Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be exasperated with posters who refer to ‘the terminally offended’?

312 replies

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:11

Been lurking on a couple of threads recently and I just get so frustrated by posters who use these phrases:

”People are offended by EVERYTHING these days.”

”Snowflake”

”The terminally/permanently offended”

etc

It’s just so empty and pointless; you could equally have used these phrases against, say, people objecting to page three photos a few years ago (and, to be fair, some of these posters probably did).

People get so angry when prejudice is pointed out to them. You just know they’re aching to say “This is political correctness gone mad!” but they at least know that’s been discredited, so they pull out one of those other meaningless catchphrases.

AIBU to wish that people could actually articulate a reason that people shouldn’t be offended by insidious prejudice rather than just slinging pointless insults?

OP posts:
StupidMove · 18/03/2024 17:53

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 13:45

I think I’m the poster you’re referring to.

Leaving aside the vogue words, which don’t seem very clear or helpful, I’m not sure what you’re suggesting. Are you saying that it’s usual to be upset and angry about an ad showing mum, dad and two small daughters on bicycles with a strapline about mum keeping up? That that ad is some powerful “cultural representation and education”, whatever that is? If so, we’ll just have to agree to differ.

It does make me laugh that some people can see such influence in tiny, everyday things but can’t accept that their point of view might deserve even the mildest questioning, or even being ignored altogether.

I don’t think people should get ‘upset and angry’ about the advert. But I am very glad that people do question this stuff these days. Little by little, it will hopefully get us to where we need to be, despite the odd blip in the road.

Give me that over the racism, sexism, homophobia etc that I grew up around in the 70s and 80s any day. Hopefully overall we will get to a better world thanks to the people that question things. Prejudice is not always overt. And yes things like adverts matter.

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 17:42

All this breast beating about the CP ad—not about whether it was offensive or stupid or anything but about the supposed harm done to cp, or culcha, or interesting advertising when someone complains about the ad is just so odd to me. CP is not some well meaning elderly granny being pulled up by stroppy woke teens! The advertisement is an expensive, professional, campaign to get customers to come pay for use of the facilities. If the advert creates more confusion, boredom, disgust, annoyance, or anything other than cash on the barrelhead it has failed in CP’s own terms because it has failed in its great natuonal duty to separate the punters from their cash. Thats it!

Criticism is engagement so I can assure you that mere criticism doesn’t mean CP doesn’t get what it wants from the advertising campaign—don’t you remember the benneton ads of yesteryear. Even running and then apologetically pulling an ad or an entire campaign is a very well known advertising midel. So don’t weep for CP until you see their year end revenue.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 17:40

I did wonder what the actual stereotype causing the issue was. Women being unfit was my guess, but wasn't 100% sure.

Anyway the joke is on the rest of the family because what they don't realise is she's slipstreaming them and is going to overtake 100 yards from the end of the ride and laugh in their faces.

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 17:35

@LancashireTart To my way of thinking the advertisement is presenting women/mothers as weak, less physically fit and capable, and figures of fun. As I said, not a huge deal but just another added tiny brick in the sexist wall!

LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 17:13

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 17:07

Sorry- what I meant was there seemed to be a suggestion that keeping an eye on not perpetuating stereotypes would somehow prevent agencies make quality advertisements. That avoiding sexist and old fashioned representations of women would mean that advertisements like this one couldn't be made...

Perhaps I'm misunderstanding what you're saying, so please correct me if I'm wrong. The CP ad isn't perpetuating stereotypes and wasn't sexist so I don't know how anyone can draw any conclusion that it is.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 17:08

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 16:42

@Underthinker "Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good?"

Are you suggesting that the CP advertisement was good?

No I'm asking if all media religiously avoided anything that could be seen as a stereotype, would it reduce quality? Would things feel weird, contrived or samey?

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 17:07

Sorry- what I meant was there seemed to be a suggestion that keeping an eye on not perpetuating stereotypes would somehow prevent agencies make quality advertisements. That avoiding sexist and old fashioned representations of women would mean that advertisements like this one couldn't be made...

LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 17:05

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 16:42

@Underthinker "Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good?"

Are you suggesting that the CP advertisement was good?

Well, it certainly wasn't bad, was it? And it most definitely wasn't offensive.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 16:50

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 16:42

@Underthinker "Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good?"

Are you suggesting that the CP advertisement was good?

What was wrong with it? Other than the interpretation you place on it, I mean, which requires you to suppose that it would have any effect on anyone’s thinking at all.

