despite me calling at 8am sharp after being on hold for 45 minutes. Was told GP can ring anytime between 12pm and 8pm. Not ideal to be worrying all afternoon incase I miss the call but hey. GP did indeed ring and prescribed antibiotics, advising cough will improve slowly itself. Antibiotics made a slight difference and I muddled through a busy month of Feb in the hope I'd start feeling better.

Over the past few days I'm struggling again. I fall asleep but suddenly awaken gagging and unable to swallow. It's freaked me out and then I'm too anxious to go back to sleep. Horrible spluttering cough which leaves me feeling lightheaded. Chest hurts. Bladder seems to have given up on me and I'm leaking atleast once day after an episode. Rang GP yestrday but to no avail. Re-attempted this morning 8am sharp and after 25 minutes on hold again offered a phone consultation. I insisted on a face to face app but none left. I feel so fed up and upset. It's an absolute shitshow. Wtf will it take to be able to actually see a doctor??

OP posts:
TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 19:25

PaddingtonsHat · 15/03/2024 19:02

There are not enough GPs. Allied health professionals are needed because of demand, and the government are incentivising surgeries to employ them. Perhaps you have needed to see more than 1 HCP but there are a lot of people who can be managed effectively by other team members.

The rhetoric that GPs are fobbing people off when patients don’t get exactly what they want is damaging. If we dish out antibiotics to everyone then we’re irresponsible and contributing to antibiotic resistance, but if we don’t we are fobbing everyone off. Can’t win, and I can totally see why my colleagues are leaving the NHS in droves.

I accept that they are under great pressure, but I don't think telling patients they are not receiving a shit service is the way to go. And I also am not convinced all the extra activity by nurses etc is productive.

Ohmegerd · 15/03/2024 19:24

Sorry about my language 😣I'm sat here coughing my lungs out and feeling extremely annoyed.

OP posts:
Ohmegerd · 15/03/2024 19:23

RemarkablyBrightCreature · 15/03/2024 19:15

Your symptoms sound like whooping cough to me - it’s ripping through our local population like wildfire. Waking up in the middle of the night feeling like you can’t breathe is classic WC 😢

This is why I wanted to be seen face to face. So GP can listen to my chest, check my temperature etc as fuck knows really what it is. I hinted at a reflux possibility and he wasted no time clicking away a prescription for antacids!

OP posts:
RemarkablyBrightCreature · 15/03/2024 19:15

Your symptoms sound like whooping cough to me - it’s ripping through our local population like wildfire. Waking up in the middle of the night feeling like you can’t breathe is classic WC 😢

Starburst24 · 15/03/2024 19:12

I had a really bad chest and sinus infection last October. Rang the surgery at 7.55 and finally got in a queue at 8am. I was 17th in the queue
gets to 8.40 and 3rd in the queue. Phone line cuts off
Rang back and 16th in the queue. Finally got answered at 9.10 to be told no appointments and to ring back the next day
tried nhs 111 online. Filled in the form and it came up with ‘someone will call within the hour’
I got a call at 10.10PM. So over 12 hours later.
They arranged for the surgery to call me the following day and I got antibiotics prescribed over the phone by the gp who called at 9.20am the next day.
Changed GP surgery that day as I was fuming. Moved to the one my parents are at

Had another chest infection in December. Phoned new surgery at 8am and was seen face to face at 9.20am that day.
Have some ongoing issues with something else that has flared up in the last month so did the online consultation last Wednesday. Had a text link to book on Thursday and saw a gp yesterday and meds issued. Cannot fault the new surgery at all. GP was on time, really listened, had a look at a couple of things I’d mentioned as I don’t think he was familiar with the issue, had read my notes so knew what the hospital had suggested regarding pain relief and told me what wasn’t suitable and what he suggested and how it was a safer option. Never had an appointment on time before at the old surgery. Always at least 20 minutes late and I even got missed at one appointment and sat for two hours begging someone saw me.

wish I’d changed earlier

PaddingtonsHat · 15/03/2024 19:02

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 18:42

My entire point is that activity is being inflated by pointless additional contacts with nurses and other staff, brief telephone appointments which need to be repeated, etc where in the past one in person appointment would have resolved the issue.

