Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being a step-mother

115 replies

VestibuleVirgin · 15/03/2024 06:25

It used to recieved wisdom that it was pretty much always the man who would reject a woman's existing children if he remarried
Today, from the threads here, it's the women who absolutely viscerally hate their DPs or DHs children from a previous relationship.
From not taking them out with 'their birth DCs' (i.e leaving them behind), through not wanting to provide any care for them at their 'too frequent' access visits, and not wanting DH to spend to spend time with them, to hysteria that they must 'not be entitled to any of MY money when I die because their real mum will provde'...
Is it because you think the mother of the kids has some hold over you DH/P?
Is it because you would rather neither you nor your oh had any remider of his past life?
Many male animals kill the offspring of the previous male they have conquered.
Here, it seems like many of you would be happy if your DSC didn't exist!

OP posts:
EmilyGilmoreenergy · 15/03/2024 08:33

I interpreted the semi parenting to mean you have to do parental things like provide safety, food, wash clothes etc, be considerate and make sacrifices and adjust your life but then also have understand ultimately you have no say and have to step back for things like decisions about schools, parents evenings, graduation etc

Untethered · 15/03/2024 08:33

Some of the batshit anti-step mum threads I recall:

  • a step-mum who who wanted to take her baby on holiday on her maternity leave with her mum. Some posters castigated her for going on holiday without her DSC, even though their dad wasn’t going
  • a step-mum who wanted to take her 11yo DD and dd’s friend to Rome and the ex said OP should be taking 15yo DSD, not the friend, even though their dad wasn’t going
  • a step-mum whose husband was going on a work trip and the ex wanted OP to have her DSC to stay the week even though it was mum’s contact time.
  • a step-mum who had been doing school pick-ups and drop offs for DSC for a year but her work meant she couldn’t do them anymore without stress and the mum AND the DH castigated her.

There are so many more, I could be here all day.

Saymyname28 · 15/03/2024 08:32

I think in most cases its actually misplaced resentment towards their partner for shirking his responsibilities.
I'd say most relationships with children end becuase of the fathers behaviour being so unbearable. I don't know many women would rather be a single mother than be a part of a good two parent household. It takes alot for a woman to break up her young children's home. (In most cases imo)

So you have a man that doesn't want to look after his kids but has to see his kids. And reels in his new partner to look after them. She resents how much she has to do for the kids and how bad their behaviour is (becuase of inconsistent Disney dad over here) but directs that bitterness at the kids rather that her partner becuase it's easier.

gannett · 15/03/2024 08:29

Bananasandtoast · 15/03/2024 08:23

How can you be only semi parental and at the same time treat them exactly the same and show them the same love as your own kids?
Does that mean "semi parental" is, in truth, unacceptable?
Or does that mean that you have to hold back on your own kids?
Not being goady, just trying to understand where the line is.
My DSDs mum would lose her mind if I genuinely started treating her child exactly as if she were my own. Not to mention how perturbed DSD herself would feel.

The line has to be negotiated based on ages, the other parent's involvement, logistics... it's not be the same in every case. If the other parent is absent, the step-parent may need to take over the role of parent fully, in a way that would be inappropriate if the other parent lived two doors down and was still involved.

I think a lot of the threads on MN, where a step-parent wants to exclude her step-children from her "little family", arealso quite obviously egregious and damaging, but those posters always seem to get a lot of support along the lines of "they're not your responsibility".

I do acknowledge it's difficult! Really difficult. But no one is forced to be a step-parent, you choose to become one. That means you're signing up for that difficulty.

ObliviousCoalmine · 15/03/2024 08:28

See @gannett you can't figure it out either. You can't be semi parental with step children but then have all children (bio and step) on a par with everything. Are we 'semi parenting' bio kids too then? Who picks up the other bit? Nobody knows because it's a fucking hard job.

I didn't say bad. I didn't say it wasn't worth it. I said it was hard.

Bananasandtoast · 15/03/2024 08:23

gannett · 15/03/2024 08:18

The difficulties of being a stepmother seem fairly obvious to me. Yes, it's a tough line to walk to be a semi-parental figure with no established boundaries. But the bottom line is that you do have to provide love and care to children you play a role in raising, and you shouldn't show favouritism to some children in the household (ie your bio ones) over others. That's all basic, non-negotiable stuff.

If you don't feel you can do that, that's fine. There's an easy solution. Don't get involved with men who already have children if you're not cut out to help raise them.

I have never wanted to play any role in raising children and found filtering out fathers to be extremely simple. It baffles me that anyone can't manage that.

