Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if I should say something now

184 replies

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 10:01

This is a bit of a strange one but it keeps popping into my mind.

I was at university with someone who had an older boyfriend. I can now see through adult eyes that he was very controlling and was really a very sinister character but he actually appeared very nice on the surface, had a professional and well respected role.

I recently found out he has died, which had me thinking about some things. It was ages ago, over twenty years, but he told me some things which now I’m a but horrified by though I didn’t really take them in at the time.

Is it worth telling her? We aren’t close but she’s on my social media.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Bluegray2 · 16/03/2024 13:57

I wouldn’t tell her, what’s the point of doing it now, it won’t change anything, she won’t be able to get his side of the story so may not even believe you, he may also have been lying or exaggerating

Are you trying to ease your own consciousness? Or are you shit stirring

sammylady37 · 16/03/2024 12:00

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 09:57

Because I wasn’t in touch with her and had no way of doing so.

What do you think I should have done?

No way of getting in touch? Yet she seems to have found you online easily enough.

gloriawasright · 16/03/2024 11:31

Leave her alone.
Either she knows,and always has done. Or didn't know and can do nothing about it now.
She was his wife.
I'm not really sure where you fit into all this.but you sure as hell have no right to be telling tales about her late husband.
You kept quiet back then. You should keep quiet now.
Your desire to offload any of his past wrongs is actually quite weird.
What's your motive? What do you want to gain from telling her anything?
The more I think about this.
the more I think that you are unhinged if you think to tell her is the right thing to do.
Step away from this poor woman.leave her alone.none of this is your business.

changemyspots · 16/03/2024 11:23

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:46

I mean, the thread has mostly tried to turn into an attack on me and genuinely I don’t know why.

Out of the blue one day I get a friend request and a message and I’m a bit troubled by it and wonder what to do.

And somehow the thread becomes about me.

I expected possibly a bit of a hard time for not doing anything years ago, but I’ve been accused of some really horrible stuff here and it just isn’t fair.

OP - I’m with you. I also think it’s something that she might want to know.

however, I would say not now. Maybe she never clicked he was abusive , but I’d agree that he’s probably been a controlling man for years.

i think you maybe need to re connect with her in some way and see what she says.

If she was happy with him- say nothing. If it turns out she wasn’t she MAY want to hear this.

I had an abusive ex and personally I’d want to know that he had been gaslighting me.

but I’d wait a while before thinking of saying something

NineofPopes · 16/03/2024 11:12

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:59

You think ordinary men in their thirties terrify teenagers to move in with them?

Your view of ordinary and mine differ significantly then.

There you go again. Your only evidence that he did this was one conversation 20 years ago during which you were drunk, and which didn’t strike you as frightening enough at the time to act on.

I think it’s at least as likely that he was making it all up to frighten you than that he decided to spill all his dastardly deeds, while stone cold sober, to someone he had no reason to think wouldn’t go straight to tell his girlfriend, thereby wrecking his grand plan (which is nearly as wacky as those caretakers in Scooby Doo who dress up as ghosts to keep people away from old fairgrounds, until unmasked by Scooby, Shaggy and co).

You have erected your idea that this was an abusive marriage solely on this memory, plus the age gap. It’s pretty flimsy ‘evidence’.

similarminimer · 16/03/2024 11:10

I think that naturally you are seeing this as the one big important thing you know aabout their relationship. And other people are pointing out that this, however disturbing, is an event in the context of a 30 year relationship that led to children, a relationship that you know little about having been out of contact with her for 20+ years. If he were alive then she would have a choice about what to do with the information- but now she is dead she has no choice. It would potentially be a huge grenade going off and you cannot be certain that the fall out would be positive or helpful for her or her bereaved children.

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 11:05

PossumintheHouse · 16/03/2024 11:02

You keep saying it isn't about you. So is it about her then? You care so much that you want to talk to her about this 20 years down the line?

