Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should say something now

184 replies

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 10:01

This is a bit of a strange one but it keeps popping into my mind.

I was at university with someone who had an older boyfriend. I can now see through adult eyes that he was very controlling and was really a very sinister character but he actually appeared very nice on the surface, had a professional and well respected role.

I recently found out he has died, which had me thinking about some things. It was ages ago, over twenty years, but he told me some things which now I’m a but horrified by though I didn’t really take them in at the time.

Is it worth telling her? We aren’t close but she’s on my social media.

OP posts:
NotQuiteNorma · 15/03/2024 18:21

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:15

Just the one but it was a long one (several hours.)

There were several hints but that was when he explicitly admitted what he’d done.

Great. So blow her world apart and there's nothing she can do with the information because he's dead so she'll spend the rest of her life burdened with an inner conflict she can never resolve because the person she would need truth and justice from can never give her that. Yeah, great idea. Go for it...

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:19

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 18:15

Sorry there will be people on this thread who've had this happen to them.

Different people will experience the same things and have different reactions though.

OP posts:
NotQuiteNorma · 15/03/2024 18:17

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 16:59

Thats not what I was (note the last tense: I have accepted I am BU) suggesting I do.

If someone had lied to me I would want the truth. If someone had deceived me I would want the correct version. If someone had tricked me I would want to be put straight. But that is me.

But it's not you. It's her, and she might not feel the same way. In that sense it is selfish because you're only looking at this from what you would want and not what she would want. Honestly, just leave it be, the time to do this is long gone.

JMSA · 15/03/2024 18:16

No, it's too late.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 18:15

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:13

Equally, neither do you.

That’s not meant to sound like an arse. None of us know. That’s just how it is.

Sorry there will be people on this thread who've had this happen to them.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:15

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 18:14

@Perhapsishould how many conversations did you have with him where he told you how abusive he was being?

Just the one but it was a long one (several hours.)

There were several hints but that was when he explicitly admitted what he’d done.

OP posts:
MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 15/03/2024 18:14

@Perhapsishould how many conversations did you have with him where he told you how abusive he was being?

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:13

Itsonlymashadow · 15/03/2024 18:07

You actually don’t know how you would feel if the man you had been with your entire adult life died. You have no idea what it would feel like for your husband of decades dies, but was an awful person.

You don’t know how you would feel if your husband of decades died and was wonderful, though he did some weird shit at the beginning.

You don’t know how you would feel if you had been in an abusive marriage and he does and you feel conflicted. You feel free but also have some grief and have to help your kids with their grief while feeling free.

You don’t know how you would feel if a someone you knew decade ago turned up to tell you that they knew he was an abusive creep and decided not to tell you. But wants you to know now.

You can guess how you would feel. But you don’t actually know. You assume if an abusive partner dies, it’s easy to get over. It’s not. It’s complicated and Grief is complicated without abuse.

Equally, neither do you.

That’s not meant to sound like an arse. None of us know. That’s just how it is.

OP posts:
Itsonlymashadow · 15/03/2024 18:07

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:03

Bubble - all I can say is I would want to know.

That is not me saying I will do anything with that information. But I would want to know, to understand and to process.

It was a bit of a moral dilemma. I do think some posters just like to give others a hard time (I don’t mean you) and some of the reactions roaring that I’m selfish (for asking a question Hmm) are ridiculous.

You actually don’t know how you would feel if the man you had been with your entire adult life died. You have no idea what it would feel like for your husband of decades dies, but was an awful person.

You don’t know how you would feel if your husband of decades died and was wonderful, though he did some weird shit at the beginning.

You don’t know how you would feel if you had been in an abusive marriage and he does and you feel conflicted. You feel free but also have some grief and have to help your kids with their grief while feeling free.

You don’t know how you would feel if a someone you knew decade ago turned up to tell you that they knew he was an abusive creep and decided not to tell you. But wants you to know now.

You can guess how you would feel. But you don’t actually know. You assume if an abusive partner dies, it’s easy to get over. It’s not. It’s complicated and Grief is complicated without abuse.

Kittythecutest · 15/03/2024 18:05

Even if she was in an abusive relationship, she isn’t now. I agree with others that there is nothing to be gained anymore by telling her. If she was in an abusive relationship and she knew ‘what he was like’, she will still be grieving the change in the life and the fact that her children have lost, and need to grow up without, their father which is a huge part of being widowed.

I think you need to forgive yourself for not telling her all those years ago. You were very young and some sorts of abuse weren’t understood/discussed back then, so it’s understandable that you didn’t realise the full repercussions until much later.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 18:03

Bubblepoppers · 15/03/2024 17:41

I think you are getting such strong reactions isn't because posters are meaning to be agressive, but because what you were thinking of doing is a pretty horrific prospect. You've had one or two posters agreeing with you that they'd like to know, but the vast majority (96% at this point) think you should keep quiet.

I know you're not going to do it, and I don't think you were meaning to cause harm to the woman in question, but I don't think you've taken on board just how strongly people feel about it and how out of step with the majority you are with your POV on this one.

Edited: just seen the last update that you're upset about the responses OP, I don't want to / mean to cause you any more upset with this post

Edited

Bubble - all I can say is I would want to know.

That is not me saying I will do anything with that information. But I would want to know, to understand and to process.

It was a bit of a moral dilemma. I do think some posters just like to give others a hard time (I don’t mean you) and some of the reactions roaring that I’m selfish (for asking a question Hmm) are ridiculous.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:59

NineofPopes · 15/03/2024 17:46

Surely, rather than pouting, the fact that about 97% of people not only think you shouldn't, but have pointed out what an utterly bizarre and tonedeaf thing this would be to do to someone who is a virtual stranger and recently bereaved, off the back of a single drunken conversation decades ago, should be making you think?