How can you be only semi parental and at the same time treat them exactly the same and show them the same love as your own kids?
Does that mean "semi parental" is, in truth, unacceptable?
Or does that mean that you have to hold back on your own kids?
Not being goady, just trying to understand where the line is.
My DSDs mum would lose her mind if I genuinely started treating her child exactly as if she were my own. Not to mention how perturbed DSD herself would feel.

gannett · 15/03/2024 08:18

The difficulties of being a stepmother seem fairly obvious to me. Yes, it's a tough line to walk to be a semi-parental figure with no established boundaries. But the bottom line is that you do have to provide love and care to children you play a role in raising, and you shouldn't show favouritism to some children in the household (ie your bio ones) over others. That's all basic, non-negotiable stuff.

If you don't feel you can do that, that's fine. There's an easy solution. Don't get involved with men who already have children if you're not cut out to help raise them.

I have never wanted to play any role in raising children and found filtering out fathers to be extremely simple. It baffles me that anyone can't manage that.

ObliviousCoalmine · 15/03/2024 08:15

Being a step mother (presumably also a step dad but I don't have that experience) is one of the hardest things I've ever had to do.

In a nutshell, you have to love children "like they're your own" but maintain many, constantly moving, variable boundaries because you must remember that they are not your own.

It's incredibly difficult, and that's if all the parents get on well. It requires an astronomical amount of emotional maturity and patience to navigate and maintain any sanity and sense of self.

BuddhaAtSea · 15/03/2024 08:09

@VestibuleVirgin shall we wait till you have your own step children and then we can talk? I’m not condoning bad behaviour, but it seems to me you’re talking from a child’s perspective, not an adult’s, your blame is misplaced. And there is an awful lot to understand when you’re the grown up.
The children are not the step mother’s children. They have their own parents. And it’s the parents’ responsibility to look after their own children.
I’m a mother and I have common sense and good morals, I’d like to think. DP has a preteen and acts as if parenting is a hobby. So rather than, yet again, ruining my day off (because he hasn’t thought what he’s going to feed her and it’s way past her meal time/it’s raining and she needs her coat/she is bored etc), I’ll make my own plans and leave them to it. Doesn’t mean I dislike the child, it just means I’m not her mother. Like with any of my friends’ children, I’m happy to adjust my expectations, but I’m not going to parent them.
Are you telling me that because I’m in a relationship with her dad I should automatically mother his child?

Untethered · 15/03/2024 08:07

Today, from the threads here, it's the women who absolutely viscerally hate their DPs or DHs children from a previous relationship.

What a crock of shit, I’ve never seen this visceral hate and I’ve never been a step-mum. And you know it, OP, because you’ve disabled voting.

I spend a lot of time on MN and for every 1 unreasonable step-mum, there are 9 first wives or men who are unreasonable in their expectations of a step-mum.

I’ve seen you on various threads, you are the variety of poster who uses misogynistic words like ‘hysteria’ and who thinks step-mums should only exist to serve the needs of their step-children, above their own needs and the needs of their bio children, whilst the actual parents get a free pass to prioritise their jobs or social lives.

benjoin · 15/03/2024 08:05

There's a book I often see recommended on here called "Stepmonster" it's worth picking up if you're interested in the history and psychology of being a stepmother. And it is primarily about step mothers. Personally I think its an underappreciated and under discussed role in our society

socks1107 · 15/03/2024 08:01

What you see on the threads is step mums that are struggling and have reached a point where they need some support. It's a hard task, I never ever expected the cute 6 year old to steal from me repeatedly, lie almost daily, both to us and about us and break mine and my daughters things deliberately. Add into that an ex who has been awful from the start and I would say that on occasions I need support, I need some where to rant and let off steam just as I do my own children some times. But this is a snapshot of time and wouldn't reflect the happy weekends or holidays we've shared or the parents evening I've never missed ( mum won't go) or the help I give her dad navigating a teenage girl with trendy clothes and makeup.

My husband will also have times where my children are driving him mad and I recognise that and plan some weekends out to give him much needed space. They aren't his children, she isn't mine and with that we don't share biological feelings towards them and that's ok. To just start another thread (second this week I think) bashing stepmums who are doing their best is another inbuilt prejudice that feeds into society and into young people who then have a bias that all stepmums are wicked and out to steal their Dad. It's untrue, it's unhelpful and is hurtful to many of us.

