Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be exasperated with posters who refer to ‘the terminally offended’?

312 replies

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 14/03/2024 21:11

Been lurking on a couple of threads recently and I just get so frustrated by posters who use these phrases:

”People are offended by EVERYTHING these days.”

”Snowflake”

”The terminally/permanently offended”

etc

It’s just so empty and pointless; you could equally have used these phrases against, say, people objecting to page three photos a few years ago (and, to be fair, some of these posters probably did).

People get so angry when prejudice is pointed out to them. You just know they’re aching to say “This is political correctness gone mad!” but they at least know that’s been discredited, so they pull out one of those other meaningless catchphrases.

AIBU to wish that people could actually articulate a reason that people shouldn’t be offended by insidious prejudice rather than just slinging pointless insults?

OP posts:
5128gap · 18/03/2024 20:59

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 18:20

The advertisement is an expensive, professional, campaign to get customers to come pay for use of the facilities.

AFAIK it was a static online ad. One stock photo and 5 minutes work for a copywriter (if one were needed at all). Probably £75 all in. I don’t know if they bought space, but that’s cheap as chips online these days.

I do think advertising is a bit of an obsession with some people, particularly political campaigners and academics, because it carries the ‘demonic’ qualities of being (mostly) capitalist; and the industry boasts - quite wrongly - of its power to persuade, so adding up to a perception of powerful corporations brainwashing and manipulating us.

It’s all bollocks. Most ads do absolutely nothing except for a bit of reinforcement of brand recognition or help for a new product launch. Virtually all money spent on advertising products in mature markets is wasted.

I understand the objection to this ad, though I don’t perceive it that way. But however it’s understood, the ad itself is utterly trivial.

What I do wish they’d do is turn the volume down on TV ads!

I'm guessing you don't recall Nick Kamen taking his 501s off in the launderette?

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 20:43

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 20:25

@FourLeggedBuckers
Sometimes this place reminds me how little my world view overlaps with some other people. The search for meaning is an integral part of life and humanity - for me, at least.

But not every bit of meaning you infer from a work is an accurate reflection of its creator's intentions or views.

I could say that in the above sentence "my world view" implies that you see the world as yours and only you may view it, and "humanity - for me" means that you see yourself as the only real human and no one else matters -which would be incredibly offensive and selfish views.

And obviously you wouldn't be able to tell me I was reading too much into it or leaping to the wrong conclusions because that would be to dismiss the search for meaning that was an integral part of my life.

You’re entitled to interpret my comments in any way you choose. It doesn’t change what I meant, just because you’ve projected a different meaning onto it. That meaning is fascinating, because of what it says about you - and possibly about wider sections of society as a result.

That’s why there is no subject too low brow or insignificant for analysis - every half-arsed advert, and every half-arsed interpretation of it says something about the creator (of both advert and interpretation).

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 18/03/2024 20:40

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 20:27

Most of the academic work done on the analysis of advertising and much popular culture is pointless rubbish. So many turgid theses, so little insight or purpose.

Film studies - in some respects at least - is worthwhile. But then films can be substantial, complex and thoughtful productions that examine many issues in ways unique to the medium. Shake ‘n Vac ads or ABBA songs not so much.

It’s not sniffy to take that view. It’s common sense.

Like @FourLeggedBuckers , I have spent many, many years interpreting literature including Shakespeare and other ‘high-brow’ texts. But I still believe quite deeply that you can analyse even tiny fragments of language and find meanings of all kinds. Analysing the conversation between teenagers yields all sorts of information about views, prejudices etc even when they’re being fairly taciturn!

OP posts:
pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 20:31

The intention of the author is only one way to evaluate a piece of art or cultural artifact.

And not the most interesting one. But the assumption that we have to accept the good intentions of the artist or actor underlies a lot of the conflict at mumsnet over whether something is “really” racist or harmful. MN often assert that good intentions, or ignorance, give people or art a pass. While the rest of us are not so sure.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 20:27

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 20:18

See: this is simply “futility” dressed up as principle.