Edited

Final post Smile

Possum, all I can say is I would want to know. I’ve found things out after my parents have died, some good some bad, but they all help to explain and put events into context. Sometimes the truth isn’t palatable and sometimes I do feel that things are best left: I sometimes wonder that about people finding out their siblings or parents are not related by blood or something equivalent, especially if they are quite elderly when it comes out. But for the most part we do seem to think the truth, even if the truth isn’t great, is better than the alternative.

But I accept these circumstances are different. And it most probably is best left.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 11:03

Anyway - just in case anyone is wondering still I have said several times that I’m not going to do anything. Her messaging me brought back some memories and remembering as an adult jolted me a bit and I wondered if I should do anything. I’m not convinced this makes me the fount of all evil that some posters seem to think I am but I do think the thread is going to run and run, that posters will keep presenting their own benign version of events and that is a bit worrying … you can think it’s unreasonable to say anything but I am a bit disturbed by how many insisting that I’ve made this up, that this was a nice man wronged in some way by me Hmm

OP posts:
PossumintheHouse · 16/03/2024 11:02

You keep saying it isn't about you. So is it about her then? You care so much that you want to talk to her about this 20 years down the line?

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/03/2024 11:01

she had been in a relationship with him for some two years before university. So she would have been 16/17 then.
So wasn't 16 when she moved in? Was her family never concerned then? 16 yo dating someone twice her age?

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:59

NineofPopes · 16/03/2024 10:57

I don’t think that at all. I think you have almost no evidence other than the basic fact of an age gap and a conversation from two decades ago during which you were drunk to suggest that this wasn’t a perfectly ordinary marriage. Maybe he wasn’t at all a nice person, but people marry not very nice people and make lives with them every day.

And I think the fact you considered, for more than a second, contacting a new widow to tell her that you were bothered by something her dead husband said to you 20 years ago and are unburdening yourself about now that he’s no longer alive, suggests a very, very strange mentality and a weird self-importance.

You think ordinary men in their thirties terrify teenagers to move in with them?

Your view of ordinary and mine differ significantly then.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:58

@betterangels

It is not about me at all. At all.

@MyGooseisTotallyLoose

She had been in a relationship with him for some two years before university. So she would have been 16/17 then.

@ClawdeenWolf you seem to be heavily suggesting I’ve done something wrong or been inappropriate in some way and I don’t see how.

She was my friend; I met her boyfriend (as he was then) just as she met mine and I met other friends’ boyfriend. Once, on a night out, I went to sit somewhere quiet as I was a bit upset and he came with me. Then the conversation happened.

So - apart from not doing anything which I accept - what did I do wrong? What deserves to be ‘called out’?

OP posts:
NineofPopes · 16/03/2024 10:57

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:34

I think even without that conversation the fact he was a man in his thirties targeting a teenager was dubious to be honest. (Her, not me.)

With the conversation, it becomes sinister and very disturbing. That doesn’t mean I’m going to do or say anything but I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed and the poor, poor man having his name blackened’ view that some of you seem to.

I think you’re right @Hankunamatata or he’d have made her Sad

I don’t think that at all. I think you have almost no evidence other than the basic fact of an age gap and a conversation from two decades ago during which you were drunk to suggest that this wasn’t a perfectly ordinary marriage. Maybe he wasn’t at all a nice person, but people marry not very nice people and make lives with them every day.

And I think the fact you considered, for more than a second, contacting a new widow to tell her that you were bothered by something her dead husband said to you 20 years ago and are unburdening yourself about now that he’s no longer alive, suggests a very, very strange mentality and a weird self-importance.

MyGooseisTotallyLoose · 16/03/2024 10:55

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:44

Do you hear yourself?

Do you honestly think a 31 year old man terrifying a sixteen / seventeen year old girl so she moves in with him is NOT sinister?

Why was she at university with you at the age of 16?
And why was she living alone at 16? How was she funding this and uni?

ClawdeenWolf · 16/03/2024 10:53

I'd like to know what your relationship was with the man, to be honest. Are you the same age as him, or his wife? What was the message she sent you via Facebook?

You've drip-fed certain information and not given a great deal of detail about other stuff (the abuse you suggest may have happened). Despite other people telling you to leave it alone and despite saying you won't speak to this woman, you have continued in the mindset that you are right.