(Other than thinking “Good timing. I was pondering a short family break. I’ll check Center Parcs out.”)

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 16:42

@Underthinker "Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good?"

Are you suggesting that the CP advertisement was good?

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 16:38

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 15:49

@Underthinker Well, it's a bit of a lazy advertisement, but having the man lagging behind would at least subvert, rather than reinforce stereotypes. Or it might be sweet to have them waiting for a smaller child, maybe with a puppy. Always assuming CP allows dogs......Or have the woman looking happy and carefree and miles ahead.

But that's my point. Having the dad lagging behind would just be reinforcing a different harmful stereotype that you've already mentioned. Then you suggest changing the concept entirely to get around this.

Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good? Has that already happened to some extent?

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 16:10

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

Your nym rather gives the game away at the start, doesn’t it?

  1. yes I was referring to your point about advertising not being culturally significant.

  2. I’m finger typing on my phone or I would be less terse.

  3. I could write a dissertation on the political and cultural significance and force of advertising because it is a well known subject for investigation in fields like sociology, anthropology, literary criticism, and even business studies since companies spend a fuckton oof money on them. Whether you know it or not advertising moves people and shapes public opinion.

  4. Guilty, I suppose, of using some shorthand terms like “tone policing” and “sea lioning” to describe online phenomena. Of course the terms snowflake and permanently offended do the same. Objecting to my language rather than to the point I am making is both tone policing and a form of registering offense even if rather delicately and by imputation.

  5. This is all quite British, of course as it is part of British (high) culture to affect a robust indifference to other’s opinions, to refuse to make a fuss, to carry on, no complaints, don’t draw attention, don’t be needy, don’t be emotional, blah blah…

  6. in Rhetoric of Reaction the political scientists/historians look at the typical responses of reactionary forces to any hint of progressive change. These are assertions that the change will put cherished values in jeopardy, be futile, or perversely produce unexpected negative outcomes.

I would argue that sll this tut tutting about people who are permanently offended is just a fairly typical reactionary pose expressed in a classic british cultural form (stiff upper lip, lets not be hasty).

I’m not surprised that the idea of cultural production itself is largely invisible to some posters. You have to be an outsider, or want serious change, to note injustice and the cultural forces that push against change.

Do some posters take it too far? Yes! I find the endless charges of ableism, ageism, and misandry quite tedious because they are often besides the point, derailing, or in bad faith. But that isn’t to say those things are not legitimate things to talk about or taise as a problem.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 15:57

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 15:09

"Are you saying that it’s usual to be upset and angry about an ad showing mum, dad and two small daughters on bicycles with a strapline about mum keeping up?"

Ridiculous to be upset and angry. However entirely sensible to be exasperated and think "oh, for heavens sake-has nothing changed?" Like those advertisements who think it's so incredibly funny to present men as incapable of cooking, cleaning or looking after children.

I don’t think we disagree. As I said above, the CP thread’s OP was about how CP should be “ashamed” of themselves for the ad. I don’t see it’s surprising that posters would then say “you’re being over-sensitive” (or other similar terms).

If the OP had said “it’s exasperating to see portrayals of mums like that” I doubt there’d have been much of a pushback. That said, plenty of posters couldn’t see any reason at all to be bothered by it, even if they understood the nature of the objection perfectly well. Interpretations will vary.

And, as the poster immediately below your last post pointed out, it’s sometimes difficult to say anything without attracting criticism from one quarter or another. Which itself tends to make people exasperated.

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 15:49

@Underthinker Well, it's a bit of a lazy advertisement, but having the man lagging behind would at least subvert, rather than reinforce stereotypes. Or it might be sweet to have them waiting for a smaller child, maybe with a puppy. Always assuming CP allows dogs......Or have the woman looking happy and carefree and miles ahead.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 15:36

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 15:09

"Are you saying that it’s usual to be upset and angry about an ad showing mum, dad and two small daughters on bicycles with a strapline about mum keeping up?"

Ridiculous to be upset and angry. However entirely sensible to be exasperated and think "oh, for heavens sake-has nothing changed?" Like those advertisements who think it's so incredibly funny to present men as incapable of cooking, cleaning or looking after children.

So if an advert portrays a family bike riding with one member failing to keep up, is there any non-problematic option available? You could argue that...

Dad = portraying dads as inept.
Mum = portraying mums as unfit.
Kid = portrays an abusive family where the parents ride off ahead, leaving kids to struggle.

