Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should say something now

184 replies

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 10:01

This is a bit of a strange one but it keeps popping into my mind.

I was at university with someone who had an older boyfriend. I can now see through adult eyes that he was very controlling and was really a very sinister character but he actually appeared very nice on the surface, had a professional and well respected role.

I recently found out he has died, which had me thinking about some things. It was ages ago, over twenty years, but he told me some things which now I’m a but horrified by though I didn’t really take them in at the time.

Is it worth telling her? We aren’t close but she’s on my social media.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:59

PossumintheHouse · 15/03/2024 16:55

Out of interest, are you in a relationship with a partner of over 20 years, have children with them? If they died, and a friend called you up out the blue to say he was a sinister manipulator, how do you think you would you feel about that? Would you really want to hear it?

Thats not what I was (note the last tense: I have accepted I am BU) suggesting I do.

If someone had lied to me I would want the truth. If someone had deceived me I would want the correct version. If someone had tricked me I would want to be put straight. But that is me.

OP posts:
Allfur · 15/03/2024 16:58

You could possibly validate her feelings, people in abusive relationships often have no outlet

PeonyFlush72 · 15/03/2024 16:56

If she knows he was a creep and has had a bad marriage then your comments may make her feel even worse and embarrassed. I'm not sure it will make her feel better to have an outsider confirm how awful he was.

She may also feel angry and bitter that she could have been saved from this (not that I blame you for staying quiet).

If she has had a lovely happy marriage then your comments could completely throw her off course and make her second guess all her happy memories.

I suppose either way I don't see how this could benefit her which tbh is the only thing that matters.

PossumintheHouse · 15/03/2024 16:55

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:50

Yes recently. Thank you.

@TinkerTiger that’s why I asked here. I honestly don’t get why some of you are being so aggressive with me. I think it’s a valid question. I know I would want to know. I also know she is not me.

Out of interest, are you in a relationship with a partner of over 20 years, have children with them? If they died, and a friend called you up out the blue to say he was a sinister manipulator, how do you think you would you feel about that? Would you really want to hear it?

TinkerTiger · 15/03/2024 16:54

@Perhapsishould I think this is the issue. You're making it about you, no matter how you phrase it.

I would be angry with someone who did NOTHING back then but now they feel some guilt or are going through some self-discovery want to make themselves feel better.

You were young back then so it's understandable why you did nothing. But keep it undone. Don't bring it all back up for her now. I'm talking from personal experience.

The last thing she needs right now is someone from her past turning up to bring up some shit that either she was fine with, or accepted wasn't right but chose to deal with it in HER own way.

Leave it be.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:50

Crumpleton · 15/03/2024 16:46

Did he die recently ish, if so just for peace of mine maybe send her a message of condolence and take things from there.

Yes recently. Thank you.

@TinkerTiger that’s why I asked here. I honestly don’t get why some of you are being so aggressive with me. I think it’s a valid question. I know I would want to know. I also know she is not me.

OP posts:
TinkerTiger · 15/03/2024 16:49

Omg please leave this woman alone. She made her choices and they are none of your business, whatever 'wisdom' you think you have in your later years that's made a drama of your younger years 🙄

Honestly if I was her I'd tell you to fuck off

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 16:46

Then your first contact in 2 decades is..
'Hey so sad about your husband.....anyway.... he told me once when I was drunk 20 years ago that he was being an arse to you.. wanna catch up?'

Crumpleton · 15/03/2024 16:46

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:39

I think I can manage to ‘hold my tongue’. I haven’t been in touch with her as this was a time before social media and the like. I had a year abroad as part of my degree. In that time, she graduated and to be honest vanished. I think she may have qualified as a teacher but it was at a different university to the one we went to. And now she’s re-emerged if you like.

Did he die recently ish, if so just for peace of mine maybe send her a message of condolence and take things from there.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:39

I think I can manage to ‘hold my tongue’. I haven’t been in touch with her as this was a time before social media and the like. I had a year abroad as part of my degree. In that time, she graduated and to be honest vanished. I think she may have qualified as a teacher but it was at a different university to the one we went to. And now she’s re-emerged if you like.

OP posts:
Crumpleton · 15/03/2024 16:36

Have you been in touch/spoken to her since her DH has died?

If you haven't and think you can hold your tongue maybe start there.
I'm sure once conversation gets flowing if he was abusive towards her she can now open up and chat to you without fear of any backlash from him, if she doesn't give any sign that he was abusive accept that they lived a happy life together.

You don't/won't need to say anything, if you both wish concentrate on building back up your friendship but leave the past where it belongs.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:34

ClawdeenWolf · 15/03/2024 16:18

@Perhapsishould I suspect you're probably going to do it whatever anyone here says, but I'm curious as to what you might know about this man that she doesn't, that you think she might need to know know.

What was your relationship with her husband?

I must admit I am baffled by this. I accepted almost straightaway that the consensus was not to and took this on board.

Where have I said otherwise?

I haven’t, have I?

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:33

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 16:20

But are you pining for her? How many conversations did you have with her husband where he admitted being abusive and you did nothing?

I don’t know what you mean by ‘pining for her.’ Are you trying to suggest some sort of unrequited love? I’m married and have young children of my own.

