Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Autistic 6 year old at a funeral?

117 replies

SenQuestion · 15/03/2024 09:29

More of a what would you do?

My son has autism with a language delay and emotional/ behaviour issues.
My husbands grandmother has just died. My husband has told our son and my son just keeps repeating "daddies grandmother has died". When we watched the queens funeral, my son asked where the queen is, and then kept repeating "the queen is in the box". If we took him to ther funeral he would likely say and repeat things like this. He is very delayed socially and very behind his peers with language. He also doesn't like change and can get bored and overwhelmed. There are days at school were he runs out of the classroom and down the corridor and has meltdowns.

Would you take him to a funeral? I am unsure. I also don't want members of my husbands family judging my son for something he cant help/ understand.

OP posts:
Selkiee · 15/03/2024 17:00

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/03/2024 16:43

The only times I’ve attended a funeral and there have been kids there, the kids were either lett to shout and cry or allowed to run around making loads of noise. In each case their parents went on and on at the wake about how their children were lifting the mood and bringing comfort and joy by reminding everyone of the circle of life. Just utterly delusional.

It’s not that kids being at funeral is wrong, it’s that their parents are far too often totally oblivious to the noise and disruption and mistakenly think they are adding to the occasion. Exact same with weddings IME.

So yeah, if he can’t be quiet and still I wouldn’t take him, sorry. He’s not the priority here.

Yes, this is exactly why I made my comment above.

I'm Irish Catholic, saw my first dead body at 3, was at mass every Sunday and Holy Day from birth. Still didn't attend my first funeral until 11. It's not damaged or scarred me or made me feel I've been kept out of death or it's rituals. I've grown up to wash the bodies of dead relatives and dress and get them ready for the undertaker etc after a death at home from my 20s no problem. I was a well behaved child and knew how to behave at mass and on solemn days like Good Friday but in my family and community it was generally accepted that funerals weren't a kiddies day out. We'd be kept in school and taken to the grave at the weekend with flowers and a picture if it was a close relative. If the wake went on all day we'd pop into the pub for a packet of crisps and some juice after school to see the rest of the family. We might even get invited in the days before the funeral the funeral to join a decade of the rosary or just to see Grandad in his coffin and give him a kiss goodbye if it was felt it was right. But we wouldn't be at the funeral to be fair to the mourners.

So I'll stand by what I say and with this point made from a pp, funerals aren't appropriate places for little children. The mourners don't need them fussing,
shouting out, disrupting the service.
And so many parents DON'T parent these days. They gaze on adoringly while their child makes merry mayhem and distracts people.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 15/03/2024 16:43

The only times I’ve attended a funeral and there have been kids there, the kids were either lett to shout and cry or allowed to run around making loads of noise. In each case their parents went on and on at the wake about how their children were lifting the mood and bringing comfort and joy by reminding everyone of the circle of life. Just utterly delusional.

It’s not that kids being at funeral is wrong, it’s that their parents are far too often totally oblivious to the noise and disruption and mistakenly think they are adding to the occasion. Exact same with weddings IME.

So yeah, if he can’t be quiet and still I wouldn’t take him, sorry. He’s not the priority here.

IfYouDontAsk · 15/03/2024 16:24

ttcat37 · 15/03/2024 14:34

No. It’s grossly cruel to take a 6 year old to a funeral.

In your opinion. I went to a relative’s funeral at that age and it was good to be able to say goodbye and understand that I wouldn’t see that person again.

ColleenDonaghy · 15/03/2024 16:24

ttcat37 · 15/03/2024 14:34

No. It’s grossly cruel to take a 6 year old to a funeral.

You might think that.

Those of us who grew up in cultures with different customs around death are doubtless shocked by posts on here where grown adults ask questions in advance of attending their first funerals. I think it's grossly cruel to raise children without an understanding of death and its rituals.

Waffleson · 15/03/2024 16:18

I'm surprised at these responses, my children have been to two funerals, including my child with SEN who isn't much older than yours. In one DH had to take him out and wait outside. But at least we all got to attend the wake. Family members were very happy to have my children there. At the end of the days it's a family event, albeit a sad occasion. Given you also have a one year old I would be inclined to maybe skip the main funeral and attend the wake. But really it's up to you and what your family wants.

Selkiee · 15/03/2024 16:10

A funeral isn't an appropriate place for any 6 year old, SEN or not.

I've been to a lot of funerals and I'm Catholic. I can't remember the last time I saw a child under 10 at one, even then those children were very mature for their age and were totally silent and it's unusual for school aged kids to be at them.

The last thing a grieving family needs is a distressed or disruptive child at a funeral. He should stay home.

Gonnagetgoingreturnsagain · 15/03/2024 16:06

Anotherdayanotherdollar · 15/03/2024 15:56

In your opinion maybe.
My 6yr old has been to many funerals, and has seen several dead bodies laid out. He is in no way traumatised by it, nor did he become overly upset by seeing other people upset, as suggested on this thread. It's the cultural norm where we live.

Are you Catholic?

Generally in UK if you're not Catholic (Protestant etc) you don't go to funerals as a child. I don't know why it is but you just don't. I think I was 12 when I first attended one.

I don't think it's a good or bad thing for children to go to funerals but some might not understand, be upset by coffins, be upset by other people crying and not understand death yet. So for me I'd wait until they were at least 10.

Anotherdayanotherdollar · 15/03/2024 15:56

ttcat37 · 15/03/2024 13:03

Errr, no, he’s 6? Funerals are not an appropriate place for a 6 year old. Jesus.

In your opinion maybe.
My 6yr old has been to many funerals, and has seen several dead bodies laid out. He is in no way traumatised by it, nor did he become overly upset by seeing other people upset, as suggested on this thread. It's the cultural norm where we live.