LewishamMumNow · 15/03/2024 07:59

I don't think there's anything goady or angry about OP; she's asking a reasonable question based on the threads she's been reading, tho' as PP have said, people tend to start threads when they are in particular situations. I can't relate to most of them as the someone is being so completely unreasonable most of the time.

LewishamMumNow · 15/03/2024 07:58

I agree being a SM sounds awful. Plenty of the work, and none of the thanks and love.
I'm a single mother by choice to 3 DC, but I won't be dating anyone until my kids are in at least their mid teens, because I don't think it would be fair on them.

Floofydawg · 15/03/2024 07:58

You're really fucking angry OP. Maybe take a chill pill or something.

Woahtherehoney · 15/03/2024 07:56

Not in my case. We have my DSS 4/5 nights a week and I adore him. He’s my little best friend.

It might be different for us as I don’t have children (DP’s ex has two others who are her new partners) so he is our sole focus and he comes on holidays, I do school runs, wash his clothes, cook, we have days out just the two of us - I wouldn’t change our set up for the world.

yes it can be challenging - we’re going through an autism diagnosis for DSS but he’s an amazing kid.

MiltonNorthern · 15/03/2024 07:56

Thicklegs · 15/03/2024 07:41

I feel like this is misogynistic. In my own experience it's the step fathers that are the problem.

My stepdaughter and I have a great relationship. She's an adult now. We spend time together, she confides in me and she made a real fuss of me on mothees day. She always does.

She lived with her mom and stepdad and other siblings. She has a real problems with him and from what I've heard was a nasty bully.

My own stepmother growing up was amazing. My stepfather was the cruel one.

Why are women always made to feel like shit?! Most of us are just doing our best!

I mean children who are abused in the home are most likely to be abused by a non related man but sure, step mums are the problem 🙄

VestibuleVirgin · 15/03/2024 07:52

Floofydawg · 15/03/2024 07:47

Your post basically just attacks all SMs, and is based on no particular experience or circumstance. It's pointless.

Actually, i refer to the posts 'on here', i did not accuse all SMs.
Also, if you read the responses I have posted, you'll see that I was step-child, so no, your immediate judement of 'no experience' was way fucking wrong

OP posts:
Floofydawg · 15/03/2024 07:47

Your post basically just attacks all SMs, and is based on no particular experience or circumstance. It's pointless.

VestibuleVirgin · 15/03/2024 07:46

Floofydawg · 15/03/2024 07:40

Would also love to know WTF it's got to do with you OP. Do you even have any experience of this situation?

Eerm, yes I do
And of course, let's attack the OP because it's easier to misinterpret the post than try to articulate an answer.

OP posts:
WhingeInTheWillows · 15/03/2024 07:45

Step mothers (and fathers) are like all people - some good, some bad and a range in between. Behind every bad step mother is an ineffective, weak dad who is happy to go along with whatever the step mum wants.

Thicklegs · 15/03/2024 07:41

I feel like this is misogynistic. In my own experience it's the step fathers that are the problem.

My stepdaughter and I have a great relationship. She's an adult now. We spend time together, she confides in me and she made a real fuss of me on mothees day. She always does.

She lived with her mom and stepdad and other siblings. She has a real problems with him and from what I've heard was a nasty bully.

My own stepmother growing up was amazing. My stepfather was the cruel one.

Why are women always made to feel like shit?! Most of us are just doing our best!

Floofydawg · 15/03/2024 07:40

Would also love to know WTF it's got to do with you OP. Do you even have any experience of this situation?

Youcannotbeseriousreally · 15/03/2024 07:40

If you’re insisting you’re not just being goady let’s reframe it.

do you think ALL husbands are useless arses who never help with housework?

do you think ALL stay at home mums are lazy ( or hero’s)

do you think ALL teenagers that are rude and nasty are damaged due to PURELY their parents actions?

because this sample of the population would lead you to believe these statements are 100% true … but people come here to moan / ask for support / vent. People don’t come here to share the good stuff do they?

you’ve made an assumption that suits you, but believing it’s true based on what you read on mumsnet is really quite stupid don’t you think?

EmilyGilmoreenergy · 15/03/2024 07:37

The posts here on the step parents forum are not representative of all step mums it is an outlet for people who are struggling with various issues and anything I have seen that is nasty or unfair on the children rightly gets overwhelmingly called out, you are seeing what you want to see to reinforce your negative experience and opinions.

I have a loving and enriching relationship with my SC who has chosen as a teen to live with us.
Some parents are incredibly selfish, some step parents are too but every circumstance is different and nuanced and your seething post is not covering you in glory either.