You are simply asserting that there is high culture (worth studying) and low (not worth studying) but of course Dickens, for all his popularity, was once considered low culture and not taught or considered worthy of teaching. I’m 63–the study of popular culture, advertising, ephemera and the ephemeral in culture has been ongoing for my entire adult life. The field began way back in the 1930’s at least with Walter Benjamin if we don’t date it to Montaigne’s essays in the 1500’s. So lets not be so sniffy about people reading in to a CP ad as though its absurd.

Most of the academic work done on the analysis of advertising and much popular culture is pointless rubbish. So many turgid theses, so little insight or purpose.

Film studies - in some respects at least - is worthwhile. But then films can be substantial, complex and thoughtful productions that examine many issues in ways unique to the medium. Shake ‘n Vac ads or ABBA songs not so much.

It’s not sniffy to take that view. It’s common sense.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 20:25

@FourLeggedBuckers
Sometimes this place reminds me how little my world view overlaps with some other people. The search for meaning is an integral part of life and humanity - for me, at least.

But not every bit of meaning you infer from a work is an accurate reflection of its creator's intentions or views.

I could say that in the above sentence "my world view" implies that you see the world as yours and only you may view it, and "humanity - for me" means that you see yourself as the only real human and no one else matters -which would be incredibly offensive and selfish views.

And obviously you wouldn't be able to tell me I was reading too much into it or leaping to the wrong conclusions because that would be to dismiss the search for meaning that was an integral part of my life.

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 20:19

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 19:56

The search for meaning (within words and images) is indeed an important philosophical discipline. But it runs into the sand when the subject matter is a single, online Center Parcs ad.

Analysing the works of Dickens is one thing. Parsing a picture of a family cycling through Elveden or wherever with a few words of innocuous text added on, is quite another.

I fundamentally disagree with you - a CP advert has more potential for relevance to modern society than the works of Dickens - and I say that as someone who has spent a fucktonne of my life interpreting Shakespeare, and defending the teaching of historic literature.

Just because something is modern, trivial, and low brow does not mean that it isn’t worthy of analysis, or significant in what it can tell us about society, values, prejudices and the general zeitgeist.

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 20:18

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 19:56

The search for meaning (within words and images) is indeed an important philosophical discipline. But it runs into the sand when the subject matter is a single, online Center Parcs ad.

Analysing the works of Dickens is one thing. Parsing a picture of a family cycling through Elveden or wherever with a few words of innocuous text added on, is quite another.

See: this is simply “futility” dressed up as principle.

You are simply asserting that there is high culture (worth studying) and low (not worth studying) but of course Dickens, for all his popularity, was once considered low culture and not taught or considered worthy of teaching. I’m 63–the study of popular culture, advertising, ephemera and the ephemeral in culture has been ongoing for my entire adult life. The field began way back in the 1930’s at least with Walter Benjamin if we don’t date it to Montaigne’s essays in the 1500’s. So lets not be so sniffy about people reading in to a CP ad as though its absurd.

LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 20:16

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 18/03/2024 19:44

I’m not sure that’s true of any advertising - or any language or any image!

Very few words, phrases, pieces of art are completely ‘neutral’; everything we create contains shades of our feelings, beliefs, culture and prejudices.

That’s not to say every creation is worth getting upset over of course!

But it’s equally foolish to imagine that every advert is pure and untainted by prejudice. Indeed, the power of the advert often lies in that prejudice.

"But it’s equally foolish to imagine that every advert is pure and untainted by prejudice. Indeed, the power of the advert often lies in that prejudice."

I agree with that, but it certainly isn't applicable to the CP advert.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 19:56

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 19:12

Searching for meaning, especially strained meaning, is often fruitless

Sometimes this place reminds me how little my world view overlaps with some other people. The search for meaning is an integral part of life and humanity - for me, at least.

And I don’t believe in “strained” meaning - all meaning is interesting and valuable, even if the logic behind it seems bonkers, because it explains a lot about the person who proposes it (even if it seems to me to have little relevance to the concept it’s ascribed to).

But hey, we’re all different and each to their own…

The search for meaning (within words and images) is indeed an important philosophical discipline. But it runs into the sand when the subject matter is a single, online Center Parcs ad.

Analysing the works of Dickens is one thing. Parsing a picture of a family cycling through Elveden or wherever with a few words of innocuous text added on, is quite another.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 19:47

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 19:02

Fair enough. I'm ducking out now- I've said my piece. I've already been called obnoxious and told I was trying to be an arse on this thread-that's enough for today!