You've made assumptions as to their relationship despite not knowing anything at all about it beyond a drunken conversation decades ago.

I suspect some of the above is why you've been called out by posters. There's something iffy about this to me.

betterangels · 16/03/2024 10:51

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:44

Do you hear yourself?

Do you honestly think a 31 year old man terrifying a sixteen / seventeen year old girl so she moves in with him is NOT sinister?

That's not the point here. The point is that you want to tell a widow, a woman who you don't actually know at this point, about what you were told as a teenager. It's making the whole thing about you, which is what people are reacting to. Go deal with whatever guilt you have about inaction somewhere away from her.

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:46

I mean, the thread has mostly tried to turn into an attack on me and genuinely I don’t know why.

Out of the blue one day I get a friend request and a message and I’m a bit troubled by it and wonder what to do.

And somehow the thread becomes about me.

I expected possibly a bit of a hard time for not doing anything years ago, but I’ve been accused of some really horrible stuff here and it just isn’t fair.

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:44

betterangels · 16/03/2024 10:42

I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed

Do you hear yourself?

Do you hear yourself?

Do you honestly think a 31 year old man terrifying a sixteen / seventeen year old girl so she moves in with him is NOT sinister?

OP posts:
Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:44

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:39

I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed

That speaks volumes about your motivation then, doesn’t it? How could anyone not feel pity for a woman who’s widowed with two kids?

That is not what I said. I did not say I didn’t have pity for her.

But some posts here are very dismissive of the fact that certainly when I knew her the relationship was extremely controlling, and abusive. And I don’t think men like that change. You evidently do.

OP posts:
betterangels · 16/03/2024 10:42

I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed

Do you hear yourself?

BIossomtoes · 16/03/2024 10:39

I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed

That speaks volumes about your motivation then, doesn’t it? How could anyone not feel pity for a woman who’s widowed with two kids?

Perhapsishould · 16/03/2024 10:34

NineofPopes · 16/03/2024 10:26

With respect, you admit you were a drunk teenager when this one conversation you remember as so damning occurred, and that it was twenty years ago. It’s just as possible that you misunderstood or have misremembered as that what you are ‘remembering’ indicates a subsequent abusive marriage. Or that the joke was on you, because he made the whole thing up for the sake of alarming you?

I’m not sure I find it terribly realistic that a sober 30something spent several hours explaining to a drunk teenager that he hoaxed his girlfriend into moving in with him by frightening her.

I think even without that conversation the fact he was a man in his thirties targeting a teenager was dubious to be honest. (Her, not me.)

With the conversation, it becomes sinister and very disturbing. That doesn’t mean I’m going to do or say anything but I don’t have quite the same ‘the poor, poor woman widowed and the poor, poor man having his name blackened’ view that some of you seem to.

I think you’re right @Hankunamatata or he’d have made her Sad

OP posts:
SD1978 · 16/03/2024 10:26

Sorry, you would be utterly selfish and unreasonable. An interaction 20 years ago, with what is now a stranger, you've had no contact in 20 years, and you want to potentially further blow up her life, after he's dead. That sounds about as selfish and self absorbed as you can get

NineofPopes · 16/03/2024 10:26

Perhapsishould · 15/03/2024 19:13

He was still a man in his thirties who terrified a young girl to make her move in with him.

I don’t buy that he magically changed, to be honest.

With respect, you admit you were a drunk teenager when this one conversation you remember as so damning occurred, and that it was twenty years ago. It’s just as possible that you misunderstood or have misremembered as that what you are ‘remembering’ indicates a subsequent abusive marriage. Or that the joke was on you, because he made the whole thing up for the sake of alarming you?

I’m not sure I find it terribly realistic that a sober 30something spent several hours explaining to a drunk teenager that he hoaxed his girlfriend into moving in with him by frightening her.

Hankunamatata · 16/03/2024 10:20

I think even if you had said something to her at the time she probably would have cut ties with you if his control was that tight

Swipe left for the next trending thread