Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

College study and LCWRA

63 replies

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 12:47

Not sure if this is the correct place for this but I’m in receipt of PIP and UC LCWRA for mental health issues.

Sitting at home all day is not helping me at all I feel, and I wanted to look at what I can do to improve this as I find a routine to be very helpful in managing these difficulties.

I’m also starting to find isolation difficult, and feel I may like to try something just to see how I am able to cope. Genuinely cannot see life improving for me if I carry on the way I am.

I had a look at a local college and what is offered as initially I trained in art years ago, but this subject has really got me nowhere I feel, and the arts is such a competitive industry.

I know you are allowed to study part time on UC. Issue is, the course I am interested in is full time, I am unable to find any part time courses that offer what I want.

Only issue is, if one is in receipt of PIP and LCWRA because they find face to face contact with others difficult then this would likely be contradicting the reasons for LCWRA.

I equally can’t afford to lose the money, but then what am I supposed to do if I cannot try and improve my life because it would go against me?

I find it appalling really that people are threatened with having the money removed if they wish to try and improve their life. I feel as though once on benefits you can’t get off them due to this.

Would I be unreasonable to just apply for a course full time, study for it and not tell them? I equally don’t want to get into trouble for doing this as I equally need the money. It’s so difficult.

If starting a course means potentially losing the money then sadly I’ll just have to forget it and remain on benefits it seems.

Can anyone give me some advice? TIA

OP posts:
Frumpitydoo · 15/03/2024 16:49

@Confusedandvulnerable Sorry I don't understand your question?
To be clear I detest the DWP and am not in agreement with their rules, but if you can work, whether that is college study or running your own small business, then in their eyes, you are fit for work.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:48

@Mrsttcno1 In my opinion it’s a disgrace those people got their money removed for simply trying some work.

Can’t wait for this new health element to be introduced as this might mean those who try don’t lose the money so abruptly.

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 16:48

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 16:44

As I say, this is my first hand experience, working in an organisation that supports people through these processes as well as others. I have directly seen exactly that happen.

The risk is yours and yours alone to take of course, but if you really can’t afford to lose the money then I can’t stress enough that I would recommend discussing any study etc with them first.

I imagine unfortunately it's an assessor dependent thing. Some assessors are outright awful.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:47

@Universalsnail Mine also massively fluctuates and LCWRA doesn’t mean no capability at all so don’t really see why a small Etsy store working from home should affect it. It’s not exactly ‘going out’ to work.

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 16:44

As I say, this is my first hand experience, working in an organisation that supports people through these processes as well as others. I have directly seen exactly that happen.

The risk is yours and yours alone to take of course, but if you really can’t afford to lose the money then I can’t stress enough that I would recommend discussing any study etc with them first.

Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 16:43

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:40

@Universalsnail Thank you for clarifying this a bit more. I would be surprised if working on a small business by yourself would contradict LCWRA for the face to face reason.

I guess we will see what happens when I am reassessed. But according to the job centre, which I have all in writing, i am allowed to do this work without no longer being entitled to LCWRA. I have autism and ME/CFS and so condition fluctuates massively.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:40

@Universalsnail Thank you for clarifying this a bit more. I would be surprised if working on a small business by yourself would contradict LCWRA for the face to face reason.

OP posts:
Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 16:40

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 16:22

As I’ve said above, you still need to be very very careful.

I have first hand had experience of supporting adults who have set things up (for example at Etsy store) and as a result upon assessment for LCWRA been changed.

Not all work requires face to face communication, and thus they can and do argue that if you are capable of ordering supplies, producing a product, marketing a product, setting up a website, taking orders, sending orders, financially operating a business venture (even a small one, like my example of an adult I assisted who had literally just set up an Etsy store selling digitally downloadable products), then you absolutely have capacity for some work and work related activities because every single one of those tasks is an example of a work related activity.

People's conditions massively fluctuate though.
I work on LCWRA. Some months I manage 10 hours over the whole month. Some months I manage 2. Many months I manage 0. My fatigue condition varies significantly. A removal of LCWRA would mean that I would be in poverty on the 0 months and I would be expected to find other work which I can't do because on the 0 months I can't work. I had a meeting with the job centre to ask if I could do this work and was encouraged to give it a try with an understanding that if would vary significantly each month due to my fatigue condition and an understanding that it wouldn't impact my LCWRA. At reassessment my condition is just as fluctuating as it was when I was first awarded it.

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 16:31

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:24

@Mrsttcno1 That does seem strange if it wouldn’t contradict any of the reasons for LCWRA. What are people less fortunate meant to do if so? Struggle in poverty? Particularly if they are only able to run the business part time due to their health.

I don’t believe the intention is for anybody to ever struggle in poverty, but the point is that those who are capable of working should work. Removing LCWRA does not remove all UC, and so those people working are not worse off or at a financial disadvantage, they will simply be on the sliding scale of UC, having their wage topped up unless/until they are earning an amount on which they are no longer eligible for UC.

