Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is it right the media can lift stories from online forums like mumsnet about sensitive information?

57 replies

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:31

I’m referring to a thread which was taken down this morning due to the OP being concerned her BF would catch wind of the story now being posted by the media.

For those who didn’t see it, she was asking advice about her 40yr old BF and his habit of treating his old cuddly toy as if it were alive etc.

I was shocked - not necessarily that they’d quoted her and other posters (I know it’s what they do) but they’d even published the name of the toy, which would be identifying beyond belief! (Not to the whole world, but the unaware BF and possibly those closest to him).

The majority of posters saw the humorous side, but I and a few others were more concerned about the vulnerability and MH of the man in question. As well as placing the OP in a stressful position of praying her BF doesn’t come across the article, or have someone point it out to him who is unaware of the link - him suffering underserved humiliation and possibly MH issues and the ending of a relationship - it’s meant she’s had to delete the thread, thereby stopping any further useful advice, which was the whole point!

In the article they referred to her as ‘the anonymous woman/poster’ I think, but then they named the toy and posted a load of quotes that I’m sure the posters would not have wished the BF to see.

I’m not altogether surprised that the media have casually placed the OP and her BF in a potentially damaging position as their primary focus is to ‘sell’ stories, but shouldn’t there be some kind of regulation where they at least limit the damage caused, i.e absolutely no identifying features etc?

Isn’t there a difference between someone selling a paper their story and a journalist scouring a ‘private’ (I know not literally) forum, where posters are encouraged to share their honest thoughts and feelings in order to get help, and publishing it without permission online for everyone to see and have a good laugh at?

I guess what I’m asking is -

AIBU to think journalists should not be allowed to publish stories from advice forums such as mumsnet where sensitive topics are encouraged without at least the OP’s permission?

OP posts:
Boomer55 · 15/03/2024 08:30

Nothing online has copyright, or viewed as confidential. It’s probably best not to post things than can identify you.

TinkerTiger · 15/03/2024 08:07

I think it will be fine bc a lot of these crazy stories are just that. Stories.

Herdinggoats · 15/03/2024 07:56

I think you are out of line repeating details of a deleted post and reiterating many of the details from it. That wasn’t necessary to bake your point of should people expect messages here to end up in the wider press.

HelloMiss · 15/03/2024 07:53

Too much importance is given to what is essentially just a time wasting forum to kill a bit of boredom or ask a few questions

And op, I didn't see the thread but you alone have basically re-hashed it here

And you've also broken talk guidelines

LenaLamont · 15/03/2024 00:33

It’s a bit of a reach to jump from “anonymous boyfriend with weird over-attached to stuffed toy hits tabloids” to him committing suicide, OP. Don’t you think you’re being a bit melodramatic?

KattyBoomBoom95 · 15/03/2024 00:11

Um, journalists have followed people around for decades hoping to catch an embarrassing photo to share with the world. I always feel for people who get caught naked, usually with a long distance lens when they thought nobody was around/were trying to quickly change clothes.

First time I ever really thought of it was when Sheryl Crow was snapped naked while changing for a magazine shoot - people were holding a towel to protect her modesty but the journalist obviously got a sneaky photo from the other side.

People say it's part and parcel of being famous but I always thought it was shitty as musicians etc are just normal people who got famous through their gift of music. It can't be any less mortifying than it would be for the average woman on the street having her nude pictures posted on the front page - maybe even worse as it won't be forgotten quickly like with a random person.

Sceptical123 · 15/03/2024 00:09

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/03/2024 00:07

Then why do you blame the press for this and not the poster who freely gave the information to the world?

Name of toy - surprised it was used

PP’s clarified may not have been actual name

Sorry, I’m off to bed now, early start

Thanks to everyone who have contributed this evening! 💐

OP posts:
Sceptical123 · 15/03/2024 00:07

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/03/2024 00:02

Not really. Nobody should expect privacy on the internet… just as they shouldn’t expect not to be public information if they walk out their street corner and dance in chicken suit

I didn’t literally mean private - more that it was in a discussion on a forum asking for advice and wasn’t actively seeking publicity around it. And concern that the journalist had printed the name the BF used to refer to his pretend ‘son’, which most would agree isn’t normal, and sounded perhaps beyond just silliness, but hopefully that’s all it was. As PP’s have said it was probably not the name he actually used so that’s brilliant for him and the OP. I’m just sorry she felt she had to delete her thread while she was still asking for advice.

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/03/2024 00:07

Sceptical123 · 15/03/2024 00:03

Thanks @Isittimeformynapyet yes you’re probably right. Of course I understand the concept of what is posted on a public forum is not protected in cast iron as it was voluntarily posted, obviously. It was more that the guy who had this odd ‘habit/behaviour’ didn’t have a say in it being broadcast etc, but I must have missed a PP making the name up in the first place 😂 that makes me feel a lot better! I probably am taking it too seriously but if it wasn’t the toys actual name then that’s a lot better. I was just feeling really sorry for the guy who could have MH issues, we never got that far in the discussion and sadly for the OP, she has to delete before she got any further advice…

Then why do you blame the press for this and not the poster who freely gave the information to the world?

MamaWillYouBuyMeAWillYouBuyMeABanana · 15/03/2024 00:03

If the op is posting that much identifiable stuff then that's on the op.

Even if it wasn't in the press her bf could Google something and it would come up.

I, like many other nc on here change the amount and ages and sexes of my kids, my sexuality my age... all sorts of little irrelevant details so if something ever did get out I could 100% deny its me.

Sceptical123 · 15/03/2024 00:03

Isittimeformynapyet · 14/03/2024 23:57

I think you're being overly serious about this @Sceptical123.

Fluffy was not the toy's real name! If I remember correctly it was a poster who named it and everyone else ran with it.

My take on it was that the bf thought it was funny, especially when the OP mentioned his post-sex comment. I'll never know though.

Thanks @Isittimeformynapyet yes you’re probably right. Of course I understand the concept of what is posted on a public forum is not protected in cast iron as it was voluntarily posted, obviously. It was more that the guy who had this odd ‘habit/behaviour’ didn’t have a say in it being broadcast etc, but I must have missed a PP making the name up in the first place 😂 that makes me feel a lot better! I probably am taking it too seriously but if it wasn’t the toys actual name then that’s a lot better. I was just feeling really sorry for the guy who could have MH issues, we never got that far in the discussion and sadly for the OP, she has to delete before she got any further advice…

OP posts:
Doyoumind · 15/03/2024 00:03

It's public, not private, as PPs have said. It's not really any different to Twitter/X. Maybe it's more public as you can read MN without an account and not Twitter.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 15/03/2024 00:02

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:58

Answered that one

Not really. Nobody should expect privacy on the internet… just as they shouldn’t expect not to be public information if they walk out their street corner and dance in chicken suit

WhateverMate · 14/03/2024 23:59

No I think public forums are fair game and posters have a responsibility for themselves and what they post, knowing it could end up anywhere.

Plus, I think a lot of the weird and whacky threads that end up in the media are started by journalists anyway.

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:58

saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/03/2024 23:57

I find it more shocking that people don’t understand that posting something on internet is the equivalent of putting a sign up in their front yard.

Please tell me what is ‘private’ on the internet?

Answered that one

OP posts:
saltinesandcoffeecups · 14/03/2024 23:57

I find it more shocking that people don’t understand that posting something on internet is the equivalent of putting a sign up in their front yard.

Please tell me what is ‘private’ on the internet?

Isittimeformynapyet · 14/03/2024 23:57

I think you're being overly serious about this @Sceptical123.

Fluffy was not the toy's real name! If I remember correctly it was a poster who named it and everyone else ran with it.

My take on it was that the bf thought it was funny, especially when the OP mentioned his post-sex comment. I'll never know though.

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:57

LenaLamont · 14/03/2024 23:50

It's low hanging fruit for the tabloids, but this is a pubilc forum so what is posted here is considered as being in the public domain.

Newspapers don't need anyone's permission for publishing stories based on information in the public domain.

(I bet Fluffy will be most displeased and not allow the bloke to see the OP anymore)

Yeah I understand that by the very nature of the post it would attract attention bc it is bizarre. But they didn’t have to name the toy, I think that’s what surprised me. It would be a potential relationship breaker and cause significant distress and upset to the OP’s BF who had no say in his ‘story’ being out there in the first place.

OP posts:
notacooldad · 14/03/2024 23:56

If the op has any sense she would have changed all identifying features. It’s ossinle to do this and keep to the point of the issue.

FourLeggedBuckers · 14/03/2024 23:55

Ah c’mon, nobody posts in AIBU for privacy, the whole board is publicity seeking. Some threads on here probably get more readers than some of the tabloids.

Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:54

CrappyBarbara · 14/03/2024 23:46

OP you put the word private in quotes. What does that mean? This is not in any way shape or form a private forum. Where did you get the idea that it is?

I was typing the explanation the same time you were posting I think. I know it isn’t literally private, but do you not think there is a difference in posting information with the aim to get advice and posting an article designed to ridicule the subject, who is a real person at the end of the day?

OP posts:
Sceptical123 · 14/03/2024 23:52

I get that it’s fair game bc it’s a public forum. And lol @BobbyBiscuits i hope you’re right and that wasn’t the real name in the first place (love what you did 😂)

I guess it’s more a question of ethics and media responsibility. You’re absolutely right @KrisAkabusi that the info was supplied by the OP. I was just surprised they named the toy from her post, given the nature that they’d lifted it from a ‘private’ discussion board, and by private I mean that the OP hadn’t called the tabloids with the aim of getting it published in a random article in a paper or online - it was on an advice forum, seeking advice, not publicity.

@JustWhatWeDontNeed Totally see what you’re saying, I guess I’m just thinking, if we were to read in a few days time that the OP’s BF had had a breakdown or killed himself as a result of him finding out his OH had written some pretty personal, private and let’s face it humiliating things about him online (her decision etc, I know, but she was seeking advice, not out to ridicule him like the online article) - would the topic of media responsibility be more relevant?

I’m waffling I know, it’s a massive topic and if you post online it’s public property, yeah, but, meh 🤷🏼‍♀️

OP posts:
LenaLamont · 14/03/2024 23:50

It's low hanging fruit for the tabloids, but this is a pubilc forum so what is posted here is considered as being in the public domain.

Newspapers don't need anyone's permission for publishing stories based on information in the public domain.

(I bet Fluffy will be most displeased and not allow the bloke to see the OP anymore)

FourLeggedBuckers · 14/03/2024 23:50

Basic internet security: don’t post anything online you aren’t happy for the whole world to know.

Honestly, people need to have a little responsibility for their own actions. And I have more sympathy for Fluffy than any OPs who don’t understand how the internet works.

CrappyBarbara · 14/03/2024 23:46

OP you put the word private in quotes. What does that mean? This is not in any way shape or form a private forum. Where did you get the idea that it is?