No one is pouting. I am simply aware I have information that isn’t really mine to have if you like.

Wondering whether to do anything with this information does not make me selfish.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:58

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 15/03/2024 17:38

I can absolutely see why the thought crossed your mind, it's great that you've accepted it wouldn't be the best course of action too.

MN is literally supposed to be a sounding board to get opinions, and that's what you've done and are sticking by the consensus on here.

Not all of us have perfect trains of thought in these heavy situations op, don't beat yourself up about your thought process 💐

Thank you. That’s exactly what it was. I have no idea why long after I’ve accepted it is best left people are endlessly coming on to tell me what an awful person I am Hmm

OP posts:
TinkerTiger · 15/03/2024 17:55

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:33

It’s definitely a mistake to have posted as to be honest these comments are really upsetting. I’m not selfish or any of these really spiteful comments and I don’t deserve any of them.

Well think of how she would feel if you approach her.

AuntMarch · 15/03/2024 17:47

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 13:02

@Picklestop My motives may be misguided but my intention isn’t to be cruel.

I get the uneasy impression she was in a very abusive relationship and I wondered if it might help her to have some things put into context.

How would telling her he manipulated her into moving in with him, which consequently led to marriage, kids and however many years together be helpful? He's already gone so it won't be pushing her into leaving an abusive situation. She'll just have anger she can't direct anywhere and probably some conflicting emotions about how much she loves her children, while also considering the fact they were only born because he was like that!
None of that head fuck is worth it when he's already dead.

NineofPopes · 15/03/2024 17:46

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:33

It’s definitely a mistake to have posted as to be honest these comments are really upsetting. I’m not selfish or any of these really spiteful comments and I don’t deserve any of them.

Surely, rather than pouting, the fact that about 97% of people not only think you shouldn't, but have pointed out what an utterly bizarre and tonedeaf thing this would be to do to someone who is a virtual stranger and recently bereaved, off the back of a single drunken conversation decades ago, should be making you think?

Bubblepoppers · 15/03/2024 17:41

I think you are getting such strong reactions isn't because posters are meaning to be agressive, but because what you were thinking of doing is a pretty horrific prospect. You've had one or two posters agreeing with you that they'd like to know, but the vast majority (96% at this point) think you should keep quiet.

I know you're not going to do it, and I don't think you were meaning to cause harm to the woman in question, but I don't think you've taken on board just how strongly people feel about it and how out of step with the majority you are with your POV on this one.

Edited: just seen the last update that you're upset about the responses OP, I don't want to / mean to cause you any more upset with this post

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 15/03/2024 17:38

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:33

It’s definitely a mistake to have posted as to be honest these comments are really upsetting. I’m not selfish or any of these really spiteful comments and I don’t deserve any of them.

I can absolutely see why the thought crossed your mind, it's great that you've accepted it wouldn't be the best course of action too.

MN is literally supposed to be a sounding board to get opinions, and that's what you've done and are sticking by the consensus on here.

Not all of us have perfect trains of thought in these heavy situations op, don't beat yourself up about your thought process 💐

Itsonlymashadow · 15/03/2024 17:36

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:21

No she isn’t in fact

She isn’t what?

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:33

It’s definitely a mistake to have posted as to be honest these comments are really upsetting. I’m not selfish or any of these really spiteful comments and I don’t deserve any of them.

OP posts:
zingally · 15/03/2024 17:23

Absolutely not.

Presumably this is from quite a long time ago, so it's old news.

Also, she liked him enough to marry him and have children with him. So I can only figure he wasn't "that bad".

The man is dead, so what are you hoping to achieve? She's not going to leave him now he's dead, is she? Leave this WELL ALONE. You'll only cause a grieving widow even more pain.

As an aside, I learnt something very sad and awful about my own dad (completely accidentally) very soon (talking days here) after his death (nothing illegal or anything like that). Did I tell my mum? NO. Because I knew it would hurt her immensely for no purpose.
I did tell my uncle (my dads brother) who was there with us. Because I had to say it to someone. We met up afterwards, and both decided we'd take it to our graves. There's no reason to burden other people with pain unnecessarily.

Gazelda · 15/03/2024 17:21

I can't understand why you don't see that your idea was selfish.

Have you ever heard the phrase "don't shoot the messenger"?

In any case, you had a convo with him 20 years ago where he revealed himself to be a creep. You've neither seen nor spoken to them since. You can't possibly have a sense that she was in an abusive relationship.

How on earth do you think she'd have reacted if you'd gone ahead with telling her.

  • Oh gosh, I had no idea. Thank goodness you've made me see that the husband I knew wasn't who he said he was.
  • Wow, really? You bitch. Why didn't you tell me. You could have saved me and the children from a life of unhappiness.
  • I don't believe you. Why would you make something like that up?
  • I always thought there was something fishy about that prowler story. Don't feel bad about not telling me - we had many happy years.
  • yes, he confessed on our wedding night. We'd put it behind us but you bringing it up now has brought it all back.
Etc etc

None of this would bring any happiness to her. You risked causing more pain to a grieving widow. Don't try to justify this.

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:21

BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 17:02

She’s not in an abusive relationship. She’s a widow with two kids. Do you not think life’s probably hard enough for her without someone she’s had no contact with for 20 years stirring the pot?

No she isn’t in fact

OP posts:
BIossomtoes · 15/03/2024 17:02

Allfur · 15/03/2024 16:58

You could possibly validate her feelings, people in abusive relationships often have no outlet

She’s not in an abusive relationship. She’s a widow with two kids. Do you not think life’s probably hard enough for her without someone she’s had no contact with for 20 years stirring the pot?

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 17:00

Thanks @PeonyFlush72 for a balanced response.

OP posts: