Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it right the media can lift stories from online forums like mumsnet about sensitive information?

57 replies

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:31

I’m referring to a thread which was taken down this morning due to the OP being concerned her BF would catch wind of the story now being posted by the media.

For those who didn’t see it, she was asking advice about her 40yr old BF and his habit of treating his old cuddly toy as if it were alive etc.

I was shocked - not necessarily that they’d quoted her and other posters (I know it’s what they do) but they’d even published the name of the toy, which would be identifying beyond belief! (Not to the whole world, but the unaware BF and possibly those closest to him).

The majority of posters saw the humorous side, but I and a few others were more concerned about the vulnerability and MH of the man in question. As well as placing the OP in a stressful position of praying her BF doesn’t come across the article, or have someone point it out to him who is unaware of the link - him suffering underserved humiliation and possibly MH issues and the ending of a relationship - it’s meant she’s had to delete the thread, thereby stopping any further useful advice, which was the whole point!

In the article they referred to her as ‘the anonymous woman/poster’ I think, but then they named the toy and posted a load of quotes that I’m sure the posters would not have wished the BF to see.

I’m not altogether surprised that the media have casually placed the OP and her BF in a potentially damaging position as their primary focus is to ‘sell’ stories, but shouldn’t there be some kind of regulation where they at least limit the damage caused, i.e absolutely no identifying features etc?

Isn’t there a difference between someone selling a paper their story and a journalist scouring a ‘private’ (I know not literally) forum, where posters are encouraged to share their honest thoughts and feelings in order to get help, and publishing it without permission online for everyone to see and have a good laugh at?

I guess what I’m asking is -

AIBU to think journalists should not be allowed to publish stories from advice forums such as mumsnet where sensitive topics are encouraged without at least the OP’s permission?

OP posts:
GirlMum40 · 15/03/2024 12:51

Sorry but rehashing a forum thread IS lazy. I could do it with absolutely no media training. They don't even usually write much about it other than quoting the thread. Boring non stories, lazy, and potentially causing someone who was genuinely wanting advice to feel uncomfortable. It may have taken courage to post that thread, and then it makes clickbait trash news that all the trolls comment on.

Elphame · 15/03/2024 12:57

There is nothing the least bit private about Mumsnet.

If you choose to post something here then it's on the internet forever (unless you request deletion) and can be picked up and used by anyone, anywhere at any time for any reason.

Any feeling that this is a private forum is entirely illusionary.

C8H10N4O2 · 15/03/2024 13:24

Buckle up OP - not only can journalists lift content from any public forum but MN actively promote threads from here on other social media.

Don't post in public anything that you don't want your employers, family, friends and enemies to read. "Public" includes groups of the type you find on FB and Whatsapp.

notagainski · 15/03/2024 22:34

That poster knew exactly what they were doing when they posted that heap of made up bullshit story about their boyfriend and his cuddly toy.

GoodAfternoonGoodEveningAndGoodnight · 15/03/2024 22:42

Sorry, as much as it pains me, YABU.
That's what journalists do in the age of social media.
Cheap filler content, for which they trawl forums etc.
When you sign up to here you are agreeing to your content being shared.
Moral of the story is don't share anything personal you wouldn't say out loud in real life.

GoodAfternoonGoodEveningAndGoodnight · 15/03/2024 22:44

@C8H10N4O2
Buckle up OP - not only can journalists lift content from any public forum but MN actively promote threads from here on other social media
Yes, have seen them link threads from here in both Twitter and Facebook for example

longhourss · 15/03/2024 22:47

I agree, and it annoys me that Mumsnet won't allow users to have the ability to delete and edit their threads and posts. I've had a post go onto the news before, and luckily I had changed enough information for it to not be too identifiable but it was still stressful and caused me a lot of anxiety.

I prefer using Reddit because I know I can at least edit and/or delete my posts

New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Swipe left for the next trending thread