Working part time doesn’t mean you wouldn’t receive any UC, you will never be worse off for working, so those who are in poverty and capable of working CAN and are encouraged to do so because they will be better off for doing so. Lots of people work and also receive UC top ups, it isn’t one or the other.

Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 16:31

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 15:57

Yes, but the reality is that if as OP is suggesting they want to set up a business, that will be taken into account at their next assessment and you will find that if a person is capable of managing to set up and operate a business then they are going to struggle to maintain that they have LCWRA. Part of my current job is supporting people through this process and in my experience if the assessors can make an argument for you being able to work, then they will make that argument.

We have seen first hand people who have set up even small businesses and it been decided at their next assessment that at the point you are capable of setting up a business (in one example it was an Etsy store selling digital items), corresponding with customers, taking orders, producing and providing product, managing sales etc, then they lose LCWRA because if you can do all of those things then you are capable of work.

Depends what business if is.

If for example she gets LCWRA for mental health and fatigue but she sets up a little Etsy business selling printables which therefore doesn't require face to face talking to people, etsy handles all the invoicing, and can be done in periods around her fatigue then that would be fine.

LCWRA is limited capacity to work not no capacity to work.

Plenty of people have fluctuating conditions and this is taken into account by LCWRA and PIP.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:30

@Frumpitydoo How is one equally expected to live with no money?

OP posts:
Frumpitydoo · 15/03/2024 16:25

Adding to @Mrsttcno1 's post, if you can go to college and study then you are fit to work in the eyes of the DWP.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:24

@Mrsttcno1 That does seem strange if it wouldn’t contradict any of the reasons for LCWRA. What are people less fortunate meant to do if so? Struggle in poverty? Particularly if they are only able to run the business part time due to their health.

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 16:22

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:17

@Mrsttcno1 I get a lot of what you are saying, but if it is a business such as sole trader, where for example you make stuff to sell from your own home, and therefore don’t interact face to face then I don’t see how that can really go against someone? As you wouldn’t be physically interacting with customers. This does seem like my only option tbf.

I’m not talking about the type of business such as a shop in the community, chippy or cafe where you would be expected to engage frequently face to face with customers.

Edited

As I’ve said above, you still need to be very very careful.

I have first hand had experience of supporting adults who have set things up (for example at Etsy store) and as a result upon assessment for LCWRA been changed.

Not all work requires face to face communication, and thus they can and do argue that if you are capable of ordering supplies, producing a product, marketing a product, setting up a website, taking orders, sending orders, financially operating a business venture (even a small one, like my example of an adult I assisted who had literally just set up an Etsy store selling digitally downloadable products), then you absolutely have capacity for some work and work related activities because every single one of those tasks is an example of a work related activity.

Frumpitydoo · 15/03/2024 16:21

@Mrsttcno1 is saying if you are capable of setting up a business then you are capable of working. Nothing to do with f2f etc.

Frumpitydoo · 15/03/2024 16:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 16:17

@Mrsttcno1 I get a lot of what you are saying, but if it is a business such as sole trader, where for example you make stuff to sell from your own home, and therefore don’t interact face to face then I don’t see how that can really go against someone? As you wouldn’t be physically interacting with customers. This does seem like my only option tbf.

I’m not talking about the type of business such as a shop in the community, chippy or cafe where you would be expected to engage frequently face to face with customers.

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 15:57

Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 15:38

This is not true. You can work and receive LCWRA if whatever you are doing doesn't contradict the reasons you have it. They won't stop it just because they have a reason to believe you could do any job whatsoever. Plenty of people on LCWRA can work a little in the right role. On LCWRA you get a £600 a month work allowance that you can earn without it impacting your benefits. It isn't just for people who couldn't possible conceive they could work.

OP I would go to college and see what disability support and financial support they have that would enable you to do the course. If may meen as it is full-time that you will need to come off LCWRA but thats ok because you have other means of financial support. Or it is not possible in which case is it possible to do the course or a similar course part time, therefore allowing you to keep LCWRA.

Definitely don't right it off. I understand your worries but the worst you can just re apply for LCWRA if needs be.

Edited

Yes, but the reality is that if as OP is suggesting they want to set up a business, that will be taken into account at their next assessment and you will find that if a person is capable of managing to set up and operate a business then they are going to struggle to maintain that they have LCWRA. Part of my current job is supporting people through this process and in my experience if the assessors can make an argument for you being able to work, then they will make that argument.

We have seen first hand people who have set up even small businesses and it been decided at their next assessment that at the point you are capable of setting up a business (in one example it was an Etsy store selling digital items), corresponding with customers, taking orders, producing and providing product, managing sales etc, then they lose LCWRA because if you can do all of those things then you are capable of work.