I am conscious I did not ‘do the right thing.’ Unsurprisingly, what I would do now, in my forties, is not what I did when I was still a teenager. My own mum had just died (that was the context of the conversation) and I had had a bit too much to drink. What he was saying and the significance of it didn’t fully sink in until much later, by which point she was unfortunately no longer part of my life. So things moved on and now she’s reappeared if you like and it got me wondering.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:30

TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 15/03/2024 16:27

@Perhapsishould I was trapped in a very abusive relationship for years. If someone approached me 20yrs later to tell me their thoughts and give me some context, I'd think they were a a massive dick

You did nothing at the time and now feel weird about it. Opening up old wounds for her is incredibly selfish. You are incredibly selfish, you're doing this for you not her. You think she doesn't know what he was like? She was married to him, she knows a lot more than you

I really don’t think I am selfish. I am considering what is best to do, have asked on here and am taking that advice. Unpleasant remarks about me do nothing other than being unpleasant.

OP posts:
TheGrimSqueakersFlea · 15/03/2024 16:27

@Perhapsishould I was trapped in a very abusive relationship for years. If someone approached me 20yrs later to tell me their thoughts and give me some context, I'd think they were a a massive dick

You did nothing at the time and now feel weird about it. Opening up old wounds for her is incredibly selfish. You are incredibly selfish, you're doing this for you not her. You think she doesn't know what he was like? She was married to him, she knows a lot more than you

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 16:20

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:02

I’m female 😂

No, nothing has been ‘explained to me.’ I think you’ve all got your narratives and I’ve got mine.

But are you pining for her? How many conversations did you have with her husband where he admitted being abusive and you did nothing?

ClawdeenWolf · 15/03/2024 16:18

@Perhapsishould I suspect you're probably going to do it whatever anyone here says, but I'm curious as to what you might know about this man that she doesn't, that you think she might need to know know.

What was your relationship with her husband?

PossumintheHouse · 15/03/2024 16:16

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:14

That’s what I thought. I really have been mulling over what the best thing to do is. I feel like I would want to know but equally don’t want to assume anything. Some people are just jumping down my throat for the sake of it: it’s so tedious.

No, we aren't. It's a hideous idea. Sadly, it seems like you're looking for that one poster to validate the harm you're weirdly keen to inflict. Congratulations, you found one.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:15

ClawdeenWolf · 15/03/2024 16:13

Well yes, your narrative is that she's not going to be bothered by the death of her husband because you think he was abusive. 🤷🏻‍♀️

No, that’s not what I’m saying at all.

I am saying that it is possible she ‘is not bothered’ but what I think is more likely is that she has all sorts of conflicting emotions.

What I do know is that she was lied to and tricked as a very, very young person and I know this and I do not know whether I should let her know. Why that is worthy of some of these posts I don’t know.

OP posts:
Mostlyoblivious · 15/03/2024 16:15

Just be there for her as a friend, as someone suggested sending a nondescript message and see if she wants to be in touch.

I would say though that she will be feeling very complex emotions and tragedy may well be one of them despite the nature of the relationship - look up trauma bonding.

I also think you do need to examine your motivation to tell her: it’s not criticism or aggressive to say it’s more about you than her, however you do need recognise that.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:14

Allfur · 15/03/2024 16:05

I would want to know if i were her although I'm not sure it would surprise her

That’s what I thought. I really have been mulling over what the best thing to do is. I feel like I would want to know but equally don’t want to assume anything. Some people are just jumping down my throat for the sake of it: it’s so tedious.

OP posts:
ClawdeenWolf · 15/03/2024 16:13

Well yes, your narrative is that she's not going to be bothered by the death of her husband because you think he was abusive. 🤷🏻‍♀️

Itsonlymashadow · 15/03/2024 16:08

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:02

I’m female 😂

No, nothing has been ‘explained to me.’ I think you’ve all got your narratives and I’ve got mine.

It has been explained. It's been explained why, even if he was abusive its still going to be distressing time for her.

If he wasn't, its still a distressing time for her.

Your assumption that she won't be bothered doesn't make sense. She had kids with him, who will be distressed. That in itself is awful for a parent.

And even if she is really happy and her kids upset isn't distressing her, there's a high probability you pointing out you knew he was abusing her and looked the other way instead of telling her before she married him IS likely to upset her. And she can't even confront him. Its likely going f to leave her confused about many things that happened since with no way of getting closure.

And for what? Cause you want to? There's no thought for her in the process.

peachgreen · 15/03/2024 16:08

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 15:46

I a listening. I will not say a word. I’m just a bit alarmed really by how many seem to think that this man’s death is a tragedy she is torn apart by when I’ve indicated what he did, which was petrify a young girl in order to get her to move in with him.

Just because you wouldn’t grieve for the person he was however many years ago doesn’t mean that she isn’t grieving for who he was now. And even if he was abusive, that still doesn’t mean she isn’t grieving for him. “Complicated grief” (which is what many people who lose an abusive spouse experience) is, in many ways, even harder and more painful. It’s offensive to suggest this could be in some way a relief for her. Only she gets to decide that – and given he’s the father of her children, I suspect it’s highly unlikely.

Allfur · 15/03/2024 16:05

I would want to know if i were her although I'm not sure it would surprise her

Swipe left for the next trending thread