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 15:09

"Are you saying that it’s usual to be upset and angry about an ad showing mum, dad and two small daughters on bicycles with a strapline about mum keeping up?"

Ridiculous to be upset and angry. However entirely sensible to be exasperated and think "oh, for heavens sake-has nothing changed?" Like those advertisements who think it's so incredibly funny to present men as incapable of cooking, cleaning or looking after children.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 13:45

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 13:30

This is such a 5 blind men and the elephant” topic. Its obvious that the accusation that “some people” are “permanently/professionally/terminally offended” is going to be a hard topic to discuss in good faith because the accusation itself is politicized.

One person’s “lived experience” of aggression /racism/sexism (its in quotes because I remember a recent thread where some posters went ballistic over the term) is another person’s everyday normal behavior or desired world or culture.

The accusation that so and so is a snowflake or easily offended is a straight up form of tone policing or even sometimes sea lioning. It is meant to derail the discussion and either shut it down or embarrass the accused into backing off the complaint.

It is ironic that the “I'm offended by the offense” crew are not able to recognize how very snowflaky they themselves are. They can’t tolerate a hint of perceived criticism of a stance on a behavior or language which they claim is trivial.

Like the pister upthread who asserted that adverts are not a significant form of cultural representation and education? At least when its centre parks. Because all these robust “it doesn’t bother me” types turn up gnashing their teeth and wailing about something that they do see as important: , trans issues, jkr, the rotal family, ableism, ageism. Its just a question of whose ox is gored not a principled stance on offense.

I think I’m the poster you’re referring to.

Leaving aside the vogue words, which don’t seem very clear or helpful, I’m not sure what you’re suggesting. Are you saying that it’s usual to be upset and angry about an ad showing mum, dad and two small daughters on bicycles with a strapline about mum keeping up? That that ad is some powerful “cultural representation and education”, whatever that is? If so, we’ll just have to agree to differ.

It does make me laugh that some people can see such influence in tiny, everyday things but can’t accept that their point of view might deserve even the mildest questioning, or even being ignored altogether.

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 13:30

This is such a 5 blind men and the elephant” topic. Its obvious that the accusation that “some people” are “permanently/professionally/terminally offended” is going to be a hard topic to discuss in good faith because the accusation itself is politicized.

One person’s “lived experience” of aggression /racism/sexism (its in quotes because I remember a recent thread where some posters went ballistic over the term) is another person’s everyday normal behavior or desired world or culture.

The accusation that so and so is a snowflake or easily offended is a straight up form of tone policing or even sometimes sea lioning. It is meant to derail the discussion and either shut it down or embarrass the accused into backing off the complaint.

It is ironic that the “I'm offended by the offense” crew are not able to recognize how very snowflaky they themselves are. They can’t tolerate a hint of perceived criticism of a stance on a behavior or language which they claim is trivial.

Like the pister upthread who asserted that adverts are not a significant form of cultural representation and education? At least when its centre parks. Because all these robust “it doesn’t bother me” types turn up gnashing their teeth and wailing about something that they do see as important: , trans issues, jkr, the rotal family, ableism, ageism. Its just a question of whose ox is gored not a principled stance on offense.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 17/03/2024 19:17

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

Very true. I think we probably see things fairly similarly after all. You’re right that the title of that thread was a little hyperbolic…

OP posts:
BigFatLiar · 17/03/2024 19:14

I think it's a bit OTT in some areas. It hits home when then broadcast a disclaimer against an old movie or program saying it reflects attitudes at the time. You'd be an idiot to think otherwise but no doubt some do complain.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 17/03/2024 19:08

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 17/03/2024 18:44

Fair enough.

I think I still disagree. You say this:

I’m saying that vocal opposition to an ad like that is a disproportionate response.

By ‘vocal opposition’, do you literally mean just saying anything at all? So you think, if people are a bit disconcerted by the advert, perhaps because they feel it’s part of a tedious pattern of gently mocking mums (which could be in turn part of a bigger, more unpleasant picture of attitudes towards mums), they should just shut up in case they annoy someone?

Seems kind of wrong.

I feel a better approach might be for that person to be able to voice their unease and to articulate why, and perhaps the people of a different viewpoint might say, “Hmmm, that didn’t occur to me, and to be honest, on balance, it seems ok to me.”

That clearly didn’t happen; the accusations of ‘snowflake’ abounded, and some posters had to explain basic sexism 101 to a minority of posters that increasingly resembled an angry MRA gang!

I do think a lot of people don’t see prejudice and they need it pointed out to them Every Single Time. Otherwise progress towards a more equal society is much slower.