Universalsnail · 15/03/2024 15:38

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 15:15

Starting up a business will provoke exactly the same problems, if any of the work you are doing there contradicts LCWRA then it will be stopped at next review.

I think the problem is that you’re focused on is wanting to try a full time degree or set up a business without risking losing the comfort blanket of UC. UC isn’t there for that reason though. It, especially LCWRA, is there to support people who physically cannot work, who couldn’t even conceive it possible to be self employed or start up a business, people who are truly unable to support themselves. It’s not there to act as a cushion for people to “follow their dreams”. This means that if they have any reason to believe that actually you COULD be working & earning money, then yes they will stop LWCRA/UC, because you would no longer be in the category of people who need it- which lots of people of course do and should be able to access it.

This is not true. You can work and receive LCWRA if whatever you are doing doesn't contradict the reasons you have it. They won't stop it just because they have a reason to believe you could do any job whatsoever. Plenty of people on LCWRA can work a little in the right role. On LCWRA you get a £600 a month work allowance that you can earn without it impacting your benefits. It isn't just for people who couldn't possible conceive they could work.

OP I would go to college and see what disability support and financial support they have that would enable you to do the course. If may meen as it is full-time that you will need to come off LCWRA but thats ok because you have other means of financial support. Or it is not possible in which case is it possible to do the course or a similar course part time, therefore allowing you to keep LCWRA.

Definitely don't right it off. I understand your worries but the worst you can just re apply for LCWRA if needs be.

Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 15:15

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 15:09

@Mrsttcno1 I think my main fear is that due to my autism, if I apply, then tell them then it dosen’t work out then I’ve lost everything.

Sometimes it may seem like it’s really shit, but maybe it’s better the devil you know. Might just be better starting up a business.

Maybe I’m also too concerned about what other people would think of me if they knew my income was from benefits.

Edited

Starting up a business will provoke exactly the same problems, if any of the work you are doing there contradicts LCWRA then it will be stopped at next review.

I think the problem is that you’re focused on is wanting to try a full time degree or set up a business without risking losing the comfort blanket of UC. UC isn’t there for that reason though. It, especially LCWRA, is there to support people who physically cannot work, who couldn’t even conceive it possible to be self employed or start up a business, people who are truly unable to support themselves. It’s not there to act as a cushion for people to “follow their dreams”. This means that if they have any reason to believe that actually you COULD be working & earning money, then yes they will stop LWCRA/UC, because you would no longer be in the category of people who need it- which lots of people of course do and should be able to access it.

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 15:09

@Mrsttcno1 I think my main fear is that due to my autism, if I apply, then tell them then it dosen’t work out then I’ve lost everything.

Sometimes it may seem like it’s really shit, but maybe it’s better the devil you know. Might just be better starting up a business.

Maybe I’m also too concerned about what other people would think of me if they knew my income was from benefits.

OP posts:
HighCortisolIsMyName · 15/03/2024 15:08

If its fulltime can you apply for student finance?

I'm on LCWRA and PIP and I'm pretty sure I can study but I'd get mainly student finance with possibly a little topped up by UC?

I could be wrong though, it's been a few years since I checked

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 15:07

@SpringtimeBunny I get it’s taxpayers money and that, but gosh don’t they make us feel like shit for receiving it? Like we can help the way we were born.

I frankly dislike the way they are always watching over peoples shoulders, practically dictating what we can and can’t do when on that money when the majority claiming are deserving of it anyway. Benefit fraud is a drop in the ocean compared to all the tax evaders.

That’s partly why I felt like finding something that’s suits me so one day I wouldn’t need to claim anymore. They’re even thinking of checking up on peoples bank accounts now too.

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 15/03/2024 15:04

Confusedandvulnerable · 15/03/2024 14:45

@Mrsttcno1 Seems like it may just not be worth the risk then. I don’t trust them really they are underhanded.

May be better just dealing with the isolation factor in other ways and for now will just have to continue feeling like a scrounger.

The media doesn’t help matters or these disgusting benefits programmes broadcast on TV. It’s so damaging to one’s self worth.

It’s why despite all the criticism of it, I’m honestly partly in favour of this new health element, which may enable people to try at things without losing money.

If this is something you want to do then why don’t you just have a conversation with them about it?

I think the issue really is if anything you are doing directly contradicts the reasons you receive these benefits. If you’re doing so because you cannot interact with others face to face for example, then yeah they would be well within their rights to say if you are capable of doing a full time degree which requires this then you can work.

I don’t think they are against people bettering themselves/working either, that’s why UC is on a sliding scale so you are always going to be better off doing some work, it’s not a case of if you try and work then your money is stopped, it is a scale to slide down rather than a cliff to jump off.

Domino20 · 15/03/2024 15:03

Would you be able to share with us what type of course you're interested in? Maybe someone would be able to find you an alternative provision?