I work in the NHS and I've seen this in other areas. Activity looks great but in reality the situation is shit.

There are not enough GPs. Allied health professionals are needed because of demand, and the government are incentivising surgeries to employ them. Perhaps you have needed to see more than 1 HCP but there are a lot of people who can be managed effectively by other team members.

The rhetoric that GPs are fobbing people off when patients don’t get exactly what they want is damaging. If we dish out antibiotics to everyone then we’re irresponsible and contributing to antibiotic resistance, but if we don’t we are fobbing everyone off. Can’t win, and I can totally see why my colleagues are leaving the NHS in droves.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 18:42

Parker231 · 15/03/2024 18:36

Data published by NHS England shows that for the year to October 2023, there were 50.9 million additional general practice appointments delivered when compared to October 2019.

My entire point is that activity is being inflated by pointless additional contacts with nurses and other staff, brief telephone appointments which need to be repeated, etc where in the past one in person appointment would have resolved the issue.

I work in the NHS and I've seen this in other areas. Activity looks great but in reality the situation is shit.

Parker231 · 15/03/2024 18:36

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 18:27

But the point is I get the appointment with the doctor after several pointless appointments with staff who cannot do what needs to be done. Which means activity is inflated to no positive effect. I absolutely do not believe more actual GP appointments are happening - it is very obvious at my surgery that they are not. Hence why they were found unsafe and lost their contract.

Data published by NHS England shows that for the year to October 2023, there were 50.9 million additional general practice appointments delivered when compared to October 2019.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 18:27

Parker231 · 15/03/2024 18:01

DH was a GP for 25 years until he’d had enough and handed back his contract. GP’s aren’t avoiding patients - there are more patients wanting appointments than there are available. GP’s are leaving and not being replaced.
If you can’t get an appointment it’s because someone else has been given it. More people can have phone appointments than face to face.

More people are getting appointments since lockdown but there still aren’t enough to go around.

But the point is I get the appointment with the doctor after several pointless appointments with staff who cannot do what needs to be done. Which means activity is inflated to no positive effect. I absolutely do not believe more actual GP appointments are happening - it is very obvious at my surgery that they are not. Hence why they were found unsafe and lost their contract.

Tootytoot78 · 15/03/2024 18:13

Aydel · 15/03/2024 13:19

My mother died because she was unable to see a doctor in person, or to get any tests. She was constantly told, for over a year, by a GP on the phone that her painful chest and breathlessness was due to a pulled muscle. It wasn’t. It was terminal lung cancer. The outcome probably would have been the same, but she needn’t have been in pain for so long.

My best friend was transferred to our local Macmillan Palliative Care yesterday as she has been told she has two months at the most.
My lovely brave friend has been back and forth to her gp ( when she could get an actual appointment)for the past 3 years, to be met with apathy and her being made to feel she was a nuisance.
I have lost all faith in the NHS.

ohthejoys21 · 15/03/2024 18:11

Sickens me how doctors refuse to see patients now. My dd woke up unable to swallow her throat was so painful. Had to take her to private doctor who took a swab and she had antibiotics within the hour. Turns out it was strep A.

She was getting worse by the hour. I have no idea what would have happened to her if we didn't have a private gp. In my grandma's day, the same doctor every time would pay you a home visit. What does the future look like?

Parker231 · 15/03/2024 18:01

TheYearOfSmallThings · 15/03/2024 14:45

I do not believe GPs are providing more appointments in any meaningful sense.

Ten years ago I would call, make one fixed appointment to see my GP, and be discharged with the appropriate actions completed in about 10 minutes (prescription, tests, referral, whatever.)

Now I would fill in an online form, and wait for a call from the nurse or clinical pharmacist which may come at any time in a 4 hour window. If I miss this call, I will get a message telling me to call again tomorrow if I still need to speak to them. If I do answer the call they will be pleasant but never have any answers, so they will need to speak to someone else. Then call me again to clarify something. Then speak to a doctor. Then call me again. Lots of time, lots of consultations, higher activity on paper, but no increase in actual care delivered. They are making themselves busy and wasting patient time too trying to do clever gatekeeping instead of just providing the appropriate care. It looks good on paper but as a patient it feels shit.