You’re right that I was loose in describing discussion of issues generally as ‘vocal opposition’. I agree that there should always be the opportunity to discuss - and always the expectation of receiving contrary views in return.

What I meant more specifically was that strongly expressed opposition to essentially trivial material, or contrived offence/concern etc, including urging withdrawal or defacing or de-platforming or whatever, tends to be all too common. I do not believe CP had any reason to be “ashamed” of its innocent, no doubt well-intended, ad.

It’s really all about the manner and grounding of the objections, I suppose.

I do stress that I’m not suggesting that you contrived offence at the CP ad or that you were even strongly opposed to it. I’m just making the point that cries of ‘snowflake’ are much more likely when people voice vehement complaint or demand action.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 17/03/2024 18:44

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 17/03/2024 14:46

I take your point that discussion - particularly online - can become heated over small things. But I’m not sure that’s really the issue on this thread.

What I think provokes the ‘snowflake’ etc comments in this context (and I repeat that I dislike the term and others like it) is the imposition of a point of view or philosophy on something that just can’t bear the weight.

The CP ad is a good example. It wasn’t to everyone’s taste, but one or two people were even saying “see, CP have taken it down, there was a problem”, as if the ad was so unacceptable that it should have been withdrawn.

I’m saying that vocal opposition to an ad like that is a disproportionate response. (And I do think we have to take thread titles and comments at face value if they’re apparently sincere.) Arguing the principle of things unless there’s a very strong reason to do so is generally a good way to lose all sense of perspective and scale.

Fair enough.

I think I still disagree. You say this:

I’m saying that vocal opposition to an ad like that is a disproportionate response.

By ‘vocal opposition’, do you literally mean just saying anything at all? So you think, if people are a bit disconcerted by the advert, perhaps because they feel it’s part of a tedious pattern of gently mocking mums (which could be in turn part of a bigger, more unpleasant picture of attitudes towards mums), they should just shut up in case they annoy someone?

Seems kind of wrong.

I feel a better approach might be for that person to be able to voice their unease and to articulate why, and perhaps the people of a different viewpoint might say, “Hmmm, that didn’t occur to me, and to be honest, on balance, it seems ok to me.”

That clearly didn’t happen; the accusations of ‘snowflake’ abounded, and some posters had to explain basic sexism 101 to a minority of posters that increasingly resembled an angry MRA gang!

I do think a lot of people don’t see prejudice and they need it pointed out to them Every Single Time. Otherwise progress towards a more equal society is much slower.

OP posts:
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 17/03/2024 18:24

Jumpingthruhoops · 17/03/2024 16:23

But it is people like this that I think are labelled as "terminally offended" because they don't live a normal life anymore, they can't maintain relationships, it's actually very sad to see.

This. It's because literally every aspect of life has become so heavily politicised. Even if you think about what people do on a daily basis:
-Get up, wash/brush teeth/skin care/make up (are those products harming the environment?)
-Make breakfast/lunch (are the ingredients harming animals?)
-Get the train to work (should I walk/cycle?).
-Man on train looks at me oddly (Is this sexism?)
-See ads on the way to work (are they 'offensive' or 'inclusive')?
-Get to work, send emails (Am I using correct pronouns!)
And so on and so on... And that's before we've even looked at what might be happening on/in social media/TV/newspapers!!
While it's of course good to be mindful of these things, for most of us, seeing a political angle in every aspect of life is getting utterly tedious.

Whilst I don’t disagree with this, it doesn’t seem relevant to the point I was making with this thread. When posters chuck out the phrase ‘terminally offended’, they’re usually doing it in response to one specific thing that is being discussed; they know nothing about how that poster generally lives their life. They’re using it as a way to discredit the poster by implying that they do live the life you’ve mentioned, but on zero evidence!

OP posts:
NeedWineNow · 17/03/2024 18:22

GoodnightAdeline · 14/03/2024 22:06

But there ARE so many terminally offended people.

We used to just take things as clearly intended even if clumsily worded, it was a healthier way to communicate as it meant you generally saw the best in people and took what they said in a positive or constructive way.

Now it’s all about looking for micro aggressions, or alternate meanings, it’s mentally exhausting and means so few people live to up to all these imaginary standards.

In the process we’ve lost humour, honest opinion and become very thin skinned. Nobody is happier.

This 100%

CurlewKate · 17/03/2024 18:03

@WillYouPutYourCoatOn Gosh. Well, I hope you feel better for that.