Oh, no. That’s not on.

And not by me.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 18/03/2024 19:44

LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 19:14

The point of the ad is simply trying to promote CP with an excited child wanting to ride off quickly. Translating it into anything else is just silly and, frankly, looking for issues that simply don't exist. That isn't healthy.

I’m not sure that’s true of any advertising - or any language or any image!

Very few words, phrases, pieces of art are completely ‘neutral’; everything we create contains shades of our feelings, beliefs, culture and prejudices.

That’s not to say every creation is worth getting upset over of course!

But it’s equally foolish to imagine that every advert is pure and untainted by prejudice. Indeed, the power of the advert often lies in that prejudice.

OP posts:
BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 18/03/2024 19:37

pikkumyy77 · 18/03/2024 16:10

@WhatsTheUseOfWorrying

Your nym rather gives the game away at the start, doesn’t it?

  1. yes I was referring to your point about advertising not being culturally significant.

  2. I’m finger typing on my phone or I would be less terse.

  3. I could write a dissertation on the political and cultural significance and force of advertising because it is a well known subject for investigation in fields like sociology, anthropology, literary criticism, and even business studies since companies spend a fuckton oof money on them. Whether you know it or not advertising moves people and shapes public opinion.

  4. Guilty, I suppose, of using some shorthand terms like “tone policing” and “sea lioning” to describe online phenomena. Of course the terms snowflake and permanently offended do the same. Objecting to my language rather than to the point I am making is both tone policing and a form of registering offense even if rather delicately and by imputation.

  5. This is all quite British, of course as it is part of British (high) culture to affect a robust indifference to other’s opinions, to refuse to make a fuss, to carry on, no complaints, don’t draw attention, don’t be needy, don’t be emotional, blah blah…

  6. in Rhetoric of Reaction the political scientists/historians look at the typical responses of reactionary forces to any hint of progressive change. These are assertions that the change will put cherished values in jeopardy, be futile, or perversely produce unexpected negative outcomes.

I would argue that sll this tut tutting about people who are permanently offended is just a fairly typical reactionary pose expressed in a classic british cultural form (stiff upper lip, lets not be hasty).

I’m not surprised that the idea of cultural production itself is largely invisible to some posters. You have to be an outsider, or want serious change, to note injustice and the cultural forces that push against change.

Do some posters take it too far? Yes! I find the endless charges of ableism, ageism, and misandry quite tedious because they are often besides the point, derailing, or in bad faith. But that isn’t to say those things are not legitimate things to talk about or taise as a problem.

Very well put.

OP posts:
LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 19:14

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 18:23

@LancashireTart What, in your opinion, is the point of the ad? Why "keep up, mum"
not "keep u,dad" or "keep up, Sally"?

The point of the ad is simply trying to promote CP with an excited child wanting to ride off quickly. Translating it into anything else is just silly and, frankly, looking for issues that simply don't exist. That isn't healthy.

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 19:12

Searching for meaning, especially strained meaning, is often fruitless

Sometimes this place reminds me how little my world view overlaps with some other people. The search for meaning is an integral part of life and humanity - for me, at least.

And I don’t believe in “strained” meaning - all meaning is interesting and valuable, even if the logic behind it seems bonkers, because it explains a lot about the person who proposes it (even if it seems to me to have little relevance to the concept it’s ascribed to).

But hey, we’re all different and each to their own…

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 19:02

Fair enough. I'm ducking out now- I've said my piece. I've already been called obnoxious and told I was trying to be an arse on this thread-that's enough for today!

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 18:29

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 18:07

I don’t think a dad struggling to keep up with his family is reinforcing a harmful stereotype in the way that it with the roles reversed.

OK, let's assume that's correct. That means in any media produced going forward, when depicting any family doing a sporting activity together, are we saying the only acceptable plot is to have the mum be the best at the activity? Every single time without fail? How long then till "unathletic Dad" is also a harmful stereotype?

Well that’s not really what I said. There are multiple ways of presenting a family engaging with sport - and here’s a magnificent idea, how about not focusing on who “wins” at a leisure activity anyway?!