DH was a GP for 25 years until he’d had enough and handed back his contract. GP’s aren’t avoiding patients - there are more patients wanting appointments than there are available. GP’s are leaving and not being replaced.
If you can’t get an appointment it’s because someone else has been given it. More people can have phone appointments than face to face.

More people are getting appointments since lockdown but there still aren’t enough to go around.

Mimilamore · 15/03/2024 17:54

It's all gone to pot since we came out of lockdown. Had to change medical centres because our usual one went over to " walk ins" up to 4 hours wait.
I've never seen my new gp. I'm 69 and fairly uncomplicated but do need a med review at least once a year. Had to ask for the last one, chase it up, chase up the blood test forms, chase up the result.... not easy getting the blood test either.
My husband is complex, 15 medications taken, not reviewed for 2 years, he has managed to get an appt next week ( waited since Christmas) for a review of his breathing as has severs asthma, COPD and sleep apnea .... all of which have worsened significantly. Our pharmacist is very diligent and does a good job but repeat scrips often not sent across, meaning one more trip to collect for either my husband who struggles to breath and walk at same time or me.
Our minor injuries was good today though, 1hr 15 mins to have a wound checked and new dressing applied.
Its even scarier at wknds when you have to call 111/999 or wait all day for duty doc at walk in ( if he can get here, live on an island)
Very insecure....

Pennyandolive · 15/03/2024 17:52

Sorry you’ve had such a shit experience OP. I don’t understand how there is so much inconsistency between how practices run. How is it some can be amazing and some can be so poor?

My surgery and especially my G.P. is amazing. I have a very complicated and quite rare condition that requires quite a lot of medical intervention and my G. P. makes an effort to be actively involved and there to support me. He has made an effort to learn about my condition and to research possible treatments and is always looking for ways to make my life easier. He has helped fight my corner when issues have arisen with sickness leave from work and has generally been an exceptional practitioner. The surgery always have appointments when I call. I can always be seen in the same day if needed or within a couple of weeks if not urgent. When my children have been unwell, even if I’ve just called for advice, they will see them just to be sure. If a longer appointment is needed they make sure they book me at the end of a morning or afternoon so that the dr isn’t trying to get to the next patient. It’s unacceptable that my experience isn’t more common when it’s something as important as health!

NotTerfNorCis · 15/03/2024 17:31

I don't have horror stories like the ones here, and in fact my local GP is relatively good. I called last year reporting breathing difficulties and got a face to face appointment that morning. He did fob me off a bit, but at least he saw me.

My parents' GP is also easy to get hold of, but recently, when my father had a fall and was in a lot of pain, I never managed to get a doctor out to the house for him. The paramedic came three or four times, and there was a registrar, but no actual doctor visit. I think he could have got a face to face if he'd been able to walk and leave the house, but he wasn't. Dad ended up in hospital and away from home for about six weeks.

SleepyRich · 15/03/2024 17:30

gamerchick · 15/03/2024 17:16

I can't believe you typed that out with a straight face Confused do gps have magical powers and can see and touch you through a bloody phone?

Unbelievable.

:) that made me chuckle too!

I'm really quite surprised that some people are being prescribed antibiotics over the phone, especially for coughs. Perhaps if the patient is having a flare of a chronic lung condition and has a plan in place for exacerbations. The vast majority otherwise are self limiting and antibiotics are of absolutely no benefit at all, sure most people with a short history of very viral sounding symptoms so can be triaged and given advice over the phone, but if in that triage they sound unwell enough/persisting long enough that they likely need treatment I would think it risky to do this without having a face to face, even if briefly!!!