CharlotteBog · 15/03/2024 14:49

ttcat37 · 15/03/2024 14:34

No. It’s grossly cruel to take a 6 year old to a funeral.

Please explain why.

MabelMaybe · 15/03/2024 14:41

I've taken a SEN 5 year old to a funeral. DH's family so he sat with the family and I sat in the back row with non noisy toys (I think plastic animals) and Haribo decanted into a ziplock bag so it didn't rustle if I opened it. He was fine and I'd have just taken him outside if he was being disruptive. He went to another one at 7 and sat with extended family.

If you want him there, take him. He's part of the wider family of the lady who's died. If you think he won't understand, stay at home with him. Often OPs about children are very supportive but you seem to have got a lot of "I wouldn't take children to a funeral" so I'm happy to balance it up a bit. You know your son and whether he could sit in a doctor's reception etc. (quiet place with lots of adults) for 30 minutes or so.

Dotjones · 15/03/2024 14:36

Funerals aren't a suitable place for young children regardless of whether they are autistic or not (unless they are the person the funeral is for obviously). It's not like a wedding where they can "just" ruin the couple's day, disruption at a funeral can cause people long term psychological damage.

ttcat37 · 15/03/2024 14:34

CharlotteBog · 15/03/2024 13:11

Perhaps you need to broaden your mind. Just because YOU don't think it's appropriate doesn't mean everyone does.
Very many children attend funerals.

No. It’s grossly cruel to take a 6 year old to a funeral.

Coconutter24 · 15/03/2024 14:33

I wouldn’t take a 6 year old to a funeral, autistic or not

LlynTegid · 15/03/2024 14:28

I would not take a six year old to a funeral, regardless of their abilities.

clpsmum · 15/03/2024 14:26

No I wouldn't take any six year old to a funeral tbh

Hufflemuff · 15/03/2024 14:15

I actually wonder why you even considered it to be an option???

I wouldn't even take a neurotypical 6yr old to a funeral unless it was for their parent or sibling (god forbid).

Caterina99 · 15/03/2024 14:04

My grandfather died last year. He was 93 but sound of mind.

I didn’t take my children to his funeral (age 5 and 8). They probably would’ve been fine, but I just felt they were too young and it wasn’t necessary.

LauderSyme · 15/03/2024 14:00

No I definitely wouldn't take him.

My autistic son attended his first funeral aged 10 and I had to take him out as he became dysregulated as it was too overwhelming for him.

It was important to him that he say goodbye to the dearly departed, but as his parent it was difficult because I was concerned about his feelings and those of the other attendees.

CrotchetyQuaver · 15/03/2024 13:53

No I wouldn't take either of them. 6 is a bit young in my opinion regardless of his autism etc. my own DD were 8 and 9 when they went to the first family funeral, I didn't think they were ready for it before then and this was a much loved great uncle who they had seen most days and observed his decline from fit and active to old and frail.

Mummame222 · 15/03/2024 13:45

CharlotteBog · 15/03/2024 13:42

I really don't like the dismissive "children don't belong at funerals" comments being spun out as if it's fact.
It smacks of narrow mindedness ignorance to me.

When I was young I lost someone and wasn’t allowed to attend the funeral. There was no closure and it really affected my understanding of the situation, my Mother always regretted it. I’ve let my children go and they’ve processed death far better then I ever did.

we can’t protect children from death, it’s the one certainty of this life. We are creating fear around it and making it a taboo by not allowing them to go.

ColleenDonaghy · 15/03/2024 13:45

KreedKafer · 15/03/2024 12:07

it would not be a useful way for your son to understand about death and bereavement

Even if it was, the purpose of a funeral isn't to provide the children of extended family with a teachable moment/learning experience. the top priority should be the feelings of the immediate family, rather than relatives wanting to teach their children about death. Absolutely bring a child to a funeral if they're able to be silent and sit still during the service - but don't if they can't.

Children learn how to behave at these things by doing. It is entirely normal and healthy the world over for 6yos to be at a funeral, although I know it's not always the cultural norm within the UK.

Mummame222 · 15/03/2024 13:43

SenQuestion · 15/03/2024 09:36

We also have a 1 year old. I am fine staying home to look after them both and my husband just goes to the funeral.
In this situation do you think that is the best option?

If your six year old will not benefit from the funeral ie understand and get an opportunity to say bye, then no, he shouldn’t go.

If they were close and you think it would be good for his understanding of the situation then yes, he should.

CharlotteBog · 15/03/2024 13:42

I really don't like the dismissive "children don't belong at funerals" comments being spun out as if it's fact.
It smacks of narrow mindedness ignorance to me.

ACuriousHare · 15/03/2024 13:41

Children don't belong at funerals unless they had a close relationship with the deceased imo.

My uncle died unexpectedly last year and I did not take either of my young children, even though his own grandchildren (including a baby) were attending, because neither he nor my bereaved aunt had a close relationship with my children.

It is one thing for the children/grandchildren/young close relatives of the deceased to be noisy or disturb events at a funeral - in this case, they are part of the life story of the deceased and remind the mourners of their family life. In my aunt's case, she and my uncle had been heavily involved in their grandchildren's lives and provided regular childcare. Seeing the kids there was a comfort for her, even though they were a bit of a nuisance to the smooth running of everything.

My children would not have had the same associations for her and would not have brought her or other family members the same sort of comfort. If they had been disruptive, it would simply have prevented everyone from concentrating on my uncle and celebrating and commemorating his life. So I left them at home.

Riverlee · 15/03/2024 13:31

If your six year old, autistic or not, is unable to sit through an adult-orientated service, then I wouldn't take him.