Show people engaging with sport and enjoying themselves without singling one out as the hopeless case. Sport is about so much more than that, and it’s a regressive stereotype in itself.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 18:27

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 18:23

@LancashireTart What, in your opinion, is the point of the ad? Why "keep up, mum"
not "keep u,dad" or "keep up, Sally"?

It doesn’t have a point, except to remind people of the opportunity for nice bike rides at Center Parcs.

Searching for meaning, especially strained meaning, is often fruitless.

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 18:24

If your arguments aren’t robust about something trivial, they’ll never stand up to the complexities of bigger issues.

I can’t agree with that. Arguing vociferously about a Center Parcs ad showing a happy family on bicycles doesn’t advance any cause. It sets it back if anything.

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 18:23

@LancashireTart What, in your opinion, is the point of the ad? Why "keep up, mum"
not "keep u,dad" or "keep up, Sally"?

WhatsTheUseOfWorrying · 18/03/2024 18:20

The advertisement is an expensive, professional, campaign to get customers to come pay for use of the facilities.

AFAIK it was a static online ad. One stock photo and 5 minutes work for a copywriter (if one were needed at all). Probably £75 all in. I don’t know if they bought space, but that’s cheap as chips online these days.

I do think advertising is a bit of an obsession with some people, particularly political campaigners and academics, because it carries the ‘demonic’ qualities of being (mostly) capitalist; and the industry boasts - quite wrongly - of its power to persuade, so adding up to a perception of powerful corporations brainwashing and manipulating us.

It’s all bollocks. Most ads do absolutely nothing except for a bit of reinforcement of brand recognition or help for a new product launch. Virtually all money spent on advertising products in mature markets is wasted.

I understand the objection to this ad, though I don’t perceive it that way. But however it’s understood, the ad itself is utterly trivial.

What I do wish they’d do is turn the volume down on TV ads!

LancashireTart · 18/03/2024 18:19

CurlewKate · 18/03/2024 17:35

@LancashireTart To my way of thinking the advertisement is presenting women/mothers as weak, less physically fit and capable, and figures of fun. As I said, not a huge deal but just another added tiny brick in the sexist wall!

You see, the ad is definitely not offensive per se, that's just how you interpret it and that's on you. In other words, tough.

I would sincerely hope that the ad wasn't pulled because people have complained that it's sexist/derogatory because it simply isn't.

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 18:14

Also I've just looked at the image again. Its a massive stretch to say it depicts her as struggling to keep up. She's pretty much level with the Dad and a couple of metres behind the kids - which is probably a good place to be so you can keep an eye on them. She looks fit, healthy & relaxed and not at all out of breath. If anything the stereotype is "cheeky kid" rather than "unfit Mum".

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 18:07

I don’t think a dad struggling to keep up with his family is reinforcing a harmful stereotype in the way that it with the roles reversed.

OK, let's assume that's correct. That means in any media produced going forward, when depicting any family doing a sporting activity together, are we saying the only acceptable plot is to have the mum be the best at the activity? Every single time without fail? How long then till "unathletic Dad" is also a harmful stereotype?

FourLeggedBuckers · 18/03/2024 17:53

Underthinker · 18/03/2024 16:38

But that's my point. Having the dad lagging behind would just be reinforcing a different harmful stereotype that you've already mentioned. Then you suggest changing the concept entirely to get around this.

Will it get to a point where advertisers or people in creative industries more generally are too focussed on avoiding stereotypes than actually creating something good? Has that already happened to some extent?

I don’t think a dad struggling to keep up with his family is reinforcing a harmful stereotype in the way that it with the roles reversed.

An inept dad sticking his kid in front of a tablet so he can game/ watch football, can’t work out how to clean a kitchen - those would be reinforcing a different, harmful stereotype.

The CP advert was bad - not because I found it offensive, but because it was crap, lazy, unthinking advertising, with an undertone of light misogyny. That isn’t what I look for in a successful advertising scheme.

I also disagree with a PP who said that arguing principles is pointless and leads to a loss of perspective. Arguing about things at the smallest level is the first step in changing things at the highest levels. If your arguments aren’t robust about something trivial, they’ll never stand up to the complexities of bigger issues.