No not all surgeries are like that OP, if that was my experience I'd move to another practice.

gamerchick · 15/03/2024 17:16

Rosesanddaisies1 · 15/03/2024 14:23

But what do you expect a GP to do in person that they can't do over the phone? It's not like they can see your lungs. They're making the best use of their very over stretched time. I am a big fan of e-consult and phone appointments, so much easier. Do yourself a favour and take the phone appointment.

Edited

I can't believe you typed that out with a straight face Confused do gps have magical powers and can see and touch you through a bloody phone?

Unbelievable.

chorusline79 · 15/03/2024 16:33

@Aydel I am so sorry this happened to your mum. How many people are slipping through the net as they can't get an appointment ..

My Docs is awful too - I rang 25 times last week one day and couldn't even get through to make an appointment. I went down there in the end and waited at the desk and they were very huffy with me but I got an appointment and that will be my tactic from now on.

MoonWoman69 · 15/03/2024 16:23

I'm in Leeds and my GP's are exactly the same. I was going to move, but having read the reviews of the other local ones, they all sound the same! My husband even went to my surgery and asked for an appointment as I have had chronic back pain for 5 weeks now and my usual painkillers have decided to make me violently sick. He was told I needed to ring at 8am the next morning. I rang bang on 8 and I couldn't even be added to the queue! How does that even happen?
I'm fobbed off every time I ring now. And I know it's not personal, this is without them asking my name! Surgeries are not fit for purpose any longer.

ALongHardWinter · 15/03/2024 16:18

Can't offer any constructive advice,but I'm seconding what previous posters have said about the GP surgery being deserted, despite being given the impression when you try to book an appointment that they are rushed off their feet!

TM1979 · 15/03/2024 16:11

Yep..ours is awful. They won’t answer the phones, sometimes they hang up on you. There’s only one doctor anyone wants to see and you can expect to wait 3 or 4 weeks if not more to see her. She only works 3 days.
The staff at reception are so rude too. They want to decide whether or not you need a doctor. They shut for lunch 1-2.30 and take the phone off the hook at 4.15. There’s an emergency gp from 6pm in a town about 30 minutes drive away. Sometimes that’s your best bet. I’m in Ireland and I hear the same craic about other places. Got worse since covid for sure.

MorrisZapp · 15/03/2024 16:09

If GPs can work from home without seeing patients then surely the next step is AI, and no GPs at all, just a computer? All those years of doctors pleading their unique professional training and now they're saying just ring up, it makes no sense. I might as well ring a GP in India, is this on the cards?

It also makes a complete mockery of all the common health advice and public campaigning 'if x happens, consult your doctor' - good luck with that. Preventative medicine is in the bin if only urgent and difficult cases warrant an appointment.

I'm happy for pharmacists to dispense much more than they're currently allowed to, and happy to see nurses, practice pharmacists etc if it's deemed appropriate. We can't keep venerating doctors though if they don't have diagnostic skills. They're just a worst case clearing service.

NeedToChangeName · 15/03/2024 16:06

We pay higher taxes in Scotland but our surgery is great. I can get through by phone, get an appointment within 48 hours, I've had some hospital tests same day. No complaints

KnittedCardi · 15/03/2024 15:59

Skiphopbump · 15/03/2024 13:25

Mine has an econsult system. The dr then calls and invites you in if needed. It all happens on the day you just need to complete the econsult before 11 am. I find this a really good system.

Same. It works really well here. Have had meds prescribed and ready at the dispensary same day too. Pretty impressed by the new system. We get 30 min time slots for calls too, which means no hanging around.

Forgiveme · 15/03/2024 15:58

Ours is pretty bad.

Over the last few years (and these are pretty much 90% of all dealings we've had with them):

Misdiagnosed DC with chickenpox when they had hand, foot and mouth

Argued with me and refused a Right to Choose referral - eventually conceded I was right, but took two phone calls and me printing off an email to resolve - they'd "not heard of it before".

Archaic in their systems - as above, there was no way for me to forward an email to them, I had to physically print off an email, take it down to the surgery and wait for them to call me.

Usually pretty good at same-day call backs (no in-person appointments however), except one time when they had none left - without seeing nor speaking to a GP, had antibiotics prescribed for DC, just from the receptionist asking the doctor.